Added: 3 years ago
From: 0TyMoss0
Views: 21,172
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (266)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • idk... what would the book be about then? the children? Harry's job? The danger is all gone, there's not much left to do... i don't think a book about chasing the remaining death-eaters would be exciting..

  • after the last movie I feel like my childhood is over ):

    i know this is old but I still feel the same way!!

  • OMG dude! ur so hot! call me!!! =)

  • omg thanks ....and will do..... thanks 4 the video!

  • I want a book about the Marauders.

  • I think we all want a book eight (...just some people haven't realised it yet). <3 :D

  • not harry's kids!!!!!!!!!!!! Harry's parents!! don't u wanna know all the crazy things james did to objain Lily! and sirius's pranks!

  • We need a real book 8!One with harry`s kids!Cause the epoulge ended with his son going to hogwarts,and we dom`t know what house he`ll be in!!

  • Do you not think J.K. Rowling wasn't told to make a book eight or doesn't know we want a book 8, she did. She has said she doesn't intend to because she always planned it as 7. I appreciate your efforts but I think we should just be patient with her(she needs a break she said it herself) and wait until she writes something else which she will. because a writer like her it just not natural to just stop forever what you most enjoy in life....she just needs a break in my opinion.

  • i think there will always be people who want an eighth book, but it's probably not ever going to happen. it would just be too impossible to satisfy the majority of fans with an eighth book, which is why i think she doesn't want to do it. just imagine the PRESSURE!!

    however, if she DID write another sequel or whatever, it should be about Harry's parents' time at Hogwarts. that's just me though :P

  • yep i reckon thats gunna happpen

  • Im a Twilight fan, I want a fifth book.

    I am readingHP now im in the middle of the halfbloodprince, lovethe books.

    Oh well to my point, if there comes one more book, people want anotherone, ad thats how it will be FOREVER!

  • @wannabuffalo i would love that book! i love muraders

  • I would love for her to make a different series on other material, she is that good a writer that she can fill a page with words and make me love them. But come on lets not drag on Harry Potter any longer, lets do the movies and get em done. But continue to reread every book until you die because its the best material around.

  • i agree , in fact I wouldn't be interested in seeing another story of hers and I bet she could make it even better seeing as she has more experience as a writer now(it wouldn't suprise me) so I will look forward to her writing something new actually because to me it just seems to much of harry potter is at a end and has very little to continue with that could really be epic.

  • me2! you might get some rest from reading the tales of Beedle the Bard, but I have already read those stories online, d...!

  • do u haev MSN messenger? go2 my profile and msg my ID! i

  • An eighth book would have nothing in it. The series concluded. Unless you wanted a terrible book on how harry's son is being bullied, going through puberty, got herpies at fifteen, and then impregnated some witch. Doesent sound like she has anymore good matierial. Trust me I love the books, but you people just have to let it go.

  • well, no thats not it. do some reserch:

    she wrote Beedle the Bard (that came out already), shes writing an encyclopedia and she actually is writing something like a book 8. no, it's not going to be another one of those 500 pagers, but it'll explain some things that Dumblodore said, but we couldn't quite understand cuz dumbledore's just wierd like that :P

    and no, i dont think any of us will ever let harry go because we just love him so much and i dnt care wtf u say about it either

  • she does have more good material. She wants to write something else instead of harry potter now though because she only intended it to be 7 books from the beginning.

  • i want one too, but... she's ended it X|

    if they made one about their kids... it wouldnt be the same, they've moved on,

    it cant last forever, nothing good ever does,

    i keep on rereading all of the books, i still enjoy them... time after time again, im on the 2nd one again for like the 4th time.

    i refuse to let them die, to me, when they got to the 4th & 5th movie... the movies wasnt as good as the 1-3 ones in my own opinion... not the same classical felling

  • I'm sure most of us sincerely wish that J.K. Rowling would create an eighth book, but she's made it clear that she wants a break. I would really enjoy it if she one day decided to make a book, possibly even a second series using the children of Harry-Ginny, Ron-Hermione, and the others.

  • or like a sorta like spin-off

  • i think book 8 should be about harry's and ginny's children at hogwarts

  • a book 8 would be cool.....but what would it be about....they already ended the story....

  • there should be no book 8 but she should have said there occupations

  • she did in a press confrence:

    Harry is an Auror

    Hermionie is a...nothing :)

    Ron works somewhere in the Ministry

    and Ginny... i dont remember what Ginny does, but look it up, i no she has a job

  • well i dnt think there needs to b a book 8 if u think about it she completely finished the book she nearly killed of every1 and u find about the future and thier kids. Also if they write about they're kids then it wont be harry potter anymore. i like harry potter as much as the next guy but j.k ended it in such a way that u cnt write another book.

  • Haha.. That prolly won't work, no offense.

    But I'm sad because Harry Potter and the Half-Blooded Prince was suppose to come out in November, but now it's coming out in early 2009. :(

  • dude all the books are already out

  • get over it and get a life douche wad

  • OMG JK is already doing the whole book series again from hermione's point of view. isn't that enough?

  • Say what?

  • what since when?

  • seriously?

  • yep

  • If you have an eighth book it'll ruin it. You ever heard of "Too much of a good thing". It wont be as special anymore,

    they have already told us the marriages and such, bloody hell, whats past that, boring-ness.

  • you greedy cunt!

  • hell i want a book 8 too! who doesnt?

  • book 8? lol r u actually being serious? are you really serious?! jk wouldnt do that lol

  • i want better Harry Potter movies. they started goin down hill after The Prisoner of Azkaban

  • oh, and in case you didn't know, the lord of the rings saga is also based off books.

  • o ya sure, lord of the rings is the worst movie ever, harry potter rocks

  • both movies have their positives and negatives. its about what you like more, a dangerous journey or sneaking about in a dangerous school.

  • well ok heres my point.

    theres really nothing to write about

    except maybe what happens in the prologue

    or maybe about his kids

    i just wonder if there is anything more she can write about

  • Well, yeah. But she could always write about their kids adventures right?

  • I got scared with your voice. It doesnt match with your look. I thought I was going to listen a teenager/kid voice instead. LOL. But I totally agree... Harry Potter would never end.

  • your cute, lets have sex on our harry potter books

  • i hope she writes another one i was to sad when i got the last book

  • ah k :p

  • It will be great if she write's something about New Generation! That will be great!

  • Yeah

  • what is there to put into the 8th anyways voldemort's dead harry has kidds yadadada

  • HAHAHAHAHAH. Dudu, I SOOOOOOOO Agree with you :):)

  • dude im with ya! FINALLY SOMEONE THAT AGREES!!

  • Thank you. :) watch the video that this is a response to you will enjoy it. :)

  • what you wanna a boocake?

  • shes plainning on making it, she would call it

    Harry Potter: and the Life situations, as she said to a reporter.

  • well what i wondor is what she would write about... like harry's kids or something

  • Yeah!! that would be totally awsome!

  • It is Great that you want to but they are going to be other books and movies of Harry Potter but this time it will be harry's kids. But what would happen. And she endind the book with all was well. that means it is the end. Just wait soon she will make a diffent book. Give her some time.

  • haha do u really think we can get JK Rowling make a book 8?? GET A LIFE!!

  • dude if fans have the power to make her write an 8th then after that. then we will want a ninth and etc. just suck it up. HP is OVER just wait for the movies. or why dont you buy the rights to harry potter from jk and write your own 8, 9, and so on.

  • your not getting book 8 YOUR NOT get over it.. your stuck with beatle and the bard or wadever coming out on december 4th sooooooo maybe you could go get a gf have a kid and name him harry potter then you write the 8th book

  • Wow!!! One minute and twentyfour seconds??? Wow that's alot of of spare time!! With that much you could get a life O.O...

  • she cnt make another book, srry but she cnt, harry potter is 36 years old in the last book. its gunabe puzzling to make a new book and voldemort comes back out of the blue, and it wouldnt feel like the classics, or right, if they made a new villian. i heard a rumor that shes guna write i book about harrys kids, but still i dnt think that wnt be liek the best harry potter that we know, and yh im depresses that wuz the last book but JK needs a break, after 9 years making the books(: i <3 her books

  • grammar much?

  • hahahaha i laff at your retarded voice

  • get a life....dude

  • cute {:

  • he dies in the seventh tachesjittbaby, ur sorta retared

  • No he doesnt, He does die, but Voldemort's Soul dies, not his, So that Horcrux is gone and he kills Voldemort.

  • I'd love to see Harry Potter 8, but she couldn't really pick up where we left off. I'd love a generation 2 series though

  • ummmmmmmmmmmm....ok

  • arschloch!

