Devils Advocate time kiddies.. First off her voice is incredibly monotone and when it's not it goes painfully flat. Instead of putting a little of herself into the song she makes the mistake alot make and she goes for a literal clone of the original tune. As far as the video is concerned it's filmed in B+W w/a soft focus which is usually used to cover any complexion flaws. Now I'll be called a "Hater" a kneejerk immature response used by someone who has no facts to back up their argument...
The key to being a good singer is not to try and "mimic" how the vocalist of your cover sings their song. You need to find your own original tone of voice that makes you different from all the other millions of singers out in this world, or you can go the easy way and use auto-tune like most artists do now a days.
Your voice is brilliant :) But i think you have a different voice to Amy Lee and your voice is unique and beautiful in it's own right :) Very well done :)
Your voice is really good, and it kinda sounds like you have an accent lol, but idk what is wrong with these people, because you do not sound like amy lee
@ally0587 I have no doubt she can sing good all im saying is that this one is spot on key, rythme, and everything else, thats all im saying, i love that song, but it just sounds to real, sorry?
Holy crap, girl. You are so freaking amazing it isn't funny.
Go audition for America Idol or something. Seriously. They'd let you on in heartbeat, especially if you sang this song (which is extremely hard to sing).
@dakotaroach96 did you listen to the rest of her videos?? She isn't lip singing and she most likely had the just the music playing in the back ground without the words so that could b y the rythm is on spot match.
IS THAT AN EXTRA LARGE ZIT UNDER HER BOTTOM LIP OR JUST SOME STUPID PIMPLE LOOKING PIERCING! IF ITS THE ZIT PLEASE POP IT. IF ITS THE PIERCING PLEASE SEEK MEDICAL HELP IMMEDIATELY. THUMBS UP IF YOU DISAGREE.
wow, She sings for 45 seconds and get 317k view cuz she's hot... And now she's trying to get people to send her they're beats for her to use.. Selfish in my opinion.... Beats aren't hard to make.. she could learn.
She good but i think you guys are exaggerating the whole amazing thing
@SpudTheSnail mabey you should listen to the actual song you fucker. you obviously are jelous, and cant sing, so youre taking out ur frustrations of ur lowness on her... what a freak. ( i love you amanda, ur amasing <3 )
@iheartjoshramsay100 Maybe you need to read a grammar book. I have listen to the actual song, and it is not awful, but I have no idea how that pertains to the subject of her version being awful. I'm not "jelous" of this girl. I am however capable of making musical sounds with my voice, like most humans are (because I am not mute). I do not understand what my lowness is :/ It is kind of a relative term. I am 5 4, so compared to a giraffe, I guess I'm low to the ground, but not compared to a mouse
@riahbabe11 WHAT?? Amy Lees voice is such a different wonderful voice!!! Yeah she can also sing very good, but she sounds more like... hmm... celine dion or something but not Amy Lee. this is another version of the song, she sang with her own style (which is not bad :D )
Wow... A million and one covers on youtube and finally someone who sounds like the artist their covering.... Blown away... Keep it up... Do you write originals???
Why would you even think this if fake? Fools! Rebecca Black is a fake. You can tell. This girl, has AMAZING talent, that y'all are bashing. Girl, you're singing is wonderful.
im sorry but im a singer myself and yes you do have a good voice but in most of your vids you are also backed up by the original singer if you listen carefully you can hear the original singer in the back ground which enhances your own voice so try singing a song without the original singer in the back ground and then see how peoples comments look after
@lilstar774-Sie Deutsch?! so ist meine Schwester! Ich spreche ein wenig Deutsch aber auch. @idaAmanda-your so pretty! you actually look a little german-are you?! anyway-i believe your the one actually singing this-you have a very pretty voice!and no matter what anyone else says-keep on going-you'll make it far in life-get a good singing career. i know you will- 8D
You are very good. Although, sometimes your timbre sounds a little choked. Make sure you are opening up those airways and getting that beautiful tone ALL the time. It almost sounds like some of your tone is locked away in your chest. Make sure your using all of your air support and keep pushing through. Again, you are VERY good. Take it from a 4 year music major, you are doing quite well for yourself. Keep singing and never let your passion die. Good luck to you. :)
Sorry to say that but you are too cute for showbusines... It's like : first, there is your face and then the music but no one listen to the music because they are still in shock ;D
its realy not fake ,and i can understand this by your voice.just some people cant hear the difference between notes,and voices!good job u have an amazing voice!
