Added: 5 years ago
From: lostalex77
Views: 53,453
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (558)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Zero is not a speed metal song stick to ur Christian rock crap

  • @Betterthanieverknew homophobia won't be tolerated. goodbye.

  • @24014dp misogyny won't be tolerated. goodbye.

  • @Alkalinetrioreligion homophobia won't be tolerated. goodbye.

  • Cool

  • I'm huge Ev fan, obviously not her best cover... but still good

  • btw: kinda says it right there ^ derp derp

  • i thought it was a pretty okay cover aye.

  • I actually like this song by her after I listined to it a few times... ^^

  • @finalrelm this song isn't by her... is a smashing pumpkins song. look it up

  • @MeYouDisgust okay dumb ass think I don't know that? obviously she had a connection with it and sang it, don't treat me like a child I was just giving my two cents and honestly, get over yourself, :) thanks

  • @finalrelm "Don't treat me like a child"... What?

  • ....just liked the double pedal drumming at the end.

    as for the rest of the song, pf not good imo

  • wow this is horrible

  • totaly shit

  • i aam sorry to say this, but not good, no one can do billy justice :(

  • Lol, I kinda like it.

  • doesnt metter whatever you say i like it......

  • I wonder if she realises she's not the only female vocalist in a band. Lacuna Coil... Flyleaf..... Arch Enemy.... Walls Of Jericho..... Amy Lee needs to think before talking.

  • shit, relax your not perfect, neither am I, nor anyone else. People make mistakes, RELAX

  • I am relaxed xD

  • she said she's the only female artist in that group of performances (was it ozfeast or something?) (but no other female vocalists were there...It was no referance to in all the world it was in that event,)

  • I like Evanescence and The Smashing Pumpkins, was expecting this to be good but it sucked. She was trying to shout instead of using her actual good singing voice that would of still butchered the song horribly. The best Evanescence could do is leave covering Smashing Pumpkins to bands that could do SP justice....... im not an Evanescence hater but this cover really is awful.

  • @OneCrazyMuthaFucka i concur.

  • @OneCrazyMuthaFucka you have all the reason

  • WTF I thought this was going to be good but it's terrible. One of the worst covers ever. Smashing Pumpkins are way better. Shame that it's only Billy now.

  • Huge Evanescence fan and Huge Pumpkins fan... and that cover didnt do either of them any favours!

  • you like evanescence...don't talk

  • Comment removed

  • YOU PIECES OF SHIT!, I used to like this band but they just destroyed this song.....

  • i actually kinda like evanescence but that was a pretty poorly sung cover... that was totally devoid of any emotion and pretty much monotone the whole way through. this girl has a voice but she sure didn't use it here.

  • u dumbass bitch!

    u don't even know what the fuck emo means, ur just one of those poser idiots who listens to fake wanna b rock

    n u are a fucking hater who listens to shit so called "music"...? evanescence is music and they still made this crappy song a lot better!!!

    so FUCK YOU u SHIT BAG

    n suck a big dick!

  • if smashing pumpkins is "fake wanna be rock" , then why is this band that you seem to like so much covering their music. clearly they have some respect for the smashing pumpkins if they were compelled to play their music. i listened to evanescense when i was like 11 because it was "catchy" and certainly not because i knew good music... btw this video nearly ruined a good song for me.

  • but that doesn't mean that people like u, the dude who posted this and all the people who are supporting "the band u like so much" have to insult evanescencence

  • Don't get all righteous and ethical. The only reason i decided to insult your band was because you insulted my band. to quote you, "smashing pumpkins fucking SUCKS!! really bad!". you didnt even back that up. At least i my insult had some validity. Maybe I would consider this cover if the drummer wasnt using consant fucking double bass pedal and if the guitar sounded decent. Plus the singer sounds like my four year old cousin having a temper tantrum.

  • i said that stuff about ur silly little band because there was all these haters talking crap about evanescence, even the dumbass who posted thia video was talking smack!! who the HELL r u anyways? u weren't the person i was arguing with to begin with

  • who am I? Lets just say that I am someone with a decent taste in music, unlike you who enjoys listening to shitty goth pop ripp-off music. And by the way when you argue with a fellow pumpkins fan you are arguing with me so yes, you were arguing with me in the first place.

  • alright! i admit, i started the arguement

    but ya idiotic pumkin fans started the pussy shit talk! so do me a favor and shut the fuck up BITCH!!

    don't even bother to reply

    ur wasting my time!

