Are both of the top comments on crack? Sing better than Whitney? Has more soul than WHITNEY? Hahahahahahahhaha please not only is Whit's tone a 1000x better her Technique and musicality far surpass Kelly easily. But yes Kelly can blow!!! Love this performance a lot, specially those last belts.
Wow, I most definitely agree that Kelly was the best on American Idol but to compare and say that she's better than Whitney, Celine and Christina (that's just absurd!!!!) All four of these women have totally different voices and I wouldn't dare say that one is better than the other cuz they're all in a league of their own lightningshock12. A bit of an exxageration on ur behalf
damn those notes at the end!!!! where are they coming from!??!?!?! and she's so cute at the end... she's all... hehehe thank you! love kelly forever!!
Outrageous... that's the word!! My god! What are those notes!!!?? AMAZING to the T-bone!! Go Kelly! You were definitely brilliant and unbeatable here!!
I love how she gives this soulful heartfelt performance with these crazy vocals and high notes and belting and the she ends giggles and goes thank you in this sweet innocent little voice.... oh i love kelly clarkson
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
she yelled too much at some moments but she was good...she is a good singer i just dont like when someone is oversinging all the time...but she was sweet at the end when she politely said thank u :D
WOW. She can sing. She is better than fantasia for a fact. She can sing better than Whitney houston and Celine Dion. And please, She will blow Christina Aguilera away. Kelly Clarkson is the best american idol ever. She has an excellent and flawless versitale voice. She has power. She can sing anything. Go Kelly.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Thats saying A LOT. Kelly is an amazing singer but Christina and Fantasia are right up there with her. Lets remember an amazing singer is NOT one who can belt super high notes. Its a Singer who has a unique tone, emotion, and interpretive skills. Range is a plus but its really good too. Again I agree with you Kelly is awesome but lets not get carried away :)
Love Whitney's voice. Love Kelly's voice. Don't care too much for Celine's.
But Kelly is unbelievably awesome, and this performance is EPIC. And as much as I love Whitney, Kelly has more soul than both Whitney and Celine. Hear it. Believe it.
@jerjuant i'm such a huge kelly clarkson fan and i'm confident that as the years go by and her voice just keeps getting stronger, that you will probably eat these words.
@christiantry: a little late aren't you??? she has been around almost an entire decade, and she still has not gotten better. i guess i will die before i eat my words. deal with it.
@jerjuant I barely stumbled upon your snobby comment today, so sorry i couldn't get to you a year in advance. I love Celine, Whitney, and Kelly and respect all their hard work as artists, but I think what you said about this Kelly Clarkson is unfair. I've seen Whitney at her worst, so trust me when i say Kelly at her best is much better. By the way, she is soo much better than when she started. The depth her voice has gained is incredible and she's not stopping. She has major talent.
@jerjuant I commented you because i'm a guy who believes people should treat others with respect whether they're celebrities or not. I'll stop commenting you after this because I realize that it is pointless. It's pointless because you're rude, vulgar, and will probably continue badmouthing others the way you do. Just realize you're in for a world of trouble in the future guaranteed. Have a nice day!
@christiantry: well one word of advice for you, every single person, the world over is obligated to have an opinion. that's just a fact you will have to deal with. that is exactly what i did. gave MY opinion. are you gonna go around harassing peoples opinions that stray away from your beliefs??? i would hope not. but thank you for sharing your thoughts. good day and god bless.
@jerjuant Ok, I lied. I need to comment you again because your rebuttal is bogus. I respect your opinion, but I don't appreciate the negative angle in your comment you used to put kelly down. If you would have put it simply that you personally believed that Celine and Whitney were better, I REALLY would have been fine with that. Let me remind you, you became hostile first by asking me to crawl up a butt and die. I think you need to check yourself before you wreck yourself.
Among the best in the whole wide world. Love it how she apparently ran out of breath when she said "thank you" at the end. These notes seem to flow so easily if you know what I mean.
