This strange song about a mob lynching was originally written for Ada "Bricktop" Smith. Django also wrote the song Brick Top about her. This is a great version.
A supreme artist, Ethel Waters had to fight tooth and nail for every success she achieved in show business. When Lena Horne found she was making a film with Waters she heard terrible stories of how Waters treated other women in shows, especially beautiful younger women. But as it turned out nothing happened. Horne respected Waters and many people felt Waters realized that. And they didn't have that much contact making the film.
Wow. I've never heard anything like that. Haunting and beautiful in its simplicity and the emotion she put in the last few words... She actually told a story.
Without doubt, Ethel Waters is a consummate storyteller -- in the musical form. The tone is apt. The diction, superb. And the music doesn't overwhelm the storyteller. Like her contemporary, Lena Horne, is a highly visual storyteller. Both women are better appreciated without the mike in hand. You see, both storytell with the ENTIRE body, with heavy emotional expression coming from the face, singing with eyes wide open and looking directly at the audience. Wow!!!
This is wonderful, Mochaman have you listened to Kirsty Macolls version with the Pogues, I confess that is where I first heard it. But Kirsty is no longer with us, she died in a freak boating accident, RIP on of Scotlands finest
I too would like to thank you for posting this poignant song sung by Ethal Waters. Though now 70 years of age, I have never had opportunity until this evening. The voice is magical; the song, one that has stuck with me through the ages.
Ethel Waters does this as well as anyone. Music is a matter of taste, of course, but Middler and Labelle just seem to be screeching, to me. Ella?, well, she was great, too.
The contrast between the smoothness of melody + the version of miss otis' servant, on one side, and the rawness of the plot, on the other, is one of the clearest evidences of Porter's incomparable genius that I know.
Legend has it that Cole Porter was bragging to a friend that he could write a song about anything. So the friend picked up an invitation containing the title words from Porter's desk and challenged him to write a song around it. I think Porter succeeded admirably.
Thanks for posting - this is one of my favorite Waters songs. Somehow she manages to weave in the formality, the pathos and (by singing it straight) the sly humor of this song. I believe this was the first recorded version, and I have never heard better. Many of those who covered it, including Ella, Bette Midler and Labelle, were Waters admirers.
I like this version... it's such a sad song (the sadest song I've ever heard), and I can't take it seriously in an up tempo beat lol. Thanks for uploading!
I am 27 yrs. old, and you would not believe it but my uncle always talks about Ethel Waters, and you gave me the opportunity to hear one of the greatest singers that ever walked the earth. i want to Thank You for posting, it was GREATLY appreciated. I have a new appreciation for the music in this era, and I will be looking forward to more of your postings.
This song always makes me laugh. Thank you for posting this.
---------Ellen
Shabannie 6 days ago
A gorgeous reminder of a bygone age that my parents would quote from. Don't you just love Cole Porter and Ethel Waters.
chrisburke52 1 week ago
Carmen Mcrae did this song totally better im so sorry to say but this was not the best ive heard of this song
DenzellMachai1998 2 months ago
This strange song about a mob lynching was originally written for Ada "Bricktop" Smith. Django also wrote the song Brick Top about her. This is a great version.
Diosprometheus 3 months ago
miss otis regrets she's unable to lunch today....
i love both ella's and ethel's...
Merna201 4 months ago
as much as i love Ella this evokes all the emotions needed for this song
seanandnaim 4 months ago
A supreme artist, Ethel Waters had to fight tooth and nail for every success she achieved in show business. When Lena Horne found she was making a film with Waters she heard terrible stories of how Waters treated other women in shows, especially beautiful younger women. But as it turned out nothing happened. Horne respected Waters and many people felt Waters realized that. And they didn't have that much contact making the film.
waynebrasler 5 months ago
Wow. I've never heard anything like that. Haunting and beautiful in its simplicity and the emotion she put in the last few words... She actually told a story.
themostbeautifulone 8 months ago 3
Without doubt, Ethel Waters is a consummate storyteller -- in the musical form. The tone is apt. The diction, superb. And the music doesn't overwhelm the storyteller. Like her contemporary, Lena Horne, is a highly visual storyteller. Both women are better appreciated without the mike in hand. You see, both storytell with the ENTIRE body, with heavy emotional expression coming from the face, singing with eyes wide open and looking directly at the audience. Wow!!!
ccaammiiittoo1 9 months ago 2
Killer!
fukuinerd 10 months ago
ella fitzgerald does this on songbooks for cole porter
renascencewoman 10 months ago
Luv it!!!
msgo4245 1 year ago
Awesome! TY.
paulostroff99 1 year ago
Fantastic! another good version is by The Jack Jackson Band
Terry
5601mason 1 year ago
OMG I looooooooooooove this. I love Bette Midler's version too. Thanks for posting this.
mochaman15 1 year ago
This is wonderful, Mochaman have you listened to Kirsty Macolls version with the Pogues, I confess that is where I first heard it. But Kirsty is no longer with us, she died in a freak boating accident, RIP on of Scotlands finest
Sukkii25 10 months ago
I love this beautiful, mysterious, timely song.
greengringo2003 1 year ago
Its a priviledge to listen to this song.
wavesnearmyhome 1 year ago
Ethel Waters and Alberta Hunter sings the best version of this song in this time 1930/40...
bobinobaker 1 year ago
Comment removed
bobinobaker 1 year ago
One of Cole Porter's most poignant and characteristic numbers done almost true to character, what a great surprise to find. Thanx for sharing..
stlivermore 1 year ago
This is one honey of a Decca.
JCJasion 1 year ago
I too would like to thank you for posting this poignant song sung by Ethal Waters. Though now 70 years of age, I have never had opportunity until this evening. The voice is magical; the song, one that has stuck with me through the ages.
