To Juanmarkosla. Your opinion is very much appreciated. However, please spell "no" as know when you're referring to knowledge. (Is this better killyridols1977?)
I suppose, if I really wanted to make a good point, I should have used better punctuation. Perhaps using the word "no" in place of the correct know was an accident, however, I felt the need to inform Juanmarkosla about his simple mistake. I hope it was as helpful a comment as was yours, sans the lack of punctuation.
You guys no nothing about music, He conveys an emotion with his style of music, and there is nothing hip or trendie about XIU XIU's music, Jamie stewart is amazing and brings to the table an amazing talent and song writing enigma, if you dont like XIU XIU, fuck off and stop watching their videos.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Too bad Xiu Xiu is hipster shit and Jamie Stewart thinks that singing bad and making completely erratic noise in no apparent key makes the music eccentric and interesting or unique. That being said this song is pretty nice and lacks many of the core elements that make Xiu Xiu hipster shit. I've yet to find anyone who can explain to me what is enjoyable musically about Xiu Xiu other than that it's "unique". Someone correct me please?
Well, first off, he and the music are not out of tune. At all. You just feel like it is because you don't have a musical formation, don't be an ass about it. Saying he sings badly is like saying Neil Young, Tom Waits, Antony Hegarty or Daniel Johnston sing badly, and that would be daring, right. Secondly, the lyrics allow such harsh singing cuz the narrator is obviously tortured by something he's trying to "forget" so it's genuinely justified. Fabulous Muscles is a Fabulous album and that's all.
I'm referring to most of their other songs when I say "in no apparent key" (not this one) and I didn't say out of tune, that's completely different. And my opinion on his voice is obviously subjective. I don't actually think his voice is bad, per say, but quite often obnoxious and it doesn't seem justified. I've heard many other artists pull off deeply acidic lyrics keeping all the emotion without having to break their voices so often as he does. Still didn't say what's enjoyable though. :<
@MolesAsses you can say that about most atonal music. i don't enjoy most of xiu xiu's stuff, but i think some of it is really great. try FTW ... he uses random clashing noises more artistically (appropriately) in a smaller dose but even without it, i think the song is great.
So pissed I missed Jamie on his last tour, and even more pissed I missed his 12 month ambient CD mailing. Definitely gonna see him on his next tour for the new album.
Well Jamie stewart is openly Bisexual and sings many songs of guys he has had issues with. However as ALL music is its put there for the listeners interpretation so coz most of his lyrics arent very literal, you could use the metaphors in your head to think about a girl or whatever. doesnt matter what sex it is lols its just good music and i <3 jamie stewart
wow im not gay but i APPRECIATE this fucking band so much and my xiu xiu tattoo wil prove it, i love jamie and all of xiu xiu sooooo much who cares what they fuck
his voice is incredible, sounds like its gonna break on every line. and that guitar, sounds so ambient. great song! only just found out about it but i love it already!
great song. But yes, that does not surprise me that the singer is Bi. Might be a gay group, especially considering there is a song they wrote "Fabulous muscles."
because people are frightened by androgyny and feel the need to slip anything that they feel uncomfortable with into a category that they've already figured out how to deal with.
interesting. this is the first i am hearing or seeing from these guys. i decided to check them out cause they are opening for sunset rubdown and i am pretty impressed. not bad
I feel like I'm watching someone break down
Hipochacco 4 months ago
Anythings better than adaytoremember lolololol
Gimssssss 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To Juanmarkosla. Your opinion is very much appreciated. However, please spell "no" as know when you're referring to knowledge. (Is this better killyridols1977?)
Mebrycepark 10 months ago
I suppose, if I really wanted to make a good point, I should have used better punctuation. Perhaps using the word "no" in place of the correct know was an accident, however, I felt the need to inform Juanmarkosla about his simple mistake. I hope it was as helpful a comment as was yours, sans the lack of punctuation.
Mebrycepark 10 months ago
To Juanmarkosla. I agree very much so with your comment however please spell no as know when you're referring to knowledge from now on.
