@A3cello I'm not sure if that's fake or not but ur evidence is just outright stupid. It's youtube's fault that the sounds is not syncronising, many old videos on youtube recently starts having this issue too.
Also, she's not showing any expression because she's concentrating on the music. Non-professional-level musicians (i.e. not Midori or Perlman-level) often do that, and it does not mean in any way, shape, or form that they are not enjoying the music. (Heck, even I do that. Haha.) Also, about the bow thing, it's fine. There's no definite standard for how bows should be held, just general guidelines. She's no Julian Lloyd Webber, but you have to admit that's she's pretty good for her age.
Okay people... seriously. Stop it. Just shut up and enjoy the music and talent of this girl. She's obviously doing this because she loves playing cello and performing, not because her parents forced her to. Her mom's smile shows that she's proud of her kid and she wants her to be successful. It's true that Asian parents sign their children up for a lot of activities, but they do that only because they want them to have a lot of experiences in life. I would know, being Asian-American myself.
Asian parents force kids take as many extra courses as possible. Look at the mother's satisfied face! what a pity, these kids did not have a real teenage life.
Comment removed
taiwannathan 5 days ago
嗯~聲音跟影片沒有搭起來，我幫你們看看，看是否能將它搭配起來，如果好了再告訴你們。
taiwannathan 5 days ago
抖音好像有點微弱，真的很棒
pudding19960216 2 weeks ago
@MrMASAHIRO1997 she is concentrating on her show, so, she doesn't have any face emotion
hkgkaree715 3 weeks ago
娜娜好棒唷~真替妳感到驕傲^^讓我想起小時候拉琴的回憶，
我國小的時候跟娜娜是同一位老師耶><
ernieko0630 3 weeks ago
是現場演奏的沒錯，是Youtube轉檔的時候將聲音和影像分離了。
thpan 1 month ago 3
Love Joe Hisaishi's music...but I'm sorry: THIS IS a fake. I don't mean she's necessarily a bad cellist but on THAT vid, that's "play back"!
A3cello 1 month ago
@A3cello I'm not sure if that's fake or not but ur evidence is just outright stupid. It's youtube's fault that the sounds is not syncronising, many old videos on youtube recently starts having this issue too.
Cafu192 1 month ago
@A3cello Hey dude!!, It's not a fake, that's youtube's fault, so please check it again, ok?????
taiwannathan 5 days ago
大有可為
chiaen27 3 months ago
感覺音樂和他的拉的沒有很合....影片關係？配音?
osakasinya 3 months ago
@osakasinya 应该是影片关系吧？这种事经常在YouTube发生。
iluvspockandsylar418 3 months ago
Also, she's not showing any expression because she's concentrating on the music. Non-professional-level musicians (i.e. not Midori or Perlman-level) often do that, and it does not mean in any way, shape, or form that they are not enjoying the music. (Heck, even I do that. Haha.) Also, about the bow thing, it's fine. There's no definite standard for how bows should be held, just general guidelines. She's no Julian Lloyd Webber, but you have to admit that's she's pretty good for her age.
iluvspockandsylar418 4 months ago
Okay people... seriously. Stop it. Just shut up and enjoy the music and talent of this girl. She's obviously doing this because she loves playing cello and performing, not because her parents forced her to. Her mom's smile shows that she's proud of her kid and she wants her to be successful. It's true that Asian parents sign their children up for a lot of activities, but they do that only because they want them to have a lot of experiences in life. I would know, being Asian-American myself.
iluvspockandsylar418 4 months ago
Beautiful! I can tell how proud of your mon are.
chriswhua 4 months ago
良好！ 大感激！ Fantastic!
MurphyColeman 4 months ago
0:14 - 0:30
the sound is not matching the fingering ._.
wtf
MapleTest2012 4 months ago 3
very impressive~
daidaiiou 5 months ago
where is her emotion!!?
must be molded by her parents....
MrMASAHIRO1997 5 months ago
@MrMASAHIRO1997 i bet its fake, cause she dosnt even hold her bow right -.-'
Angelhatesfood 4 months ago
@Angelhatesfood no it's not fake i heard her so please don't write things if you don't know
theviolingirl123 2 months ago
Asian parents force kids take as many extra courses as possible. Look at the mother's satisfied face! what a pity, these kids did not have a real teenage life.
grab1piece 6 months ago 2
I agree
inmyprayer 6 months ago
是她拉的嗎？音樂lag?
termier0520 6 months ago 2
好羨慕嘎~~
jamie86920 8 months ago
真美好！願這小女孩的人生也這麼美好！
taratara99219925 8 months ago
拿琴的姿勢感覺有點怪@@
yzumichael 9 months ago
拿琴的姿勢感覺有點怪@@
yzumichael 9 months ago
生了這樣一個女兒, 誰都感到很驕傲吧
wale068 10 months ago 28
好有氣質的小美女! 真好聽!
nagamiliu 1 year ago 22
像是後面配樂的~音樂和手的節奏不是很搭~~
sososa2112 1 year ago
@sososa2112 應該是影片的問題，因為後面訪問也對不到嘴，娜娜是真的很有實力的
bulldogfight 1 year ago
@sososa2112 是現場拉的喔!! 音樂是伴奏而已，影片LAG了啦! 很認真熱愛大提的娜娜 !! 絕對值得鼓勵
MissCindyblack 3 months ago
@sososa2112
MissCindyblack 3 months ago
陽龍 我是巴歷史吉他手 好好培養他 是個未來音樂大師
gimiiey 1 year ago 3