I don't like this version..For me the only one which deserves to be seen is the Italian one. The other versions don't express the pathos or beauty of the musical. It's obvious that the French version gives better the idea of the context, the period, and the book (because the original story was set in France), but I think the Italian one is the best.. Riccardo Cocciante is the singer who wrote it and I think that in Italian the way of acting and the words are amazing.
@perzekella91 Riccardo Cocciante only wrote the music, the original lyrics, the FRENCH ones, were written by Luc Plamondon, a French Canadian which is why the only version worth seeing is the FRENCH one...
If you haven't guessed by now I am getting increasingly annoyed each time somebody says, for any song, that the version is his/her own language is the best... A song in your native tongue will affect you emotionally than one in another so everyone will have a different opinion.
@MarbledPaladin Everyone has his own opinion. What i'v said is not a law, is my pure and simple point of view, that's why I wrote "for me". I can assure you that before expressing my critical opinion, i've seen all the versions, because i'm a big fan of this musical, . Although I liked the french one and the russian one really impressed me too, I can't help the fact the I prefer the italian one. we're free and we can say whatever we want, without giving offence to other. Bye ^^
"...she dances naked in my soul and sleep wont come..."?????? seriously??? c'mon ..could've translated to something a bit more sensual rather than sexual?! lols
Rispondi a questo video... Yes, i know but it's not my fault if Italian is more intense. I don't argue that it is beautiful in French, but the Italian has received more success
Even if I love english language, I must say that italian version is much better, as well the france one. I don't know why, but the songs of this play seem to be done just for languages of latin origin!
I like the English, French and even the verzion is not bad, but this musical is much higher and sublime in Italian, not only because the Italian language best expresses the idea ofpathos and love, but also for increased transport interpretation of the artists!
@feniceriascente Of all the version I listened to (French, Italian, Russian, Spanish, Polish, Korean, Dutch) I prefer the French version better for similar reasons than the ones you mentioned. I am sure that the fact that French is my mother tongue plays a part in my preference for the French version just like Italian being your mother tongue plays a part in your preference for the Italian version...
@MarbledPaladin My mother tongue is not either English and French, but I do prefer to the French version. One reason for it is that I think the tone, pronounciations and emotions of French are very suitable in this rythm and this type of music, also the original story was written in French, so I think original tastes best right!! I prefer the French version.
@HilaryPhantom i am sorry to say but the people you hear singing in this video are Garou, Daniel and Steve which are the ones who sing in the French verison. If you look closly you can tell that it is not them singing it.
P.S. your English is not that bad. I would have never guessed you did not speak it well
все равно нет и не будет ничего лучше, чем оригинальная версия!!эти голоса, эти образы, сама эта атмосфера, которую передают г-да Garou, Daniel и Patric даже через монитор компьютера-это невозможно повторить ни в какой-либо другой стране ни на каком языке, какие бы ни были гениальные актеры...))но все-таки в русской версии г-н Маракулин исполнил свою роль на бесподобно!!)))))
I own the French version, but does anyone know where I can purchase the English version of this song? I just think these three sound so incredible together.
@tionad12 Надо сказать, на английском звучит почти так же прекрасно, как и на французском, ЕСЛИ исполняют Гару и Даниэль Лавуа (вроде из французских больше никто не поёт в английской версии). А вообще, как погляжу, все версии мюзикла, помимо русской и французской - это сплошной стыд и срам.
what the hell?? That is Garou!! And Daniel!! And Steve!! :O! I love this song, but really? Come on now English people lol sing it with your real voices please!
I think that that the Russian version wasn't as good as French. In fact, I think that every language that has been done to this play sucks compared to the ORIGINAL french play.....Oh, by the way, did the user edit this? 'Cause on the bottom it says "english version edited." I was just wondering. It still sucks either way.
the difference between italian and other language is that the italian has words concentred on vowels, then it's easier and more beautiful sing in italian...
I've seen the French, so in comparison this can't even hold a candle.
I mean, I feel like it's good by itself, but because it's a version of a masterpiece...
Also, I'm not sure if all of them are lipsynching, or the audio is just off.
awriterandagamer 1 week ago
I know that's Garou singing, but who's the video of?
Lollimopsy 3 weeks ago 2
*not
ameliePower 1 month ago
I'm sure Quasimodo is lipsinging! It's note the same voice at the begining
ameliePower 1 month ago
La version française est la meilleure de toutes ! Anglaise, russe, polonaise, vietnamienne, coréenne et espagnole !