I have and she has gotten better than she was this time last year, but I still don't think she could sing this song now like she did then. But voices change it isn't a bad thing, i love the grunge she adds to her voice when she sings sober.
haha thanks! i just play the piano key for what it is, and that's the note! And I kinda memorized the sound of some of the notes. I was wrong though, it's actually an Ab5 here. :)
Kelly always makes me laugh! After delivering a spectacular performance with vocals out of this world, she very calmly says "thank you." Ah, she is so modest.
man! i really wish she could still sing like this thats the Kelly that blew everyone away. Her new rock stuff is good but its just not the powerful voice like this. I hope she can get back to this on her next album.
nobody can sing like her, nobody can even dream about singing like kelly :) she's much better than leona, her voice is much more powerful and full of soul, her high notes are beyond compare. in every performance, even if she's sick, she proves her voice comes from her heart. i usually listen to rock&alt music, but i simply love her. come to poland, kelly!
I'm not really good with actual frequencies... They are probably in the fifth octave though, but they sound different than I usually hear them, they are so much more powerful!
Lol, when she hits those "high notes" Vanessa Amorosi sounds just like one of the Chipmunks... It was creepy, I thought the video was being fast-forwarded or something.
Holy crap those notes she was hitting seriously sent chills down my spine. They really just pierce at you, I've never heard ANYONE hit anything like that, amazing.
damnnn how can she belt notes that high?? crazy!!
taZd 1 month ago
Are both of the top comments on crack? Sing better than Whitney? Has more soul than WHITNEY? Hahahahahahahhaha please not only is Whit's tone a 1000x better her Technique and musicality far surpass Kelly easily. But yes Kelly can blow!!! Love this performance a lot, specially those last belts.
MrButler124 3 months ago
She was a star right from the get-go. Talk about a "natural". Wow
edko426 6 months ago
hot damn!
musicbabylove1 8 months ago
This is absolutely ridiculous. The force is strong with this one. lol
Gotta love her.
luvaboy8020 1 year ago 2
This is the best performance of ALL TIME! It's unbelievable!! OMG!
lagms 1 year ago 2
This is my absolute favorite of all her live appearances
Cynthsam21 1 year ago
OMG......it's the best sooong ever
Thankxxxx
Where i ge'it mp3?!!
The4everlove4 1 year ago
This is the best live performance I've ever seem! Kelly is so amazing!
coldwiz 1 year ago 2
OOOOOH MY GOD!!! I think that this is her best performance!!! It's funny how she laughs at the end of the song :)) =)) Gooo Kelly!!! You're good!!
Mr68Fireman 1 year ago 2
Wow, I most definitely agree that Kelly was the best on American Idol but to compare and say that she's better than Whitney, Celine and Christina (that's just absurd!!!!) All four of these women have totally different voices and I wouldn't dare say that one is better than the other cuz they're all in a league of their own lightningshock12. A bit of an exxageration on ur behalf
JacqualynThomas 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
JacqualynThomas 1 year ago
I think this is the best live version of this song! :)
She's SOOO good! Her range is huge!
FullofAwesomeness101 1 year ago
I love Kelly. I dont care for Whitney or Celine. I think she is better.
lizzyvance 1 year ago
I think that this is her best performance. I like her... I discovered her 1 year ago with the song Brakaway.
forteledemuzica 1 year ago
cute
!
KCfanJB 2 years ago
i'll give her a standing ovation love you kelly clarkson
showgirl225 2 years ago 2
haha she shocked her self at the end hahaha sooo good she just went for it
sexychaz101 2 years ago
damn those notes at the end!!!! where are they coming from!??!?!?! and she's so cute at the end... she's all... hehehe thank you! love kelly forever!!
jcaustintx 2 years ago 3
impressive, very impressive
MrKellyClarksonfan 2 years ago 5
i watched this like hundred times and still watching lol
she is more than best she is flawless
T3raz1 2 years ago 5
Gosh... I'm NEVER tired of watching this!! It's addictive lol
simplymild 2 years ago 3
Outrageous... that's the word!! My god! What are those notes!!!?? AMAZING to the T-bone!! Go Kelly! You were definitely brilliant and unbeatable here!!
