I also read the book and saw the film about 40 years ago!
What struck me most forcibly was that Ivan Denisovich, after a day in a life that many people would think was impossible to live through, felt that he had had a good day, It's truly a tribute to the human qualities of adaptability and optimism. It would have been easy to give up and die, but he adapted and survived, just like Solzhenitsyn who went on to leave us, in his literature, an extended testament to the cruelty of Stalin's regime.
@TheCoopz95 It is valid. Solzhenitsyn was a fine writer and he revealed the true face of a evil society. If you didn't see that when you were assigned the book to read then you either had your eyes closed or indulged in the same willful blindness that kept the Soviet system in power for 70 years.
this book is a gem. it is very grim and bleak and harrowing yet there is a fundamental humanity to it that is inexplicably uplifting. i think A.S. was saying that there was truly a socialist impulse for the good in people -- it came out only in the grimmest of conditions. quite a masterful novel
1) What's the infirmary like? I doubt there'd be sexy nurses to chase. 2) Would a zek have to make up the days he's out sick? 3) Were the guards faggots? There are no women around. 4) How could a zek survive even 1 day in a cell that's -27? 5) Why weren't the zeks allowed to wear any extra clothes when they went out to work? One of the zeks got 10 days in a cell for questioning the guards when they were told to take off their shirts.
The filth, hopelessness and oppression is well adapted in this version. If the British accents get you down, can't do nothin' for you. That's like saying HBO Rome is crap because they're not speaking Italian.
can anyone help me with a thesis statement for a paper based on the Dehumanizaion theory applied to One Day In The Life Of Ivan Denisovich (the book, haven't seen the movie yet) PLEASEEE??!?!?!?!
I wonder why western people love to look at the life of the Soviet criminals?? For you, it exotic? You do not have their criminals? You have no prisons?
@gukow1 dumbass. it shows how life was like in the labour camp during ths soviet times; 1951. and Shukhov was not a criminal, he did absolutely nothing and this is the fucking point of the movie -.-
I do not think that the British can reliably show the life in Soviet labor camps. They do not know much. Therefore, this film is not a benchmark of real life. Errors in the judicial system exist in any state. In the United States or Britain, too, could be imprisoned an innocent man. In my opinion this film is a dull and meaningless. He may like to the only stupid snobs.
I say what I think of this film. I do not care what you think of me. You do not know me. If you're not a snob, then you tell me why this movie is fine?
unfortunately movie doesnt taste like the book for example in the book the man who looks at the thermometer originally says "how can i warm it with my breath in this fucking cold." in the book there are so many cusses and a naturalist manner which make the book very effective and also funny.this book is not a tradgedy but it is a fight of a man which has become senseless and steady as a rock as a result of stalin's tyranny.
Wonder how long I could have lasted there before I cried for my mommy, ha ha. She would have probably been in the next compound, so very evil those places were.
You're right. I can't believe these fucking idiots. They go and make one of the best movies ever. Based on one of the greatest books ever written, then they go and fuck it all up by casting an actor that can't pronounce Kolya correctly. Fuck this shit.. they should be shot... I'm not watching the rest of this..
Hi! I'm sarcasm do I know you?
I'm just messing with ya. This movie is great! Read the book too if you have the time.
@Allanlegacy43 If there is no wind you can walk, sit and smoke a cigarette, make some works with many attentions. Better 37 below than 40 positive for working. This is sure. But without wind. If there is wind, you cannot do anything, my friend. Ah..remember: do not touch any metal like iron at 37 below: the skin of you fingers will be damaged.
Thanks for this video. I saw this fim in 1971 at a cinema I worked at as a projectionist, it ran for 3 or 4 weeks. How the soviets treated what they interpreted to be a theat to the nation, and that happened in fairly recent history.
thanks for posting this...I have been looking for this one for years.....can't find it anywhere on the net...haven't seen it since the 70's....brilliant film...awesome!
This opening credit scene is so totally like a sci-fi movie where the space-craft hovers in to dock with the space-station.
Except for the fact the outer-space-station is actually a Siberian Stalinist prison camp, and everyone involved in this narrative is utterly totally doomed.
I also read the book and saw the film about 40 years ago!
What struck me most forcibly was that Ivan Denisovich, after a day in a life that many people would think was impossible to live through, felt that he had had a good day, It's truly a tribute to the human qualities of adaptability and optimism. It would have been easy to give up and die, but he adapted and survived, just like Solzhenitsyn who went on to leave us, in his literature, an extended testament to the cruelty of Stalin's regime.