Many thanks from a woman who was young once.....
grefaroo2 1 year ago
Awesome! As good as any ever recorded!
paulostroff99 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@paulostroff99 I think that honor goes to Labelle. IMO
carolinaguy321 1 year ago
Ethel Waters does this as well as anyone. Music is a matter of taste, of course, but Middler and Labelle just seem to be screeching, to me. Ella?, well, she was great, too.
nmbookie 2 years ago 4
The contrast between the smoothness of melody + the version of miss otis' servant, on one side, and the rawness of the plot, on the other, is one of the clearest evidences of Porter's incomparable genius that I know.
beboplula3 2 years ago 6
shes unable to lunch today because she's hanging from a tree...
sleeper554 2 years ago
Great song diminished by the herky jerky treatment of Miss Ethel's photo.
Thanks fer nuthin'
7jack7 2 years ago
Petty comment.
Werx great w/ the feel of the song...
Thx for posting...
scapegoat321 2 years ago
ooh one of my fave songs. is ethal waters the first
woman to cover this song?
TheCharleycat 2 years ago
very nice, but the most moving and simply beautiful rendition is Ella Fitzgerald.
gilraenn29 2 years ago 2
Legend has it that Cole Porter was bragging to a friend that he could write a song about anything. So the friend picked up an invitation containing the title words from Porter's desk and challenged him to write a song around it. I think Porter succeeded admirably.
owlzguy 2 years ago 12
The Labelle version is the Best to me!! Hands down!!
mrdmack2008 2 years ago 2
very , very, very good music, absolut
potatoepeter1 2 years ago
Thanks for posting - this is one of my favorite Waters songs. Somehow she manages to weave in the formality, the pathos and (by singing it straight) the sly humor of this song. I believe this was the first recorded version, and I have never heard better. Many of those who covered it, including Ella, Bette Midler and Labelle, were Waters admirers.
Somepeople 2 years ago 4
I appreciate this version! I grew up with the Bette Midler version, but I enjoy both versions.
mandragorra 2 years ago 5
Absolutely my favorite version of this song
thurberdrawing 2 years ago 6
I never tire from hearing this by any singer - it defies barriers and genre.
ashurstopera 2 years ago 3
Remarkable nice song! Thanks!
HR5308 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ella kills this performance she sounds like a soul less entertainer compared to Ella. This rendition is weak at best.
aubrey1015 2 years ago
your talking rubbish
retepnalon 2 years ago
Nothing beat Patti Austin 2009 performance at te\he statmore. She b\killled.
MamaCharisma1021 2 years ago
Ethel Waters,Alberta Hunter,Ella,Billie Holliday,ect...never comes back....
bobinobaker 2 years ago
Labelle has a version of this song on their new album, "Back to Now." I like it ^_^
silversleep731 2 years ago
beautiful song - a classic
papoocanada 2 years ago 5
I knee I had to look up this song when I read about it in Bricktop's autobiography.
InuitInua 2 years ago
my favorite version of this song. Thank you!
kenjn60 2 years ago
Try and find "The Flys" version from their unsigned album when they were known as Mozart, it's brilliant!
thelawler 2 years ago
I posted a video breaking down the chords for guitar on my channel fyi only, thanks for posting this wonderful recording
LittleBrotherBlues 3 years ago
I like this version... it's such a sad song (the sadest song I've ever heard), and I can't take it seriously in an up tempo beat lol. Thanks for uploading!
SamKisses08 3 years ago 3
God Bless you Ethel........you did good!!
emb1st 3 years ago
I think I prefer the Ella Fitzgerald version, with piano =]
o0dballu 3 years ago
i do a dance to this song ahaha
ROOBIEzacefronfan 3 years ago
Great!!!!
HR5308 3 years ago
One of my favorites! Thanks.
montannea2 3 years ago
I am 27 yrs. old, and you would not believe it but my uncle always talks about Ethel Waters, and you gave me the opportunity to hear one of the greatest singers that ever walked the earth. i want to Thank You for posting, it was GREATLY appreciated. I have a new appreciation for the music in this era, and I will be looking forward to more of your postings.
Ethel Waters........A name tattooed on my heart.
jewellrian27 3 years ago 21
Thanks, Jewell! Wish I had more of Ethel's early work to upload... ;)
Best wishes,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago 2
@RReady555 It's a beautiful, poignant song and tenderly sung.
unfortunately the file has become corrupted.
m0bin100 1 year ago
@jewellrian27 The great pity is Jewell that the recording has become corrupted.
m0bin100 1 year ago
@jewellrian27 Yes I would believe you!
Thank God you have an uncle like my niece does!
And thank the good Lord that YOU had the sense to listen!
Now do your ancsetry a favor and pass it on.
Also, teach your daughters how to tie a bow tie!
You may think this is silly but it is the ONE thing that will seperate your daughter from the "common" girls!
Whores can't tie a bow tie! ONLY a lady can!!!!
SouthernWasp 3 months ago
Thank you for posting this excellent song. Goes straight to my favorites.
Daisy4dk 3 years ago
Thanks so much, Daisy...Ethel had a long and amazing career--have always loved her work in "Cabin in the Sky".
Best,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
thanks rr such gems stand the test of time and yet still hold a ear in todays market
mrdee11091 3 years ago
I applaud your taste, Paul. "Classic" means "Timeless". Folks in 2508 will still be whistling this one... ;)
Kindest wishes,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago 2
wow, this song suprised me. Good tune!
lordmahan11 3 years ago
Heh, heh! But her etiquette was above reproach...
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
Love it!
Thanks for the info and for sharing this gem.
Corrie121 3 years ago
Thanks, Corrie...it's always been one of my best beloved Porter tunes. ;)
Regards,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago