dude havimg your notes and pattern down is the majority of the battle. take the good advice, ditch the ugly critisism and youll be set. nice work. Tool aint no joke. it was a pleasure hearing ur work.
I've seen where some of the other guys doing covers are running their guitar/bass through the pedals and straight into the line input on their sound cards (don't ask me how...never done it) and they're super crisp. You get that figured out and you'll be set. Good job on the cover...it ain't got to be perfect to be good.
dude if u wanna prove that you don't suck then u gotta do a harder song. I've been playing for barley two years and can play this song easy. pick something like YYZ or make a cover for Black Betty. something other than bitching other ppl out.
This isn't a hard song to play. I don't feel the need to 'prove' that I'm good at what I do to a website that's made up of a 90% retarded populace. I put those up for my own enjoyment, I just find it hilarious when most people post not knowing what they're talking about.
Dude I'm a guitar player but i do love to pick up the 4-string every now and then. Great job on one of my favorite songs. its probably only the vid quality that makes it sound out of tuned (which btw its not even that noticable)
ur timing is off, u NEED to tune it, u need to strum like u mean it, and make sure ur other strings are muted before u pluck another one. there, now u cant bitch at me because i gave u reasons why it sucked. just work on it a little more before u post it.
You know what. I might as well just do another video for everybody, because people apparently can't get past the fact that my D is ever so slightly out of tune.
It's a good cover. It's just the sound that gives the impression that it sounds bad and out of tune. like muffled. fuck these youtube haters that's all they do is fuckn hate.
A condescending tone is a form of being an ass, if you're not aware of that.
Your 'constructive criticism' is a form which mocks the user, stating that they're out of tune, and in fact, a moron.
I hardly care as is, so don't expect any more replies about this. You really don't have to type anything. I don't care about any points you have to make. I won't reply to anything else.
I admitted that the string is in fact out of tune, and more then likely because I sucked at tuning by ear at that point in time.
I'm not avoiding anything. I really could not care less. I'll argue all day with you if you really wanted to. It's you good sir, who are looking for an argument, not I. I'm just defending my position here.
Everything I say is completely justifiable on my end. I don't see what you're arguing, you're starting to not make sense.
Fuck 3.5 stars this is a fucking awesome cover. The only flaw in is that your low D is kinda sharp but other then that it kicks ass. I'm tryin to put my own cover of this song up.
I've gotten a lot better since this video.. I'm thinking of redoing it because it's pretty awful. But thanks for the comment none the less! I appreciate it.
Jeez as soon as 00:50 seconds kicked in it killed it for me. You didn't drop your fourth string, so it sounded out of key. You had a good feel for the tempo so I give a 4/5
Like I said, I did it by ear and I'm not proclaiming to be a master at listening for keys or anything. 90% of the time I rely on my tuner, tuners are never off. But it doesn't bother me that my key is off, I can deal.
Well, I wouldn't feel too bad about a few screw-ups while you're playing. I can't look at a guitar before it starts playing sour notes, and I'm not even the one holding it. I have henceforth, been banned from my niece's house while she's playing guitar. She's pretty good... she just can't play while I'm there.
You've gotta completely ignore what everything else is playing and just focus on what the bass line goes like lol.
I found, at first, the guitar threw me way off..because the bass plays the same thing (for the intro anyway) while the guitar plays something entirely different. Just block it out, it gets easier trust me.
It's a lot easier if you listen to the drums. Lock with the bass drum and the snare in this song and you're set. 99% of the time the bass and drums work together, since they make up the rhythm section of the band. It just takes practice. Nice job though.
Not if the drums aren't playing in time with the bass, if it's not in standard timing or the bass/drums aren't playing the same timing I find it easier just to completely focus on just the bass.
For the most part, the drums do play with the same timing as the bass, but there are parts where they take a different beat, so you're right about that. But when the bass plays the main riff the first few times, it's the same rhythm.
sounds good, the timing sounds off on the intro but maybe my tabs wrong and yours is right. i've been beginning to trust my ears more than tablature lately because of this...
nicely done! Haha I laughed at your video description. "But you know what? I made a few mistakes, i can live with it." Way to stick it to those douchebags who think they know everything and wanna criticize you when they have no videos. rock on!
fuckin nice work man
mathusala666 8 months ago
Good fret work it's hard keeping such a confusing rythem but u managed just keep practicing and you'd have this song down pat
72KLEW 11 months ago
pretty damn good man, not an easy rhythm in context. definitely wanna tune that 4th string though ;P
UberDoku 1 year ago
if you kno you did bad. dont have the right effect, and your tabs were wrong.... why post it
AcrylicMockingbird 1 year ago
dude havimg your notes and pattern down is the majority of the battle. take the good advice, ditch the ugly critisism and youll be set. nice work. Tool aint no joke. it was a pleasure hearing ur work.
loswainwright 1 year ago
Out of tune, But you're pretty good. Keep practicing.
