Added: 11 months ago
From: Coresongs85
Views: 22,292
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Both BTBAM's and this version are good. All the haters whp hate this version can shut the fuck up and GTFO!!

  • fucking terrible, why the hell is some shit metalcore band covering Floyd? The fucking butchered this

  • @MuleMan14 Yet you searched this. How ironic and sad.

  • @MuleMan14 misery signals is a prestigious metalcore band. asking alexandria is a shit metalcore band. misery signals is musical and you should listen to them before you bash them

  • The only reason Pink Floyd ever existed is so that Misery Signals could cover them.

  • @ParachutesOnParade as much as this comment is probably true ;) I think pink floyd may have existed to mindfuck the world

  • WHAT THE FUCK?!? Roger Waters would Back hand each and every one of these fags for this piece of shit... modern bands should really stay the fuck away from masterpieces

  • @1979rickfukingjames I think they would probably backhand people like you first for giving a shit. Also I think most bands would be happy to know that someone wants to play one of their songs, it's pretty much saying "I think your music could entertain a lot of people". Not to mention permission must be given from the original band before a cover can be released, otherwise they could get sued for copyright.

  • Why do all modern bands have a singer that sounds like a faggot?

  • @GamerzPro1231 TROLOLOLOLOLLLLLL!!!

  • @GamerzPro1231 Because you have your own taste in music? Like almost everyone else on the planet.

  • @57Royston No I'm completely serious he sounds like a total faggot.

  • I like everything except the vocals. idk they just don't appeal to me

  • I love hearing a version of this song without the fucking jazz shit in the beginning

  • this band is very underrated which is a shame. they have some of the best guitar work out there right now. hopesfall was another band that didnt get the attention they deserved and they were gods at melodic breakdowns

  • And that drumming...that damn drumming, it's the biggest reason I listen to Misery Signals in the first place :)

  • I never played Homefront, but DAMN the people who made this game has my taste in music. They're just missing Between the Buried and Me :)

  • @LetsGetHighOnMorris Between the Buried and Me's cover of this song kicks ass too.

  • @ChildOfBodomx13 shit im gonna have to check that out right meeeow...

  • This is actually really good. I was not expecting it to be this great. Being an avid fan of the genre of music Misery Signals plays and being an avid fan of Pink Floyd I find this to be very appealing

  • @OneSmexyBuffalol I'll translate "dis shizz iz da BOMB NIGGA"

  • @OneSmexyBuffalol loved hopesfall, I still listen to satellite years and that EP with april left in silence all the time

  • The drums are soo so crazy.

  • Just an awesome song

  • wait wait wait

    this was in a GAME soundtrack?! Buying that shit asap

  • Syd Berret is turning over in his grave...

  • @CthulhuDarkLord Us and them is on darkside. Syd left after Piper at the Gates of Dawn.

    I think you mean Roger Waters is turning over in his... living flesh

  • hay que escucharlo varias veces para que te guste, a la primera es una mierda pero después le tomas cariño. Cuesta asimilarla

  • 45 people are "them"

  • Bad Ass Breakdowns

  • 44 people have hearing problems.

  • pink floyd is better.

  • Both the original and this version of the song are amazing. I listen to many genres of music and Misery Signals will always be one of my favourites out of any of them. So much passion goes into their songwriting, not as much these days but they still continually put out good music. Whether you hate metalcore or not, you can't go past this band. Also Branden Morgan, their drummer, is classically trained. He could play fast and monotone metal if he wanted.

  • Comment removed

  • Maaaan, this shit its awful :\

  • I forget Karl can sing. One of the most talented bands by far. I WANT THEIR NEW SHIT TO COME SOON! Better sound like controller...

  • @HaveYouHeardOf Actually, it'd better sound like Of Malice :] Controller was a fantastic album but nothing matches their early days.

  • Kinda has a deftones/incubus feel to it.

  • MISERY SIGNALS DID SOMETHING ON HOMEFRONT!??? WHAT THE FUCK? I didn't even know they were famous :|

  • @notabear1 I wish they were more popular than any other band, they deserve it.

  • @notabear1 You obviously don't have to be famous to have a song on this soundtrack. It's all metal songs. ie: Who the fuck are The Ghost Inside? Yet they're also on the soundtrack....

    Also, this cover is superior to BTBAM's attempt at it, just my opinion.

  • @ImpossibleTriumph I know, but I haven't met anyone before that has even heard of MS. Also, The Ghost Inside is probably the most famous band in Brisbane of their genre :S

    I hear bands covering them all the time at local gigs.