It is real. Shut up and watch another video or leave YouTube. Got it? Good. Now, She sang good. You're jealous of her voice. Second of all, Don't watch it if you don't like it instead of bribing her down!
why r ppl calling this fake??? i agree she SOUNDS like Amy but that's her real voice U CAN TELL!!!! stop calling it fake!!! @IdaAmanda u did great job don't listen to these stupid ppl ♥
if its so fake then why has she got the same voice in every video who exactly is she taking it from, people are are hating on your vieos idaamanda evy though because they dont have the wonderful voice you have so they feel the need to be bitter. I think you can go far in life because i truly beleive this is YOU singing and not anyone else.
People that think this is Amy's voive obviously have no ear...same with those that cannot recognize that over very different songs by different singers, *her* voice is the same. She has a distictive timbre (and, I might add, an excellent one). Don't let them concern you, the only way this is a fake is if you have stashed a different singer out of camera range...or in you pocket or something ;p
Something so sweet something so dear ...some that most fear .. wow very good .. amazing :)
Jeffmtz1 3 days ago
Devils Advocate time kiddies.. First off her voice is incredibly monotone and when it's not it goes painfully flat. Instead of putting a little of herself into the song she makes the mistake alot make and she goes for a literal clone of the original tune. As far as the video is concerned it's filmed in B+W w/a soft focus which is usually used to cover any complexion flaws. Now I'll be called a "Hater" a kneejerk immature response used by someone who has no facts to back up their argument...
MrMicklethal 2 weeks ago
@MrMicklethal
i actualy agree with u -.-
adommy4life 1 week ago
I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE YOUR HAIR!!!!!!!!!! AND YOUR VOICE IS LIKE AN ANGLE. (BTW THIS IS A GIRL!! TEEHEE!!!)
cookiesandcream87110 2 weeks ago
@cookiesandcream87110 I think you meant "Angel".. an "angle" is something they use in geometry.
MrMicklethal 2 weeks ago
fell in love with you Right now... :O i am a boy and i cry... soo sweet! nice voice... ! :) 1000 likes for you...
THEDJNOKAS 3 weeks ago
At first i thought you was lip singing...... but your not
11icecake 1 month ago
The key to being a good singer is not to try and "mimic" how the vocalist of your cover sings their song. You need to find your own original tone of voice that makes you different from all the other millions of singers out in this world, or you can go the easy way and use auto-tune like most artists do now a days.
TheRedParallel 1 month ago
You're pretty good but I say articulate a little better because I couldn't make out some of your words clearly ^_^ good job
VampyreBytch 1 month ago
thats nice! you have an amazing voice!
loveinwolves4 1 month ago
so fake!
evelinohman1 1 month ago
Epic! =D
WoundedHuntress 1 month ago
love it
worldpeace3000 1 month ago
Like the real thing!Awesome!
Icemilo14 1 month ago
i swear to god i fall in love in you
faliszekmatuesz 2 months ago
your very pretty and very gifted:}
Musicgasm1 2 months ago
hellyeah
collectorofcrap 2 months ago
You are AMAZING!!!!!!!!!! <3
deanjames129 2 months ago
Your voice is brilliant :) But i think you have a different voice to Amy Lee and your voice is unique and beautiful in it's own right :) Very well done :)
MuseGem 2 months ago
Your voice is really good, and it kinda sounds like you have an accent lol, but idk what is wrong with these people, because you do not sound like amy lee
Ardnas68197 2 months ago
jaki fałsz o masakra
Izunia123451 2 months ago
great voice and your real sexy what could go wrong with you babe
UVFForever 2 months ago
Oot ihan huippu, upee soundi!!