Mebrycepark 10 months ago
Caralee i love you
unknownpleasures100 11 months ago
XIU XIU! : )
Jennytownslove 11 months ago
I love her space holiday's cove of this song
michellejesica 1 year ago
@michellejesica where can i find that?
lawlesskenny 1 year ago
@lawlesskenny they have it ob beemp3 i believe
just search around the internet and you'll come across it
michellejesica 1 year ago
touching stuff
131KrisKelmi 1 year ago
this is a great song
dalilantz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To Juanmarkosla. I agree very much so with your comment however please spell no as know when you're referring to knowledge from now on.
Mebrycepark 1 year ago
To Juanmarkosla. I agree very much so with your comment however please spell no as know when you're referring to knowledge from now on.
Mebrycepark 1 year ago
@Mebrycepark: Please punctuate your posts correctly. I'm only pointing this out because you felt the need to correct the other poster's spelling.
killyridols1977 1 year ago
To Juanmarkosla I agree with your comment but please spell no as know when you're referring to knowledge from know on.
Mebrycepark 1 year ago
You guys no nothing about music, He conveys an emotion with his style of music, and there is nothing hip or trendie about XIU XIU's music, Jamie stewart is amazing and brings to the table an amazing talent and song writing enigma, if you dont like XIU XIU, fuck off and stop watching their videos.
JUANMARKOSLA 1 year ago
I'll never understand why people consider this the best Xiu Xiu song. Is it because he yells "Ohh"? So many better Xiu Xiu songs...
idkmybffjv 1 year ago
he actually sounds better live lol
anticarebear13 1 year ago
I won't rest until you take it
prokrastinacija 1 year ago
The funny thing is that the sound quality of their CDs is the same as a piece of shit youtube video.
yexey 1 year ago
yeah thats pretty hilarious
harryistbtf 1 year ago
sonofagunder i happen to think this is very tasteful. and charmingly sad. makes me happy in a dark fantasy sort of way.
PixiesDoExist 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Too bad Xiu Xiu is hipster shit and Jamie Stewart thinks that singing bad and making completely erratic noise in no apparent key makes the music eccentric and interesting or unique. That being said this song is pretty nice and lacks many of the core elements that make Xiu Xiu hipster shit. I've yet to find anyone who can explain to me what is enjoyable musically about Xiu Xiu other than that it's "unique". Someone correct me please?
MolesAsses 1 year ago
Well, first off, he and the music are not out of tune. At all. You just feel like it is because you don't have a musical formation, don't be an ass about it. Saying he sings badly is like saying Neil Young, Tom Waits, Antony Hegarty or Daniel Johnston sing badly, and that would be daring, right. Secondly, the lyrics allow such harsh singing cuz the narrator is obviously tortured by something he's trying to "forget" so it's genuinely justified. Fabulous Muscles is a Fabulous album and that's all.
400Aesa 1 year ago 2
I'm referring to most of their other songs when I say "in no apparent key" (not this one) and I didn't say out of tune, that's completely different. And my opinion on his voice is obviously subjective. I don't actually think his voice is bad, per say, but quite often obnoxious and it doesn't seem justified. I've heard many other artists pull off deeply acidic lyrics keeping all the emotion without having to break their voices so often as he does. Still didn't say what's enjoyable though. :<
MolesAsses 1 year ago
@MolesAsses Judging by your name, I'd say you are a troll, judging by your comment, I'd say you are also most likely the best of the best.
chobitz7 1 year ago
@MolesAsses you can say that about most atonal music. i don't enjoy most of xiu xiu's stuff, but i think some of it is really great. try FTW ... he uses random clashing noises more artistically (appropriately) in a smaller dose but even without it, i think the song is great.
stevensartifacts 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
does anyone think this is good lol?
sonofagunder 1 year ago
"and I won't rest while you break my will..."