JohnPreedy 4 days ago
This is what socialism/communism looks like, yet the masses continue to shout for it.
ecnerwal999 5 days ago
I have to read this for english and it sucks balls....
TheCoopz95 3 weeks ago
@TheCoopz95 Next time try reading it with your eyes open.
twobluehorses 2 weeks ago in playlist One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, Gulag & Stalin
@twobluehorses Next time try having a valid opinion
TheCoopz95 1 week ago
@TheCoopz95 It is valid. Solzhenitsyn was a fine writer and he revealed the true face of a evil society. If you didn't see that when you were assigned the book to read then you either had your eyes closed or indulged in the same willful blindness that kept the Soviet system in power for 70 years.
twobluehorses 1 week ago
Thank you so much for uploading this stark, brilliant film. It's been 39 years since I last saw it. It has haunted me all these years.
lyrensutz 1 month ago
Ever clean the heads on your VCR?
mcleanartists 1 month ago
this book is a gem. it is very grim and bleak and harrowing yet there is a fundamental humanity to it that is inexplicably uplifting. i think A.S. was saying that there was truly a socialist impulse for the good in people -- it came out only in the grimmest of conditions. quite a masterful novel
BluesHonkey 2 months ago
Man, i'd rather be killed then live like that.
ifithurtsgo2church 3 months ago
Thank you greatly for this! Haven't seen this film for a long, long time.
speculativeboy 3 months ago
boring book
griffman3210 4 months ago
There werent any pictures or portraits of stalin in gulag.
Prisoners were regarded as not comrades and not allowed them.
zenoist2 4 months ago
Questions:
1) What's the infirmary like? I doubt there'd be sexy nurses to chase. 2) Would a zek have to make up the days he's out sick? 3) Were the guards faggots? There are no women around. 4) How could a zek survive even 1 day in a cell that's -27? 5) Why weren't the zeks allowed to wear any extra clothes when they went out to work? One of the zeks got 10 days in a cell for questioning the guards when they were told to take off their shirts.
This is an unforgettable movie.
unclejuniorsoprano 4 months ago
The filth, hopelessness and oppression is well adapted in this version. If the British accents get you down, can't do nothin' for you. That's like saying HBO Rome is crap because they're not speaking Italian.
jonnyqwst 5 months ago
what's the yellow stuf the Shukhov is eating?
brownflowerable 5 months ago
can anyone help me with a thesis statement for a paper based on the Dehumanizaion theory applied to One Day In The Life Of Ivan Denisovich (the book, haven't seen the movie yet) PLEASEEE??!?!?!?!
JillianValle 5 months ago
@JillianValle Um, ya. Just take a look at the way the prisoners were treated... there's your thesis.
ultramarine218 4 months ago
The real Ivan would never have overlooked a fish eye! Preposterous!
joelmorley5 6 months ago
its hard to watch when they all have british accents
worstedcdogg 6 months ago
Ugh.... Not looking forward to reading this for English... :/
TheChandlerLindsey 6 months ago
@TheChandlerLindsey Me either. :/
haha. Test tomorrow!
chave015 6 months ago
I'm reading this book for honors history
Armydude5678 7 months ago
READ THE BOOK IT'S THE GREATEST BOOK EVER WRITTEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
giji777 7 months ago
40 below zero and no work. Should be 50 below zero. Tarts!
grandslam1998 7 months ago
Thanks a lot! I've been wanting to see this movie for ages!
TrompelaMort1989 8 months ago
Great to see this film again. Thanks very much for uploading, really enjoyed it. I wish they would release it on DVD, it's a classic.
WizzSpell 9 months ago
I wonder why western people love to look at the life of the Soviet criminals?? For you, it exotic? You do not have their criminals? You have no prisons?
gukow1 10 months ago
@gukow1 Italian "Gulag" movie:
watch?v=LueEQhRIDQo
sergiorgio2000 9 months ago
@gukow1 dumbass. it shows how life was like in the labour camp during ths soviet times; 1951. and Shukhov was not a criminal, he did absolutely nothing and this is the fucking point of the movie -.-
CLnomnom 8 months ago
@CLnomnom
I do not think that the British can reliably show the life in Soviet labor camps. They do not know much. Therefore, this film is not a benchmark of real life. Errors in the judicial system exist in any state. In the United States or Britain, too, could be imprisoned an innocent man. In my opinion this film is a dull and meaningless. He may like to the only stupid snobs.
gukow1 8 months ago
@gukow1 You sound like a snob to me. I think you may be dull and meaningless? Take a good look at yourself. This really is a fine film!
grandslam1998 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@grandslam1998
I say what I think of this film. I do not care what you think of me. You do not know me. If you're not a snob, then you tell me why this movie is fine?
gukow1 7 months ago
@CLnomnom Ignore trolles as we do in Russia. They are helpless.
