Lebanon is a great country, it has all kinds of religions. I, myself, am Christian. when u see lebanon or anything ragarding the middle east on the TV u always see terrorism. but this is not true. Lebanon is not regarded as an arab country. we are very open minded people. Lebanon is the meeting place of all the world's cultures.
@karimzo21 well said karmin,im from the north of ireland & the western media only reports what it want,its not to fast to report the women,children & innocent men that they kill
Will keep commenting on this because we Americans have been tainted with misinformation regarding Muslims and what they stand for. I as a Christian, please realize there are extremist in in every religion.What it will take is education on everyones part. Do not be quick to judge. George had his own agenda, and it hurt a lot of innocents.LIVE, LOVE AND LEARN....
Clint? You're the best friend I ever had. Thanks for showing me everything man. Sharing. I don't know where I'd be without you. It sucks I live so far away now. But you're like the brother I never had. I don't know how I could ever thank you. I hope we are friends for life.
After commenting on this clip by Roger Waters, I realized I had incorrectly called him John. Sorry for that but I feel the rest of what I said was correct. We were never given the whole picture, and other countries are reporting exactly what is going on.If we had the correct information we would never have let George use the situation for his own personal agenda. The women and children starving or killed did not have to happen. Again, "Three Cups of Tea" by Greg Mortenson tells the real deal.
I am just now getting it! Sad to say that but God Bless John Waters and his take on this situation. We were only given one side of the story and I posted this in the wrong place. I am not Muslim. but the news has slanted it to be a crime. We need to check ourselves because indiscriminately dropping bombs has hurt women, children and people who are not guilty of anything except trying to survive. Please read "Three cup of Tea" then tell me who is the enemy ?
I had the pleasure of seeing Roger in this tour back in '07...It was such an unforgettable experience...i hadn't heard this song before, then he started playing it & i started crying, the way he explained it was so moving & sad, how people who had basically nothing were so kind to him...
how is the line "everytime a smart bomb does its sums and gets it wrong, someone else's child dies and equities in defence rise" not consider, like the greatest line in music history.... how he came up with that I don't know..greatest lyricist of all-time in my opinion...... But for whatever reason, people prefer lyrics like "p-p-p-p-poker face"
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i used to like him but he seems to blame christian beliefs for the world being so f@#$ed up. muslims blow sht up everywhere but if a song was sang about it there would be all out jihad. wtf
religion is evil period, it has brought this world nothing but war, hate, and racial fractioning. wise up, there is no santa clause in the sky, grow up
The invasion of Lebanon could not have happened if The US and GB was against it, they are the main suppliers of weapon to Israel...this is what the song is about.
and George in this song is George Bush.....The christians is blind to every war crime the Israelis do...for they are "God's chosen people"...........
In 2006 The Israeli "defence" Forces invaded Lebanon and Beiruth, and they used Hizbollah's kidnapping of 2 israeli soldiers as the official excuse to invade,. Now we know that the invasion was planned long before the kidnapping...the reason to invade was to secure water supplies from Litani River, the groundwater level in Israel is very low...so religion is not an issue here!! Only simple stealing!!
roger waters basicly tears the americans apart in this song, i think this song is great, if you listen to the words it is true about what he is trying to get across, great video
He isn't to kind to the English either buddy. Remember your government was side by side in everything that happened. And it was the English who stole the land from the Palestinians. If you want to say Americans are guilty thats fine and true, but the British are far from innocent. It is just easier to blame the US
"Reconstruction of the visuals during the song Leaving Beirut by Roger Waters' during his current Dark Side of the Moon tour. Based upon the original sketches by Bill Sienkiewicz"
thankyou for putting this on youtube. i was at the concerts but couldnt read all of the visuals. it was great to see. thankyou again for taking your time putting this up. awsome, thumbs way up high!!!!
The drug war is lost, it should have never started, Reagan was an idiot. Roger Shares that view. Just listen to The Final Cut (The Fletcher Memorial Home is the song).
funny thing is......we're all worried about beating the Terroist up...but nobody...including O and Mc....care about more lives that are lost everyday in the drug ring that outnumber the bodies lost in the Real War. How pathetic it is to worry about fighting a good fight....but this Administration sucks when it comes to fighting wars here at home.......why.
