both bands are good friends. i like to think thrice covered this song as a tribute to frodus and clearly had approval. in any case its a kickass song written by one kickass band and covered by another kickass band. just listen to it!
wow, i really like both versions, mainly the bass parts. thrice's version is a little more folkier and this is a little heavier. which isn't a bad thing on both parts. to say either one of these bands suck, shows a little immaturuty. who cares if thrice covered their song, alot of bands cover songs. and in my opinion, i can't say i have a favorite version. as both as awesome.
This is better than Thrice's version?!?!? O_o Didn't see that coming. I actually like this shite recording of it more than Thrice's studio version, and I freakin' love Thrice!!
@LOCOKaHolO insulting why it's a complement, besides thrice is not capeable of doing an insulting cover or a poor song........... even this not so great recording was very good by the way. just had to defend a fantastic band. talk shit if you must I won't ever read it.
hmm, if people compared the actual recorded versions, theres very little difference. the vocals sound very similar, thrice's just sound more compressed, which personally im not a fan of, but thats purely subjective. as with all music.
This version is a little darker then the Thrice version. Thrice is a more chill version. Obviously Dustin Kensrue of Thrice has 10X better vocals then this dude, but I like Frodus.
@mardgn81 Yeah. From Wikipedia: "2009 saw Frodus resurface as the Frodus Escape Plan/Frodus Conglomerate International/FDIC (Frodus Despotic (or Deposit) Insurance Corporation) with Liam Wilson from Dillinger Escape Plan on bass"
To be honest, I never heard Frodus until I heard Thrice cover The Earth Isn't Humming. And now Frodus is one of my favorite bands (alongside Thrice!). Both covers are pretty unique in their own right.
And this shitty live video doesn't do the Frodus version justice, while Thrice has a few good recordings of them playing it.
Why does every video on youtube turn into a fight of someone being better than someone else,especially with music? I honestly have listened to frodus for the very first time today. I only looked into this because of thrice. This is a song by frodus therefore it is only right to give them all the credit. i enjoy both versions and think these bands are both awesome. And i dont think he was in anyway dissing thrice just making a joke that everyone knows this song because of thrice. chill out people
Oh the bitter online politics. I don't thing Shelby was necessarily trashing Thrice. DC has such a rich history of Great music..(well at least up until the early 2000's) Frodus and well many other bands from the area have influenced so many bands..of all different genres.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You've got videos from the get up kids, at the drive in, and jets to brazil. Yeah, I remember liking those bands......when I was 16. Go jump off a cliff you faggot. Stick to watching videos of drunk dudes and listening to total eclipse of the heart. Hahahahahahahaha
are you serius thrice is a band for teenagers.frodus is a real band that inspired all those little kids to do their music and in the process ruin the so called post hardcore genre and make it radio friendly.
pd:yes thrice did a cover song 10 years later or more and ruined the original one.
Thrice caters to the masses, huh? Why haven't they exploded and become the next Nirvana, and all that cliche bullshit comparison? Mm? Frodus started off as a teen angst band as well. Don't put your foot in your mouth. Rather, put it up your ass. Thrice is a great band that has matured since. I respect Frodus but don't care for them. Ciao.
@TC88Menasor alright well you are an idiot. thrice covered the song (ps thrice sucks) and that wasn't a "thrice reference", it was like, sarcastic. the stock come back by stupid people like you is always "DEUHHHH YOU COULD USE BIGGER WORDS DUHHHHH".
@okcomputer1016 I think you could use a vagina buddy. PS Poste Scripts go at the end thats why it has the word poste in it so I guess your stupid huh???
@Lemaster2316 Grammar insults are the bottom of the barrel faggot. Look at the punctuation in your paragraph. Plus you even spelled the word "post" wrong. You're clearly retarded.