KseniaBar 8 months ago
shut up @jakdaxter6
mslaughter23 10 months ago
actually, "Колыма́". I've lost elder family in the Gulag. So because you've read a book you know? FUCK YOU jakaxter6
invinoveritas1221 11 months ago
wow, sometimes something is so obscure that there is no room for sarcasm. and it's kolyma you fucking jackass.
invinoveritas1221 11 months ago
Many thanks for this :)
dubmeisterdeluxe 11 months ago
I finished reading the book about 4 months ago....I liked it, but it was kind of bland...kind of boring really. I'm glad I read it though.
sotoj159 1 year ago
This is mentioned in Midnight Express ( book ). Always been curious. Thanks uploader.
Noodles37UK 1 year ago
unfortunately movie doesnt taste like the book for example in the book the man who looks at the thermometer originally says "how can i warm it with my breath in this fucking cold." in the book there are so many cusses and a naturalist manner which make the book very effective and also funny.this book is not a tradgedy but it is a fight of a man which has become senseless and steady as a rock as a result of stalin's tyranny.
shamil84 1 year ago
asshole stalin's shit
shamil84 1 year ago
The great Tom Courtenay.
HeathenLoveGod 1 year ago
Unbelievable book.
Read it for honors english.
isabell805 1 year ago
Wonder how long I could have lasted there before I cried for my mommy, ha ha. She would have probably been in the next compound, so very evil those places were.
Allanlegacy43 1 year ago
Wow. This is not as i imagined Suhov to be like. Not at all.
esamarkuc 1 year ago
It would be nice if they actually got an actor that could pronounce Kolya correctly
jakdaxter6 1 year ago
@jakdaxter6
You're right. I can't believe these fucking idiots. They go and make one of the best movies ever. Based on one of the greatest books ever written, then they go and fuck it all up by casting an actor that can't pronounce Kolya correctly. Fuck this shit.. they should be shot... I'm not watching the rest of this..
Hi! I'm sarcasm do I know you?
I'm just messing with ya. This movie is great! Read the book too if you have the time.
zombiejon 1 year ago 8
@zombiejon Talk tidy. Feel the words!
grandslam1998 7 months ago
37 below, dam I couldnt even think in that cold.
Allanlegacy43 1 year ago
@Allanlegacy43 If there is no wind you can walk, sit and smoke a cigarette, make some works with many attentions. Better 37 below than 40 positive for working. This is sure. But without wind. If there is wind, you cannot do anything, my friend. Ah..remember: do not touch any metal like iron at 37 below: the skin of you fingers will be damaged.
halsamdu 1 year ago
Shukhov looks like Sam Worthington
rustaayy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
one of my favorite books
guionlawes 1 year ago
one of my favorite books
guionlawes 1 year ago
Thanks for this video. I saw this fim in 1971 at a cinema I worked at as a projectionist, it ran for 3 or 4 weeks. How the soviets treated what they interpreted to be a theat to the nation, and that happened in fairly recent history.
Pavilion1078 1 year ago
thanks for posting this...I have been looking for this one for years.....can't find it anywhere on the net...haven't seen it since the 70's....brilliant film...awesome!
ronbro77 2 years ago
I think the original stared Tom Cortney, but the trailer suggest a new remake. But I'd like to see both
Flyingwolf46 2 years ago
Ih sorry mate it IS Tom
Flyingwolf46 2 years ago
But it's still a good day to all concerned.
greygue 2 years ago
This opening credit scene is so totally like a sci-fi movie where the space-craft hovers in to dock with the space-station.
Except for the fact the outer-space-station is actually a Siberian Stalinist prison camp, and everyone involved in this narrative is utterly totally doomed.
greygue 2 years ago 4
thanks
ladiesmutman 2 years ago