Ah yes... I've already known what and where is Lebanon... I'm not from England (or other country where people speak in english) so forgive me. I'm from Poland XD. But did I guess that George is the first name of Waters?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't understand it. Maybe someone can explain me this... Who is George? George Roger Waters? And what's lebanon? And...is he in Beirut in this video??? But there people don't speak french... it isn't holding on to the whole. Explain me this.
Man Lebanon is a counrty... Beirut is its capitol.. It's a really beatiful country and YES they do speak french over there. Primary is Arabic, French and english. The whole world is getting ignorant...
I don't care what popular opinion says, compare gold like this with the stuff Gilmour and them were doing on the Division Bell, and it's clear he made the right choice to bail.
seen this live in the marquis in cork afew years back was awesum sound in that circus tent,the man sure knows how to get his points across,keep it up roger people like you make a difference,pros and cons a must for all roger fans
Just had the awesome pleasure of seeing the show in Denver (4/30); Dallas (05/02) and Houston (05/04)...met Roger for an autograph behind the venue in Dallas & Houston! He's the most awesome, genius guy ever...what an important messenger he is.
How can we make JON STEWERT OR STEPHEN COLBERT pick this up? : ) Patsy
Just saw this show tonight (May 4 '08). Fantastic, beyond words...I was really moved by this song. Thanks so much Duchateau1984 for taking the time to put this together and post it. Too much to take in live to follow the video and all the great performers on stage.
Thank you, this is really great. I saw it on Roskilde festival in Denmark 2006 and have been wanting to listen to it very bad ever since. It's only released in Japan - and you can't download it in Denmark apparently.
Listening to that song I began to cry first time in that concert. Barcelona 21/04/2007
Perrylite 1 month ago
shut up and sing
WesB 4 months ago
Un orgasmo para los oidos, para la vista y para nuestro reproductor ....................... de música
69woodstock19 5 months ago
...there is nothing wrong with you Roger, that's called empathy... and the world could use a lot more of it.
paulypoo66 5 months ago
Comment removed
BenjiBoi56 8 months ago
There's a good reason this video has 0 dislikes...
BenjiBoi56 8 months ago 2
I live in israel, i am jewish, i totaly agree with the lyrics, but i still thing Waters is a doucebag.
tomiko183 9 months ago
Lebanon is a great country, it has all kinds of religions. I, myself, am Christian. when u see lebanon or anything ragarding the middle east on the TV u always see terrorism. but this is not true. Lebanon is not regarded as an arab country. we are very open minded people. Lebanon is the meeting place of all the world's cultures.
JKShred 11 months ago
@JKShred
"Lebanon is not regarded as an arab country"
So what are they ?
spinspermy 10 months ago
@spinspermy we are more open minded and educated than the arabs ;) , that's what i mean
JKShred 10 months ago
@JKShred
Im Lebanese, and Christian aswell.
Wake up, we are an Arab country; dont deny your roots.
You should be proud mate, dont let the Western Media and belief(s) tell you otherwise
karimzo21 9 months ago
@karimzo21 fuck this is shit. if u wanna go to ur roots, u actually are phoenician. research abel ma te7ke.
JKShred 9 months ago
@karimzo21 well said karmin,im from the north of ireland & the western media only reports what it want,its not to fast to report the women,children & innocent men that they kill
celticpride67 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Will keep commenting on this because we Americans have been tainted with misinformation regarding Muslims and what they stand for. I as a Christian, please realize there are extremist in in every religion.What it will take is education on everyones part. Do not be quick to judge. George had his own agenda, and it hurt a lot of innocents.LIVE, LOVE AND LEARN....
MsViolentSneeze 11 months ago
Clint? You're the best friend I ever had. Thanks for showing me everything man. Sharing. I don't know where I'd be without you. It sucks I live so far away now. But you're like the brother I never had. I don't know how I could ever thank you. I hope we are friends for life.
heystupid14 11 months ago
After commenting on this clip by Roger Waters, I realized I had incorrectly called him John. Sorry for that but I feel the rest of what I said was correct. We were never given the whole picture, and other countries are reporting exactly what is going on.If we had the correct information we would never have let George use the situation for his own personal agenda. The women and children starving or killed did not have to happen. Again, "Three Cups of Tea" by Greg Mortenson tells the real deal.
