Love Sarah but that Kirsty is so off key! How is she the lead singer of this group. Maybe just not a good song for her. Sarah is beautiful like always .
I just heard the album version and ran it through a music program which can detect noise and display it's volume and pitch. Kristy follows almost to a tee the album version. I don't think it was a sound error either.
Am I the only one who finds it kinda funny to see Bill Leeb in jeans and a white polo onstage, considering how he "normally" looks with Frontline Assembly? Just a thought, and great performance despite the sound issues.
A couple of years ago I posted my comment saying Kristy and Sarah don't always harmonize well. I couldn't think of a real good song to put them together as I know Sarah simply wouldn't be able to pull off Flower's like Kristy. Well I think they should do Sarah's early song called Ben's Song. I sing alot like Kristy and I was able to follow Sarah through all of it. They should reteam to give it a try.
It can't be easy to share center stage with Sarah McLachlan. With the possible exception of Enya, nobody even comes close to her in terms of vocal quality, professionalism, technical precision, depth and range of tone, and ability to physically emote.
the combination of Sarah's lyrics, Sarah and Kristy's voices together in harmony along with the music of Deleriium is what makes Silence the greatest trance track in existence
Either way, Sarah's mic is in fact not on at the beginning, and the sound man DID screw this up. The mix isn't all that great for all instruments. The sound man at front of house could have easily pulled Kristy's volume down to compensate for her louder singing style. Also, I see no signals being given by her to bring up her monitor mix, so again-her fault Listen to the first chorus... she's horribly out of tune there and that has nothing to do with anything other than not hitting the note.
@evekta11 You can't blame a loud mic for somene being out of key, that's about the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Kristy IS in fact singing out of key several times. If anything, her monitor mix might be too low and she can't hear herself which could be causing her problem, not because her mic is is too loud. Either way... she is clearly out of key several times. Sarah has perfect pitch and I've never in my life heard her hit an off note... ever. Still, nice version with both singing
What the band hears on stage stage is not the same as what you hear in the crowd (or on the recording). It's up to the sound people to get the levels right.
btw that blonde girl is kirsty thirsk, and if you want to listen to her then listen to like Matt Darey pres. Urban Astronauts - Black Flowers (Josh Gabriel Remix) which is 130 on the top 1000.. this song is number 1 on the top 1000
I don`t think that Kristy is that bad. She has a good voice, otherwise she wouldn`t have sang so many great songs (especially with Delerium). I think that the major problem here was she trying to grasp all the attention to herself. She tried too hard to make her voice "appear" more and she ended up kinda screwing up this amazing song. To me it`s clear she wanted her voice to resonate more than Sarah''s, it`s a classic "I can sing better than she can" situation. Obviously, she can`t.
Both women do a beautiful job here. I think this could have been an interesting blend of voices with nice harmonies, but the microphone levels were way off. Somebody definitely screwed up somewhere. The singers and the band were a amazing, though.
The beautiful blonde girl, Kristy, is perhaps better singer than Sarah, she is less commercial perhaps, but she is better. She is who sings Silence in the tours of Delerium and the song remains precious as she same. Its voice has many shades, is very reich. The rare thing in this presentation is that parace to be that all was designed so that only to light up Sarah. Kristy is a goddess, my goddess.
You seriously have absolutely no idea what u r talking about. Can't stand it when ppl make ridiculous comments because they want to bone the singer....
Sarah will always be the template in which all other female singers are judged!!
The sooner you realize that...the sooner you will be able to distinguish real talent.
La hermosa chica rubia, Kristy, es quizás mejor cantante que Sarah, es menos comercial quizá, pero es mejor. Ella es quien canta Silence en las giras de Delerium y la canción queda preciosa como ella misma. Su voz tiene muchos matices. Lo raro en esta presentación es que parace ser que todo se diseñó para que únicamente luciera Sarah. Kristy es una diosa.
holy shit the blonde chick fked this soooo bad , would have thrown something at her . When sarah sings everything is fine than the blonde chick just ...........
She normally makes the song, the sound technicians left her mic too high and didn't raise sarah's enough. Do you even know who she is or heard her work or are you just talking shit?
Kristy Thirsk in some other versions of this song she is amazing. McLachlan doesn't sound very good to me in this version either, sound technician fail?
@tekkentekken i agreed, that blond chick was drowning sarah out with an awful high pitch sqeel! agh! i wanted to throw summet at my pc screen! lol ahhh! :)
guys does anyone knows which woman sing this song in the cd?cause in all videos i saw the blonde women always and the second singer is always different...
