Added: 2 years ago
From: nnharbi
Views: 289,171
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (583)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @Shadylover5921 It was Paul Rodgers singing on "Beautuful." Eminem sampled the live version from a live CD that Paul Rodgers did with Queen. If you'd look at the credits of the song, you'd see that. I'm a huge Eminem fan, and "Beautiful" Iis what brought me here, but Queen + Paul Rodgers deserve credit too. And yes, the section that Eminem used in the song was edited to match the pitch of the rest of the song.

  • Paul can sing. Eminem couldn't sell his soul to the devil to be able to sing this good. That's why he's a rapper. So if Eminem brought you to this video piss off.

  • well this was disappointing..

  • @Shadylover5921 If you cant recognise that thats Pauls voice on the song beautiful, you need too clean your ears, massively.

  • @HipsterMcfunk1990 If you can't hear that it sounds exactly like Eminem's voice on the song beautiful, then you need to clean your ears as well lol

  • @Shadylover5921 are you tapped in the head? Its a paul rodgers dub...

  • @HipsterMcfunk1990 Do you know Eminem's voice as well as I do? If you don't, then you can't say that it doesn't sound like Eminem. Because it sounds JUST like him

  • @Shadylover5921 is this bloke on crack or what?

  • @HipsterMcfunk1990 I'm brunette and far from stupid. Instead of wasting your time typing out shit like that, at least try to actually converse... If you aren't a huge Eminem fan then you don't hear it. Go listen to the song Beautiful by Eminem it sounds like Eminem and I could get so many other big Eminem fans to say that it sounds just like him as well. Eminem sings the chorus of that song too, and the lines that Paul Rodgers supposedly sings sounds exactly like the voice in the chorus.

  • Estoy Aqi por Eminem :'(

  • I came here because I saw Paul singing it before Tie Your Mother Down at a Queen + Paul Rodgers gig!

  • Okay I came here because of Eminem, yes, but I HAVE A QUESTION Does Paul Rodgers sing the intro and outro in the Eminem song, Beautiful? Because it sounds like Eminem, but some people say it's Paul Rodgers, and some people say it's Eminem.

  • @Shadylover5921 eminem might as well be a singer if that was him

  • @Shadylover5921 it is obviously NOT eminem's voice.

  • @oneonta310 ?? But on the song Beautiful it doesn't even sound like this guy, it sounds just like Eminem.

  • @Shadylover5921 That's because the pitch was changed to be on the right key.

  • Every Post here Have "eminem" on it .___.

  • Its a guitarist (Paul Rogers) from Queen people, SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!

  • @TheMykcal Brian May is the guitarist from Queen, just saying...

  • ey, y'all dawgs, eminem used this on beautiful, so what? people who came here, want to see comments about this song, not of em's beautiful. i like eminem, but this song isn't eminem's

  • If you don't know which side of the bed to piss on....Eminem brought you here

  • I heard this before Eminem used it.

  • i think eminem singing the chorus in "beautiful" sounds way better!!

  • thumbs up if good taste of music brought you here not eminem

  • Comment removed

  • it shouldnt matter who brought us here..

    this song is incredible and eminem is also a talented person///so how about we shut up and enjoy the music alright??

  • i fucking LOVE Bad Company & this song & when I found out that Paul Rodgers was the lead singer of Bad Co. I was like,"damn i got great taste" :D

  • @shannonsjohnson69 good for you

  • This song kinda sums up where I am in life right now. Sadly.

  • Queen and Eminem my two favorite artist ever!

  • Its a FUCKING sample you stupid IDIOTS, rappers and artist do it all the time. Its not about whos version sounds better.

  • @Prozspect0 so what

  • @xx2n23 i say Both of them are Great and i say FUCK YOU if you say f--- EmiNem

  • love both versions !! ems ment alot to me when it came out in 2009 i was in a shitting job i hated and close to the edge, listening to it on the bus with my headphones helped me kinda :)

  • 0:42 "I'm just so f____ depressed..."

  • both versions are great

  • Everyone;s saying eminems is better but eminem got it from this guy. and its not a fucking competition. if you think music should be categorized or labeled as competition or treat it like a competition and judge and rate two completely style then your not a fan of music.