Love ya!
simplymild 2 years ago 5
I've watched it like a thousand times and still...
I'm amazed every time!!
Go Kelly! <3
Gexxxi 2 years ago 3
omg those notes..this Performance deserves 2oooooooo views!!
dreamless1988 2 years ago 6
Crazy! Insane! Amazing!
This is the best performance I've ever heard so far. I freaking love those outrageous high notes.
jdramaholic 2 years ago 4
I love how she gives this soulful heartfelt performance with these crazy vocals and high notes and belting and the she ends giggles and goes thank you in this sweet innocent little voice.... oh i love kelly clarkson
IdolReady 2 years ago 6
Sick performance, THAT'S RIGHT KELLY! Tear that song apart and make the audience gag!
jack4088 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she yelled too much at some moments but she was good...she is a good singer i just dont like when someone is oversinging all the time...but she was sweet at the end when she politely said thank u :D
tatjana1707 2 years ago
kelly is so adprable!btw im in love with this song!
demifan620 2 years ago
OMG I don't know how I never saw this before. This is one of Kelly's best performances vocally.
JustGoingForIt 2 years ago 13
2:52
fuckin AMAZING!!!
raiNwAter8690 2 years ago 4
What a voice.
just...imposible.
lovely & natural beauty ..
KcFanXx 2 years ago 3
she the best and I love Kelly
kanty35 2 years ago 10
Amazing Performance!
1234JOSHY 2 years ago 10
Pure. Effin. Genius. Now that is TALENT x 1000000!!
rockoutsf 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is singing really well in this performance, but has yet to fix some things.
Agudos not define a good singer or not!
What defines a good singer is the experience, and technical tuning.
LeonardoSilvaSantana 2 years ago
lets see you even get close to doing what kelly did in this video
BobBarkersLoveChild 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she great, but that was too much.
j1train 2 years ago
awesome i still cant get enough
kellyville77 2 years ago 5
WOW. She can sing. She is better than fantasia for a fact. She can sing better than Whitney houston and Celine Dion. And please, She will blow Christina Aguilera away. Kelly Clarkson is the best american idol ever. She has an excellent and flawless versitale voice. She has power. She can sing anything. Go Kelly.
lightningshock12 2 years ago 37
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thats saying A LOT. Kelly is an amazing singer but Christina and Fantasia are right up there with her. Lets remember an amazing singer is NOT one who can belt super high notes. Its a Singer who has a unique tone, emotion, and interpretive skills. Range is a plus but its really good too. Again I agree with you Kelly is awesome but lets not get carried away :)
CareemBrownMusic 2 years ago
you what..she probably can sing better than fantasia,christina and celine,but she cant sing better than whitney.lol
kirab07 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
better than xxxtina and fantasia, yes. but NEVER celine and whitney. even on their worst day, she is nowhere near them.
jerjuant 2 years ago
Love Whitney's voice. Love Kelly's voice. Don't care too much for Celine's.
But Kelly is unbelievably awesome, and this performance is EPIC. And as much as I love Whitney, Kelly has more soul than both Whitney and Celine. Hear it. Believe it.
rockoutsf 2 years ago 24
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i guess you and i hear two different thing.
jerjuant 2 years ago
@jerjuant i'm such a huge kelly clarkson fan and i'm confident that as the years go by and her voice just keeps getting stronger, that you will probably eat these words.
christiantry 1 year ago
@christiantry: a little late aren't you??? she has been around almost an entire decade, and she still has not gotten better. i guess i will die before i eat my words. deal with it.