@evekat11 The Blonde has a WHINY voice that sounds horrible and annoying! She smothers the mic with her mouth by grabbing it and holding it up to her mouth A LOT. Her mic was loud and she should have backed up from it, so she isn't drowning out Sarah, but instead she does the opposite! Hence I blame HER and not the sound guys for this discrepancy.
kirsty, don't sing with sarah ever again. sarah, don't make the mistake of singing with kirsty ever again lol. kirsty, by far, is not anywhere near the league of sarah's pure tones. kirsty sings between the keys, sarah sings on them.
It can't only be Sarah. The reason they have Kristy up there is because there is a backup singer in Silence, not just because they think she should be up there for no reason. And seriously, why is everyone so against Krisy Thirsk?
What a bold thing to say. Kristy is every bit as talented as Sarah. To me Kristy is the better singer. She is my fave singer of all-time. This was a benefit & Kristy was there so she sang backup. Don't be so critical!
The song is excellent. The singing is nice. I have to agree with other posters that Sarah and Kristy are not always a good match. Kristy is better off with her fellow singer in NastyByte's video. Kristy is just a strong voice. I sing like her. Good at the bottom, phenominal at the top, pointless in the middle.
The studio version is fantastic. Sarah's vocals are MUCH higher and they harmonize very will together.
This version grows on you the more you watch it. But the album version has all the character of Sarah's solo lines plus the higher pitched harmonizing.
Kristy's vocals are pretty much exactly the same as the studio version.
@TheChiFlows They don't sing together (in the same song) at any studio album. Sarah only sings on Silence. Kristy sings in a bunch of songs... Flowers Become Screens, Incantation, Duende, Heavens Earth, Til' the end of time, Returning, Self-Saboteur...
So: The only album at which you will hear them both is Karma.
Kristy really is a great vocalist, its just their vocals differ soo much I think, and the quality of the video isnt good either. Have a listen to some tracks from her album "Souvenir" or some of her other works with Delerium, like "Flowers Become Screens".
HAHAHA Just love it, i bought some techno compilation album just for this song :) Today i have just came back from a long ride through Poland freeways in my car. And guess what song was played ;)
quien viera a Bill Leeb y Rhys Fulber, las siniestras mentes detras de Front Line Assembly, uno salido del terrorifico Skinny Puppy y otro productor de grupos tan agresivos como Fear Factory. Dos señorones en lo que a musica se refiere
Love Sarah!!!!!!!!!!!
Limiriv 1 month ago
Krsty FAIL!!!!!
Limiriv 1 month ago
Love Sarah but that Kirsty is so off key! How is she the lead singer of this group. Maybe just not a good song for her. Sarah is beautiful like always .
LBcanada1 1 month ago
i don't know what are you people talking about,when blondie sings great...
WhiteWave4 2 months ago
9 dislikes ?!? ha ha i am sitting coming in my pants and 9 people don't like this? wow, the world actually has 9 living dead among us .. hmm
carlafierro7 2 months ago
I just heard the album version and ran it through a music program which can detect noise and display it's volume and pitch. Kristy follows almost to a tee the album version. I don't think it was a sound error either.
closettopopenbottom 2 months ago
Am I the only one who finds it kinda funny to see Bill Leeb in jeans and a white polo onstage, considering how he "normally" looks with Frontline Assembly? Just a thought, and great performance despite the sound issues.
TylerInTraining 3 months ago
Sarah is Sarah 4eva
willtrac 3 months ago in playlist willtrac's favorites
yeah the sound guy fucked this up.
mrjdgibbs 4 months ago 2
tiesto mixxx
diegocondevalado 4 months ago
Sarah McLachlan is sooo motherly! I wish I could meet her :-/
pampers1919 5 months ago
A couple of years ago I posted my comment saying Kristy and Sarah don't always harmonize well. I couldn't think of a real good song to put them together as I know Sarah simply wouldn't be able to pull off Flower's like Kristy. Well I think they should do Sarah's early song called Ben's Song. I sing alot like Kristy and I was able to follow Sarah through all of it. They should reteam to give it a try.
closettopopenbottom 5 months ago
This song is RARELY performed live, very rarely. I'm sure they didn't have much time to rehearse this for the benefit concert either.
marsneedstowels 6 months ago
im sick of listening blond Blondie she has a name her name is Kristy call her with her name
seeeliwww 6 months ago
To have both on this stage...i would have been a crybaby!
futuristlimited 7 months ago
The blond's voice isn't out of key at all..actually.