Heissy91 1 month ago
This song is lovely in all versions. French is probably my favorite, and then Spanish, but it´s lovely in all languages.
CrimsonRoseOfDanube 1 month ago
Beautiful voices.. :) So powerful.
MagMaybe 1 month ago
I don't like this version..For me the only one which deserves to be seen is the Italian one. The other versions don't express the pathos or beauty of the musical. It's obvious that the French version gives better the idea of the context, the period, and the book (because the original story was set in France), but I think the Italian one is the best.. Riccardo Cocciante is the singer who wrote it and I think that in Italian the way of acting and the words are amazing.
perzekella91 2 months ago
@perzekella91 Riccardo Cocciante only wrote the music, the original lyrics, the FRENCH ones, were written by Luc Plamondon, a French Canadian which is why the only version worth seeing is the FRENCH one...
If you haven't guessed by now I am getting increasingly annoyed each time somebody says, for any song, that the version is his/her own language is the best... A song in your native tongue will affect you emotionally than one in another so everyone will have a different opinion.
MarbledPaladin 1 month ago
@MarbledPaladin Everyone has his own opinion. What i'v said is not a law, is my pure and simple point of view, that's why I wrote "for me". I can assure you that before expressing my critical opinion, i've seen all the versions, because i'm a big fan of this musical, . Although I liked the french one and the russian one really impressed me too, I can't help the fact the I prefer the italian one. we're free and we can say whatever we want, without giving offence to other. Bye ^^
perzekella91 1 month ago
is garou singing the first part?? or is that the guy playing quasimodo
meangirl714 2 months ago
@meangirl714 garou
1000oleggg 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Красивые слова,Но исполнение честно говоря не понравилось. И всё таки "She dances naked" это даже как то пошло.
TheMegaKaban 2 months ago
"beneath her rainbow coloured dress, there burns a well" :-))))))))))
Mayepokpok 3 months ago
The original italian version with the french one are the best.
FansDiGemmaDelSud 3 months ago
Comment removed
FansDiGemmaDelSud 3 months ago
this is the worst version. english isn't adapt to this type of thing, it's much more better in other songs!!
therebbi95 3 months ago
lol pheobus isn't cute at all
EzebelaTiture 3 months ago
The French singers sang this English version.
Latincitizen 3 months ago
Love french version and italian too <3
FleetStreetQueen 4 months ago 2
garouuuuuuuuuuuu is god compared to this madness !!!!
OUCHEN1900 4 months ago
Comment removed
OUCHEN1900 4 months ago
what the fuck? It's the french singers singing in english! The english people are lip-syncing!
nakool1995 4 months ago
"...she dances naked in my soul and sleep wont come..."?????? seriously??? c'mon ..could've translated to something a bit more sensual rather than sexual?! lols
FRENCH=BESTTTTTTTTTTTT
carolineptenchick 4 months ago
@carolineptenchick I couldnt agree more!!
Lypriest 4 months ago
time to wash my brain out with the french version >.<
xClaudeFrollosGirlx 4 months ago
Garou in English !!!! yes the best musical singer in the world now in English :)
Thenewdane 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very strong, ya :) But Russian version is the best
TheMarat1972 5 months ago
Very strong, ya :) No Russian version is the best
TheMarat1972 5 months ago
is the second guy nicolas cage??
momoW3 5 months ago
i don't like the english version of ndp, i think the italian one is better! or french :-)
rebelleYA 5 months ago
so so . Russian version is cool
MrSampledon 5 months ago
Rispondi a questo video... Yes, i know but it's not my fault if Italian is more intense. I don't argue that it is beautiful in French, but the Italian has received more success
LuciaSing91 5 months ago
Comment removed
LuciaSing91 5 months ago
French Version of Caurse better
ninucaa19 5 months ago in playlist Belle
Listen to italian version...my favourite...
marzia108 6 months ago 3
French or English or any other language... Garou still takes my breath away.
LadyaLL96 6 months ago
Steve the best!His voice is just amazing!
philippehungary 6 months ago
French version is much better ...
Pyrageelysh 6 months ago
can you post the lyrics of that version please?
suzzane25 6 months ago
Even if I love english language, I must say that italian version is much better, as well the france one. I don't know why, but the songs of this play seem to be done just for languages of latin origin!
