Added: 5 years ago
From: patoportnoy
Views: 367,987
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (488)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Uhhh locoo.. Ese solo te hace llorar... Yo estuve ahi!! 3 MOSTROS! jajaja.

    Gracias por el video man!

  • Ear candy I call that! Thx patoportnoy.

  • @jcoo71 you are welcome sir ! I 110% agree with you

  • me gusta satriani,pero kedo chikitito con la zapada de jhon P

  • But seriously. Where is Steve Vai??

  • full of feelings! amazing!

  • I watched so many of these AWYAWM jams but I always come back to this one. John's solo is just AMAZING!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I extracted that video as mp3 and added it onto my iphone man, it's that good

  • @MHU999 Nice dude.. that was my idea when I recorded this solo !!

  • if it wasnt for pull me under,we would never know who or what a dream theatre was,lol

  • @evelskunny ehm, yes, we would:)

  • Comment removed

  • Lo mas curioso es que las "peores" partes del solo son cuando se embala, las partes en las que toca mas lento son mucho mas bonitas y hacen que el solo sea realmente bueno. Grande Petrucci!

  • the rhythm guitarist in the back should have just stopped playing... hahaha

  • this is Joe Satriani playing there, than at 2:06 starts Petrucci with just another shredding solo not really shifting the beautiful song of Joe to another level

  • AHHHH Eric Johnson I wanna see the resttt NOOoooo!!!!

  • can't get rid of that melody out of my head, cause it's also in my heart !

  • dumb ass thats joe satriani... fucking hate that fool.. look at that nasty ass shiny head of his... eeeewww!!!!

  • wow i just cried when petrucci started his solo. damn

  • *sigh*

  • Petrucci's part 2:05

  • AWESOME!...Thank you!

  • Complete orgasm for the ears!!

  • lmao watch at the bottom at 2:36, someone is taking a photo of themselves under john so they're pulling a funny face with john petrucci in the background haha, you see a brief flash and a face 

  • @Poowetisnub that was the security guy..

  • q buena rola

  • When Petrucci comes out on these G3 concerts, I always feel a breath a fresh air, like "Ahhh the familiar ol master is coming out to play." I just really like the guy.

  • my favorite part is 3:51

  • amazing john and joe

  • EVEN WE MISSED EJ IN THIS VIDEO, WE KNOW IT'S GONNA BE TRANQUIL AND PURE AS ALWAYS..EJ IS THE MAN FOR SUBTLENESS GUITAR SOLO PLAYING AND I LOVE HIM FOR THAT..BUT, I'LL BE JP 4EVER!

  • how can anyone dislike this. besides sound quality, its a total eargasm

  • NO! Why does the video end right before EJ plays? FUUUUUUUU--

  • I've always felt sorry for Satch's rhythm and bass guitarists.....when can they see the "limelight?"....they've been so dedicated....for years. Rock on!!

  • wow petrucci hits the high notes there.. is he using a 24 fret?

  • recently saw satch, and it was 2 hours of him shredding, amazing.

  • Im sorry but I have to say that Petrucci is unquestionably much tighter than Satch.

  • petrucci is fast, hands down! but satriani is really good in mixing his notes!

  • watch the whole thing...,Petrucci comes in at around 2:00

  • Petrucci reaches heights here, seldomly reached by other musicians, let alone guitarists. It truly makes the mind soar in freedom.

  • It's Russell Allen of Symphony X on guitar!!! hahaha

  • why people comment if they don't watch the entire video?

  • es q esta kncion la tokn satriani y petrucci miren el vid entero!

  • This is Satriani not Petrucci

    but i like/love both

  • @Grabtanz watch the entire video!

  • maravilloso(buen aspanol?)

  • Eric John son was comming to stage at the end?! I need to see this DVD!!!

  • @WhiteDeath unfortunately.. there's no DVD or complete bootleg of this show.. what a shame

  • good....the  only petrucci

  • What is played at the Gates of Heaven

  • ES Joe Satriani cafre!!!!!!!

  • @sergimysterio Si no ves el video entero, no sirve... JP sale a improvisar a la mitad del video...

  • Sin dudas Petrucci es un guitarrista de puta madre, pero de ahi a decir que es uno de los mejores solos de la historia (como aseguraron algunos)... creo que hay demasiado fanatismo. Creo que no se puede hacer un mejor solo en este tema, porque todo el tema en si es un gran solo.