TheCommonStrangerr 7 months ago
It can't be easy to share center stage with Sarah McLachlan. With the possible exception of Enya, nobody even comes close to her in terms of vocal quality, professionalism, technical precision, depth and range of tone, and ability to physically emote.
BellaBellucci69 7 months ago in playlist Sarah McLachlan videos
the combination of Sarah's lyrics, Sarah and Kristy's voices together in harmony along with the music of Deleriium is what makes Silence the greatest trance track in existence
kleytahn 8 months ago
Either way, Sarah's mic is in fact not on at the beginning, and the sound man DID screw this up. The mix isn't all that great for all instruments. The sound man at front of house could have easily pulled Kristy's volume down to compensate for her louder singing style. Also, I see no signals being given by her to bring up her monitor mix, so again-her fault Listen to the first chorus... she's horribly out of tune there and that has nothing to do with anything other than not hitting the note.
Rustbukkit69 9 months ago
@evekta11 You can't blame a loud mic for somene being out of key, that's about the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Kristy IS in fact singing out of key several times. If anything, her monitor mix might be too low and she can't hear herself which could be causing her problem, not because her mic is is too loud. Either way... she is clearly out of key several times. Sarah has perfect pitch and I've never in my life heard her hit an off note... ever. Still, nice version with both singing
Rustbukkit69 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
love this and them, perfect
sde22ssw 9 months ago
love this and them, perfect
sde22ssw 9 months ago
What the band hears on stage stage is not the same as what you hear in the crowd (or on the recording). It's up to the sound people to get the levels right.
gooble69 10 months ago
Total Karaoke, that went bad, bad.
LiecoWave 10 months ago
omg sarah mc lachian is sexy as fuck
palmer3977 11 months ago
btw that blonde girl is kirsty thirsk, and if you want to listen to her then listen to like Matt Darey pres. Urban Astronauts - Black Flowers (Josh Gabriel Remix) which is 130 on the top 1000.. this song is number 1 on the top 1000
joshmdmd 1 year ago
another version of a spectacular song, the blonde compliments her vocally, or I am deaf.
jvjames1 1 year ago
that blondie fucks it up
bilat86 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
bilat86 1 year ago
love the bass!!!!! ms leah randi!
jencupcake 1 year ago
why is the blonde bitch singing while sarah is singing?
sarahjshell 1 year ago
Wow! Sarah kind of got muted during the chorus because Kristy belted it out! I wasn't expecting that.
GoldeneyeMarine 1 year ago
sorry if i'm slammin, or spammin this video..
these singers are angels!
dp535i 1 year ago
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT!!!
dp535i 1 year ago
Comment removed
nasser62 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don`t think that Kristy is that bad. She has a good voice, otherwise she wouldn`t have sang so many great songs (especially with Delerium). I think that the major problem here was she trying to grasp all the attention to herself. She tried too hard to make her voice "appear" more and she ended up kinda screwing up this amazing song. To me it`s clear she wanted her voice to resonate more than Sarah''s, it`s a classic "I can sing better than she can" situation. Obviously, she can`t.
ThaisM87 1 year ago
Comment removed
ThaisM87 1 year ago
Comment removed
ThaisM87 1 year ago
detune zombie alert ! somebody shoot the blonde !
jarjar2b 1 year ago
wow...
that heroin skeletal kristy chick has zero right to be trying to share live vocals with McLachlan.....
Gawd!!!
lordofchord 1 year ago 2
вот это класс
serjio35 1 year ago
they did a awesome job for live but the back up singer needs to eat a steak or 10.
southofheave1985 1 year ago
Kristy sounds awful. She needs to step back and let Sarah to her thing.
LBcanada1 1 year ago
back up singer sounds shit.
marcovella7 2 years ago
Both women do a beautiful job here. I think this could have been an interesting blend of voices with nice harmonies, but the microphone levels were way off. Somebody definitely screwed up somewhere. The singers and the band were a amazing, though.
TwoFlightsDown 2 years ago 4
the high voice here is perfect
robi2000 2 years ago
The beautiful blonde girl, Kristy, is perhaps better singer than Sarah, she is less commercial perhaps, but she is better. She is who sings Silence in the tours of Delerium and the song remains precious as she same. Its voice has many shades, is very reich. The rare thing in this presentation is that parace to be that all was designed so that only to light up Sarah. Kristy is a goddess, my goddess.
PabloFolky 2 years ago
@PabloFolky
You seriously have absolutely no idea what u r talking about. Can't stand it when ppl make ridiculous comments because they want to bone the singer....
Sarah will always be the template in which all other female singers are judged!!
The sooner you realize that...the sooner you will be able to distinguish real talent.