MsViolentSneeze 1 year ago
I am just now getting it! Sad to say that but God Bless John Waters and his take on this situation. We were only given one side of the story and I posted this in the wrong place. I am not Muslim. but the news has slanted it to be a crime. We need to check ourselves because indiscriminately dropping bombs has hurt women, children and people who are not guilty of anything except trying to survive. Please read "Three cup of Tea" then tell me who is the enemy ?
MsViolentSneeze 1 year ago
I had the pleasure of seeing Roger in this tour back in '07...It was such an unforgettable experience...i hadn't heard this song before, then he started playing it & i started crying, the way he explained it was so moving & sad, how people who had basically nothing were so kind to him...
BenjiBoi56 1 year ago
nio mames, esa rola me hace lloirar siempre...
soad829 1 year ago
how is the line "everytime a smart bomb does its sums and gets it wrong, someone else's child dies and equities in defence rise" not consider, like the greatest line in music history.... how he came up with that I don't know..greatest lyricist of all-time in my opinion...... But for whatever reason, people prefer lyrics like "p-p-p-p-poker face"
SydPring 1 year ago 3
rock on ...roger waters...lyrically nobody beats u...not even come close to you
Mahtabmu 2 years ago 4
@Mahtabmu I would say Ray Davies beats him
Colin2k41 1 year ago
You've made me cry. We're all human children of God, Allah, Yahweah, and I do not, never will understand the wars we wage against each other.
60bunnies 2 years ago 5
Great Video!
calcio90 2 years ago
Great guitar by Andy Fairweather Low
easyTaff 2 years ago 5
Yes.......Can still here those notes resinating around the Rod Laver aren in Melbourne........Great Show...
Roger tells it as it is!
penfloyd 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i used to like him but he seems to blame christian beliefs for the world being so f@#$ed up. muslims blow sht up everywhere but if a song was sang about it there would be all out jihad. wtf
reggdunlop2003 2 years ago
religion is evil period, it has brought this world nothing but war, hate, and racial fractioning. wise up, there is no santa clause in the sky, grow up
aintdoingit 2 years ago
The invasion of Lebanon could not have happened if The US and GB was against it, they are the main suppliers of weapon to Israel...this is what the song is about.
and George in this song is George Bush.....The christians is blind to every war crime the Israelis do...for they are "God's chosen people"...........
2401sigurd 2 years ago 5
In 2006 The Israeli "defence" Forces invaded Lebanon and Beiruth, and they used Hizbollah's kidnapping of 2 israeli soldiers as the official excuse to invade,. Now we know that the invasion was planned long before the kidnapping...the reason to invade was to secure water supplies from Litani River, the groundwater level in Israel is very low...so religion is not an issue here!! Only simple stealing!!
2401sigurd 2 years ago 3
roger waters basicly tears the americans apart in this song, i think this song is great, if you listen to the words it is true about what he is trying to get across, great video
LewisBrophy 2 years ago 7
He isn't to kind to the English either buddy. Remember your government was side by side in everything that happened. And it was the English who stole the land from the Palestinians. If you want to say Americans are guilty thats fine and true, but the British are far from innocent. It is just easier to blame the US
johncostigan2 2 years ago
Thanks a lot for posting this! You are great.
45Akira 2 years ago
Comment removed
VIZTEK35 2 years ago
Such an amazing and heartfelt song
SidewinderBudd11 2 years ago 4
****ing incredible. It seems to be missing the "Wait, am I eating her food?" moment, though.
copbphoenix 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This seems to be a stolen copy of the video feed for the gig. Nice to be able to snatch it but hey.
deeperslice 2 years ago
Can't you read?