    Lo de John estuvo perfecto y mantiene su estilo personal (incluso creo que hace mucho no escuchaba que improvisara con tan buen gusto sin marearse con tecnicismos) pero no exageremos y sean objetivos.

    Saludos para todos

  • El primero fue con Vai y Robert Fripp, lo digo proque fui a las 2 noches de los 2 shows.

    Por otro lado, yo vi esta participacion como un tributo de parte de John a Joe, no se olviden que este tema forma parte del disco instrumental mas vendido de la historia, y eso no es poca cosa. Vean algunos documentales que hay colgados po ahi y van a entender lo que fue Surfing with the Alien para la historia de la guitarra. A tal punto que hoy en dia sigue sin ser superado

  • Primero que nada, felicitaciones por el video, yo estuve en esa noche en primera fila y recuerdo claramente ese momento.

    Por el nick que usas es mas que evidente que sos fana de DT asique cualquier cuestionamiento contra Petrucci seria como hablarle a una pared, pero igualmente pediste que comentemos, asique aca va lo mio, aunque seguramente voy a tener que firmar mas de una vez para que entre todo.

    1º que nada, este fue el segundo G3 en la Argentina

  • petrucci is just amazing

    

  • es verdad !!!!! me disculpo!! :S

  • Both Very Great Guitarists!

  • any man who is that comfortable to where sunglasses inside or in the dark of a concert is severly awesome

  • Well I'm an average musician and I am nowhere to playing even a fraction as good as these guys but I know there is nothing like a better musician... people like what they hear and thats all... petrucci and satriani and for that matter vai, eric johnson or whoever can never be compared and their works can never be compared either. All of these guys have different techniques for eg. satriani uses legato for speed while petrucci uses sheer picking speed... a lot of stuff counts for... guitar,gear..

  • Petrucci is great buuuuuuuuuut Joe Satriani is THE man.

  • Comment removed

  • NO RESUME!? 25 years of the most dynamic prog music and a solo album to boot? (Dream theater makes queensryche seem so simplistic and dated it's not even funny) That's like saying Arnold Schwarzenegger wasn't a bodybuilder. That's like saying Stephen Hawking doesn't have a quantom physics resume. People like you make me question humanity.

  • @BillyJimmyBobbyTimmy oh yeah and that "superelvan" sucks

  • @evelskunny what??

  • @evelskunny

    WHAT? Have you ever actually listened to Dream Theater? Other than Mindcrime, what Queensryche are you referring to?

  • @evelskunny dude satriani's one of the best in the world

  • @debakkertje12 and techniquewise petrucci is even better, the nerve of evelskunny to say such thing is unbelievable ;o

  • @evelskunny I love Queensryche as much as the next guy, but I'm pretty sure John Petrucci could kick Michael Wilton's ass in a guitar battle all day long.

  • WHAT A HUNK

  • I actually didn't care for it that much. Seems like a bunch of random noodling to me. No references to the melody of the song, just .... licks. Good playing, but the JP of yesteryear is gone, it seems.

  • wow! Pertrucci's solo is just unbelievable. Man is this on a dvd or recording somewhere? I love this song but have heard so may times that I just don't connect with it anymore. Reconnected.

  • @racso100m1 mira el video enteroooooooooooo

  • @bilbobolson666 mira el video enteroooooooooooooooooo

  • @patoportnoy jja al principio m parecia q era ruddes xD

  • petrucci is god!

  • John, you give me goosebumps

  • This is Joe sat in beginning n then Petrucci joined .. !!!

  • that's joe satriani

  • @slim89 watch the entire video.. G3.. Joe Satriani's song.. but the extended solo is played by the Incredible Petrucci.. watch.. you won't regret it!

  • @patoportnoy to think that petrucci knew the song THAT well is incredible, He can improv SO well!

  • Is he Joe Satriani?

  • @aprilliakite he's John Petrucci (the guy with the extended solo). He is a MUCH better guitarist than Joe Satriani 

  • @jckbac9 I wouldnt say hes a better guitarist then Joe Satriani although i like his playing style alot more, Satriani has a huge amount of routin from his recorded albums and live shows he has done. Satriani is maybe not as techically skilled as Petrucci, though Satrani is way more experienced and therfore his playing is alot more versatile. In this aspect Satriani is a better guitarist