Rride3 2 months ago
Excellent. Amazing. =)
cherokeew0 2 months ago
@ally0587 I have no doubt she can sing good all im saying is that this one is spot on key, rythme, and everything else, thats all im saying, i love that song, but it just sounds to real, sorry?
dakotaroach96 2 months ago
Holy crap, girl. You are so freaking amazing it isn't funny.
Go audition for America Idol or something. Seriously. They'd let you on in heartbeat, especially if you sang this song (which is extremely hard to sing).
RenegadeDragonNinja 2 months ago
Ignore what people say about you lip singing girl you did an amazing job.
Alley0587 2 months ago
amazingg!
arianafan68 2 months ago
wow
BloodyBoiZ 2 months ago
I love U
KoSSuMeTaL 2 months ago
Wow you can sing girl !
Po11yy 2 months ago
It was amy lee she mouthed it i just played the track and her side by side every note the same and the rythm and everything
dakotaroach96 2 months ago
@dakotaroach96 did you listen to the rest of her videos?? She isn't lip singing and she most likely had the just the music playing in the back ground without the words so that could b y the rythm is on spot match.
Alley0587 2 months ago
God damn! Wtg, anyone who can sing and keep up with amy lee deserves a huge round of applause!
CelinaItonami 2 months ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!
axebdus 2 months ago
i love it you sound just like her your good
Grace34222 2 months ago
INCREIBLE
RN26Sj 3 months ago
Awesome !
TrueCanadianGamer 3 months ago
O.O audition for American idol? Please!! ^0^
TheCosplay101 3 months ago
Nice, but lose the lip ring. It detracts from your beautifull face.
bretstep 3 months ago
Your Gorgeous!
LilHaze0 3 months ago
what do you record with :]
Stonehelm66 3 months ago
wow. ur really amzing!! i luv ur hair and lip ring, lol. u should try out for american idol!!!
emochick8321 3 months ago
You're amazing(:
bandswimcheer3 3 months ago
nice job u sound realy great
demonknight231 3 months ago
u sound like her
mazie145 3 months ago
wow.. you are great ! *-*
agi231999 3 months ago
'-----------'
TranceElevation 3 months ago
You're absolutely fantastic! ^^ It was great, so beautiful... Wow!
Waulish 3 months ago
Holy shiat, im in love *__________*
ChiillaHKiillaH 3 months ago
Wauu , aiva mieletön ääni ! :O
TheKiuska 4 months ago
awesome ♥
i love this song and your voice is amazing =)
TheDeutschlandgirl 4 months ago
wow that was amazing
NicolePickle27 4 months ago
uskomatonta
Sssanna4 4 months ago
finaly i faund a good cover! you are amazing! :o
Sssanna4 4 months ago
u need to get a better camera and a sound engineer. Other than that u are awesome.
noobsound 4 months ago
you are beautiful, but I don't think your singing sounds all that amazing
cherryboomboomiii 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check the cover i did of this song on my page its a hip hop version of it check it out people!
OfficialVirus 4 months ago
So GooD
TheToxik64100 4 months ago
IS THAT AN EXTRA LARGE ZIT UNDER HER BOTTOM LIP OR JUST SOME STUPID PIMPLE LOOKING PIERCING! IF ITS THE ZIT PLEASE POP IT. IF ITS THE PIERCING PLEASE SEEK MEDICAL HELP IMMEDIATELY. THUMBS UP IF YOU DISAGREE.
HEARTHEANGELSVOICES 4 months ago
I've been told I sound like Amy too. We should get together <3
laurag333 4 months ago
wow, She sings for 45 seconds and get 317k view cuz she's hot... And now she's trying to get people to send her they're beats for her to use.. Selfish in my opinion.... Beats aren't hard to make.. she could learn.
She good but i think you guys are exaggerating the whole amazing thing
GavinClementMelanson 4 months ago 7
This is awful.
