In the 2nd half after the C min. cadence, before the long trill, you play the RH line thusly: G, A, B FLAT, C, D, C, B FLAT C, D, long trill on E flat -F. Using the logic of the time, this is wrong! Why play B flat; a mistake? In this simple piece by Bach, such an error is so jarring its far worse than any wrong note in Feux Follets. The Liszt and Moszkowski show real talent, but the Sarabande belongs in the partita not in a flower show! Some slow Schubert? You're too good for this!
In the 2nd half after the C min. cadence, before the long trill, you play the RH line thusly: G, A, B FLAT, C, D, C, B FLAT C, D, long trill on E flat -F. Using the logic of the time, this is wrong! Why play B flat; a mistake? In this simple piece by Bach, such an error is so jarring its far worse than any wrong note in Feux Follets. The Liszt and Moszkowski show real talent, but the Sarabande belongs in the partita not in a flower show! Some slow Schubert? You're too good for this!
manhattanvor 1 year ago
Comment removed
manhattanvor 1 year ago
Comment removed
manhattanvor 1 year ago