The Girl Who Lost the Stars

[MelonsAreAwesome]

I cried.

[Ikanem]

Yes this causes manly tears. Yes it always will. But what really stands out is the quality of the editing and the choices of direction, the creator took. If want your proof, when the tear hits the ground, it sinks up with the real emotional part of the music. Moreso if you have also seen the scene that this is from. Just a beautiful display of understanding how a scene should work, and good execution.

[FartPoilce2009]

Good choice of music

[FartPoilce2009]

I've watched this so many times! I will never stop crying to this :*D

[FartPoilce2009]

:*D this is beautiful

[nogohoho]

*manly tears* *sniffle* ಥ_ಥ

[UsernameMadeNChina]

At first I was like:

LOL Y U SO CHEESY? ლ(°▽°ლ)

Then I was like:

NO, Y U SO SADDENING? ლ(ಥ益ಥლ)

[netancat]

woot 800th like!! :DD

[LeHetaliaNeko]

;w;

[rocio2732]

If you andy are reading read closly! I know that you don't like me AND I don't like you but why are we enmies. Next time you see me please tell me about it. Your ex friend Karla

[souleatherzero]

THE ELEMENTS OF HARMONY ARE INSIDE US, BUT SOMEPONY JUST FORGOT IT, lets try to remind them that everypony in the world... i mean all of us CAN be friends to reach to our equestria together like bronies

¡¡¡YAY PONIES!!!¡¡¡YAY METAL!!!

[ganonlink]

I like how the clips turn gray just like Twilight.

[RetardGamingHD]

I can make this not sadness! :D

Without honesty, there is NO TROLL FACES!

Just look at that AJ Trollface <3

[TheCerlium]

THIS is so beautiful I'm crying like i've never dropped tears Before

[TheEffingAwesomeClan]

This made me baww

[Zdudeisme]

Meh.

[rosetheeevee]

Such a beautiful video!

[Yoyogio123]

HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGG



[RaveTuba]

(╯ಥ益ಥ)╯ Y SO SAD?

[msbloweverythingup]

*TEARSTEARSTEARSTEARSTEARS*

[mylaceandwhiskey]

a friend of mine gave me this as a christmas present. he told me to watch it every time I feel upset or have had a bad day and know that he'll always be there for me.

he just told me he never wanted to speak to me again. this is the first place I came.

thank you for this video. and P, I love you.

[rocio2732]

@mylaceandwhiskey The same happen to me.I am a girl 11 years old and This thing happen to me.I had a friend named Andy, he is really cool and is11.He was the best friend I ever had.But when he knew that i had a crush on him he soon was acting like an ex- friend.This year 2012 I invent a school named FriendshipAcademdy. Any way if you (Andy) ever read this just remember that I will always lead you through and be there. I will never lie,or be rude.So if you find friendship share it like I am .

[RazorRaven619]

This is honestly one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen. Excellent work!

[yara455]

wonderful! This music SHOULD be in MLP!

[meshutora]

The most saddening scene from Return of Harmony to the most triumphant scene from Return of Harmony, A good message and a great song from Chrono Crusade!

*sniff* ;'3

[SuperGoodGirl444]

this is sooooooo sad! ;(

[KlashikEggzampal]

Golden

[JJangoFett]

Fluttershy noooooooooooooooo! :(

[andmos100]

you are amasing whith the frienship mesage.

[smbz821]

this was truly well done, why doesn't this have over a 100k views? I've seen some AMV's from shows like ben 10, and Avatar the last airbender that have over 100k views, and they're not even that good, they're just fight scenes without too much editing with Linkin Park music playing.

[ponybug22]

I broke down and cried when I saw this video, because a dear friend of mine was killed in a car accident while chasing a Tornado just outside of Tuscaloosa, Alabama. He was so smart and he was a wonderful person and I miss him terribly.

[MinusMan561]

@ponybug22 "while chasing a tornado"

okay no offense but.....chasing a tornado...umm...

[ponybug22]

@MinusMan561Who are you to judge someone you didn't even know? Devin loved Science and weather.