  • @xx2n23 ...

  • thumbs up if eminem sent you here :)

  • toooo short :(

  • Lmao, my comment a year ago on page 14, has 1047 thumbs ups.

  • watch this vid because eminem used it in his song-beautiful ~

  • @goldeneye007man do it.

  • Eminem brought all of us here

  • @fabledogify no.I like Eminem,but I knew this song because of Queen+Paul Rodgers!

  • @fabledogify Uh... no, I'm here for Brian May's guitar and Paul's voice.

  • @fabledogify No. Shut up.

  • @Phillippousi your just mad that your the minority, even though I dig this song too

  • @fabledogify Indeed.

  • @fabledogify Of course not, there's a lot of Queen fans even without Freddie Mercury

  • @Reivazo Eminem brought me here. Lol shut the fuck up.

  • @fabledogify Yea lol

  • Not the best, but ok.

  • thumbs up if eminem brought you here. Thats one of the many great things about hip hop and samples. they take you to songs you will never hear in your life.

  • im just so fuckin depressed, i just cant seem to get this off my chest

  • Eminem!

  • why would this be better than em's? they're two totally different songs. no way to compare the two really. your all dumb for even trying to.

  • I think we should be willing to really respect Eminem for putting this into one of his most emotional songs. This song must have been one that really spoke to him on a deeper level, and for him to add it shows that he's not just a rhyming-puppet, but rather an open minded musician. Props.

  • Eminem's version is much better but this is okay

  • @EmileIsNoble lol respect ur opinion, but on the guitar is mister bryan may from queen says it all.

  • @EmileIsNoble Eminem didnt do a version. He just used Pauls vocals for his song.

  • this version is way better than eminem's crap

  • there is no way, to be better than eminem. And there'll never be a way....

  • This song is way better in Eminem's song "Beautiful" ,all though I still like it :)

  • thumbs up if eminem used this song for his beautiful song and got permission to do it so its not better its really the same....

  • @Ganzuji em is a LEGEND

  • @Ganzuji

    what is wrong with ppl like you? Eminem just took a sample of this song. Eminem's beautiful is a song of its own its not a cover.

  • eminem used it in a very good way (Y)

  • @jugglerkkev The only reason you got to the top is because you showed boobs... but I guess that's the way most people do :)

  • @jugglerkkev Indeed he did.

  • @jugglerkkev because hes the king of sampling

  • @jugglerkkev Eminem`s version is better :))

  • @crocolea agreed

  • i trying to find version from beautiful, its better but i cant find it :(

  • @LemanSSJ

    what do you mean? it is the version of Eminem's Beautiful he just chopped and screwed it like the rappers do it with most samples.

  • who the fuck dislike this thous 15 people are fucking retarded

    this song is so beautiful

  • im so glad Em used this, it made me find this beautiful song :)

  • This song is great, I find the best songs because of rap samples(eminem song), I thing most songs should not be touched, but Eminem made this sample so good.

  • I wonder who turned Marshall onto this one originally. Thanks for the upload. big brian may fan here anyways, but never heard this before - and cant remember paul rodgers at all, thanks again.. ox

  • Paul Rodgers should be proud that EMINEM took his song

  • Eminem made this a work of art...

  • @Ocie7 How did he make this a work of art? It was already a work of art.

  • @swegirlsarenotblonde Rock Therapy was a one-off project comprising of Queen guitarist Brian May, Rolling Stones drummer Charlie Watts

  • Thumbs up, if you want to thumbs up!

  • i like eminem because,besides being very good at what he does,more people are getting to know paul rodgers and his work

  • I DIDN'T come here because of Eminem :-)

    I came here because of Paul Rodgers. Is that ok everyone???

  • @bojo8686 good one m8 :). i kinda really like the eminem guitar one and all that though.

  • "thumbs up if you came to hear this cause of ......"

    Im sick of this stupid phrases....

    Just shut the fuck up and listen the fucking song!

    If you give me a like for this, i will cut your thumb!

  • @Fronxzy cut mine then :)

  • I think paul is glad that eminem used a sample of his song

  • @BeutenLB This is not really Paul's song. It was done for charity back in 1996 and a number of musicians contributed to it. Paul Rodgers did not write the song.