For those that don't know, Dustin Kensrue (Thrice Lead Singer) did guest vocals on a song by The Out Circuit, who is fronted by Fodus' last Bassist
lolzalot44 6 months ago
Fantastic song. I love the bass line more than anything.. =D
christopher2step 9 months ago
both bands are good friends. i like to think thrice covered this song as a tribute to frodus and clearly had approval. in any case its a kickass song written by one kickass band and covered by another kickass band. just listen to it!
dames48 11 months ago 4
wow, i really like both versions, mainly the bass parts. thrice's version is a little more folkier and this is a little heavier. which isn't a bad thing on both parts. to say either one of these bands suck, shows a little immaturuty. who cares if thrice covered their song, alot of bands cover songs. and in my opinion, i can't say i have a favorite version. as both as awesome.
imhereformusic 1 year ago
Comment removed
thesauciestaround65 1 year ago
i heard they will change their name into underhillus, is that true?
getzingo 1 year ago
a frodus/dillinger esc plan split would be so sick.
shelby needs to record some mo tracks.
tylerarnold1234 1 year ago
Not only that, but Frodus' myspace says that they approve of (and even thank) Thrice's cover.
JohnMark8403 1 year ago
Two great bands. No feud here people, get over it and learn what sarcasm is.
JohnMark8403 1 year ago
This is better than Thrice's version?!?!? O_o Didn't see that coming. I actually like this shite recording of it more than Thrice's studio version, and I freakin' love Thrice!!
Cactus78 1 year ago
yea..its a bit insulting IMO.
thrice version FTW indeed.
LOCOKaHolO 1 year ago
@LOCOKaHolO insulting why it's a complement, besides thrice is not capeable of doing an insulting cover or a poor song........... even this not so great recording was very good by the way. just had to defend a fantastic band. talk shit if you must I won't ever read it.
Lemaster2316 1 year ago
Comment removed
likelylike 1 year ago
hmm, if people compared the actual recorded versions, theres very little difference. the vocals sound very similar, thrice's just sound more compressed, which personally im not a fan of, but thats purely subjective. as with all music.
joewhittles 1 year ago
Thrice's version ftw
Fanchus 1 year ago
Yep that's Liam Wilson from Dillinger.
ZosoDelta 1 year ago
"This next one is by...uh...Thrice?" HAHAHAHAHAHAHA AWESOME!!!!
TheNatedogg56 1 year ago 6
This version is a little darker then the Thrice version. Thrice is a more chill version. Obviously Dustin Kensrue of Thrice has 10X better vocals then this dude, but I like Frodus.
Dantheman5584 1 year ago
wow camera man is all up in their shit
bomberboy203 2 years ago
Isn't that the bassist for Dillinger?
mardgn81 2 years ago
@mardgn81 Yeah. From Wikipedia: "2009 saw Frodus resurface as the Frodus Escape Plan/Frodus Conglomerate International/FDIC (Frodus Despotic (or Deposit) Insurance Corporation) with Liam Wilson from Dillinger Escape Plan on bass"
aaronbobaron 1 year ago
Comment removed
tylerarnold1234 2 years ago
To be honest, I never heard Frodus until I heard Thrice cover The Earth Isn't Humming. And now Frodus is one of my favorite bands (alongside Thrice!). Both covers are pretty unique in their own right.
And this shitty live video doesn't do the Frodus version justice, while Thrice has a few good recordings of them playing it.
hankelcopia 2 years ago 2
I think Frodus should be glad Thrice covered their song. It's getting there music out there and known.
xXReidABookXx 2 years ago
frodus u rule
Jackstrider 2 years ago
everyone, STFU. and both versions are great so go suck a dick
HCxDav3man 2 years ago
I agree Thrice version is better and thats rare for a cover thats sounds better then the orginal for me
Enishu 2 years ago
this guy's got the right idea, if Frodus sucked Thrice wouldn't have covered them.
hotsnakes1 2 years ago
Thrice is my FAVORITE BAND, ever. But the original version of this song is better than Thrice's cover. IN MY OPINION.
So let's stop being douchebags here, shall we? Arguing over the internet is like winning the special olympics. Even if you win, you're still retarded.
hotsnakes1 2 years ago 3
fuck everyone on youtube who's used that quote. I swear I see that on nearly every video
barimaphone 2 years ago
gawd the thrice cover is way better.
RadicalSlurpee 2 years ago
dude ur hilarious, u just started a huge fight
hahah
Jackstrider 2 years ago
Why does every video on youtube turn into a fight of someone being better than someone else,especially with music? I honestly have listened to frodus for the very first time today. I only looked into this because of thrice. This is a song by frodus therefore it is only right to give them all the credit. i enjoy both versions and think these bands are both awesome. And i dont think he was in anyway dissing thrice just making a joke that everyone knows this song because of thrice. chill out people
helmd005 2 years ago 23
Agreed!