Kryuxo 1 year ago
yeah great job i'm trying to learn it aswell lol its an amazing song
bigrob0809 1 year ago
The bass in Tool is orgasmic.
Nice cover man
MFMITF 1 year ago
dude idc if the tabs right thats really bad ass. did you learn by sound or you actually look it up?
MongooseTheMangy 2 years ago
Thanks a lot ! I did the best I could with the tab I had at the time. This was a good few years ago mind you.
justinc182 2 years ago
Did you forget to put in in drop D or is that the video? Either way great job.
TheSoYa 2 years ago
It's probably the video, at the time I was playing through a 10 watt guitar practice amp into a $2 computer mic.. not the best setup for sound haha.
Thanks !
justinc182 2 years ago
I've seen where some of the other guys doing covers are running their guitar/bass through the pedals and straight into the line input on their sound cards (don't ask me how...never done it) and they're super crisp. You get that figured out and you'll be set. Good job on the cover...it ain't got to be perfect to be good.
RussianProverb 1 year ago
Yeah solid work on this song. I fuck up way more when I play it. Awesome song
paintking142 2 years ago
Keep practicing, it'll get better!
And thanks a lot for the comment!
justinc182 2 years ago
@ddaybook7
He is fucking good, this song is the shit.
SO why does it matter if its easier then most?
Its an amazing song.
So suckkk it.
SuperBOOMFry 2 years ago
There are far too many idiots on youtube, haha.
justinc182 2 years ago 2
@justinc182 and u are 1 of them
rottfather1 10 months ago
this is fucking good
BunnilovesMilo 2 years ago
Thanks a lot !
justinc182 2 years ago
i like it, think you could do Vicarious?
nuparu3 2 years ago
Sure! I'll try to get around to learning/putting up a video of that.
Whenever I get my bass amp back in my house that is.
justinc182 2 years ago
dude if u wanna prove that you don't suck then u gotta do a harder song. I've been playing for barley two years and can play this song easy. pick something like YYZ or make a cover for Black Betty. something other than bitching other ppl out.
ddaybook7 2 years ago
This isn't a hard song to play. I don't feel the need to 'prove' that I'm good at what I do to a website that's made up of a 90% retarded populace. I put those up for my own enjoyment, I just find it hilarious when most people post not knowing what they're talking about.
justinc182 2 years ago
Dude I'm a guitar player but i do love to pick up the 4-string every now and then. Great job on one of my favorite songs. its probably only the vid quality that makes it sound out of tuned (which btw its not even that noticable)
Jimbof612 2 years ago
Ps. This video was posted before you probably even started playing bass, champ.
justinc182 2 years ago
you suck bro
brandoncheese1 2 years ago
Hahah, you wish.
justinc182 2 years ago
ur timing is off, u NEED to tune it, u need to strum like u mean it, and make sure ur other strings are muted before u pluck another one. there, now u cant bitch at me because i gave u reasons why it sucked. just work on it a little more before u post it.
elconijo 2 years ago
tune it!!!!!!!!!!!!!
auralpeak 2 years ago
You know what. I might as well just do another video for everybody, because people apparently can't get past the fact that my D is ever so slightly out of tune.
Awesome.
justinc182 2 years ago
It's a good cover. It's just the sound that gives the impression that it sounds bad and out of tune. like muffled. fuck these youtube haters that's all they do is fuckn hate.
PirateMario89 2 years ago
suck's....
takis665 2 years ago
Care to give me a solid reason why it sucks?
Don't bother posting if you're just going to be a mindless idiot.
justinc182 2 years ago
Woah, let's tune bud!
HugelyBig 3 years ago 6
Hold on.
I'll get my time machine, travel back in time, and fix my tuning, just for you k?
It's only the top D that's out of tune. I, apparently, sucked at tuning by ear back then. I accept it.
justinc182 3 years ago
Perhaps a revised version rather than being an asshole when somebody gives constructive criticism is a better way to handle things - just saying.