  • Impossible from the very begining she said only 7 books it makes no sense for an eight book besides everyone is dead and grown what would this book be about Harry potter and his Son's First Date.

  • yeah aha

  • suuuuuuuuure!

  • ARE YOU SERIOUS!!??!?

  • i love ur accent and i think ur hot :)

    i dont think can be a book 8 though

  • she has a new book coming out in October called beetle something cant think of the name right now but it has five short story tails told by dumbledore

  • really?u really want the book???how bout u try reading something else?u seem serious

  • I'm sure JKR would tell you what countless fans have said... The story is OVER. She's made it clear that she's done with HP, and if she doesn't want to write another HP book, nothing on this earth will convince her to do so.

    I have not finished reading the series, but I will soon, and I thank those of you who have replied to this recently for not spoiling it completely. You might think the ending sucked, but JKR wrote the books, she can end them how ever she wants to.

    Get over it and grow up.

  • The ending to the seventh book kinda sucked. So if she wrote another HP book, it would really suck. there would be no plot line to it what-so-ever. I love the books, but 7 is enough.

  • yerh there was no plot because it was the END she has had the plot since she was a teen and its never changed so dnt complain i dout you cud ryt to such a standard as her

  • if you got the book 8 then you would want the 9th!

    i wouldn't want HP8... i prefer a book written by Rowling in which she explains everything about the books

  • 3 words dude. You are gay

  • I would love to have an 8th book!!!

    It really is sad that it finally ended but we really have to move on because Harry Potter is a great series, but it doesn't mean everything.

    Actually I loved how the 7th book ended!!! It was  sad and really happy at the same time.

  • how does voltermot die?

  • the way I expected!

    n_n

  • Harry destroyed all the horcruxes and Voldemorts killing curse hit himself

  • it already ended people got married and had children Voldemort dies , what more do you want!

  • dude the story has ended man. CLOSED ENDING ../ OVER.

  • dont be an idiot as much as everybody would like another book its never going to happen jk s already in the process of writing other books andother stories she is not going to return and drag out the harry potter line... anyway voldermort if gone and dead and the whole 20 years later thing just makes another book irrelevant as we'll always no he survives .... just shut up and be content

  • Yeah sorry but it's over. Voldemort is dead. Sequel is out. The background story before the books was for the most part already explained. Prequel pretty much out. Unless they did a marauders thing with Harry's dad and friends...that could be ok...but it wont happen.

  • i loved the end of 7th book.

    don´t think it´s a good idea to continue the story...

    but i would another story that jk rowling whritesssss

    that would be great

  • The only new HP book I would want would be a prequel about Dumbledore's years.

  • that would be good

  • jk rowling wanted book seven to be really special becasue it was the last one. wouldn't it be weird if she didn't another one with no voldamort?

  • Seriously..Voldemort is freaking dead, what else could she do? oh a new a villian! such a great idea...no, terrible terrible freaking idea.

  • i luv harry potter but there is no fucking point 2 get an 8th one. Voldemort's dead and nothing else is gonna happen. It's gonna be kinda of boring. but the ending was cool and it should be the way it is.

  • True, there's really nothing to happen anymore :/

    But I thought the ending was terrible! It was actually a pretty lazy ending, seemed more like one of those fanfictions stories. But I don't know, maybe I'm the only one who didn't like it :P

  • the ending was never going to live up to anybodys expectations ... nobody could have written an ending that would satisfy everybody .. i agree it was a bit of an anti climax but i dont think it was lazy ... if you dont believe me why dont you try writing a better one and then paste it over your last chapter and keep your comments to yorself....

  • How stupid can you be? If you said yourself that the ending was a bit of an anti climax how can do you tell me to keep my comments to myself?

    Did I offend you? Did I say anything bad about the book? The hole series is fantastic, but I MYSELF didn't like the ending.

    If you liked it then that's very good for you, but just because someone else didn't like it you don't have to be rude to that person.

    How old are you anyway??? That's so ridiculous.

  • so do iiii

  • ANOTHEER BOOK PLEEEEEEEEASE !!!

  • Here's a list of thing you must do...

    1. Speak to a shrink.

    2. Get a job.

    3. Move out of your parents house.

  • What would happen? Voldemort's dead.

  • i also want a book eight, i love all the harry potter books and it would be great of JK Rowling could just write at least 1 more book.