jerjuant 1 year ago
@jerjuant I barely stumbled upon your snobby comment today, so sorry i couldn't get to you a year in advance. I love Celine, Whitney, and Kelly and respect all their hard work as artists, but I think what you said about this Kelly Clarkson is unfair. I've seen Whitney at her worst, so trust me when i say Kelly at her best is much better. By the way, she is soo much better than when she started. The depth her voice has gained is incredible and she's not stopping. She has major talent.
christiantry 1 year ago
@christiantry: why don't you crawl up kellys ass and just die. i give a shit. stop commenting me. it's pointless really.
jerjuant 1 year ago
@jerjuant I commented you because i'm a guy who believes people should treat others with respect whether they're celebrities or not. I'll stop commenting you after this because I realize that it is pointless. It's pointless because you're rude, vulgar, and will probably continue badmouthing others the way you do. Just realize you're in for a world of trouble in the future guaranteed. Have a nice day!
christiantry 1 year ago
@christiantry: well one word of advice for you, every single person, the world over is obligated to have an opinion. that's just a fact you will have to deal with. that is exactly what i did. gave MY opinion. are you gonna go around harassing peoples opinions that stray away from your beliefs??? i would hope not. but thank you for sharing your thoughts. good day and god bless.
jerjuant 1 year ago
@jerjuant Ok, I lied. I need to comment you again because your rebuttal is bogus. I respect your opinion, but I don't appreciate the negative angle in your comment you used to put kelly down. If you would have put it simply that you personally believed that Celine and Whitney were better, I REALLY would have been fine with that. Let me remind you, you became hostile first by asking me to crawl up a butt and die. I think you need to check yourself before you wreck yourself.
christiantry 1 year ago
I've been trying to look for the performance forever! I finally found it. This is one of the most underated(and unknown) performance by Kelly ever!
acatisfinetoowut 2 years ago 5
Agreed - probably the best R&B performance I've heard Kelly sing
kbcfancep 2 years ago 7
Seriously...
the end notes are the best vocals i have ever heard in my LIFE. wow:)
and on the final run at 3.14 does she sing "I don't know this line"??:L
bumblywumblybee 2 years ago 12
Haha no she sings "It can tear you down inside" eventhough she usually sings "up" and not "down".
calvy 2 years ago 2
Among the best in the whole wide world. Love it how she apparently ran out of breath when she said "thank you" at the end. These notes seem to flow so easily if you know what I mean.
Myra1991JR 2 years ago 3
this is easily one of her best performances ever
IdolReady 2 years ago 6
Jesus Christ! She belted the s*%^ out of this song! Those notes were so powerful!
FurImmerLamm 3 years ago 11
She must have a throat made of steel)))) and 2:53 is unbelievable, simply amazing, that's how Kelly really CAN sing! Bravo!
RochilMuse 3 years ago 10
damn i watch this everyday...
raiNwAter8690 3 years ago 7
me too except that i download this into my mp3 so more convenient
11singingmachine11 2 years ago 2
wow amazing high note, christina could never hit!
FilipinooPride 3 years ago 11
u love kelly clarkson?
polynomiallover 2 years ago
holy SHHIIIIITT
raiNwAter8690 3 years ago 4
Her best performance ever <3<3<3
Best Live Performance in world <3
Sradomil 3 years ago 5
Kelly ur amazing ... I LOVE U!!! "hahaha thank u" haha super ^^ xx
FloLovesTatu 3 years ago 3
amazing perform!!
she's so damn good!!
Breakaway1992 3 years ago 2
Amazing voice !!
innocentssss 3 years ago 3
I love the "hahaha thank you :)" it was so cute love kelly!! :D
Well done.
ratandkow 3 years ago 4
lol wow - that was awesome !!
greattvshows452 3 years ago
HOLY HELL! THAT WAS FREAKING AMAZING!
krammybear 3 years ago 3
No words
Lovekellycl 3 years ago
incredible! and i love how she says "thank you" all quiet and sweet after nailing some HUGE notes. haha
americanidolfan5 3 years ago 4
Wow she nailed this!
dan1818dan 3 years ago 3
Scott WM!!