  • @Simoto92 Satriani "is more experienced, and therefore more versatile?" I'm sorry but that logic is simply flawed. Anyway, I like Satch, a lot, and I respect your opinion, but I have listened to ALL of Petrucci and Satriani's work and I watch a LOT (probably too many) live performances on youtube of the guitarists, and John Petrucci is without a doubt a superior guitarist. John's unbelievable technical ability aside, he plays with WAY more feeling. Listen to voices, spirit carries on & best of t

  • @jckbac9 I will have to agree with you on that one, John Petrucci to ME is a better guitarist aswell, And believe me, im a huge DT fan, The reason why i replied to your last comment was because i thought you were nothing but a close-minded fanboy of Petrucci with no experience of listening to other guitarists, but you clearly showed you were not ;) Just listen to Lines in the sand and The Razors Edge solo, especially Razors Edge! Its probably the most satisfying and absolute solo ever written.

  • :O petrucci parece un mounstro, mucho muscolo o grasa, parece que esta gordazooooo, comparado con los demas musicos, ni la segunda guitarra de satriani es tan gordo, y peor aun con eric, parece que se carga una bateria en sus hombros....xD

  • i didn't think this song could get any better...i was wrong! These 2 dudes are my fave players in the world. Amazing!

  • culiaw... no puede haber aparecido asi de la nada... yo defeco el lugar xD jajaja que grandes por dios!!

  • but thats not Trooch, that's SATCH!

  • Comment removed

  • Petrucci is real guitar GOD.....let's bow down our head to our God :')

  • I freek'n hate shaky cell phone videos as a rule, but this one is worth listening to even though it makes me sick to watch it. Petrucci has the gift!

  • Now that's a solo. :)

  • We all may think this is special in an unspeakable kind of way, but just think how it made Joe feel, his heart must have melted. If anyone is uncertain why Joe wears glasses, it's because of moments like this, so he can keep his tears to himself. Forever John, and Forever Joe...

  • he makes everything better and fast.

  • I've lost counts how many times i've been listning to this.

    This is so PERFECT!

  • god, I love these guys.

  • John Petrucci is the LOVE OF MY FUCKIN LIFE, I've just cried a river over this solo

  • If it feels good and seems right Petrucci has to be in there somewhere.

  • wow petrucci really feels the song...i did not expect someone to play this song as good as satriani but there it is!

  • You're right

  • permiso, te comento... el g3 estuvo acá en el 2004 con fripp y vai

    gracias por el espacio... una masa el petru en alto tema del ladope

    flor de video man! un abrazo

  • Best best solo played on earth <33

  • both 2 are fuckin genius

  • absolutly beautiful!!!!!!!!

  • You are a dumbfuck. Petrucci combes in half way through for his own solo. Take the time to actually watch these geniuses at work

  • Did you even watch the video.. or just the first 10 seconds? Ignorant moron.

  • @girottox derp

  • che flaco es satriani que petrucci?

  • No me canso de ver este video... Pato grabaste uno de los mejores solos q escuche en mi vida =D

  • is that eric johnson at the end of the song?

  • yep ;D

  • why the hell they didnt release a DVD of this show and the one with Paul GIlbert....how stupid

  • Lmao Satriani is the man. If you look at any video of him doing the tapping part, he ALWAYS busts out that smile.

  • Don't know too much about bass, but is Dave's bass a Bongo Bass?

  • @Lydianshadow Im pretty sure its a stingray, but they look alike. Either way both are amazing bass guitars.

  • @Starsmuse

    bongo

  • @mattbergbass Yeah i didnt notice the second pickup until after i posted that haha.

  • yes

  • best player ever, nuff said. just glad he didn't decide to keep that hairstyle haha

  • DarkPhantomSky...you are such a poor guy. especially for not feeling music!

  • Holy fuck Petrucci...

    I love watching the guy behind him almost shitting his pants

  • haha especially at 3:24

  • hahahahha admit it,,, he's the best

  • i love it when satch kicks it into mixolydian during his live versions

  • yeah me too. i think the solo's sound better over mixolydian

  • that solo sucked actually

  • jp rules over the world,,,you must not hear well i guess,,,,,or you don't possess a heart to understand this solo,,,but i don't blame you those notes are god like so you can't get them

  • satriani con petrucci è come laura pausini con giorgia..se c'è qualche utente italiano, mi dica se non è cosi'

  • Un po' particolare come similitudine, ma diciamo che è cosi...:D

  • ti ringrazio della risposta..non sono nuovo a questo genere di domande fuori come balconi

  • Sì, hai ragione... Petrucci è veramente un genio

  • Mierda! xq no ahi este tipo de mejestuosidad en Ecuador!