  • Pretty good for the metalcore style... I think if they had stuck with the clean vocals throughout, this would be a classic cover. The guitars and melody changes at 2:20 are great.

  • siendo lo progresivos que son, pudieron haber hecho un cover mucho mejor, con más de ese post-rock que hicieron con "Worlds and Dreams"

  • This version is the best and beast

  • dude you guys sat this cover is better than BTBAMs ? hahahaahaha they take away from Pink Floyd, trying to give it too much of their own style.. Between The Buried And Me > Misery Signals for covers and of course their musical pieces

  • Misery Signals is probably one of the most influential Hardcore/Metalcorebands with their 7 Angels,7 Plagues origin.

    One of the few bands,that is emotional and very complex at the same time, just listen to Mirrors.

    This band deserves more recognition.

  • Misery Signals is too much of an innovated band for some people to handle.

  • This is a kick ass remake!!! This band gets no suport all there music kicks ass!!!

  • Ahh dude, this isn't a good cover. :(

  • Why does every guy who sings these days sound strained like he's taking a dump at the same time? Frikkin hate voices like that.

  • shit thumbs down

  • This is horrible. They're raping the song

  • floyd is king nice try tho noobs V stfu

  • man this is so horrible if your going to capture the goodness of Pink Floyd don't make it metal people who say this one is better haven't listened to true music listen to the Dark Side of the Moon this song will make sense.

  • @pvtsoap262 This isn't Metal, it's a shitty fusion genre called Metalcore. If you want to here a good Metal cover of Pink Floyd, the band Dream Theater covered the whole Dark Side album.

  • @clonecomanderfox I'll try it out also don't you think its funny that this game could only get covers for there songs for how poor these motherfuckers are can't make a good game I might add.

  • @pvtsoap262 They actually got covers because Metalcore speaks more to a "hip" audience.

  • This band has been one of my fave's for 7 years!

  • Not terrible, but certainly not an improvement over the original

  • Dear christ, they ruined this song. BTBAM did an excellent cover of this song though.

  • No...

  • I cannot believe all the hate this is getting.......It is a marvelous cover!

  • i listened until i heard his voice, this song is supposed to be soft and emotional, not cranky and pubescent

  • All I have to say on this one, WTF!!??!!

    I'll give you an example of good cover: No Quarter( Led zeppelin) by TOOL. Now that's cover. Changing genres can work at times but WTF.

  • I listen to all kinds of music. Death to Pink Floyd and what not. I have listened several metal bands cover Iron Maiden, Deep Purple, Black Sabbath, and they're really good. But this is fucked up. The melody is good, but WTF

    I know people are strange and we all have different opinions, and I completely respect your opinion, if you like this one or not.

    And as far as drumming is concerned, start listening to Danny Carey(Tool).

  • this is complete crap. pink floyd is the only one who could do this.

  • Bwaaah you kyeant here the wurds when hes skreeming :((((((((((((((((((((( Jeez people, listen to all kinds of music. I listen to music from soft-jazz to progressive-metal, from acoustic-ambiance to dubstep to instrumental-fusion, punk-rock and blues. Not trying to put myself above anyone on some stupid musical hierarchy, but that's exactly what you people are doing when you can't open your mind to something new or different.

  • This fantastic........ The drumming is amazing..

  • fucking god damn...they absolutly killed this shit, there melody and tone was perfect for this cover..i love pink floyd and this song, so this being done is just a total mind fuck for me..fucking sick

  • I knew about misery signals from back in the Jesse zaraska days....best shows of my life and even met Jesse and the guys :)

  • Fucking disgusting. Stumble upon this thinking it might have a shot and I find nothing but shit. Way to destroy a really good song by a classic band. What is wrong with this fucking generation?

  • Comment removed

  • @Ghostwolf12 They didn't destroy anything.They covered a song by a band they like, and made it sound like their own style.Exactly what a cover should be. If you wanted to just hear an exact copy of the original song just listen to pink floyd.Do me a favor and do a better cover of this song.

  • @Ghostwolf12 OPEN YOUR MIND!!! thats what pink floyd is all about! Folks Are So Narrow These Days!

  • if i hadn't know the original Pink Floyd's song, i'd like it. But unfortunately i do know it

  • New Mis Sigs is going to be amazing!! Even though 2 members left, as long as they still have the morgan brothers together the music will stay amazing, and Karl will always be a beast behind the mic!! Besides, the 2 new guys could be amazing newcomers as well. So excited. =)

  • @camstr

    you know anything about a new Signals album?