SpudTheSnail 4 months ago
@SpudTheSnail mabey you should listen to the actual song you fucker. you obviously are jelous, and cant sing, so youre taking out ur frustrations of ur lowness on her... what a freak. ( i love you amanda, ur amasing <3 )
iheartjoshramsay100 4 months ago
@iheartjoshramsay100 Maybe you need to read a grammar book. I have listen to the actual song, and it is not awful, but I have no idea how that pertains to the subject of her version being awful. I'm not "jelous" of this girl. I am however capable of making musical sounds with my voice, like most humans are (because I am not mute). I do not understand what my lowness is :/ It is kind of a relative term. I am 5 4, so compared to a giraffe, I guess I'm low to the ground, but not compared to a mouse
SpudTheSnail 4 months ago 3
@SpudTheSnail Yes it Full-Of Aww :)
milenamuza 4 months ago
@milenamuza Clever ;)
SpudTheSnail 4 months ago
@SpudTheSnail ;) Indeed
milenamuza 4 months ago
Really good job. :)
ffishy21 4 months ago
u sound just like her!
riahbabe11 4 months ago 40
@riahbabe11 WHAT?? Amy Lees voice is such a different wonderful voice!!! Yeah she can also sing very good, but she sounds more like... hmm... celine dion or something but not Amy Lee. this is another version of the song, she sang with her own style (which is not bad :D )
XxBenBarnesLoverxX 2 months ago
@riahbabe11 maybe she is *stares at IdaAmanda*
ColdBlitz12456 1 month ago
Damn that's perfect! i love your'e voice so much... (: <3
MissVivii13 5 months ago 2
THIS IS FUCKING AMAZING. KEEP ON SINGING. <3 FUCK HATERS. <3
nellygurl11 5 months ago 2
Ai suomalainen tyttö :P
TheSuperTB 5 months ago
WOW!! SOOO FUCKING GOOD JUST WOOWWWW
psychomaggot1 5 months ago 2
sssssssssssssssooooooooooooooooooo fake
mse74648 5 months ago
WOW! O: WHY DIDNT THEY FIND YOU AND NOT BIEBER!?!?!
EastCoastActing15oh5 5 months ago
DAMN!! thats all i got 2 say
MsTraxxasman 5 months ago
WHAT THE FUCK YOU'RE AWESOME!!
anfane90 5 months ago
Wow... A million and one covers on youtube and finally someone who sounds like the artist their covering.... Blown away... Keep it up... Do you write originals???
DatsPP 5 months ago
Ur amazing girl..keep it up!!
Gockaldy 5 months ago
you are amazing girl you made me cry
hotbambi2010 5 months ago
wtf thatz more fake than my gfs tits , u suck ass
androandro789 5 months ago
your voice it's beautifull! =)
piliconejilla 6 months ago
you´re a great singer! beautiful!!
Catwoman2811 6 months ago
LOVE IT OMG !!!!!!
AmyxDawson 6 months ago
When Amy sings this song, I cry, when I hear this, I insta-cry. fff Beautiful voice! Definitely keep singing!<3
xoxgangstakittyxox 6 months ago
Gosh that face... beauty. *.*
DemonSlayer2121 6 months ago
ne zna koje si godiste ali svaka cast
MrNessa1992 6 months ago
WoW! i got goosbumps! oh, n btw u HATERS, ill tell u why it iiss her voice, listen to her accent u dumbA**es ,different from Amy Lee's!
MyScorpio1995 6 months ago
lip singing .
wifeyz22 6 months ago
@jambuttie49 Yeah because amazing singing MUST mean its fake.
XGracieGraceX 6 months ago
your amazing
gooders2000 6 months ago
You have a beautiful voice. Wow. I'm amazed.
JFR199 6 months ago
Why would you even think this if fake? Fools! Rebecca Black is a fake. You can tell. This girl, has AMAZING talent, that y'all are bashing. Girl, you're singing is wonderful.
BlastedHipsters 6 months ago
thats so fake you can tell that your mouthing it
mse74648 6 months ago
@mse74648 Hater's are gonna keep hating. You're going to continue being stupid.
SouthernDiscussions 6 months ago
@mse74648 Yeah smarts shes not mouthing it her cameras just slow. Everyones are!!! Can't you just belive that or are you just too jealous.
Bittyboo7 6 months ago
I want to marry you
TheB4ki 6 months ago
Wow you got VOICE!!!