Stop leaving comments on my youtube accout ya baw!!!! lolol
seriously! lol
Megz41 3 years ago
i loved that performance, just awesome, like i mean wow!
sexy beast
Megz41 3 years ago 3
hell yeah
Megz41 3 years ago 3
I literally giggled like a schoolgirl when she said 'thank you' at the end. :/
iLaughAtConcrete 3 years ago 6
See, when Kelly sung this, she just wasn't just hitting those high notes.
She was beating the crap out of them, taking their lunch money, and got away with vocal MURDERRR.
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago 3
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G-!-!-!
sutarts 3 years ago
Dang, I wish she was in this vocal form now! That was incredible!
ILkBigButts 3 years ago
have you seen any videos from the 2 worlds 2 voices tour?
repentyourselff 3 years ago
I have and she has gotten better than she was this time last year, but I still don't think she could sing this song now like she did then. But voices change it isn't a bad thing, i love the grunge she adds to her voice when she sings sober.
ILkBigButts 3 years ago
It was only a few years ago. =] I'm pretty sure she could pull it off again. She just needs to practice it a few times. xP
I have faith in Kelly.
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago
She can pull it off but she doesn't want to...
anyway KELLY ROX!!!
sutarts 3 years ago
OKAY! To prove she can still belt out those high notes (when she wants to)
Go search on Youtube "Kelly Clarkson Baltimore Never Again".
=] SHE'S STILL 100% KELLY.
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago 2
She is good...nice scream though
idolfun14 3 years ago
amazing
xtashgraphics 3 years ago
incredible...she hits an A5 here, its her highest note!
americanidolfan5 3 years ago
wow you have a good ear for music
elu24991 3 years ago
haha thanks! i just play the piano key for what it is, and that's the note! And I kinda memorized the sound of some of the notes. I was wrong though, it's actually an Ab5 here. :)
americanidolfan5 3 years ago
No, your right. She hits both G#5 and A5 here!
CareemBrownMusic 3 years ago
Nay! Her highest note belongs to Natural Woman on American Idol. =]
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago
well thats her highest note overall, but its in her whistle register. i meant her highest note in chest voice. :)
americanidolfan5 3 years ago
I think she can hit higher than A5,, even though it's not shown..like B flat?
kgntndh 3 years ago
Yeah, she has touched B flat briefly before too!
CareemBrownMusic 3 years ago
amazing.. amazing....
crizelajoy 3 years ago
WOW! :D
ratandkow 3 years ago
Kelly always makes me laugh! After delivering a spectacular performance with vocals out of this world, she very calmly says "thank you." Ah, she is so modest.
saxysaxist 3 years ago 2
Kelly doesn't sing she SAANNNGG!
Pinkin1211 3 years ago 3
Actually, i love kelly more to singing R&Bs. But the Rocks songs are more awesome to her.
kgntndh 3 years ago 2
DAMN kelly SANG that song...
breehilll 3 years ago 2
l0l the title you put makes it look like kelly is the trouble with love
l0l i know that was lame...
angel0634 3 years ago
lawlz, i got it.
i noticed that too, HAHA.
repentyourselff 3 years ago
She's having fun and she's giving us an amazing performance !
jokc7179 3 years ago 2
That right there my friends is what I call perfection.
Cynthsam21 3 years ago 6
this is beyond perfection....
BobBarkersLoveChild 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's straining like mad. Her voice sounds so messed up after that screaming fit at the 2:53 mark.
xoxmellymelxox 3 years ago
i know this may be a foreign object to you, but a Q-TIP would do your ears WONDERS!