  • @RiceInSight Only that they made an update a while back about writing new material in june/july or july/august or something which is promising...also they are about to embark on a pretty big tour so that's also good news. Good to see the band back to life again in a big way. I'd check youtube continually after the tour starts for new songs performed live if I were you, other than that all I can tell you is that bands usually go on tour to promote new albums or to rock out before new albums =)

  • ok get this rite i kno my pink floyd and this version is retarded thhey basically took this song and shit on it btbam did i amazing job and we can sit here and argue who did a better cover but nothing will top pink floyd but just to let u dumasses kno this is terible completely ruined the song

  • This version shits all over the BTBAM version.

  • Best song ever!!!

  • the drummer is friggen givin' er

  • this has ruined the song

    screaming is not singing i can get on stage and scream but it wont be considered singing

  • @albear200 Screaming takes so much talent you don't even know

  • @albear200 Hahaha, yea, you can scream like everyone can, but you can't scream cohesively to music like karl or any other professional metal vocalist. Regardless of what you think or your personal taste, this kind of screaming DOES take talent, and it certainly compliments this type of music.

  • The Drums in this song are sooooo amazing

  • Both Between the Buried and Me, and Misery Signals covered this song well.

    I don't see why people should hold them so close, because they are very different.

  • Thumbs up is you think BTBAM nailed it way better. Where's the need for two bands from this demographic to try this song?

  • i hate misery signals, but this is awesome.

  • Comment removed

  • Misery Signals remains one of the few metalcore bands I still enjoy. But with the loss of one of the founding guitarists I'm hesitant about new material. Fingers crossed.

  • @GoongalaGoongala Ryan is still in the band. The only "original" member whose recently left is Kyle and he plays bass.

  • I knew them before homefront, ive never even played or heard anything about them being involved with homefront.

  • New Misery Signals?! YES!

  • Interpretations are allowed in cover tunes, just as long as you ask for consent from the person/band/publisher you are paying royalties to. David Gilmour gave the okay on this and it exists now. U mad?

  • who else knew about Misery Signals before homefront ?

  • @HoRizoN2797 I have known them since 2007.

  • @HoRizoN2797 seen them 3 times in concert

  • @HoRizoN2797

    It's not like they're a new band bro...

  • @HoRizoN2797 lots of people. :P

  • @HoRizoN2797 i did, i just realized homefront has an amazing line up of bands for the soundtrack, i thought the game was kind of shitty tho, at least the music is badass

  • @HoRizoN2797 damn... way off

  • @HoRizoN2797 what the hell is homefront?? lol..

    

  • @Sleeeeve24 the game whose soundtrack this song appears on

  • i like the little "any colour you like" bits thrown in the middle

  • I think it's so awesome that they also included "Any Colour You Like". Really fills it out

  • interesting

    that's all I have to say

  • this is so fucking cool

  • I'll bet Pink Floyd themselves even like this. Fuck the haters.

  • I'll bet Pink Floyd themselves would even like this. Fuck the haters.

  • Pure fucking abomination.

  • Just wish the guys that mixed this for the video game album did a better job. I'm used to hearing much better production from Mis Sigs.

  • i fucking love this cover, the original is fucking amazing but the original brings in a calm and relaxing feeling this one brings in a fucking brutal metal version! i fucking love both of these bands

  • Funny how all the pink floyd fans think they ruined the song. Misery signals is awesome, and it is just a COVER song, the original still exists, so top having a fucking cry and go listen to it instead.

  • It's pretty good. I miss Shuma's vocals from 'Mirrors' though. And I thought it was funny when they say "God only knows" in this song, but they have a whole song dedicated to how God isn't real.

  • fuck yes misery signals drummer outdoes himself once again

  • hmm...I don't think anyone can top the original, it's really hard to remake such a classic. Good try though, I love me some misery signals...

  • 6 Pink floyd albums at a bargain price on EBAY, See item number : 260763918346

  • @Frijs get a job. Misery Signals is 10x more succesful then you will be in your entire life.

  • Sounds really great. Been waiting to hear something new by them for a long time :)

  • They ruined the song!

  • @Frijs no they made it better

  • @malusironforge for a deaf

  • @malusironforge Metalcore sucks, I doubt it makes Pink Floyd better.

  • @malusironforge nothings better than Pink Floyd dude.

  • No matter who covered this song i wouldn't love it as much as the original

  • @OfficerMelon Thats what I said but actually, between the buried and me covers it and its actually seriously epic... They dont add or take away from it at all

  • I have to say the song isn't slaughtered and that's cool.