[ThePa1riot]

@Tyranitar635 Troper brohoof!

[ThePa1riot]

@theguywhoannoysme I know what you mean. I'm friendly but I have exactly two friends in my life and I'm far from both of them. I wise woman once told me to keep trying to make friends and it will get better in time. I'm no Confucius and Socrates, but I can offer this (sir_anthony@comcast.net) if you ever want to talk about the show!

[ThePa1riot]

@Freefall224 I'm so sorry for your loss and I know they are getting a hero's welcome elsewhere.

[ThePa1riot]

@siverfanweedo As much as I want to offer my hand in friendship to you and magically make both our problem go away I think we both know that's not how it works. I'm in the same boat, this show and this fandom have inspired me to try harder at making friends, it's not easy but I know it will be worth it. Still (sir_anthony@comcast.net) here's my email address if you ever want to talk about the show. Brohoof?

[MewYuki23]

What I love about this version of Twilight's "de-saturation" is that it focuses on just what she lost. This is truly heart-rendering and remarkable.

[SpyroAndMLP]

8 people still dont got friends how sad TT^TT

[arsanderesteban]

Chrono Cross?

My Little Pony?

You sir, are god.

[tyman955]

That was beautiful.

[VornadoDelta]

I just can't hold back all my man-tears.

[ehhgirlxXx]

oh god, i'm crying now...my boyfriend has been feeling pretty depressed lately with family things, and i showed him this and he realized how much his friends meant to him. he's feeling a lot better now. so, my thanks go to you, Gabuex, and keep up the good Brony magic :)

[RLYoshi]

There is a reason this got on TV Tropes...It is just too awesome for words.

[JackiePhantom13]

BEAUTIFUL! JUST BEAUTIFUL!!!! ♥

[courteibutt]

GABUEX! YOU MUST KNOW THAT YOU ARE AMAZING! Seriously. This is one of the most beautiful things I have ever seen. Thank you.

[itsnotgayina3way]

*snif*

*stand up*

*start slowly claping*

BRAVO!!

[1dirvish]

I wish this was a canon scene, without the, you know without the pauses and text. (a 30min show cant afford the pauses.)

[ReyTheMysterioDKO]

I loved this

[WaffeDerMacht]

I DL'd this.

[crris14]

*widens eyes with jaw drop...then does a sad smile and tears up* thats the best thing i ever saw on youtube! *wipes face* thank you

[stupidresults]

Now see, THIS would've made the episode GOLD. I loved Season 2's first episode a lot, but if there had been more focus on Twilight turning grey like you said then that would've just hit the nail on the head, I'd say. <3 Thank you so much for putting this together. There are tears rolling down my cheeks atm. :'D

[GabuEx]

@stupidresults You're very welcome! :)

[SilverDHedgehog2]

i dont know how u managed to complete this without giving up in tears....

Bravo...

[DeathReaver10]

manly tears have been shed this day

[GiggleSnortBangDead]

This was so fantastic. Tears were certainly shed by this pegasister - though, the manliness of these tears could be debated.

[Brynms]

TIL that travail IS a real word.

[MrOttoin]

The best way to finish watching this video, is by cracking open a beer.

[SpyroAndMLP]

Story of wat i didnt have in my life befor this show :D

[SpyroAndMLP]

Dam dude this vid is so EPIC and TRUE I had to put it on my favorits =*D

[xXxMearadxXx]

I'll admit it. I cried.

Editing like this takes talent. Brava good sir, brava indeed.

[wolfmansmh1]

manly tears where shed.

[Freefall224]

My brother and my childhood friend were killed in action. My brother was always there for those who needed him and would do anything to help, and my friend would never leave anyone he knew, for any reason. Sometimes, I look back upon the days they were still alive, and I just now realized those two were the elements of generosity, kindness, and loyalty. But they were both the incarnation of sacrifice, one of the most important elements.

[GabuEx]

@Freefall224 :( I'm very sorry for your loss, and I thank them from the bottom of my heart for their service.