"Reconstruction of the visuals during the song Leaving Beirut by Roger Waters' during his current Dark Side of the Moon tour. Based upon the original sketches by Bill Sienkiewicz"
Duchateau1984 2 years ago
thankyou for putting this on youtube. i was at the concerts but couldnt read all of the visuals. it was great to see. thankyou again for taking your time putting this up. awsome, thumbs way up high!!!!
kenny9048 2 years ago 4
this was so amazing live
i went to da first of 3 shows bak in 06 in hollywood bowl
fuckin amazing
frying balls
diegopunk 2 years ago
roger loss her father in the 2° ww, from here born her peacespirit. peace and love from beirut to beijing, from moskow to washington
superplipi 2 years ago
Breathtaking!
RebelYellHim 2 years ago
AMAZING!!!!
0liveirahug0 3 years ago
Extraordinary.
dnamir 3 years ago 4
What a tune!!!!
alcoholismb 3 years ago
Brilliant
MaxGiu 3 years ago 3
investigate 9/11...
Stopandthink69 3 years ago
This song is an anti-war landmark. Fabulous as always by the real Pink himself. Peace.
rockaires 3 years ago 9
Rog' is god!
MilkShack 3 years ago 2
Just as i remeber it at Roskildefestival! - This song made me cry the first time i heard it... Fills me with both sadness and anger.
pitstop1516 3 years ago
thanks!!!
beholder9000 3 years ago
Great recreation!
whichonespink977 3 years ago
The drug war is lost, it should have never started, Reagan was an idiot. Roger Shares that view. Just listen to The Final Cut (The Fletcher Memorial Home is the song).
Killercreek 3 years ago 6
George. is George Bush. the president of the United States...
pitiful
madoyle88 3 years ago
funny thing is......we're all worried about beating the Terroist up...but nobody...including O and Mc....care about more lives that are lost everyday in the drug ring that outnumber the bodies lost in the Real War. How pathetic it is to worry about fighting a good fight....but this Administration sucks when it comes to fighting wars here at home.......why.
helpmeifucann 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no George is not george bush, that george is all americans.
epheus 3 years ago
i dont know why you got thumbs down on this... but you're right lol...
OmmakYaAoun 3 years ago
Ah yes... I've already known what and where is Lebanon... I'm not from England (or other country where people speak in english) so forgive me. I'm from Poland XD. But did I guess that George is the first name of Waters?
zbyszekszczecin 3 years ago
Rogers full name is George Roger Waters, but he abandoned the George early in his life.
AndrokleSasser 3 years ago
I saw the show live from Beirut, Lebanon!
Nice Vid! !10x
Bonzia 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't understand it. Maybe someone can explain me this... Who is George? George Roger Waters? And what's lebanon? And...is he in Beirut in this video??? But there people don't speak french... it isn't holding on to the whole. Explain me this.
zbyszekszczecin 3 years ago
Jesus, man. "Who's George?"
Where the hell you been these past eight years -- in a cave?
No offense, but... if you don't know what/where Lebanon is, nobdy here can help you. Look it up in an atlas.
TurnTheTideIn2009 3 years ago 5
George = George W. Bush, president of the United States of America
The official language in Lebanon is Arabic, although France is spoken by a large part of the population.
I love this song.
AndrokleSasser 3 years ago 2
Man Lebanon is a counrty... Beirut is its capitol.. It's a really beatiful country and YES they do speak french over there. Primary is Arabic, French and english. The whole world is getting ignorant...
OmmakYaAoun 3 years ago 33
getting ignorant? i think you are wrong my friend the world always was..
scoobyDx 3 years ago 3
I don't care what popular opinion says, compare gold like this with the stuff Gilmour and them were doing on the Division Bell, and it's clear he made the right choice to bail.
rhesusmonkeydave 3 years ago 4
I saw him do this in 2006 in Philadelphia. It was amazing. Thanks for adding this video so I can see it again.
This has got to be one of the most touching songs he has ever written!
RebelYellHim 3 years ago 3
God bless Lebanon!
abouabsielias 3 years ago 7
Rogers music has taken reasonable slip since he left pink floyd but his poetry it just as strong as ever...
RebelFactor4Life 3 years ago
Saw him at the O2 a couple of weeks ago, this song was by far my highlight of the night.
ccinnz 3 years ago
great song also saw him at 02 18may
wozzawoe 3 years ago
Saw him in Philly (June 2nd, 07). This song and the entire show was just awesome.