RockStar5656 2 years ago
I kind of like this version more...hmmm
beatlesfanman 2 years ago
Oh the bitter online politics. I don't thing Shelby was necessarily trashing Thrice. DC has such a rich history of Great music..(well at least up until the early 2000's) Frodus and well many other bands from the area have influenced so many bands..of all different genres.
starsapart0 2 years ago
welllll I found out about Thrice through Frodus via this song. ass backwards? at any rate both are great bands
barimaphone 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You've got videos from the get up kids, at the drive in, and jets to brazil. Yeah, I remember liking those bands......when I was 16. Go jump off a cliff you faggot. Stick to watching videos of drunk dudes and listening to total eclipse of the heart. Hahahahahahahaha
ssjvinnieg 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Funnily enough, this is the one song on the Alchemy Index that blows. Makes sense because so does Frodus.
ssjvinnieg 2 years ago
Interesting. This was my favorite song on the Earth CD, possibly in the entirety of The Alchemy Index. Guess my opinion's wrong.
MercuryClock 2 years ago
I guess so!
ssjvinnieg 2 years ago
Funny. Lern2sarcasmfgt.
MercuryClock 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are you serius thrice is a band for teenagers.frodus is a real band that inspired all those little kids to do their music and in the process ruin the so called post hardcore genre and make it radio friendly.
pd:yes thrice did a cover song 10 years later or more and ruined the original one.
meetdoctordoom 2 years ago
Thrice have matured so much through their later albums. I'd say saying "I listen to tr00 music" is far more childish than Thrice ever were.
Bamshu 2 years ago 2
Thrice's version is actually better? The original is just a classic. Thrice really spruced it up.
TheStageCrew 2 years ago 3
Thrice caters to the masses, huh? Why haven't they exploded and become the next Nirvana, and all that cliche bullshit comparison? Mm? Frodus started off as a teen angst band as well. Don't put your foot in your mouth. Rather, put it up your ass. Thrice is a great band that has matured since. I respect Frodus but don't care for them. Ciao.
wrestlewithgod 2 years ago
Although i love thrice, 'This next one is by, i dunno thrice?', is very funny
EliteKermit 2 years ago
I got excited when I heard DFA :D
aidenfan92 2 years ago
i dont get it... so thrice coverd this song? or did they steal it? i'm confused?
triviumlambofgod 2 years ago
It was a cover. Thrice are big Frodus fans.
Bamshu 2 years ago
i think he said: the next one.. is by.. i dunno thrice?
=) nice joke
DonZzZn 2 years ago
what did he say about thrice?
the second one?
Aztecalt1997 2 years ago
"This next one is by...
I dunno, Thrice?"
ShatteredSilence 2 years ago 3
oh ok thanx
Aztecalt1997 2 years ago
No problem.
ShatteredSilence 2 years ago
DFA1979 and Danger at the beginning?
Amazing
:D
AceXVI 2 years ago
love the thrice reference at the start xD
TC88Menasor 2 years ago 11
@TC88Menasor you're stupid
okcomputer1016 1 year ago
@okcomputer1016 well done, very constructive. soon you'll be using big words like a real boy.
TC88Menasor 1 year ago
@TC88Menasor alright well you are an idiot. thrice covered the song (ps thrice sucks) and that wasn't a "thrice reference", it was like, sarcastic. the stock come back by stupid people like you is always "DEUHHHH YOU COULD USE BIGGER WORDS DUHHHHH".
okcomputer1016 1 year ago
@okcomputer1016 I think you could use a vagina buddy. PS Poste Scripts go at the end thats why it has the word poste in it so I guess your stupid huh???
Lemaster2316 1 year ago
@Lemaster2316 Grammar insults are the bottom of the barrel faggot. Look at the punctuation in your paragraph. Plus you even spelled the word "post" wrong. You're clearly retarded.
okcomputer1016 1 year ago
@okcomputer1016 Lol probly the worst thing you could ever say.
squatchmaster5000 1 year ago
Fucking Awsome
Skiz0id 2 years ago 3
what an odd bunch
okszoneer 3 years ago 3