  • @GOODY61 no he perfromed it do u know that not all musicians write their own shit some arnt talented enough

  • @Pfeiffinator23 Rodgers may not have written this song but he has been the composer on many well-known rock classics. By the way , let me suggest some remedial English classes for you. You need some help with your posts.

  • @GOODY61 cuz i shorten my words up online no fuck u nigger

  • @Pfeiffinator23 I don't buy into your statement , I believe it's more of an education issue. Also name calling and profanity generally does not increase a person's credibility so my suggestion is you take this into account on subsequent posts. This ends the lesson for today. Your welcome !

  • @GOODY61 lmao bicth ill swear all i want n u cant do shit bout it n look at all the words im shorting lmao bitch ass nigger

  • @Pfeiffinator23 - Please use English when you respond to posts. May I suggest Remedial English classes for you ?

  • @GOODY61 lmao okay i'll accually type right to make you shut your pussy mouth haha. Better because i'd say so, Oh and fuck yourself you queer ass bitch you think your cool because you correct people on youtube lmao your a pathetic piece of shit.

  • @Pfeiffinator23 The correct spelling is "actually" not "accually".

  • @GOODY61 lmao fuck urself, but look not even 300,000 views n it was put up a year ago haha he sux n so do u...

  • @Pfeiffinator23 Your just an illiterate troll who posts on a few youtube videos, you have never done anything which would warrant 300,000 people watching you.

  • @GOODY61 state championship in football had prlly over 500,000 ppl watching me n tht is in about 2 1/2 hours haha not a year ur just trollin on me bitch.

  • @GOODY61 When I moved to Iowa, they put me in remedial reading class - fifth grade. I didn't realize exactly what that was back then, but it helped me out :). Also, who are some of his other works with, if you dont mind me asking - not trying to annoy or anything like that. I'm just kinda sad that I can't remember this dude or connect his obvious talent with anything I've heard. (dumb i know)

  • @GOODY61 soo u done?

  • thumbs up if you're intending to post a comment asking for thumbs up regarding the fact that many people came here because they listened to Eminem's Beautiful.

  • Thunbs Up If you came to hear this because of eminem and then really like this song

  • good song ruined by emo pictures created by a 12 year old girl who just wants to be pretty under her ugly glasses!

  • thumbs up if you want the same version that u heared on eminem "Beautiful" XD

  • i dont know eminems version, im just impressed by his voice.

    saw him singing a beautiful blues on a documentation bout queen..

    his voice is really really really greeeaaaat!!

  • but who actually sings it at the beginning of the eminem song? Coz I kinda prefer that one :S

  • @eternalphoenix87 This guy but it is a live rendition with Queen.

  • Thumbs up if you knew this song before eminems beautiful

  • 2:19 to 2:32 the guitar or whatever that instrument is sounds great!! and well it makes the song sadder.

  • @jr4chargers it's a guitar played by Queen guitarist Brian May. that guitar sound is one of a kind, and the way he plays it is a different thing altogether. he's one of the most respected guitarists of our time, for his playing, his ideas and his genuine persona. glad you enjoyed it

  • rodgers aint no freddie, but he's good.

  • @TheJokersAdvocate96 this is Pauls song, not freddie's

  • i love this song because its sounds good on Eminem's beautiful

  • I see why Eminem choose this in Beautiful because this is simply that beautiful

  • ha eminem who? fuck i came here cause of paul rodger himself

  • @avielknot me too! i knew this song before emimem used it, and i prefer this version

  • i like the speeded up version in beautiful better i think

  • Red special Guitar of Brian May :)

  • wonderful song...</3

  • i'm thanking eminem for coveing this song.. so i could find it....

    very beautiful.

  • I find it so awesome that one amazing singer like Paul Rodgers can influence another amazing singer like Eminem :)

  • heres the version used on beautiful if youre looking :) --->  /watch?v=-YVJ8j6jmR4

  • @LarziJL No it's really not. Fuck that stupid white boy. I came here to listen to a classic.

  • @LarziJL Sorry. But Eminem mixed it perfectly.