BobBarkersLoveChild 3 years ago 5
I don't want to stoop to your level Melsss, but you'd be practically fisting yourself if Underwood hit those kind of notes. :P :P xx
welshjoe21 3 years ago
she really does have an amazing set of pipes :)
thnx 4 uploading the video :P
Darkness010887 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love kelly, i'm a huge fan and an Expresser, but this is a bit excessive.
j1train 3 years ago
don't pretend like ur're kelly fan.
she turned this song in a powerful ballade with this performance.
hipboi 3 years ago
Christina Aguilera's live performance are excessive. This is tastefully powerful
Pinkin1211 3 years ago 4
i love this song!!! thanks for putting this up. :)
btw, you left out an 'l' in Kelly
PaigeMatthews63 3 years ago
Wow. A-ma-zing! Beautiful. Lovely. Perfect.
Any other way to describe it? Nah...
Love you KC!! Hope the song on your next album will be just as great!!!
Her cute laugh and "thank you" at the end are very cute. Perfectionism is in the air...
ordinarycharmed 3 years ago 3
oh my gosh. shes freaking amazing.
KCfan7706 3 years ago 2
Those A5's back to back were great, she is awesome
sanjayasbrother 3 years ago 12
i agree i missed watching her doing soul/funk/R&B she sounds good and infact, BETTER.
shiliz 3 years ago 9
man! i really wish she could still sing like this thats the Kelly that blew everyone away. Her new rock stuff is good but its just not the powerful voice like this. I hope she can get back to this on her next album.
jon1323 4 years ago 6
Can you believe this song was considered a
FLOP in 2004 "Thankful album? Did we used to
be stupid? OH! Kelly co-wrote this song.
Celinemmx 4 years ago 8
i honestly think this is her best performance ever...
and the laugh is just adorable!
bleachedrose 4 years ago 7
Kelly we all love you. You are the only true Idol.
Celinemmx 4 years ago 11
nobody can sing like her, nobody can even dream about singing like kelly :) she's much better than leona, her voice is much more powerful and full of soul, her high notes are beyond compare. in every performance, even if she's sick, she proves her voice comes from her heart. i usually listen to rock&alt music, but i simply love her. come to poland, kelly!
killerpl 4 years ago 16
I know I totally agree! I can't even describe how amazing I feel Kelly is.
jennnerz 4 years ago 7
Omg.
Kelly
I Fucking adore u
Im seeing you for the 5th time on the 14th :)
You are the BEST idol EVER :)
ljb0089331 4 years ago 5
Its amazing the way she can go from so high back to low
gchunni 4 years ago 4
hahaha.. i love at the end when she laughs and says "thank you!".. so effing cute
awaitingamnesty 4 years ago 5
This was fucking phenomenal
l0os3nup 4 years ago 4
What notes are she actually hitting here? They are awesome, does anyone know the actual notes though??
welshjoe21 4 years ago 3
I'm not really good with actual frequencies... They are probably in the fifth octave though, but they sound different than I usually hear them, they are so much more powerful!
o0ber 4 years ago
I think they are around F5, amazing!
jennnerz 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
these high notes is really great! but nothing beats VANESSA AMOROSI in high notes!
Kaurstad 4 years ago
Lol, when she hits those "high notes" Vanessa Amorosi sounds just like one of the Chipmunks... It was creepy, I thought the video was being fast-forwarded or something.
o0ber 4 years ago 3
Woww! No other Idol's winner can sing that good!! She's so awesome !!
jokc7179 4 years ago 7
Holy crap those notes she was hitting seriously sent chills down my spine. They really just pierce at you, I've never heard ANYONE hit anything like that, amazing.
o0ber 4 years ago 7
I was looking for this.. Thanks.. Kellys the best..
Calo0o 4 years ago 2
this is amazing. WOW. AMAZING> OMG> AMAZINFA>
nlee035 4 years ago 3
DAMN!! best performanc eof this song I think!! :-)
NikoJaquez 4 years ago 4
Love love love I've been looking for this!!!
SexehJoe 4 years ago 3
YES !
henny66306 4 years ago 2
The heavenly angels must have looked down to see which angel on Earth was singing...and saw Kelly singing as on this vid. Magical.
henny66306 4 years ago 4
heh, wow! she went crazy on that song at the end!! great emotion.
stampnstom 4 years ago 8