  • i also thought the ending was perfect like i finished and i said, ok it is a deserved ending, and tears. i want a book eight tooo!!!!!!!!!

  • There cant be an 8th book! The ending was so perfect. JK rowling has worked her butt off in these books. A sequal is to dangerous! LEave these great stories the way they are! Remember those disney movies when we were little. The reason they all died was because they had a horrible straight to DVD sequals that ruined it! dont let that happen to harry potter have a horrible book sequal that could ruin it. Im only using disney as an example.

  • elderscrossing . com

    It's good for a fanfiction. Also, it is "approved" by Rowling meaning it is canon.

  • The books are like done. I mean sure I want an eighth book. But the books are done there over, she ended the series so I think it should be left that way.

  • its over u nerd there not makeing any more get over it

  • they should do another book, but there's not much that could be in it, coz they've grown up and stuff, and if they did stuff with the children its basically repeating the first book... any ideas what could be in the 8th?

  • i emailed them:)

  • I want book 8 too , who doesn't?

  • What would they do? Go to Magic College?

  • omg every harry potter wants the 8th book ...but she told us what happens now ...you know about their kids and stuff ..i think they should just like do one book with harrys and rons and dracos kids in it ...i also think that the book professor dumbledore gave to hermione in his will should be published ..i know she made like between 1 and ten of themm but i think she should publish thousands ...i love harry potter ...but i think the films are a let down !!:(

  • I agree the films ARE a let down

  • LIAR!!! there is no 8th book!!!

  • Final message people - again I was reading Book 7 on the beach while most of you were crying over Cedric Diggory,,,,the 8th book that comes out by surprise in 2009, "Harry Potter and the Drood Mystery" starts off with the Potter kids, James Sirius. Albus Severus. and Lily Luna coming home to tell their father that a new professor claims to know their father personally.

  • That would be so awesome. But i can't believe you. :(

  • ur cute :)

  • as much as i want book 8 to happen its not.

    and for the people out there saying that there pretty sure its gonna happen pls just shushh, ur getting peoples hopes up for nothing.

  • it doest make sence that potter gets number 8. c'mon, Voldemort IS destroyed, he cannot return. I think Harry captured the deatheaters in that 17 year time, after he killed the dark lord.

  • just watch the video that this is a response to...

  • I am personal friends with a number of important people in New York and Los Angeles, around the globe really, so I received advance copies and was reading Book 7 on the beach while most of you were crying over Sirius Black. There will be a Book 8, in 2009, and the title is "Harry Potter and the Drood Mystery." There is a new teacher at Hogwarts, and I will reveal this to you,,,,a very accomplished wizard learned about time travel and had set some events in motion.

  • stop talking bullshit ya cockless little whore, there isnt going to be a book 8 and it aint gonna be called that either. if there is a book 8 and of that name then i will ask you for your adress and postcode or wateva dependin where you live and send you a £1000 worth of wateva your currency is and if you like you can even send me a message every week until then reminding me cuz that is how confident i am that you are talking out of your ass

  • no. Drood Mystery....seriously? is that best you could come up with for a fake title and trying to prove your so important? A friend's brother works at bloomsbury and has told us no such book is coming out. So stop spreading false rumor, until J.K Rowling can confirm it herself!

  • well just so u know jk rowling is writing but another book not more harry potter who said shes done writing idiots and yes id love there to be a harry potter 8 but it aint goin to happen

  • no no no no

    it would shit the "heptology"

  • didn't watch the whole video but i want that too.

  • Umm.. she kind of put a epilogue at the end of the seventh book. And I wish that she would write an eight but mostly everyone is dead! You'd have to kill of Ron and Hermione just to make the eighth book! :O But seven is like the most magical number, so I guess there's another reason to leave it seven books. I wish though... :P

  • Jesus christ, she said she was done writing.

    Maybe a prologue, but it's not gonna be HP8.

  • awesome .

  • Did you not read the ending? Okay it would make no sense for her to continue. Everyone that was important is dead, he has no rival. Not to mention hes an adult now. So what force her to write a story with Dracos child and Harrys as rivals? Honestly...

  • She doesn't have to write about the next generation. Screw them! Go with the Marauders! (Before the prequel. I would /love/ to know what really happened about 'The Prank'.)

  • Amber your idea is a good one. It would be nice to know a little more about them. Not a long series like Harry Potter though.

