Added: 3 years ago
From: TheThiefArchive
Views: 31,586
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (34)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 4:53

    F**K You CBC

  • I'll admit this verson isn't as bad as Arabian Knight but the fact that they turned a masterpiece into a forgetable experiece just bugs the shit out of me.

  • can someone tell me why in the Pan-Scan DVD of this cut has credited Steve Lively and Bobbi Page for being in Alladin? they doesnt even appear in the main cast!

  • amah feelinlooh?

  • well, it was a little bit better then the miramax cut (mainly because of no broderick or winters, and the ending montage song), but i'm still interested in seeing the recobbled cut

  • @GilliganKrueger0829

    Its a lot better. :)

  • Comment removed

  • I have not seen this movie in forever,good thing I watvhed it. I had no idea so much corruption was "tailored" in the release of this feature. I do not care which version it is, it was still amazing. I am surprised anyone is talking about this feature, because it is a good movie. I thank Richard williams for even having the idea to be butchered in the first place, because without him, this feature would never have settled upon my eyes.

  • @KijuiKiwi Actually, about 3/4's way into the production of the movie, he was kicked off of the project because it took too long to make. So if anyone is to blame, it's the Completion Bond Company. They added all the stuff Richerds didn't want in the movie.

  • @MadmoneyMac actually the ones to blame is the Warner bros guys, who didnt like because it had no stupid shit that disney came up and became absolete (songs, funny characters and a flawed storyline) and gave it to the cbc

  • Daaang Tak was hot at the end all tan and prince like ^^

  • Ok if i were to give these movies medals the recobbled version would get gold, this one would get silver, and the miramax one would get bronze. They really deserve nothing, but i have to be nice cause I like Matthew Broderick.

  • there are multiple versions? this is the only version I've ever seen... where can I find other ones?

  • Hey, this version isn't THAT bad. The Miramax is version is far, FAR worse. >_> I like Tack's voice in this version much more, it's so cute. (not his narration voice obviously...) Also, the Thief has no annoying voice.

  • You're all going to hate me for saying this, but I didn't think it was that bad. I like all 3 versions of the movie. This, Recobled and Mirimax, but for their own reasons. I like recobbled for being the original, i like this version for introducing the songs, and I like the mirimax verision for the thief's funny lines. But I do think this is my favorite version. Recobled and Mirimax being my 2nd and 3rd, respectively. No offence to anyone who hates this version.

  • @jlan93 Me to! I like all 3 versions but this one is my favorite. It's so beautiful.

    so do'nt feel alone on that.

  • man that 2nd song is bad.

  • This is a crapass movie. XD The optical illusions were definitely awesome, but the rest of it's pretty bad. Poor dialogue, certain areas of suggestive material, i.e. ZigZag, the witch...XD

  • Oh, and I hate this stupid fn song. seriously. and the 80's background music...someone just take it out back, put it out of it's misery and bury it.

  • Doesn't this movie remind you of Raggedy Ann and Andy? With all the allusions and such it is really something. But I still think the story could have used some work.

  • Well, most of the animations were done by the same person.

  • "Special Thanks to THE COMPLETION BOND COMPANY, INC."

    The irony of those words being in the credits is unbelievable. What balls to put that in there.

  • Why is that? Just curious.

  • Because this film was ruined by them. Richard Williams (director) worked on this with his own money for 26 years before his work on Roger Rabbit made it possible to get the rest financed. About 20 minutes were left to animate, Aladdin was coming out and he lost his financing and was forced to turn everything over to a completion bond company whose job it is to finish a film as cheaply as possible-- even if it's terrible. Search "Thief and the Cobbler Recobbled" to see what the film almost was.

  • Yes, it isn't fully animated because it is UNFINISHED as you state yourself. And the Recobbled version isn't "precious" to me-- I just feel it's the best version available. I could go on about Orson Welles' "Other Side of the Wind" too as another lost movie curiosity. At least this one can be viewed. I'd like to see the last workprint that Williams made but it simply isn't in circulation so I'll take the fan edit with its rough storyboards and pencil tests, thanks.

  • Considerning it is unfinished and still more visually appealing I say the recobbled cut is amazing. I do not find the unfinished scene's distracting at all. sure I would have loved to see them finished BUT BY WILLIAMS. NOT poorly reanimated, please stop bashing on everyone who loves the recobbled cut. I do not go around critizing people because they like this version and the disney version.

  • By muscling in on a conversation that didn't originally involve you, you ARE criticizing me. Look, I understand what the people who put together the recobbled cut were trying to do and it's very commendable (I really mean that; I'm not being patronizing) but I happen to prefer watching complete animation rather than storyboards with a soundtrack. That's why I like this version. So can we please just bury the hatchet?

  • @KahnBB6 How about "NO thanks to the Completion Bond"?

  • @ForbiddenDouchebag They should have put that in the credits, sure, but they didn't. It broke the filmmaker's heart and was powerful enough of an experience to make him want to retire early from the industry and never discuss the film again-- let alone have anything to do with it from that point on. I'll stand by my original comment: what balls to have put "special thanks to the completion bond company" in the credits for this film. The only thing worse is how Miramax further destroyed it.

  • @KahnBB6 yeah i think "balls" was the joke of the entire movie...

    and epic masterpiece of balls, though... ^_^

  • This is a catchy song? What country is this from?

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more