  • respeto a Evanescence pero sinceramente no me gusto ese cover y descompuzo muy feo la canciòn

  • Evanescence is a good band and all but

    I don't Amy Lee's voice is right for this particular song.

  • NO WORDS.

    Terrible.

    I think that Billy Corgan should do something to make sure that something like this WILL NOT HAPPEN again.

  • I love Evanescence, but honestly...I'm really not into this cover. Amy's got a gorgeous voice, but it's not right for this song. The Pumpkin's version is far superior.

  • for me Amy gives the song the dimension it always deserve, I get bored with the pumpkins version, just the 4/4 taa taa taa,

    this is great

  • Third, only because is faster doesn't mean it's better. The SP version it's in that tempo for a particular reason and meaning. Evanescense do it faster only because they want to and try to pass like a rock band, wich they are not AT ALL.

  • yes thank u! i agree with u

  • "im the only girl up here out of all the bands" what a ugly cunt your singing is horse shit thats how you have to stand out im a fucking girl. way to ruin a good fucking song

  • this version rocks, the pumpkins one is kind of boring cause it's slow and the singing is not intense like amy's

  • First of all. The original versions are always better than the covers. Otherwise no-one would do a cover of the first song. Duhhh!

  • not worthy to sing billy Corgan songs

  • she seems like an ok performer but she really isnt suited to sing zero. that just sounded terrible. plain terrible.

  • Out of tune!

  • the song is a tune below the standard tuning in order to suit amy's voice, you dont know about music, the pumpkins is half tune below standard like many of their songs

  • Second, i know that this version of the song is in a different key, it's pretty obvoius. But still she is incredibly out of tune, pitchy and flat pretty much all the time.

  • Lostalex77 I totally disagree, Amy Lee is an amazing performer with fantastic vodals and once again gives an excellent performance.

  • Screw all of you. Amy rocked it hard fucking core!

  • Ha... because Amy is soooooo fucking great :D

  • dumb bitch.

  • Ew, way to kill the song.

  • Am I the only one that loves this cover?

  • no i love this cover too

  • no... I love it toooooo !

  • No, I love it too

  • A very patetic performance. Horrible vocals..horrible accompaniment. So distant from the good quality of the original song.

  • You are talking shit

  • To all the people who say this band isn't allowed to do this cover you are just proving it's art, and if you say it sucks, okey art is in the eye of the beholder and real artists don't care about what you or I say, they do whatever the fuck they want.

  • The tempo is way too fast.

  • She sings so awsome!!!! <3

  • sucks

  • Horrendous.

  • I can't believe they could take a song that was so good to start with and make it this bad

    WHY

  • you kno wat people i sick of people trashing other bands doing covers for bands seriously apparently some people like it i mean they wouldnt try if nobody likes them and WHO ASKED YOU ANYWAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! if you dont like it then go away and dont listen to it ok!

  • you ait a chick, you are a tard.

  • I think this song is great!  I love it, great job Amy Hartzler!

  • What a shit attempt at covering such a great song by SP

  • lool the song by smashing pumpkin is too slow the cover by Evanescence is really really better !! LovE Amy forEvEr !!

  • Aint that the fucking truth, Evanescence isn't as good as everyone thinks, she was only good because it was a different sound. She's actually a terrible singer.

  • If she's not as good as everybody thinks how is she only GOOD for having a diffrent sound. If you don't like the band, ok but atleast express it in an inteligent way.

  • Not my fault you're too retarded to understand an intelligent comment.

    One can suck but have a different sound the the plastic music the media feeds everyone.

  • ahhh my ears! noooooo! what have you done? this is horrible! pumpkins rule! yeah billy!

  • my god this is horrible why would they insult the pumpkins like this

  • way to shovel shit in peoples ear u jackass. this is most probably what led Darcy started smoking crack cocaine.

  • NO, Darcy smoked crack because she is stupid.

  • it sucks thiis so HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i think she did an awesome job...afterall, this is usually a song sung by a GUY. give the girl some props...we all probably suck compared to her anyday. i think she did a wonderful job on this song. :] go amy!

  • ummm no she didnt

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOO.......NOOOOOOOOO­O....NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

    shes killed it ......

    uttlerly killed it............

    SMASHING PUMPKINS are so much better

  • Wow. She did a really bad job, and I usually like her, but nobody can mess with the pumpkins.

  • Yeah... right. You know I should've seen, after all that Evanescence has crapped into CDs over the years, they can totally pull off Smashing Pumpkins.

    SURE. I don't think I've ever been so sarcastic in my LIFE.