  • misery signals always makes me happy.. great job on a great song!

  • Misery Signals... = Awsome...

  • this is fucking sick, if you dont like it then dont sit and hate just gtfo, k thnx

  • This is great! The original is awesome too! I love both! But Misery Signals gave it a touch I simply love!

  • If it wasn't Pink Floyd, I wouldn't have a problem with this. But I don't think that any band is at liberty to change a classic as much as this band did. I won't judge their skill or anything, I just don't think this was the right band for the job.

  • @mets4life3064 Any fan of the original doesn't want it changed AT ALL, doesn't matter who was doing it. For that reason alone, no fan of the original should even be listening to this, go listen to the original version. This is a cover by a different band so yes it's going to sound different because they're putting their own spin on it. That's what a good cover is supposed to do. I love BTBAM but when they covered this song they didn't do anything different and Mis Sigs did so that's awesome.

  • @camstr of course this is only your opinion. Try to remember that everyone is entitled to their own point of view.

  • @camstr yea that's your opinion. I'm a huge floyd fan, and I love the original, and i appreciate and like this version. It's not like they're trying to glorify themselves by covering this song, they're paying tribute to a band that has influenced them greatly.

  • Pink Floyd and screaming should never be in the same paragraph.

  • @AuralOverdose You just used them in the same sentence!

  • This. Is. Fucking. Horrible. ...I.....this is making me sick..

  • Oh what the fuck. How badly can you miss the point of a song? How badly can you fuck up the delivery of a song?! Seriously. This is...almost painful.

  • @13HFloyd13

    close minded man.. this is amazing

  • @guitarplayer824

    It's not a matter of being close-minded. I'm a massive metalhead as much as I am a Floyd fan. They just TOTALLY missed the point of the song.

  • @13HFloyd13 what do you mean missed the point? and by the way i love floyd, always have and always will.

  • you just can't cover floyd. covers are meant to modernize an older classic. there is no need, and if you did, the cover should then be good. this is terrible. its corney, its cheap, its unoriginal. to each his own, but this is absolutely horrible. id rather listen to rebecca black.

  • @jbarbalacofilms  Well said!

  • @jbarbalacofilms no, you really wouldn't

  • @jbarbalacofilms You didn't even think the drumming is justified in the very least?

  • @jbarbalacofilms your a narrow minded twat.

  • @jbarbalacofilms i like how you stated you'd rather listen to rebecca black, implying she isn't any of the traits you listed. good job moron.

    (yes i know you used rebecca black as a metaphor, i just think it was a shitty choice)

  • @jbarbalacofilms that's because you like her asshole. Mis Sigs is better than anything you know/like

  • I love the original song and this cover is simply amazing! I'm going to have to check this band out now

  • This is probably my favorite cover on the album. I like Periphery a lot more as a band, but Us and Them is probably one of Pink Floyd's best songs in my opinion.

  • I was pleasantly surprised by this cover. It's a hell of a lot better than some of the other butchered songs on the Homefront soundtrack.

  • decent attempt. i like some parts more than others. as for covering a pink floyd song, you all should know, either is everything is sacred, or nothing is, and these days NOTHING is sacred, so whether you like it or not, this cover exists and there isn't a thing anyone can do about it. heres my point: JUST BE GLAD WINDS OF PLAGUE DIDN'T COVER THIS. (they really did a bad job at for what it's worth)

  • first song i ever heard from the band, even though its a cover of a band idc for i like this song/band so far

  • @xXSATCHM0Xx Best band. Check out everything they've released. You won't be disappointed.

  • @lobster272

    agreed

  • Am I The Only One who Shit his pants when I found out Misery Signals was on the homefront Sountrack!!..... Because if I'am I dont give a Dam!

  • the only good band on this soundtrack

  • Never liked a thing from this band, love Floyd though. I like this cover a lot. Props to them for making it their own, which is something most bands that contributed to this album didn't do.

  • BAD. kill the people that made this they just ruined one of the best songs ever

  • @Bl00dmilandsky hey. you dont have a right to talk. you are obviously brown. stay in your cage you rat.

  • @Bl00dmilandsky No they did´t, you are a moron. You can just not listen to it.

  • @Bl00dmilandsky I'm pretty sure anyone in the world would have you killed a million times sooner than they would even consider killing anyone from Mis Sigs, fuck you.

  • @camstr i doubt it.

  • No one really cares who did this over better (BTBAM or misery signals). We're all excited for new misery signals!

  • omg new misery signals! my heart just skipped a beat.

  • @futboladelic Mine too! But thats because I have a heart murmur :/