  • Watch the video that this is a video response to. He sings about all the stuff that you could write more on. "...i want J. k. Rowling to say that Voldemort had a son and the story's just begun." now would that not be awesome?!

  • Um no that would not be awsome. That would be way to overdone and overkill.

  • For Voldemort to have a son? In fanfiction maybe but not actual Harry Potter...

    Unless if it was with Bella. That would KICK BUTT! ^^

  • ILL SEND MINE BY OWL!

  • lol ya i wish but EVERYONE IS LIKE DEAD!!! that would be cool though so nice idea. but theres just not much to right about anymore

  • Watch the video that this is a video response to. He sings about all the stuff that you could write more on. "...i want J. k. Rowling to say that Voldemort had a son and the story's just begun." now would that not be awesome?!

  • i want the book eighttt !!! (8)... hahahaha yeeeiii =D... i really doo want ittt... =)

  • your such a fagg.

    and wayyy selfish.

    she has worked so hard and you wont let her be done with it.

    stupid.

  • No, im not a fag, im not selfish, i love her books and i would love to see more from her.

  • your such a fagg.

    and wayyy selfish.

    she has worked so hard and you wont let her be done with it.

    stupid.

  • if there is another book its just gonna ruin the whole series and anyway j.k rowling does have a life outside harry potter she has 3 kids so GIVE HER A BREAK!!! shes been writing the harry potter series for 15 years so just LET IT GO!!!

  • If she write harry potter 8 it would be a total failure. The story is completly OVER! i'm a huge fan of harry potter and the 7th book endend a part of my life. I grey up reading harry potter. now i'm 17 i started reading it at the age of 7.  So please don't mess up Harry Potter's history, coz it's brilliant

  • shut up hick

  • I enjoyed the series very much up till book seven - Harry won on a technicality. There were many mysteries from book five and six left untouched and unresolved in book seven. After book seven I took all my books and sold them at "Half Price Books" and bought a few beers with the money.

  • If she makes a 8 it will probily be about his kid

  • maybe more books of a different character... like... albus dumbledor for example

    haha

  • Yeah i think it's good what you're doing, but she already vowed to right only seven books. And i think she SHOULD right a new series; it would be a hit!

  • That's quite funny - an american commemorating an english ladies book

  • am i the "american" bc the books r sold here too! lol!

  • i luved harry potter, but he's getting old! she needs 2 write a new series! im incomplete w/out her books!:'(

  • yah maybe a harry potter series with Other ppl's side of the story! She could call it Tom Riddle! LOL!

  • Fucking Redneck

  • I Doubt J.K Rowling Will Write Another Harry Potter! Ox

  • trust me, J.K. Rowling is such an amazing writer, I'm sure she'll be able to write another great book. But indeed, she deserves a break after writing the best books in the world. But come on, admit it: it'd be awesome if there would be an eight book!

  • If you think about it. Everything was connected. She had a timeline previously drawn out and when she started writing the first book she knew what she wanted to happen in the 7th. I mean sure she added a few things here and there, but it was all premeditated. So, for her to go out and write an 8th book...it just wouldn't be the same. Don't get me wrong i'm a HUGE fan, but I think the best she can do is write a book about details she couldn't include in the actual books =]

    -Taylor

  • Suck enough dicks and youll get book number 8

  • i did love the ending of the books, but it was just so predictable....Still i dont think she could top it.

  • i can't understand what he is speaking all time . but he is cute xD

  • lol

  • I WANT TOO

  • I m desapointed to that it has came to an end, but it s just the way it is. it should have been over. ONE of The greatest endings of all times.

  • She has spent sooo many years of her life on these books. I think she deserves a break, it ended very very very well and it's just over. I'm a major fan too, but I think that book 7 was an amazing way to end the series and I'm extremely happy with that.

  • lol i love the books two but damn. leave the women alone.

  • OMG you FREAK!!!

    Leave the woman alone she does have a right to a life you know, she's already made history with her HP series and they're fine the way they are!!!

    Move on guy!!

  • I like harry potter and all, but this is just too extreme.

  • well it would be cool to have a 8th but i dont see how it will work see in the book it was really focosed on voldormort and harry potter

    see with out voldormort it wont reall work and to have a new villian is just not going to work but if she makes another i would love it

  • i really want more to happnen to but Voldermort dies in hte 7 th book , so how will there be a 8th book?

  • Voldemort had a son that nobody knew about....:)

  • With me! LOL