HugelyBig 3 years ago
Constructive Criticism: " Hey dude, you should redo this cover, seeing as how this one is slightly out of tune."
Being an Ass: " Woad, let's tune bud!"
Get it right, or just don't bother to comment there pal.
justinc182 3 years ago
No. Being an ass is this: "hey man this cover sucks u suck at gitar u doosh".
I was being constructive because I actually suggested something for improvement, rather than just saying you suck.
HugelyBig 3 years ago 5
A condescending tone is a form of being an ass, if you're not aware of that.
Your 'constructive criticism' is a form which mocks the user, stating that they're out of tune, and in fact, a moron.
I hardly care as is, so don't expect any more replies about this. You really don't have to type anything. I don't care about any points you have to make. I won't reply to anything else.
justinc182 3 years ago
Because you can't accept the fact that you're wrong and have no justifiable argument?
It's not that you don't care about any points I have to make. It's that you're trying to avoid somebody challenging you by acting big and bad.
And for the record, I never took on a condescending tone.
HugelyBig 3 years ago 2
I don't see your point here?
I admitted that the string is in fact out of tune, and more then likely because I sucked at tuning by ear at that point in time.
I'm not avoiding anything. I really could not care less. I'll argue all day with you if you really wanted to. It's you good sir, who are looking for an argument, not I. I'm just defending my position here.
Everything I say is completely justifiable on my end. I don't see what you're arguing, you're starting to not make sense.
justinc182 3 years ago
*Doesn't even bother reading your comment, just sees that it's there*
So you weren't going to reply again eh? Ha.
HugelyBig 3 years ago
You're trying to rush it an awful lot.
MrAndersonmm 3 years ago
why don't use D and G string togheter?!
Corgan3underscores 3 years ago
I find the D and G together to be more difficult. It probably gives a better sound, but I'm not good enough for that yet.
HugelyBig 3 years ago
I don't use D and G together, because that's not how the song is played.
So it makes sense not to do that.
justinc182 3 years ago
ahh that is y we shouldnt use tabs young one, get some good headphones crank it up, and listen closely
comalley0130 3 years ago
I'm quite lazy.
Tabs have been working out fine thus far.
justinc182 3 years ago
Great cover man! Keep up the work!
fingersantoes 3 years ago
Fuck 3.5 stars this is a fucking awesome cover. The only flaw in is that your low D is kinda sharp but other then that it kicks ass. I'm tryin to put my own cover of this song up.
Once again good cover bro
XxKiLLsWItCh79xX 3 years ago
u suck dick
crotic07 3 years ago
Oh I'm sorry princess. I don't see any of your amazing mindblowing human race progressive videos up?
Does mommy and daddy think instruments are too loud?
At least give me a legitimate reason why I 'suck dick', you're just shooting shit into the air right now stud muffin.
justinc182 3 years ago
Yes, he's not going to be able to come back from that. He'll probably call you gay or something.
NicoNegron 3 years ago
Haha, that's how it goes on youtube. People give shit but can't back it up.
justinc182 3 years ago
lol notice he still hasnt said shit
zanekidd 3 years ago
This idiot apparently has no life, so he runs around telling everyone they suck on their pot bass covers. d^.^z
Junkie825 3 years ago
Haha, apparently so.
justinc182 3 years ago
Very fucking good.I play bass also,But im not as good as you are.U in a band???
ihangfromhooks 3 years ago
I've gotten a lot better since this video.. I'm thinking of redoing it because it's pretty awful. But thanks for the comment none the less! I appreciate it.
I do play in a band, but we're just starting up.
justinc182 3 years ago
and its called.....
mensendike 3 years ago
what type of bass do you have?
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
Epiphone thunderbird.
justinc182 3 years ago
nice I have an LTD Esp black cherry
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
do you finger or pick?
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
Both, but I prefer to use a pick. I'm using a pick in this video.
justinc182 3 years ago
yeah I am trying to learn it fingering but its turning out to be pretty damn hard
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
Learn some iron maiden, it's great for building finger dexterity on bass.
justinc182 3 years ago
I play alot of maiden lol
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
Haha, well keep it up.
justinc182 3 years ago
thnks but I pretty much got the beggining I just screw up about 3 times into the intro
McBAIN1235 3 years ago
nice job great work
Raphinater 3 years ago
Nice brother man
freelancejonny 3 years ago
work on not bending your strings while you play, distorts sound and makes your strings go out of tune a whole lot faster.