That's awesome!
alexmiccol 2 years ago
1:56 OH!
rainstrife 2 years ago
Why would you have to be gay to dig Xiu Xiu? I don't get it. It's not like enjoying having a dick in your ass changes your taste in music. lol
wrarmatei 2 years ago 6
Jamie.
even if i dont know him personally, hes a very special person to me.
sining in a way so precious and breathtking that it sometimes hurts me. In a melancholic, though sweet way.
I couldnt explain my love to his music in a sentence if my life depended on it.
Also. a lot said about that 'gay or not' stuff.
Prefering a male body over a female (/the other way round, or liking both) doesnt make you any less of a musician, and/or person.
And yes, VomitShovel .
PuppenKotze 2 years ago 2
FUCK ! this is so damngreatt!!!
loganily2 2 years ago 2
This song.
sickosandsuch 2 years ago 3
So pissed I missed Jamie on his last tour, and even more pissed I missed his 12 month ambient CD mailing. Definitely gonna see him on his next tour for the new album.
claypoolsbass2 2 years ago 2
Well Jamie stewart is openly Bisexual and sings many songs of guys he has had issues with. However as ALL music is its put there for the listeners interpretation so coz most of his lyrics arent very literal, you could use the metaphors in your head to think about a girl or whatever. doesnt matter what sex it is lols its just good music and i <3 jamie stewart
VomitShovel 2 years ago 6
wow im not gay but i APPRECIATE this fucking band so much and my xiu xiu tattoo wil prove it, i love jamie and all of xiu xiu sooooo much who cares what they fuck
VomitShovel 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is xiu xiu gay? if they are,how are they gay?
jiniton 2 years ago
I wanna get married with this guy.
He's amazing.
waitressboy 2 years ago 6
fuck yeah this is a good live clip.
dansnikolayevich 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love the shoegazing drone/bourdon sound of this song.
his singing reminds me of bright eyes's conor oberst
afterbabel 3 years ago
@afterbabel Just...what? No. Not at all. No.
Gemmaaaaaaaaa 1 year ago
Comment removed
afterbabel 3 years ago
his voice is incredible, sounds like its gonna break on every line. and that guitar, sounds so ambient. great song! only just found out about it but i love it already!
nicbongo 3 years ago 5
i think they sound better live than they do on the album they havent yet captured that live energy on their albums
streetlightsonatra 3 years ago 4
i won't rest until i forget about it...c'est l'histoire de la family.
arykala 3 years ago
Please! song: "Ian curtis whislist"
strudont 3 years ago
Marlene of Kona Kai, are you there? Love, Coby
GilliganOX 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Listen, no one understands your dumb artsy bullshit, so stop posting it on every Xiu Xiu video.
bigman1225 3 years ago
Thank You Adolf Hitler, a. k. a. "Big Man1224"
GilliganOX 3 years ago 6
Yeah really, shut the fuck up.
You aren't artsy, just fucking stupid.
SillyGooseCrew 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
best gay song ever!
indignantpenguin 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great song. But yes, that does not surprise me that the singer is Bi. Might be a gay group, especially considering there is a song they wrote "Fabulous muscles."
thejerseydude 3 years ago
Is there such a thing as a straight group?
scattt 2 years ago
No, we are all closet homosexuals
poomiester666 2 years ago 8
I think there have been a few.
MorfGworfmim 2 years ago
i love you xiu xiu, i walk late at night with you blasting in my ears
isamguy0 3 years ago 21
because people are frightened by androgyny and feel the need to slip anything that they feel uncomfortable with into a category that they've already figured out how to deal with.
blinkslide 4 years ago 30
Rad stuff. Why does everyone keep asking if they are a "gay" group? hahaha.
iamthelazerviking 4 years ago 3
que buenos coño
kimeta69 4 years ago
suuuuper!
ratoutzero 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is xiu xiu a gay group?
goopi3 4 years ago
the singer is bisexual, but no I do not believe that they are a "gay" group.
jellyface 4 years ago 5
exactly. Just because somebody in the group may swing around doesn't mean you revolve around the sexual aspect, people have depth
letonelive 3 years ago 3
oh!
violentkittin 4 years ago
i still like the XITSJ version much better
LukeELrod 4 years ago
i hate that one so much. I heard this version first so i'm already accustomed to it so that makes my judgement biased from the beginning.
AndresIsTight 4 years ago
it's so weird to see jamie with a guitar, just seems so....uncivilized for him.
sohailio11 4 years ago
my favorite song by them.
amazing band.
ilovenycfashion 4 years ago
where the fuck is the bass? it NEEDS bass.
yesjakeyes 4 years ago
they have keyboards. it suffices
AndresIsTight 4 years ago
word
kloppervok 3 years ago
oh, god I love Xiu Xiu.
Jamie Stewart is amazing.
They were in PA a while ago, but i missed them T_T
I would have killed to be there.
CameraObscena 4 years ago
mm..where is the bass??...without bass it 's not the same...
chepallequestinick 4 years ago
great song
championofidiots 4 years ago
ian curtis yes, und as 11. auf da la foret. leider ned in graz gwesen.
prinz noir
speedy310769 4 years ago
Ian Curtis Whislist and Suha is the best.
kannonblack07 4 years ago
Sunset Rubdown opened for Xiu Xiu, not the other way around. XX is top class, SR is not.
asalingerreference 4 years ago
I love both bands, but Sunset Rubdown is definitely more accessible and probably should have been the headliner.
EnronCFO 4 years ago
i wasn't a fan of ibopa for the longest time, they're just starting to grow on me.
xPardonMyPlanetx 4 years ago
I luv xiu xiu
phpordie 4 years ago
So Good... :)
Sophie123455 4 years ago
outstanding performance. Thanks so much for sharing that!
thomaskantor 4 years ago
i love the valley OH
silverbolt31 5 years ago
That guitar riff at the begining sounds like U2's Sunday Bloody Sunday (when played live in the 80s). Woah.
tchsatori 5 years ago
I wouldn't trust anyones interpretation of these songs, unless you've asked him personally.
lovethelogos 5 years ago
interesting. this is the first i am hearing or seeing from these guys. i decided to check them out cause they are opening for sunset rubdown and i am pretty impressed. not bad
cheshiregrins 5 years ago
I love this song. But what's it about? Could anybody give me some insights?
Dilutedled 5 years ago
it's about suicide,
how depression and suicide runs in the family.
it's lovely.
lovesaidno1387 5 years ago
one of the most cutting-egde bands I know.
Love them, esp. this song...
ILuvTheValley 5 years ago
My behind is a beehive, theres a buzz in my backside.
oheneys 5 years ago
It looks much like their show in 4AD? O_o
I was there.. in 4AD that is. :P
Azuriell 5 years ago
My rabbit stood on hind legs and was listening....
Shakiki 5 years ago 2
my FAVORITE song
KAYLASAURRRUS 5 years ago
he didnt play this song when i saw him >.<
drufish 5 years ago
i love xiu xiu...excellent!!!
ssnadroale 5 years ago
best fucking song ever! :)
year2525 5 years ago
That crowd was so terrible there... the show was one of the highlights for me of the festival, though...
nsn173 5 years ago
i saw xiu xiu in '04. it was quite an experience.
johnnyfontaine 5 years ago
The scream is my favorite part...
bobiamnot 5 years ago
I was there and shit.
TheDeadTexan 5 years ago
Wow!
eburn 5 years ago
I was disappointed with his scream. Other than that I like it a lot.
coltmcc 5 years ago
lol... this you ever listened to the recorded version?
bahhhhh
pigdestroy3r 5 years ago
I really miss IBOPA and 10 in the Swear Jar. Why does Jamie insist on changing bands every few years.
foocat 5 years ago
ibopa was by far his best project yet
dcdude 5 years ago
god i love them.
kathrynkaye 5 years ago
Fucking amazing.
ComparedPallid 5 years ago