  • oh....kay. You know what, I guess I'm fucked, cause this SUCKED. Better than I expected, but terrifying, none the less. They need to learn how to keep tempo. SMASHING PUMPKINS FOREVER!!!!!

    Mrs. Corgan-Way

  • yeah you wish!no one can measure up to the pumpkins still i won't be a very big bitch and i'll just say nice try appreciate the effort

  • embarrassing to pumpkins

  • WHAT AN ASSLOAD OF F...

  • i love it! amy lee rocks! she has got it goin on!

  • Fuck all who thinks this sucks. This is an awesome cover, Amy Lee has an amazing voice and yeah, she CAN handle "real" rock songs. Both of her CDs are filled with real rock songs that became bestsellers. The rest of the band also rocks. EVANESCENCE FOREVER!!!

  • I don't like Evanescence, I think Amy Lee has a great voice, but she can't handle REAL rock songs, besides, it's WAY too fast and the solo is pathetic this SUCKS...

  • yall need to stop hatin evanescence is the best yay

  • smashing pumpkins rock

    i like evanescence but she cant handle billy corgans voice, the rest of the band are doing great, even the drummer who is shit

  • anyways i still LOVE Ev n mostly Amy Lee shes the BEST!!! n i seen this vid b4 n she didnt did that bd cuz ppl wer enjoying it n bsides EXACTLY THATS NOT A EV SONG! so... i still love Ev :)

  • SMASHING PUMPKINS FOREVER!!!!!!!!!

  • WOO HOOO!!!! SP 4EVR!! thats so gotta be my vanity plate... lol

  • BOOOOOOOOO evanescence sucked :(. SMASHING PUMPKINS ROCK AND THEY RULE THAT SONG!!!

  • i think this sounds kind'a good, however it would sound better if she wasn't trying to alter her voice. and where was this preformance?

  • Awful girl, Awful affected singgin'.. Awful shit; sorry: Corgan's a genious; Amy Lee SUCKS.

  • Not really. She rocks, Corgan though.....

  • hell naw i like this verison better sounds alot betta

  • well, your entitled to your opinion :-D. I won't be hostile, im not like that... just letting you know!

  • she killed it, then suffered to necrophelia... it sucked.. she needs to realize that Billy COrgan is the only one who can sing like himself (weird wording, but you get it...)

  • She revived it you moron cause I wouldn't listen to Billy Corgan live to save my life (Of course the sound of him live might kill me anyways)

  • i really like enanesence and I think amy lee is extrodinarilly talented.

    But man...this is just dirt

  • horrible... amy killed my favorite song

  • ew this song is gross

    her voice sounds terrible trying to imitate billy corgan

    its just bad in general

  • god she ruined the song.

  • Fuck, this is awful.

  • There's a HUGE gap between her voice and this song, they don't match. Too bad, she's good when performing her own songs.

  • this version sucks... the version of the smashing is just perfect

  • She can't touch the Pumpkins. Evanescence is pretty good, but

  • Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooo

  • omg, that couldn't have sucked any worse. they can't touch the pumpkins.

  • Not the voice for that song..

  • Hmmmm.... Not bad....

  • she sux balls

  • that was completely bizarre.

    stick to ur own songs, goth-chick.

  • oh man. evanescence trying to do the smashing pumpkins! that makes me sick.

    that girl sucks and so does her lame ass band.

  • wow, she fucked it up so bad, she has no talent. sing your own songs bitch.

  • Amy Lee sings this better than the actual real version!!!!

  • total shitbag munching fuckheads!

  • i think she doesnt have a rock voice, she sounds so "wanabee", to much band for her, i think she could do better only with her voice and a mellow piano song

  • complete bullshit

  • The pumpkin's voices annoy me... :\

  • ...im gonna go listen to the original now.

  • High five!

  • Wow. This version sucks. The drummer started off at like twice the speed it should be. They need to be kicked in the face. A for effort though.

  • HELL NO!!! HELL NO!!! that song was great and never needed to be changed!!! wtf, and if it was going to be sung by someone else it certainly shouldn't have been here, theres so many things wrong with this i dont know where to begin >< she now pisses me off

  • dude, this version is sooo much better, smashing pumpkins is good at their instruments for sure, but there singer sounds like a retarted cow having it's balls ripped off by a garden hoe

  • can you leave me please in peace with your shit childish behavior? Everybody has an other taste fuckin hell >_> grow up O.o I just think that the version from Smashing Pumpkins is to slow. And he sounds like a sick cat. I like it fast and Amy Lee does is really good...but..who cares..? I guess..you small child do O_o

  • I think this is a fuckin great version of Zero..it's better than the original..in my eyes...

    just want to headbang and flip completely out :)

  • in your eyes...i'm guessin your blind?