TOOLbassplayer1 3 years ago
is he actually talking about pot or is he using this as a metaphor? He is known for doing that alot!
youboob1989 3 years ago
What?...the pot or the metaphor??? :P
LeelooJay 3 years ago
uh read it closley, is he specifically talkling about pot or just using it as a metaphor for something else?
youboob1989 3 years ago
I ment...what is he known for doing alot???...the pot or the metaphor...get it now? lol
LeelooJay 3 years ago
my bad! he uses alot of metaphors in his songs so I'm asking is this another metaphor fo something! is this song deeper then just pot!
youboob1989 3 years ago
the song is sort of based around the expression of the pot calling the kettle black. and it's about hypocracy... just my understanding of the song.
TOOLbassplayer1 3 years ago
Jeez as soon as 00:50 seconds kicked in it killed it for me. You didn't drop your fourth string, so it sounded out of key. You had a good feel for the tempo so I give a 4/5
AggressiveDisorder 4 years ago
Actually... I know that tool plays in D.. so I did drop it. But I done it by ear so it may have been slightly off.
justinc182 3 years ago
Slightly? o.O Just use overtones (dunno the actual english word for it :P)
fnuggie 3 years ago
Octaves would be the english word.
Like I said, I did it by ear and I'm not proclaiming to be a master at listening for keys or anything. 90% of the time I rely on my tuner, tuners are never off. But it doesn't bother me that my key is off, I can deal.
justinc182 3 years ago
Okay, well, just so you know, my comment was supposed to be a reply to your reply to RNERHCP Don't know what's up with Youtube. Whatever.
Max7498 4 years ago
Well, I wouldn't feel too bad about a few screw-ups while you're playing. I can't look at a guitar before it starts playing sour notes, and I'm not even the one holding it. I have henceforth, been banned from my niece's house while she's playing guitar. She's pretty good... she just can't play while I'm there.
RequiemExMortis 4 years ago
I can't figure out the tempo
it's so strange
good job
RNERHCP 4 years ago
You've gotta completely ignore what everything else is playing and just focus on what the bass line goes like lol.
I found, at first, the guitar threw me way off..because the bass plays the same thing (for the intro anyway) while the guitar plays something entirely different. Just block it out, it gets easier trust me.
justinc182 4 years ago
It's a lot easier if you listen to the drums. Lock with the bass drum and the snare in this song and you're set. 99% of the time the bass and drums work together, since they make up the rhythm section of the band. It just takes practice. Nice job though.
Max7498 4 years ago
Not if the drums aren't playing in time with the bass, if it's not in standard timing or the bass/drums aren't playing the same timing I find it easier just to completely focus on just the bass.
justinc182 4 years ago
For the most part, the drums do play with the same timing as the bass, but there are parts where they take a different beat, so you're right about that. But when the bass plays the main riff the first few times, it's the same rhythm.
Max7498 4 years ago
damn your blurry fingers!
tab?? XD
finalfantasiservii 4 years ago
The orginal record has 2 bass guitars. In intro is that exactly what you play but in 2. and 3. string
alisatyricon 4 years ago
turn up the music a little
64meatpuppets 4 years ago
sounds good, the timing sounds off on the intro but maybe my tabs wrong and yours is right. i've been beginning to trust my ears more than tablature lately because of this...
lateralus15 4 years ago
nicely done! Haha I laughed at your video description. "But you know what? I made a few mistakes, i can live with it." Way to stick it to those douchebags who think they know everything and wanna criticize you when they have no videos. rock on!
calahala 4 years ago
Thanks peeps! I know it's not perfect, and I could probably do a lot better now.. but I still appreciate the comments!
justinc182 4 years ago
excellent playin man, you rock. Too bad I can't play too or I would challenge you =p I'm not good enough yet.
sinn1sl0ken 4 years ago
Nice. It sounds SOOOO close. Kudos.
babyCALVARY 4 years ago
great job
Robokobe 4 years ago
hey do you have the tabs for this
skateordie2121 4 years ago
well done:P
lemonlateralus 4 years ago
no prob j to the izzle
dunphy16 4 years ago
this is sweet man you rock my socks
dunphy16 4 years ago
Hahaha, thanks man.
justinc182 4 years ago