Carly Smithson - I drove all night

[MoiaKetsa1]

The best, she should of won.....

[hperonto92]

try celiene dion :)

[mzbooboo1989]

she was my favorite. i love this girl. she rocks. her voice is AMAZING!!!

[atlismyreasontolive1]

cindi lauper classic... I thought it was a celine dion song.

[bubbles3854]

How she did not win is a mystery to me

[Staples4351]

Idol doesn't like women rockers. Never understood why she didn't make it further.

[nudle19]

she's so good . She should have stayed longer.......america got it wrong!!!!

[cbotten106]

I'm glad she sang this one on the Idol's Live Tour. Hot, hot, hot!

[budapest49]

Simply fantastic! Carly definitely should have been in the top 2 on Idol. What a voice! I never get tired of her singing this song and also "The Letter with Michael Johns.

[littilemisspers]

is she and/or michael johns goin to come out with a cd?

[parachuteboi]

LMAO she's copying Celine's version! but unfortunately she can't pull it off! OMG, after the word "buring " she goes off key!

[may141994]

She was amazing on American Idol! x x

[SweeneyxTodd]

She really should have won. I hate that american idol tends to be completely based on popularity once america votes. The really talented and unique ones don't tend to do so well, that's why I'm so excited for Adam this season.

[missjackson58]

love it!!!!

[loganidol]

Wow. I can't wait to hear her sing this song again in concert.

[cbotten106]

Carly Smithson sings the hell out of another classic rock song and owns it completely. Her voice is awesome.