  • ajola huviera un G3 en colombia

  • Chulada de video! Chulada de solo. John s realmente grande!.

    Ese solo no fue spectacular n cuanto a tecnica como otros q se avienta, pero es realmente emotivo y bello.

  • omfg jp pwns

  • why the video cut when EJ comes in ??! :'(

  • Petrucci is like Bacon: He makes everything better

  • @tankwfw HAHAHAHAHA

  • @tankwfw well said!

  • @tankwfw mmuhahahahhaha

  • @tankwfw

    Yeah....Jon Bon Jovi said Keep the faith!

  • @tankwfw lol you made me laugh with that comment petrucci is great guitar player!

  • que hijos de puta como envidio a todos los que pudieron ir a ese g3 XD...yo por suerte pude ir a ver a Dream el año pasado (baba)

    AGUANTE LA BUENA MUSICA CARAJO!

  • ahhh q suerte la tuya vs!!!!!!!!

    ver tocar a dream seria mi sueño hahaha

  • yo fui y le regale una remera a Mike XD

  • como estuvo esa noche... LaRue tocó con petrucci, después con satriani y después con los tres..un mostro..De la entrada de petrucci que se puede decír..impresionante!

  • 3:45 he plays and Joe smiles... John is simply amazing...

  • despues dicen que los shreders no tienen sentimiento aguante John Petrucci carajo!!!!!!!!!!!

  • john is on beefcake 9000 lol, hes hench now! n what awesomeness, my 2 fav gtarists rockin out togeva! awesome!

  • just when i thought the song couldnt possibly get better...BAM petrucci power

  • Dave LaRue Dying.........XD

  • se me salen las largimas al escuchar esto

  • go listen to the Images and words album, or 'hollow years'...or 'an evening with...' Petrucci is not the robot everyone makes him out to be.

  • You call Wishful Thinking (just an example) fast playing? You lost your time trying to look stupid..listen to JP's music before you talk asshole.

  • Wow, that was mature... I'm completely swayed by your rational and logical argument on the subject!

  • Mature or not..it was the true =)

  • i'm also swayed by your logical argument

    how can you say that he didn't master the idea of dynamics, there's nothing more false, analyze the music, goddamn

  • did you even listen to the first 12 bars of this solo there are only about 6 bars where he's flying and the rest is absolutely overflowing with emotion and dynamics dude you really need to hear everything this guy plays before you make a dumbass comment like that

  • Wow, another genius... I guess I'm just going to ignore my own personal tastes, because someone on the Internet used the brilliant "dumbass" argument he learned in some Ivy League debate team.

  • if you don´t like petrucci...why are you watching this? go dream with Mr SlowAtGuitar, we admire Petrucci slow or fast as a lightning, besides...have you ever played a guitar in front of thousand people? so, more discretion in opinions before comment ;)

  • What are you talking about, did you not listen to his playing here before you commented?

    I think that his use of dynamics and "feeling" was spot in here. I immediately felt it without thinking about it...2:35.

    Besides it was a guitar solo which is the climactic portion of the song, and sound is subjective anyway. And dude, he's a pretty famous guitarist, I am going to so that he may know a thing or two about dynamics.

  • Got to say I disagree with you there, Joe. Of course it's all down to personal taste, but how much of his playing have you heard? Have you heard The Best of Times, Octavarium, Spirit Carries On . . .? Though I suppose if you could think his playing here doesn't show dynamics, you won't be impressed by anything.

    Anyway, it's nice to run into you out here in the cold.

  • owned

  • what?

    petrucci is one of the best guitarist of the world and with his band is my favourite, but joe is the master. ;)

  • @ImprobableJoe but he does save his speed? Fellow fans here have given u sufficient song names to find slow soulful parts, and you have ignored those and chosen to ridicule them instead. I dont think u r really wanting any help on this subject. Save your unsavoury comments please

  • @dvsdez

    Why are you digging up old comments to whine about people not agreeing with your opinion? Grow up, dude.

  • What I think may be happening here is..some people are not able to feel what certain musicians are playing..this doesn't mean these players are bad nor does it imply these listeners are deaf just simply uncompatable...HOWEVER...John petrucci relays such a vast reprotoire of music for anyone to not find atleast one thing they enjoy..well hey there are millions of country bars..maybe one should go there..loldvsdez you and I agree more than not..rock on for the god is John.

  • Well said, Petrucci is my all time favorite guitar player above all the rest so I'm biased but whatever, haha.