ChiaraNoemi 6 months ago 3
oww Garou im having an orgasm just from hearing ur voice =P
DaRkAnGELMLGJ 7 months ago
The french version is definitely the best.
EddieWoodJr 7 months ago 69
@EddieWoodJr Cause you haven't heard the italian version :3 or seen it on stage
LaraTF1080 4 weeks ago
@LaraTF1080 I see the italian version and it's too overplayed, I hate that. The french version is perfect, the actors are wonderful. :3
EddieWoodJr 3 weeks ago
Is it me of the translation seems eh .. less poetic than the French, which I cannot speak :)
alexetL1979 7 months ago 2
italian version is betterrrrrrrrrr!!!! xD
LadyElisabethx 8 months ago 4
does anybody know you translate the french version into the english? (I asked this on yahoo answers and somebody answered "Victor Hugo") hahahahaha
marijepronker 8 months ago
@marijepronker What do you mean ? Just translate word by word ? Cause if it so, I can do it, if you want...
ManiasWorld 7 months ago
does anybody know how translated the french version into english? (I asked in on yahoo answers and I got the answer "Victor Hugo"...) ahahahahahah
marijepronker 8 months ago
the French version is BETTER
ilovemusicforeverify 8 months ago
Frollo I really like this, although I prefer the Italian version of Vittorio Matteucci, and I'm sorry, but this Quasimodo, just do not tell me crabs!
fioresegreto88 8 months ago
I think the Italian version is much more better, its more powerful and passionate
msdraculla 9 months ago 4
I like the English, French and even the verzion is not bad, but this musical is much higher and sublime in Italian, not only because the Italian language best expresses the idea ofpathos and love, but also for increased transport interpretation of the artists!
feniceriascente 9 months ago
@feniceriascente Of all the version I listened to (French, Italian, Russian, Spanish, Polish, Korean, Dutch) I prefer the French version better for similar reasons than the ones you mentioned. I am sure that the fact that French is my mother tongue plays a part in my preference for the French version just like Italian being your mother tongue plays a part in your preference for the Italian version...
MarbledPaladin 9 months ago
@MarbledPaladin My mother tongue is not either English and French, but I do prefer to the French version. One reason for it is that I think the tone, pronounciations and emotions of French are very suitable in this rythm and this type of music, also the original story was written in French, so I think original tastes best right!! I prefer the French version.
kealeamea 9 months ago 3
which country is that?I'd like to see this musical,but I dont know if the do it in America
iuliana0403 9 months ago
I must say that I can't stand any other Quasimodo except Garou. I always get so angry when I hear ANY other guy singing this role !!
I LOVE this version, let them talk! I think this is one of the best casts. Garou, Bruno, Daniel, Steve and TINA!!
Don't get me wrong, I adore french version. But this is one of the most successfuly remaked versions... My opinion :)
Scarlett264Sk8 10 months ago 3
Phebus looks very scary here... 0_0
PierotteLeFou 10 months ago 2
This is the worst of all version this song.French,Russian and Polish version are much better.
skwara114 11 months ago 17
@skwara114 i wouldnt say its the worst, ive heard all the versions, i dont think it's that bad, although i like russian version the most
Lopz1992 3 months ago
@skwara114 French then ITALIAN
yakuzamadddogg 1 month ago
I don't understand why people think that french version is better .-.
According to me, french version is one of the worst version...
I think italian and english version are the most beautiful of all...the korean version too is more beautiful then french version <.<
Excuse me, but I think so..french version have only one thing good: Gringoire, that is not french, but Canadian.
The French are not very passional, according to me...free to think what you want
P.s. excuse my english, I'm italian
HilaryPhantom 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@HilaryPhantom i am sorry to say but the people you hear singing in this video are Garou, Daniel and Steve which are the ones who sing in the French verison. If you look closly you can tell that it is not them singing it.
P.S. your English is not that bad. I would have never guessed you did not speak it well
hottyhothotty3 1 year ago
@HilaryPhantom
I partially agrre with you about the french version. I've seen all the version and I think that the italian is by far the best for two reasons:
1) the language, even if I understand I can be suspected to force the judgement on the base of my origin
2) the acting. No other version is duly placed into a theater; they only have been sung
DeTomaGiacomo 9 months ago
@elfGosh when did you last see it?? i really want to see it again but i swear its not running anymore :/
ellimac99 1 year ago
errggg.. yucky. :P This is almost an insult to the original en francais..
