Having been a working student at Tempel I can assure that these horses are WELL cared for and are not stressed. Grant it, the training is still in progress for some of these stallions, but it is not forced. One must understand that a classic baroque style horse, such as a Lipizzan, does not, will not and should not look like the warmbloods dominating the competitive dressage arenas of current day. What most people are use to seeing one will not see with these horses because of the build.
i dont think anyone who cannot do these amazing manouvers can say its not art, the amount of time care and dedication these people have taken and the trust betwen the horse and people is increadible to enable them to perform like this, i am impressed and could only dream of teaching horse to do this! dressage actually comes from a term to train, i believe this is training the the highest standard, anyone who says this is not dreaage is not watching the same video as i!
The "Airs Above the Ground" of Haute Ecole or High School were developed for battle from the natural movement horses make in the pasture. Of all the trainers of these majestic horses, the Spanish Riding School in Vienna has mastered the methods to train these very demanding manuevers. Dressage is a French word meaning "to train", so in this instance Airs Above the Ground IS Dressage, as it is training at it's highest form.
I agree with Tallula04. This is not dressage it is art and it is started slow and it takes many years to complete. There is no harm done to the horses. The trainers are safe and competent. I am grateful that this art is still around for us to see and to share with our children.
This is very classical dressage. Airs above the ground moves were originally used in battle and have since become an art of their own. They are given so much top quality care and their training is instilled slowly to insure it is done correctly.
Sorry, but here not much is executed correctly. Beautifull horses, beautifull outfit and music make the performance, not the perfection of horses' knowledge. Go to Vienna (Aut), go to Jerez de la Frontera (Esp), go to Lipica (SLO). And compare. Horses here are taken care of extremely well, however the training lacks perfection a great deal. Classcal dressage is art. Here unfortunately the quality does not deserve to be called art. Not quite yet. Sorry, just being honest.
@claoufaeng true. the question is why a non trained horse is taken to the performance of haute ecole. Anothe question is why the first horse in handled by one person only? single rider performing caprioles on the long rein is usuually done with fully trained horses... I could ask some more questions, but I'll just let it be. I know my critique is harsh, but I do tend to be oldfashioned in these matters... Horses as such are great though.
Having been a working student at Tempel I can assure that these horses are WELL cared for and are not stressed. Grant it, the training is still in progress for some of these stallions, but it is not forced. One must understand that a classic baroque style horse, such as a Lipizzan, does not, will not and should not look like the warmbloods dominating the competitive dressage arenas of current day. What most people are use to seeing one will not see with these horses because of the build.
Musesasj 1 year ago 3
@Musesasj Well said! That, and many of these moves are difficult to pull off
claoufaeng 5 months ago
So cute.
FellPonyz 2 years ago
i dont think anyone who cannot do these amazing manouvers can say its not art, the amount of time care and dedication these people have taken and the trust betwen the horse and people is increadible to enable them to perform like this, i am impressed and could only dream of teaching horse to do this! dressage actually comes from a term to train, i believe this is training the the highest standard, anyone who says this is not dreaage is not watching the same video as i!
xxflower123xx 2 years ago 2
they all looke super stressed out
copenhagen1966 3 years ago
that is absulty amazing
TBShorses 3 years ago
The "Airs Above the Ground" of Haute Ecole or High School were developed for battle from the natural movement horses make in the pasture. Of all the trainers of these majestic horses, the Spanish Riding School in Vienna has mastered the methods to train these very demanding manuevers. Dressage is a French word meaning "to train", so in this instance Airs Above the Ground IS Dressage, as it is training at it's highest form.
TedescoArabians 3 years ago 2
It is not perfect upper level work, but the horses look well cared for and not stressed, and the handling is gentle.
pirouette987 4 years ago 2
I agree with Tallula04. This is not dressage it is art and it is started slow and it takes many years to complete. There is no harm done to the horses. The trainers are safe and competent. I am grateful that this art is still around for us to see and to share with our children.
barcocady 4 years ago
hat was this supposed to be?
showpony2 4 years ago
Eeeek! These horses are so hollow and forced. I LOVE dressage, but this is NOT what I think of when I think of the art of dressage.
These Lipizzans are amazing for being so sane despite having thier lips pulled to their ears, and neck jamed into their shoulders.
A longer neck, looser rein, and more free in the back would be much more impressive
This is from Temple Farms? Scary.
Sorry.
savvydanee 4 years ago
This is very classical dressage. Airs above the ground moves were originally used in battle and have since become an art of their own. They are given so much top quality care and their training is instilled slowly to insure it is done correctly.
tallula04 4 years ago 2
Sorry, but here not much is executed correctly. Beautifull horses, beautifull outfit and music make the performance, not the perfection of horses' knowledge. Go to Vienna (Aut), go to Jerez de la Frontera (Esp), go to Lipica (SLO). And compare. Horses here are taken care of extremely well, however the training lacks perfection a great deal. Classcal dressage is art. Here unfortunately the quality does not deserve to be called art. Not quite yet. Sorry, just being honest.
Lipicanci 3 years ago
@Lipicanci You're right, but only because they've not finished training.
claoufaeng 5 months ago
@claoufaeng true. the question is why a non trained horse is taken to the performance of haute ecole. Anothe question is why the first horse in handled by one person only? single rider performing caprioles on the long rein is usuually done with fully trained horses... I could ask some more questions, but I'll just let it be. I know my critique is harsh, but I do tend to be oldfashioned in these matters... Horses as such are great though.
Lipicanci 5 months ago
The Lipizzans are such magnificent horses. Love 'em.
TRAmPLdUNdRfOoT 4 years ago