  • OH DEAR. =/

    Pumpkins Rule

    Evanescence apparently, do not.

  • she killed perfectly good song an ownage song at that!!!!!!!!

  • Someone please put this girl out of her misery and let her know she can't sing. Those high notes are awful.

  • the way the guitar riff is played is not ment to be played this fast it looses its feel and amy lee is singing way of key and shes out of breath alot ya this really sucks ass

  • what a crap!and this silly bitch better shut up!de la merde!sp forever,hope they haven't heard this shit!

  • I would like to say that evanescense is not a good band. and this cover was such a bad idea.

  • evanescence is a good band, but they totally fucked this song up... *sigh*

  • I hope smashing pumkins did not get to see this...what got into her?this really sucks!

  • The whole time I was waiting for someone to throw a rock.

  • Mrr. I don't think it's as bad as it's being made out to be. Certainly a far cry from the original, and I think she could do it and do it a lot better than here, but this isn't the worst they've done. Hell, this isn't the worst Pumpkins cover done (for that, see Panic at the Disco's tragically soulless attempt at Tonight, Tonight).

    Not great, but not horrible.

  • Yeah i've seen the panic at the disco covering tonight tonight. i cringed at first. it sounds so wrong.

  • ruin a fuckin classic wont ya! that fucking sucks

  • Wow did that suck.....

  • kill this grou please....it only makes shit just like the cover of Thoughtless from KoRn....SHUT UP BITCH!

  • damn that was so bad i think i dislike the smashing pumpkins now for putting a song out that would eventually get killed buy some stupid ass band named evanescence. more chicks up there? shit if its gonna be like that, we're gonna have to re-write the wemons rights act's... HAHAHAHHAA

  • An horrible cover

  • that drummer kicked lopez ass

  • WHAT THE FUCK

  • If Amy Lee is anything to go by then I think we need less females 'up there'. Jeez! That was awful, butchering a classic.

  • oh gods, i saw this on tv...nearly gagged.

  • monkey turds

  • This is shit compared to the original..

  • Let Amy fucking Lee burn in hell for ruining this song!!

    I'm going to have a fucking nightmare now! Thanks alot!

  • as a longtime loyal sp fan, im offended. if only i could sue amy lee for such abuse..sp really should

  • fuck this fucking stupid amy.......she really thinks that she´ve got billy's attitude....she should be in jail

  • "I'm the only chick up here."

    I guess she forgot to mention how much that her band sounds like Lacuna Coil? But worse.

  • she meant the only chick playing that concert. and they don't sound like lacuna coil.

  • Yeah, that's true.....was just trying to make a point.

    Anyway, this cover fucking sucked balls.

  • well NO they sound NOTHING like Lacuna Coil. and all of you kids who are bashing amy lee for covering this song may be pissed off that she didnt do the best job, but there are better versions with her performing this song. and i think you should all take it easy on her because there are prolly a million other bands out there that have covered this song and sucked way worse than she could have, and Lacuna Coil DO NOT fucking suck.

  • True, Lacuna Coil effing owns

  • They don't sound like Lacua Coil. There are similarities but there not a Lacuna Coil rip off.

  • u know....the music was good, but amy............she tried to hard to change her voice to something it's not...she kept on switching between her eerie vocals and something that sounds like avril lavigne(not bashing I still dig both those chicks) but it would have probably been more favorable if she kept the same tone

  • i don't wanna get more girls up there if they sound like that id be waiting on the stage with a shotgun >=D

  • Holy. Fuck.

    Alright. Amy Lee SERIOUSLY needs to be punched in the face for this. She butchered one of my favourite songs.

    She sounds like she's trying to fuck a horse up the ass.

    You have to know what you're doing to be able to cover a Smashing Pumpkins song.

    In Bathing Light, on the other had. ^_^; Did an amazing job with "Wound".

  • I'm not gonna lie, this BLOWS! I am an Evanescence fan, and an Amy Lee fan... but this sucks hardcore. They could have done something bad ass with it. I got my hopes up, but to no avail.

  • it's a shit (amy)she cant sing while shes jumping..so give it up!.. the music is not bad..but a little bit faster..

  • sometimes covering should be forbidden...

  • fuck this shit!!!!

  • Evanescence HAD KILLED Smashing Pumpkins with her cover voice. It's more perfect than smashing pumpkins haha

  • poor billy...

  • This

    is

    horrible

    LOL