X factor Live Show 5 - Lucie Jones VS John and Edward

[Magakilika22]

How the HELL could Jedward go through instead of lucie ?!?!? Jedward are a JOKE! Lucie Jones is raw talent and should have won the whole X Factor! Simon Cowell put them through for pure publicity. What a selfish prick.

[toneboy101]

it was shocking that lucie went home to jedward most outrageous thing ever to happen on x factor , she should have won last year!!!

[SheWantsCoffee]

Can't blame Jedward for getting through. I feel really sorry for Lucie but wht's with people calling Jedward names. That's not fair. It was entirely Simon's decision.

[bennyboywwe]

have you noticed in 08 09 and 10 that whoever came 5th always comes as a shock to everyone and its always someone that is ver very good :L weird?

[PatricksSongs]

BASTARDS!

[20Honda03]

wtf, the gay cunts won it over Lucie....bloody kidding me.....whether its public or Simon, i thougt....no, i know lucie is a great singer.....fuck this show, not watching it no more

[xMischiefGalx]

I hated lucie from the start!!! she can't sing, yeas she had got the looks but the competition was about singing something she could not do

[sember68]

shame!!!!!!!!

[satu9001]

These people commenting don't seem to remember it was the public vote. It wasn't Simon's decision, he just left the choice to the public. The viewers chose Jedward over Lucy, no-one can deny that. And it isn't Simon's fault.

[jackyeah00]

@satu9001 It was definitely his decision. Dermot said ''Simon, Lucie or Jedward?'' Simon picked Jedward simple as. When she has 4x as much talent as those two

[ItsTesss]

Lucie deserved so much more to go trough then John and Edward!

[musicisinsideofme]

I swear, John and Edward are gay

With eachother

[SheWantsCoffee]

@musicisinsideofme Don't swear about things like that. You're only seeing things that u want to see and most of the time, wht u see is not true.

[lucyanna94]

Was gutted Lucie went, she has it all- the looks, the talent, the voice, personality. Worst decision Simon Cowell ever made. But she's fought back, going on Les Mis. She should've won the whole show, but maybe she's better doing West End, they usually do better than X Factor stars! Wish her luck in the future x x x <3

[liefssophie]

I was so mad when I saw this!

Simon crushed a girls dream, because he wants to laugh at the boys?

[littleliondog]

i wish lucie won and joe came 2nd. lucie wa the best and joe was just a little tiny bit less good than her. jedward r rubbish. sumtimes i fink joe is better than lucie tho, but other time si fink lucies betta than joe it depends.

[shaan46]

i like em both n BTW

LUCIE IS BETTER THAN STACEY

sorryyyy

[littleliondog]

i agree with you

[KnightWolfe2012]

john and edward can perform (if can call it that, some people do) we know that, but i thought this show was about singing which the boys cannot do

Lucie, has got the voice, personality, image, and i dont get why simon sent Lucie home.....he crushed an earnest girls' dream, and in turn her towns dream, for that is what she was to them.....LUCIE!!! I will work my way up and help you, fuck simon

[xXxScoutxXx]

Her voice isn't that good and Simon knew that. Do you really think he would send home someone who could make him money? Come on now.

John and Edward are the biggest thing to come out of this year. He was so right to save them.

[KnightWolfe2012]

if you thing they are the biggest thing.....you need to get out more

[lovemileyndppl]

IT WAS HARSH AND LITTRALLY EVERY1 WAS SUPPORTING HER AND BACKING HER UP SO SIMON CAN GO AWAY AND JEDWARDS PERFORMANC E WAS CRAP THEY WERE OUT OF TIMING AND DIDNT RLY KNOW THE KNOW THE DANCE ROUTINE AND I FEEL RRLY SORI 4 LUCIE..... HOPE U GET A RECORDIN CONTRACT AT SOME POINT CAUSE U WERE THE BEST THERE HAS EVER BEEN.:)sooo good luck

[xXxScoutxXx]

Are you kidding? EVERYONE was supporting her and backing her? LMAO. Why was she rock bottom of the votes then?

Hahaha

[lovemileyndppl]

i dont see y simon had 2 do that cause lucie was the best there ever was and he loved her and her performances and he hated jedward soooo i loveed luscie she was the best and it was cruel and i feel rlly sori 4 lucie sooo to lucie i hope u get a recording contract and i wish u good luck with ur life u were awsome and simon was rlly cruel about u and jedward and they didnt rlly know what they were doing so good luck..

[littleliondog]

nice comment :)

[lordtufty]

Ploughable fields

[ggattusoo]

Singer*

songs*

sorry am not English ^^

[ggattusoo]

I really didn't like what simon did....

( I think that he know that lucie is one of the best singers in the show and he was afriad NOT to win because of her.. coz she's the Real challenge to simon's singers)

so In order to win he just sucrefices a wonderful sing that may release sogs which all ppl will buy..

a MSG for lucie.. PLZ do like JLS and release ur album coz u already got fans ..

and am the #1....

Thanks for u ..and for the video uploader..

[dancer20gc]

I cant stand those freaking guys, they are horrible HORRIBLE!!! And i would buy music sang by lucie. :)

[xValeriexRitterx]

Love john and edward !!

[redrosedam]

you can totaly see that lucie new she was goin off when simon said im going to let the public decied poor lucie she was WAY better !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!