Fool......
lordofchord 1 year ago
La hermosa chica rubia, Kristy, es quizás mejor cantante que Sarah, es menos comercial quizá, pero es mejor. Ella es quien canta Silence en las giras de Delerium y la canción queda preciosa como ella misma. Su voz tiene muchos matices. Lo raro en esta presentación es que parace ser que todo se diseñó para que únicamente luciera Sarah. Kristy es una diosa.
PabloFolky 2 years ago
Good Day
PauleQueenie 2 years ago
holy shit the blonde chick fked this soooo bad , would have thrown something at her . When sarah sings everything is fine than the blonde chick just ...........
tekkentekken 2 years ago
She normally makes the song, the sound technicians left her mic too high and didn't raise sarah's enough. Do you even know who she is or heard her work or are you just talking shit?
Style386 2 years ago 5
yes i know who she is , shes the blonde chick who fked the song up in the video
tekkentekken 2 years ago
yes this is a bad mix :/ i don't understand why sound engineers do this kind of mistakes .. they ruin songs and songs with the most silly things .
SnakeNickkkk 1 year ago
but really who is she ? i don't know much of this band .
SnakeNickkkk 1 year ago
Kristy Thirsk in some other versions of this song she is amazing. McLachlan doesn't sound very good to me in this version either, sound technician fail?
Style386 1 year ago
i guess :) the other live is better but .. lower quality :P
SnakeNickkkk 1 year ago
@Style386 her name is Kirsty Thirsk, she's from a band called Rose Chronicles... check out their album "Shiver" it's quite good
satanblahblah 1 week ago
@tekkentekken i agreed, that blond chick was drowning sarah out with an awful high pitch sqeel! agh! i wanted to throw summet at my pc screen! lol ahhh! :)
TH3N4M3SViRGO 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheChiFlows 1 year ago
guys does anyone knows which woman sing this song in the cd?cause in all videos i saw the blonde women always and the second singer is always different...
alexseroxat 2 years ago
Sarah sings on the CD
NuclearLullaby 2 years ago
Stop hatin on Kristy
1TheTreasurer1 2 years ago
who is shara? the blonde one?
larisaies 2 years ago
It would be better if Sarah sang it alone... As for that blonde - Shut up!
TheMrj7ck 2 years ago
Love it!! is this the only live footage w/ Sarah?
Zhorellski 2 years ago
Comment removed
SecretIVUIIHear 2 years ago
i love the violin in this
tommyloika 2 years ago
yeah you would think the people setting up and running the mixers and mics would have been better considering Bill Leeb was there...
same thing happened at a Haujobb concert I went to... the soundboard guys fucked that concert up so bad...
apparentsymmetry 2 years ago 3
I have to defend blondie - it wasn't that she was out of key, her mic was turned up too high.
Blame the sound guys, and if you don't believe me, try listening to the first two lines Sarah sings. Her mics not on!
evekat11 2 years ago 16
I totally agree with eveka11 and
apparentsymmetry. This definitely sound board guys' fault. They probably had hangover from the party the night before....
mj4magic 2 years ago 3
@evekat11 The Blonde has a WHINY voice that sounds horrible and annoying! She smothers the mic with her mouth by grabbing it and holding it up to her mouth A LOT. Her mic was loud and she should have backed up from it, so she isn't drowning out Sarah, but instead she does the opposite! Hence I blame HER and not the sound guys for this discrepancy.
latnboii 10 months ago
super song ever singed
djkadirtube 2 years ago
I like tiesto
thiagoabpoa 2 years ago
god the blonde chick ruined this song.
thekrystalmethod 2 years ago 3
The blond babe always burries this song... she should be forbidden to sing this song ever again! While Sarah... well she's just a legue of her own!
oukeea 2 years ago 9
Sarah burried under off key oportunism... Creepy Kristy. Adn Sarah smiles politely... or does she?
SecretIVUIIHear 2 years ago 3
kirsty, don't sing with sarah ever again. sarah, don't make the mistake of singing with kirsty ever again lol. kirsty, by far, is not anywhere near the league of sarah's pure tones. kirsty sings between the keys, sarah sings on them.
zenshiva 2 years ago 4
Come on people. A good vocalist knows how to adapt in order to blend in. Kristy was not even trying. She was seriously out of tune!
SaphielsSapphire 2 years ago 5
Again, in the studio version Sarah's vocals are much stronger then they are here.
Sarah has not kept her vocals strong and it shows in this version of the song.
Kristy's vocals would perfectly harmonize with Sarah's if Sarah sang the song as it was recorded.
Don't blame Kristy for Sarah's weak vocals.