[HolyDemonSnap]

@Freefall224 I thank them for their service as well. :)

[RainbowSprinkles1001]

this literally made me tear up! this is beautiful! :D

[theguywhoannoysme]

So this means I'm a failure? That's hardly fair. It's not like it's easy (or even possible for somepony like me) to find these qualities in somepony else and bring them out.

[GabuEx]

@theguywhoannoysme See my reply to iluvcats2 in the comments; what I said there applies here too.

[theguywhoannoysme]

@GabuEx Oh God, it's like a Fetchquest...

[theguywhoannoysme]

@GabuEx Best Fetchquest ever. I cried. AGAIN.

[GabuEx]

@theguywhoannoysme :D *hug*

[TheSPARTANJ13]

@GabuEx FRIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEENDS (Developed for the internet by the powers of Awesome.)

[TheSPARTANJ13]

@theguywhoannoysme Wait. There's such a thing as a GOOD fetchquest?!

[TehUltim8Z]

@theguywhoannoysme If =/= if and only if.

[DylanMatthewB]

I wish I had friends.

[GabuEx]

@DylanMatthewB :(

*hug*

[McBawse]

This is the only youtube video I've favourited. Because it's my single favourite video ever.

[randomfan15]

aw how nice, great video :)

[Tyranitar635]

I was linked here from tvtropes "TearJerkers". This is by far the saddest.

[Crazy56U]

...ow... my soul hurts...

[Wobble9000]

The music fits perfectly and those quotes were incredible. This is wonderful, truly a masterpiece of artistic editing and animation.

[burntfish123]

damn straight it is.

[Shonbi]

all my wuv

[DakNJaxter]

Dude... sweet.

[kd7sov]

...Where's the "Love" button? Sure, there's the "Like"+"Fave" combo, but this needs more.

[Satoshiji]

i want to dislike this for making me manlytears, but that would be a bitch move

[Smischmal]

I had no idea that it was possible to make Twilight draining of colour even sadder, or to make her rediscovery of the magic of friendship more inspiring. You have done what I though impossible.

[DrunkVizard]

Crono Cross music always makes me cry manly tears

[ryukage19]

someone show this to faust. right, freakin, now

[GabuEx]

@ryukage19 Well, she does have a deviantART profile. ;)

[Jacieltje]

@ryukage19 Just posted it on her Deviantart-wall ;)

[stampede274]

Manly tears were shed.

[Ghstrydr86]

I have never cried from watching a youtube video until now. Amazing video, you have a gift

[VGJustice]

Manly tears were had. ; ~;

[kollerss]

i cried...

[TheRozzienator]

DJHGSADJHASDH ;A; <3

[TakoshidaEpikShinxz]

Wow. I've been fighting with my friend Ruby on a site because she dislikes Ponies and... I start sobbing everytime I watch it.

[Insainitydemon]

I cried manly tears, which is odd considering I'm a woman.

[TheSPARTANJ13]

@Insainitydemon Ponies can have that effect. Also, report any of the following to a licensed medical practitioner: irregular menstruation, explosive rainbow tears, and sudden thoughts of being a pony.

[sdaerfofsteam2]

@Insainitydemon You cried like a manly girl!

[shibitheshadowhound]

@Insainitydemon i to made tears of a male though im a female :P

[Zelenal]

Oh wow. This is magnificent. This has to be my most favorite video on YouTube now. If only there was a "Love" button.

[Gadvac]

You almost got me crying, and that's an accomplishment. Well done, Gabu, this is a great video.

[sdaerfofsteam2]

@Avykins I shall vanquish you with love and tolerance!

[Owlynator]

I got some tears in my eyes. That means you've succeeded. Congratulations!

[BlackEmerl]

GREAT!... IT´S SIMPLY AND EPIC GREAT!!!...

friendship... is the Ultimate Magic...

MLP: Friendship is Magic + Chrono Cross OST = EPIC WIN!!!!

[shamanazakura]

F**KING MANLY TEARS.....

Aw, screw it, Friendly tears...

[GabuEx]

@XPsychoBurgundyX Guys, guys, chill out a bit.  These are the kinds of responses that trolls are looking for. Trolls are vanquished with love, not anger.