HisNightDreamer 6 months ago
:D u sing amazing!
gabywuzh3r3 6 months ago
if that really is you singing then you are acctually amazing! beatiful song and a stunning voice i hope i can hear your albums in the future =)
MarvelHeroDominic 6 months ago
hey where are u from i need a girl singer i am doing stuff like sully erna's solo album and you have an amazing voice
RIPdimeRIP101 6 months ago
Perfect singing. Nuff said
GhostChasersCrew 6 months ago
im sorry but im a singer myself and yes you do have a good voice but in most of your vids you are also backed up by the original singer if you listen carefully you can hear the original singer in the back ground which enhances your own voice so try singing a song without the original singer in the back ground and then see how peoples comments look after
100themightym 6 months ago
girl this is awesome:) obviously real lol anyone who says otherwise is jealous:))
silverstrawberrys101 6 months ago
this gave me chills... :O
MAKUTASIAA 6 months ago
you have a wonderful voice keep making videos :)
TheElisiaT 7 months ago
Wow! Clearly talented and very pretty :-)
dridgley84 7 months ago
wow this is horrible!!! :O
sassycat1023 7 months ago
Beautiful And All The People That Say Her Singing Is Fake .. Then Go Somewhere Else And Leave This Angel alone! Stop Being Jealous!
JensSitemodeling 7 months ago
youre voice is better than selenA gomez´s ;) youre a good singer real!!!
321123Nelly 7 months ago
@321123Nelly haha is that really a compliment :L
ubermanvirgil 7 months ago
196 people she is good
obryanjennifer 7 months ago
@obryanjennifer 19'8' people, she is good
aliciathehedgehog1 6 months ago
you are really good i would like to meet you one day
obryanjennifer 7 months ago
im a guy and ive made a cover of this.. can someone tell me how i went?
booom593 7 months ago
she making a weird face Lol
zazszd100 7 months ago
@lilstar774-Sie Deutsch?! so ist meine Schwester! Ich spreche ein wenig Deutsch aber auch. @idaAmanda-your so pretty! you actually look a little german-are you?! anyway-i believe your the one actually singing this-you have a very pretty voice!and no matter what anyone else says-keep on going-you'll make it far in life-get a good singing career. i know you will- 8D
zantonian7 7 months ago
the audio is so amazing thats y it doesnt sound like her ha....god u really know watt ur doing
76bigfish 7 months ago
woah ur really good!
UmiTTseaclan 7 months ago
U R GOOD "
arpb100 7 months ago
holy shizz balls. you good. o.o
MCRmyKilljoy10 7 months ago
are u not American? cuz i hear an accent! :p
capitolbass 7 months ago
Wow... u almost brang me too tears, ur amazing
didoleo15 7 months ago
ppl are just jealous, anyways i love it u have an amazing voice:DD
NanZee16 7 months ago
Dudes&dudettss,Why would she be a fake? Really?! No-Lifes -_-
Popcicle299 7 months ago
you are amazng i wish i could sing at least half as good!!!
GummieBear1996 7 months ago
to much advetisement crap on your video--distracting!
icicicles 7 months ago
damn
jordan13kjordan13k 7 months ago
You are very good. Although, sometimes your timbre sounds a little choked. Make sure you are opening up those airways and getting that beautiful tone ALL the time. It almost sounds like some of your tone is locked away in your chest. Make sure your using all of your air support and keep pushing through. Again, you are VERY good. Take it from a 4 year music major, you are doing quite well for yourself. Keep singing and never let your passion die. Good luck to you. :)
tbonejmac09 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
My brother is still drooling...
Wolfofgreek 8 months ago
amazing.
SiairraSings 8 months ago
you have a lovley voice it made me cry your amazing :)
Bronya1122 8 months ago
OMG!!!!! HOLY OMG I DONT EVEN KNOW!!! You sound soooo amazing!! keep it up for sure
xZmouseZx 8 months ago
your good, but dont listen to the others..they are all jealous!
