TF G1 "Carnage in C-minor" with Chris Mcfeely

[Akutare]

Zebop is the most awesome name ever.

[WhiteWings88]

I think this could have been something pretty cool, and having a planet built on music while having a music battle between Blaster and Soundwave, kinda like Auto-Bop.

It could've been if they just did it...well...not like this.

How IS tights and tunics about music? For that matter, why have Soundwave or Blaster translate if they're just going to sing-song their lines? *sigh* Why?

[Powermastersupreme]

Nice to hear Chris's commentaries, always seem to learn something new!

[shalamar2k2]

Since when can Ultra Magnus fly?! In general Autobots are incapable of flying; save for a select few.

[Skullgrin140]

God this episode is so awful, lol. It was difficult to forget it ever happend.

[soundwavefan052]

i cant beleive soundwaves only major story in s3 is one of the shittest episodes ever. is chris doing any other commentries soon

[TomEP2]

Did anybody notice the big plot hole at 4:25? Preceptor shouldn't have been able to shoot down Devastator like that. That's saying a lot when it's a microscope against one of the most powerful combiners! WTF? It took the 4 Dinobots to just wear down Devastator but when Preceptor transforms, *bang* and Devastator falls apart like house of cards! O_o

[coker10]

I noticed it. Add to that it' the aliens' synthesizers (4 me, not their singing),, Soundwave acting close to dumb helper than the usual smart one. Stopping there; I could Energizer Eunny keep going and going and going about this crap.

[TomEP2]

It's no question why this episode is called the worst. I mean, it could be even worse than anything from Energon.

[JediAutobotX]

Such a bad episode! why!? WHY!?

[Jaimetron1]

That episode is just depressing.

[dirtypirate79]

This episode is absolute crap. I try to forget it.

[urizen123]

I'd just like to comment on the awesomeness of the thumbnail image for this video.

Galvatron's all like -

}: ]

[WolfKang1]

That was very informative. More of the same please.

[stardub]

Sweet zombie Primus! I've never watched this episode sober before. I need to drink now. Heavily. Booze. Bring me booze.

-Ralph

[thecollector75]

cant wait to see more of these comentaries, more please - graham

[CybertronNews22]

Great commentay.

But still, "Carnage in C-minor" is the most f***ed up G1 episode ever...this and B.O.T.

[primal2020]

i only saw this episode because it was the only thing broadside appeared in that i could find....not worth it,he did practically nothing but stand there.

[GWolfV2]

*Sigh* This was Soundwave's last hurrah...*sigh*

[foxcat18]

The only reason I watched this episode in the first place was because soundwave was actually in it. He didn't have alot of roles in season 3...

[ncstatester]

Very cool. Thanks for putting this up. Chris has a great knowledge base that makes these even better.

[ilovemess]

hi chris.

ray here. you know, ray down the road 'ray'?

i'm considering setting the synopsis of this 'unique' episode to music!

what you think/

ray

[UltraPrimal]

Great excellent commentary.

One error you missed though was Defensor was seen fighting along side Hot Spot. But that's OK. You where talking about something else at the time. You can't do 2 things at once. Just goes to show how many errors are in this episode if one can't keep up

lol, little fleshies.

[Actionfigurexpert]

Broadside also was in Aircraft Carrier Mode in 5 Faces of Darkness.

[sixshotmark]

Chris' comentaries are great.

[darqen666]

Thanks for putting this up. On the bit about blaster rhyming i seem to remember him saying something in cosmic rust "primes really going to have the blues for this news, there's nowhere to shop for more chorostop?"

[Alan1701b]

The highlights of this episode for me was seeing Soundwave and Broadside having significant roles and I love the moment when Broadside, in aircraft carrier mode, drops down from space and crushes Devastator.

But the animation errors are just inexcusable! How they let this episode out the way it was just boggles the mind.

I really wish that they'd reuse the voices and the story but reanimate the episode from scratch.

[Azap333]

I hate this episode I almost fell alsleep watching it lol butthanks for putting p these commintaries David don't know why Chris didn't do commentary on the UK dvds I own is well beyond me

[DragonballToys]

This was remarkably well done, thank you for it! Fascinating stuff!

[destrond69]

Dave, thanks for putting this up. I've been wanting to check out these commentaries, but the box sets I have... suck