[Lincmania]

Tears. Every. F***ing. Time

[KumoriShichiyou]

I'm not crying. Some of that chocolate milk rain got in my eyes, that's all.

[finalunusedname]

@Avykins The only thing gay about Chrono Cross is nothing! Mmmaybe Solt and Peppor. And the big fluffy dog thing. And that Square-Enix hasn't followed it up with anything.

Okay, fine, some things are gay about Chrono Cross. But not this song!

[derserdarfuehrer1]

@Avykins Hide everyone. Discord is back.

[Level85HumanStoner]

@Avykins

And just when I thought idiots couldn't get any stupider the biggest ones ever comes onto a video depicting a cartoon he clearly doesnt like and then acts as if he watched the video out of anything other than free will.

In short: fuck off you insecure wanker nobody cares what you think

[browniebob]

WHY DOESN'T THIS HAVE MORE VIEWS?!

[ForeverOdin]

Beautifully done! It was both sad and inspiring all the way through, but for personal reasons that second-to-last quote (just before "Friendship is Magic") got me bawling...

[kimiee01]

That's totally awesome! Soo touching,and lovely and cute-favin,like and subbed ^^

[sagacious03]

This was astonishingly good. Seriously, I almost cried, and I love you for uploading this!

[GabuEx]

@Avykins I'm always surprised at how happy it can get, too.

[EonEvolution197]

There's only one problem I can see with this video:

There is no 'Love' button.

[IntoTheCaramelFrappe]

..I actually teared to this... well done.. well done.

[Gaphiltefish]

Wow, I haven't been very active on youtube lately; glad I was able to watch this. Wonderful work, I must say. I felt very emotional watching this in the show, and you did a great job of recreating that.

[GabuEx]

@Gaphiltefish Thank you, sir!

[questerskillz]

That was very touching. I can see this video going places.

[DaROC1993]

I won't hide the facts here, I watched this three times now, and it brought tears to my eyes each time. I can't describe what you have done, its so incredible, so amazing. I feel like there will always be hope out there, that just so long as I keep in mind that I do have friends there, that my actions do matter to at least one person, I will be alright. Here I am, tears strewn down my face as I write this. I can't thank you enough for this revelation. Truly, you are a great person.

[GabuEx]

@DaROC1993 Awww, that's wonderful. :) I'm so glad I could do that for you. All my best.

[GabuEx]

@TheGrenpa I still love you.

[dukluvrr]

@TheGrenpa Funny, seeing how dark all of S2E1 was dark and foreboding, while S2E2 was chock full of sad moments and especially the more WTF of moments. You, sir, are one unfortunate lad.

[Glarium1]

whoever made this video deserves a Nobel prize,seriously.

[sdaerfofsteam2]

@XPsychoBurgundyX I have anger management problems. Very, very bad anger management problems. I might need to see a doctor or something.

[DracoDei]

@sdaerfofsteam2

There is no "might" about it. Psychologist/councilor, psychiatrist, or both. When you body is sick you see a body-type-doctor. Do the same for your mind. You will be glad you did (in the long term). Do note that psychologists/councilors aren't "one size fits all". You may have to try a few before you find one that is a "fit" for you.

[DashunicornII]

the amount of love between bronies is amazing. i didn't think it was possible until i became a brony, i love you guys, and love to all pegasister's out there :D

[akihearte]

I would cry manly tears...but I'm a girl.

Instead I will cry tomboy tears and say THIS IS SO AMAZINGGGGG.

[lilgrublet]

This is excellent. Thank you so very much for sharing it. Words of wisdom are always more powerful when shared.

[jbblankenship98]

*sheds tears of manliness*

[MissyBriarwood]

WHO DISLIKED THIS! D:

[iLegacy69]

@kyleisreallycool Masterbait? Just leave the internet kid. Its Masturbate*

[kyleisreallycool]

@iLegacy69 kid? I'm 20. I don't need spelling lessons from some faggot like you.