12thaye 8 months ago
Sorry to say that but you are too cute for showbusines... It's like : first, there is your face and then the music but no one listen to the music because they are still in shock ;D
PigWithAWig 8 months ago
one thing annoys me, and thats your bottom lip, it sticks out to far
RawrrSaysAsh 8 months ago
me likey
JouniorGirl 8 months ago
not bad
roro1994sweet 8 months ago
I don't understand how people could say this was fake. oO
RavenxRobin101 8 months ago
its realy not fake ,and i can understand this by your voice.just some people cant hear the difference between notes,and voices!good job u have an amazing voice!
farfallinaG9 9 months ago
Of course is not fake. Your voice is pretty amazing!
NikaKede 9 months ago
You can sing and record karaoke to the original background tracks straight from your phone too with VOCOO.
MissThebestkaraoke 9 months ago
wow your awesome i suck compared to this
gothgirl1217 9 months ago
i have watched your other videos and i have to say I LOVE YOUR VOICE! good singing! <33 *_*
bombermure 9 months ago
amazing
michelangelka 9 months ago
you did great keep it up
iceman982004 9 months ago
Awesome!
TheLilzbaby 9 months ago
Cute
Smokecankill 9 months ago
Beautiful!
BreyerLuvr888 9 months ago
Your Voice Is Amazing!!!!! Dont listen to People Who Call You "Fake" They Probably Just Are Mad That they cant Sing Like you
MsCheeseCoffee 9 months ago
Awsome voice you have!!!! would like to here that live... would have been so very awsome!! :D
simson202020 9 months ago
Best cover i've watched so far :))) <3 great job!
jeccawalters 9 months ago
You're beautiful AND talented.. Sheesh, I'm jealous O~O
babynina9 9 months ago
@TheUsiikaa
It is real. Shut up and watch another video or leave YouTube. Got it? Good. Now, She sang good. You're jealous of her voice. Second of all, Don't watch it if you don't like it instead of bribing her down!
bluepool100 9 months ago
waaaw.!!!
You have such a good voice!
I love it. ;D
bonbonck 9 months ago
just WOOOOW *___* i love it!
cochondine 9 months ago
this is really good!
SweChic1997 9 months ago
why r ppl calling this fake??? i agree she SOUNDS like Amy but that's her real voice U CAN TELL!!!! stop calling it fake!!! @IdaAmanda u did great job don't listen to these stupid ppl ♥
chicarok32 9 months ago
if its so fake then why has she got the same voice in every video who exactly is she taking it from, people are are hating on your vieos idaamanda evy though because they dont have the wonderful voice you have so they feel the need to be bitter. I think you can go far in life because i truly beleive this is YOU singing and not anyone else.
rachoox12 9 months ago 52
@rachoox12 Thank you so much!!!! :)
IdaAmanda 9 months ago 13
@IdaAmanda HOLY CRAAAAP at first i thought u were lip syncing but then i heard the rest of ur vids! duude ur awsuuume!!
VFloresTalent 5 months ago 44
@rachoox12 YOU FAKE ! NOT AMANDA! btw you suck not fake ! haha love you amanda
Arabstain 9 months ago
@rachoox12
People that think this is Amy's voive obviously have no ear...same with those that cannot recognize that over very different songs by different singers, *her* voice is the same. She has a distictive timbre (and, I might add, an excellent one). Don't let them concern you, the only way this is a fake is if you have stashed a different singer out of camera range...or in you pocket or something ;p
Keep going, you have a future in front of you.
Sean
percuseanist 8 months ago
@rachoox12 i agree
jordan13kjordan13k 7 months ago
@rachoox12 for real they definitely is hating lol
NunuInvincible829 6 months ago
@rachoox12 if its u singing u only hve one voice
shamshamwoohoo1 5 months ago
you're good no matter what the others said.....:):):)
girlmind07 10 months ago
banging voice. good choice of song aswell.
MrDanDavison 10 months ago
<3
supremesinger98 10 months ago
Reallly gooodd voicceee.... wonderfulll
Anastasianienda 10 months ago
i want ur voiceeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
xXsammyluvXx 10 months ago
amy lee? this song is by Evanescence
Volkner01 10 months ago
@Volkner01 yes amy lee is the lead singer of evanescence
xXsammyluvXx 10 months ago