NES4life 3 years ago
ty* so much for the post. Sorry, was still buzzin from the show =P
Restlesscow 3 years ago
This is 1 of my favorite songs and Videos...Just awsome. Saw him live yesterday (18th at O2) an he played this. so much fo rthe post :)
Restlesscow 3 years ago 3
OH GEORGE!
OH GEORGE!
That Texas education must've FUCKED you up when you were very small!
Oh how very, very true
big69bud420 3 years ago 43
seen this live in the marquis in cork afew years back was awesum sound in that circus tent,the man sure knows how to get his points across,keep it up roger people like you make a difference,pros and cons a must for all roger fans
omck66 3 years ago
Can I get a copy of this? This is the only song I didnt film in Dallas 2 May, got everything else, and it whoops A!
How do you contact a submitter?
RBM180 3 years ago
Saw this life, one of the most moving things I have ever seen
Natehundred 3 years ago 2
Brilliant.
Aqualung71 3 years ago
Just had the awesome pleasure of seeing the show in Denver (4/30); Dallas (05/02) and Houston (05/04)...met Roger for an autograph behind the venue in Dallas & Houston! He's the most awesome, genius guy ever...what an important messenger he is.
How can we make JON STEWERT OR STEPHEN COLBERT pick this up? : ) Patsy
dragondigger 3 years ago
peace & energy
cyyyggnus 3 years ago
Just saw this show tonight (May 4 '08). Fantastic, beyond words...I was really moved by this song. Thanks so much Duchateau1984 for taking the time to put this together and post it. Too much to take in live to follow the video and all the great performers on stage.
Live long and prosper...
cygnus
cyyyggnus 3 years ago 2
Saw the show in Melbourne Aust. Feb 07.
Great guitarists.....Dave Killminster,
Snowy White and Andy Fairweather Low.
It was interesting to see 3 generations of
loyal Floyd Fans.........
penfloyd 3 years ago
im going to see this in liverpool in may
cant wait!
macropZaZZ 3 years ago
love it
etienne0102 3 years ago 4
the comics remind me of sin city
sethmanjette12 3 years ago
Go Roger. No Matter what anyone says in their ignorance. Thank you on behalf of my entire family. Beirut misses you. You should come back someday.
Khaibar06 3 years ago
I saw this in September '06 in northern VA. Awesome show!
gamecubeclock 3 years ago
how did you get this?? have yopu got the updated one from the last year's tour? this one is from 2006's tour
mtoesperto 3 years ago
thanks for uploading this....a true classic of a song
radioactivenerd 4 years ago 4
I saw this at Hyde Park 2006, it was amazing. I loved it. One of the most interesting perspectives of world politics via music.
LetsGoBuffaloSabres 4 years ago 2
i searched for this video desperately after the mumbai concert. thank you so much.
rishikesh27 4 years ago
magnifico muy buen trabajo gracias
moymars2 4 years ago
Roger does it again..like others I saw live in Melbourne in Feb. Fantastic concert....great to hear/see it again. Thanks heaps.
moonrock1962 4 years ago
Me encanto!!
Muy buen trabajo! gracias!!
goodlenore 4 years ago
i saw this live it was awsome
thebandlife0 4 years ago 4
Thank you, this is really great. I saw it on Roskilde festival in Denmark 2006 and have been wanting to listen to it very bad ever since. It's only released in Japan - and you can't download it in Denmark apparently.
So - thank you!
Riepige 4 years ago
i love this song
Alive4Metal 4 years ago
i saw this in the 2007 tour it was AWESOME
Boston1114 4 years ago
great vid. i also saw this on the 2007 tour in australia. the message in this song is sooooooo true
kkcp23 4 years ago
great job
theMoonAV 4 years ago
thanks for adding the Video!, i love it!
1337juancho1337 4 years ago
its in french....y?
Missyourlover 4 years ago
I saw this live on the 2007 tour and loved it. Thanks for posting this video!!
Punta134 4 years ago
Great song, i was stunned when i first saw this live on the 2007 tour.
Sliwkaa 4 years ago