[iLegacy69]

@kyleisreallycool 20 Year olds doesnt go around calling people faggots. Because a person who's 20 years old wouldnt judge someone by whatever they say and go ''oh hes problably into men''

If you ARE 20, which i doubt you are. Then act your age.

[kyleisreallycool]

@iLegacy69 replace doesnt with don't . You can't start a sentence with because. Your second sentence is missing punctuation. "Then act your age." is a sentence fragment. There should be a comma after are.

[iLegacy69]

@kyleisreallycool How is that an answer. ''20 Year olds doesnt go around calling people faggots'' ''THERE SHOULD BE A COMMA AFTER ARE'' Yeah man, Its okay. I wont make you cry if you dont like this. Afterall

Friendship ~IS~ Magic, Dont you know?

[McBawse]

God, I'm actually sad that someone disliked this.

This is my favourite video ever.

[GabuEx]

@justwinx4567 Oh, come now, that's not very brony-like. Lost souls often are more in need of love than anyone else in the world.

[justwinx4567]

I can't and will not hold my man tears.

[justwinx4567]

This made me cry so hard. Amazing job, and thank you for teaching me about friendship. :) I'm proud to be a brony now.

[dxhbk4]

THIS is going on my facebook wall. Instant fave with manly tears on my keyboard.

[EquusStorm]

Many manly tears have been shed.

[xentis1501]

I COULDNT FIND THE FAV. BUTTON FAST ENOUGH

[FlamingAtheist]

Great scott!! you made me have manly tears........AGAIN!! Good show i love it.

[CharmyDweeng]

...I cried. :-

[DashmasterC]

This show and you people are too good to me! ಥ﹏ಥ

[rafflesia]

Wow...real chills. That was beautifully moving. Well done. :**}

[Dragonfangs]

I just got something in my eye, I swear!

No, seriously, I got something in my eye, it was itching like hell. Good thing I could just play this video and let the tears do their job, feeling a lot better now.

[HolyDemonSnap]

You did this really well. It gave me so many goosebumps even during the second time I watched it.

[FlCl3000]

god i really cried. a few tears actually went down my cheek with this. our school does senior quotes in the yearbook, i think ive found mine. thank you so much

[Sayiism]

its so amazing, i cried a bit

[MrBillyRex]

You, my dear friend, made me call a friend to invite him. I thank you for finding the courage to do so.

May ♥ be with you.

[GabuEx]

@MrBillyRex Awww, that's wonderful! :) I'm happy for you!

[WhirlyWillow]

You know what....I like being a brony :)

[PyroTheFox]

That was an absolutely fantastic video.

[l1nk2thepast90]

Me: Oh, it's the sad twilight scene, well i already cried at this once i can't possibly-

*quotes start appearing*

Me: *Manly Tears everywhere*

[AlexHooker91]

Chrono cross. Ponies. Best combo ever??

[atikoon1]

I don't know about you guys, but I cry at the school today watch this on my laptop.......T.T

[Haloman2023]

Manly tears,

Manly tears everywhere.

Seriously though this was beautiful and poetic, a truly great life lesson. It's strange, but in the short time I've been a brony I've come to learn so many important lessons. The most important being to not care what others think. Life is too short to go through worrying about how others think, which was exactly how I lived before. Before, I would have never confessed to being a Brony. Now I would proudly walk down the street, decked out head to toe in pony.

[GabuEx]

@Haloman2023 Sounds like you're saying that being a brony made you able to be proud to be a brony! :D That sounds like the good kind of feedback loop to me! Awesome stuff, what you say is very true.

[Paradox042]

Manly tears were shed.

[Sircxyrtyx]

Take all my Internets, you deserve them

[watchpr]

Sniff...sniff...

[LunarSea1986]

Damn you, combining Chrono Cross and ponies, gettin' me all emotional... :P

But seriously though, this was beautiful and inspiring. As someone who was once apathetic in regards to his friendships and who has now reconnected with his friends and is closer than ever to them partly due to this show, I really felt this. So much love comes out of this show and fandom that I'm constantly being reminded to treasure the relationships that I have. I've made many new friends because of it too.