Again. I strongly recommend the studio version of the song. It is fantastic.
shadowpigglet 2 years ago
It does not seem to be posting links.
Look for a final fantisy 8 vid and it has the studio verion.
shadowpigglet 2 years ago
In my humble opinion, the sound guy could've done a better job. Sarah is not a power signer. A lot of factorscan influence a signer's chords...
SecretIVUIIHear 2 years ago
This song should have been sung by only Sarah. No offense but Kristy doesn't even belong on the same stage as Sarah.
tayrivera 2 years ago
It can't only be Sarah. The reason they have Kristy up there is because there is a backup singer in Silence, not just because they think she should be up there for no reason. And seriously, why is everyone so against Krisy Thirsk?
1TheTreasurer1 2 years ago
What a bold thing to say. Kristy is every bit as talented as Sarah. To me Kristy is the better singer. She is my fave singer of all-time. This was a benefit & Kristy was there so she sang backup. Don't be so critical!
mosriteluv 2 years ago
This is definately one of my favorite songs Delerium has produced, and one of their most well known considering Sarah McLachlan sings it.
TheRadiantDrummer 2 years ago
The song is excellent. The singing is nice. I have to agree with other posters that Sarah and Kristy are not always a good match. Kristy is better off with her fellow singer in NastyByte's video. Kristy is just a strong voice. I sing like her. Good at the bottom, phenominal at the top, pointless in the middle.
closettopopenbottom 2 years ago
They should have turned down the blonde's mic to only 25% of the level it is on. I can barely hear Sarah. And I WANT to hear Sarah.
xaesthirv 2 years ago
The studio version is fantastic. Sarah's vocals are MUCH higher and they harmonize very will together.
This version grows on you the more you watch it. But the album version has all the character of Sarah's solo lines plus the higher pitched harmonizing.
Kristy's vocals are pretty much exactly the same as the studio version.
shadowpigglet 2 years ago
They're both great singers, I just think their voices DEFINITELY don't mix
PanoplyCabaret 2 years ago 4
the blond next to her is ruining the performance
barrettvela 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
drdlin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like how she moves her hips though!
drdlin 2 years ago
who is whom?
golddigger0325 2 years ago
From stage right to left, Bill Leeb, Sean Ashby, Kristy Thirsk and Sarah McLachlan on vocals, Ashwin Sood on drums, Leah Randi and Rhys Fulber
OfficialDelerium 2 years ago
@OfficialDelerium How many songs or albums did this line up do .And what are they ?.
TheChiFlows 1 year ago
@TheChiFlows They don't sing together (in the same song) at any studio album. Sarah only sings on Silence. Kristy sings in a bunch of songs... Flowers Become Screens, Incantation, Duende, Heavens Earth, Til' the end of time, Returning, Self-Saboteur...
So: The only album at which you will hear them both is Karma.
heek7133 1 year ago
@OfficialDelerium er... Left to right. -_-
OfficialDelerium 6 months ago
sarah is the best!!
lurdq 2 years ago
It blew my mind when I found out Delerium and FLA are pretty much the same band.
srb1369 3 years ago
That blonde girl sounds really bad. Sarah is voice is great though.
Gleyi07 3 years ago 4
I agree :)
BestCarFans 3 years ago
Kristy really is a great vocalist, its just their vocals differ soo much I think, and the quality of the video isnt good either. Have a listen to some tracks from her album "Souvenir" or some of her other works with Delerium, like "Flowers Become Screens".
Skyline10789 3 years ago 4
HAHAHA Just love it, i bought some techno compilation album just for this song :) Today i have just came back from a long ride through Poland freeways in my car. And guess what song was played ;)
mjshikeli 3 years ago
ace....my best dance tune in the world!!
nutta xx
sexynutta 3 years ago 4
Outstanding,well done, lovin all Sara and Del stuff,i've got 4 of the albums: Karma - Poem -Demantic Spaces - Spritual Archives
jrunbala 3 years ago 2
amazing
zivdahan 3 years ago 3
I love this song, I didn't even know that The delirium have this song :) 5/5
AgamRaizD86 3 years ago 3
Buy the Karma cd from Delerium. It's breathtaking. It has this song also.
yomahmaful 3 years ago 2
chingonsisimo
aifpivan 3 years ago 3
quien viera a Bill Leeb y Rhys Fulber, las siniestras mentes detras de Front Line Assembly, uno salido del terrorifico Skinny Puppy y otro productor de grupos tan agresivos como Fear Factory. Dos señorones en lo que a musica se refiere
iscleyva 2 years ago