  • @LarziJL How can you compare an original to a live sample? All due acclaim to Eminem for sampling it without ruining it, but I feel the songs are too different to be compared. But that's just my opinion.

  • @kassimma That may be exactly why it's so good.

  • @kassimma That might be what makes it so good?

  • @LarziJL ahahah look how stupid u look 31 for urs and 932 for the other ahaha nigga

  • @Pfeiffinator23 Hehehe, ikr.

    But well, I see 0 for yours so.

  • @Pfeiffinator23 k go and look at beautiful way more than 932 like u fucking idiot just face the facts more ppl like em than the fag ur stickin up for u nigger

  • @LarziJL If it was a little sadder and emotional then yes.

  • FUCKIN  GOOD lol

  • IM JUST SO FUCKIN DEPRESSED.....found myself sayin that not long into the song lol

  • @gaznew12 Stfu dude no one cares

  • @Livefortunes well your a treat!! i was only saying it made eminems lyrics come into my head.

  • @Livefortunes Really? No need to be a dick

  • @XxKA0SxMAGICxX i know huh wtf dude you dont have to be a fuckin prick about it ... i found myself sayin eminems lyrics right after the first few lines...

  • EMINEM REVOLUTION

    On october 10 all of Eminems rap fans are going to watch Eminems Not Afraid video on youtube which curently has 120 million views.

    Justin (FAGGOT) biebers baby has 300+million views which is a disrespectful thing to real musicians like Eminem.So everyone get together, click on NOT AFRAID, refresh your page 10 times to give it 10 more views. Lets beta this bieber disease !!

    >>>COPY & PASTE<<<

    THUMBS UP IF YOU READ THIS^

    DONT VIEW BIEBERS VID

  • Eminem actually uses a version from the Queen+Paul Rodgers album/DVD Return of the Champions. This was a sort of return-the-favour. For their Return of the Champions tour (2005-2006) they used Lose Yourself as the final song on the Pre-Concert tape. Used it as an introduction with Brian May's screaming guitar over the top. If you listen to Beautiful you can hear the audience in the sample.

  • wen u really focus on this song u feel like u wanna cry cause its so damn amazing

  • For those who came here because of Eminem - it's not that bad. Eminem uses good songs for his intros or choruses and that's great. So those who listen to him can get interested in some really good music, like this is.

  • si no fuera por eminem jamas ubiera escuchado esta cancion xd

  • If you didn't know of this before Eminem, you need to be back handed on the face. Hard.

  • eminem me trajo a escuxar esta cancion ..

  • hah eminem no I came here to hear this because I was browsing through QUEEN

  • incredible song.....

  • haha ok i came here beacause eminem brought me here

    

  • Such cool song. Amazing.

  • i like the pic at the end

  • I wish someone rearranged this song so it was like Eminem's version. Maybe I'll do it sometime.

  • @CompsciWiz Please do.

  • this is amazing!

  • awwww.

    that was adorable

    *tear*

  • @greekmustard666- good music knows no genre

  • Heard the hook of Eminem, so I searched the original version of this song.

    Its simply awesome

  • also...don't ever sell dre short...he is the goddamn oracle man, he is so good at making music it's insane. he is a beast, in my opinion the best hip-hop producer of all time no question. everything he does is so ill...he's such a perfectionist and it totally shows in all of his dope music

  • im a huge em fan but id pick this song over beautiful all the time

  • Wow, Dre sampled this vocal melody and built a predominantly minor-instrumentation around it for the Eminem track. He completely rebuilt the accompaniment to this vocal melody - which is very much a "requires music theory" type of thing to do. I know he can drop beats like no other, but this is not a talent I thought Dre would have. I bet it wasn't Dre - bet it was his studio guitarist that figured out the progression based on the vocal melody. No one else wondering how this happened?

  • @awolf007 dre is definitely classically trained man...at the very least he has some theory and harmony training, i know that for a fact. plus, let's be real...taking a major-feel harmony and switching it to a minor-feel in the same key really only requires a flattened third and sixth so it should be a breeze...there aren't many altered chords in the progression

  • @awolf007 No em produced beautiful not dre so he did everything.

  • @awolf007 No, I'm not surprised. It's very interesting how many artists who seem really unmusical actually have formal music theory training.