PierotteLeFou 1 year ago
Quasimodo is a creeper, Frollo sounds okay, and Phoebus looks plain old scary...
sakikatana 1 year ago
English version is the best one for me :) I saw the musical in London and now I can't listen to these beautiful songs in another languages :)
elfGosh 1 year ago
OK Pheobus is ugly...
Purplefizzgirl 1 year ago
@Purplefizzgirl He reminds me too much of Edward Cullen. I can't take him seriously.
KajiShinKun 11 months ago
@Purplefizzgirl no u are
vinhbethmickie 11 months ago
@vinhbethmickie you've never seen me.
I'm entitled to my own opinions. Back off
Purplefizzgirl 11 months ago
@Purplefizzgirl shut up. phoebus is the most beautiful man in this play and u called him ugly? is there any shit in ur peanut brain?
vinhbethmickie 11 months ago
@vinhbethmickie
No, as a matter of fact there is no shit in my brain, haven't you even done biology yet?
OK, maybe out of this he's good looking, but I really don't think his male up does him any good. He looks like he has two black eyes.
Purplefizzgirl 11 months ago
@Purplefizzgirl i saw his picture in reality and it's not as good as this one in makeup. but he's better than the other two.
vinhbethmickie 11 months ago
@vinhbethmickie
Which other two? If you're talking about the french version I think that one's better. He looks more real somehow.
Purplefizzgirl 11 months ago
@Purplefizzgirl i mean this version. the actor played the phoebus role looks hot!
vinhbethmickie 11 months ago 2
Klingons are unanimous, the Klingon version is better. ;)
Rickdeckard2020 1 year ago
Ok... Stop guys, if you like other versions better why the hell are you watching this one??
celgaara 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Aucune version ne peut être meilleur que la Française étant donné que c'est l'original ! ..
TheChakwa 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
TheChakwa 1 year ago
I love the italian versione better...!!!!
smile673 1 year ago 2
I like Russian version better...
avhiza 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
who are the actors??
inchet0o 1 year ago
it sound like garou making the dub and the actor just moving his lips
arokamsila 1 year ago
Who is singing this song? Is it original cast?
Wiedzminka1990 1 year ago
hey anyone knows between the 3 of them, who plays quasimodo? the last guy looks handsome as hell!
vinhbethmickie 1 year ago
все равно нет и не будет ничего лучше, чем оригинальная версия!!эти голоса, эти образы, сама эта атмосфера, которую передают г-да Garou, Daniel и Patric даже через монитор компьютера-это невозможно повторить ни в какой-либо другой стране ни на каком языке, какие бы ни были гениальные актеры...))но все-таки в русской версии г-н Маракулин исполнил свою роль на бесподобно!!)))))
LeksaMc 1 year ago
@LeksaMc ?????????????????????????
vinhbethmickie 1 year ago
I own the French version, but does anyone know where I can purchase the English version of this song? I just think these three sound so incredible together.
TexasProudCowgirl 1 year ago
@aralei13 I think that they are singing in English and so are the actors, because their lips dont match the French words.
Silfarionx3 1 year ago
Comment removed
meotida 1 year ago
english version sucks
mustafammcg 1 year ago
Ужасно звучит на английском.Русский и Французкий лучше
tionad12 1 year ago
@tionad12 Надо сказать, на английском звучит почти так же прекрасно, как и на французском, ЕСЛИ исполняют Гару и Даниэль Лавуа (вроде из французских больше никто не поёт в английской версии). А вообще, как погляжу, все версии мюзикла, помимо русской и французской - это сплошной стыд и срам.
AlexPianistka 1 year ago
what the hell?? That is Garou!! And Daniel!! And Steve!! :O! I love this song, but really? Come on now English people lol sing it with your real voices please!
Sunset567 1 year ago
That's not Garou nor Daniel nor Steve, but it's their voice. We can see the comedian aren't singing in reality
InuYashaetKagome 1 year ago
haha Shit compared with French and Russian versions!
sadadadar 1 year ago
@sadadadar
I think that that the Russian version wasn't as good as French. In fact, I think that every language that has been done to this play sucks compared to the ORIGINAL french play.....Oh, by the way, did the user edit this? 'Cause on the bottom it says "english version edited." I was just wondering. It still sucks either way.
:)
Aralei13 1 year ago 2
O my god I like very much :)
8faby2 1 year ago
the difference between italian and other language is that the italian has words concentred on vowels, then it's easier and more beautiful sing in italian...
thebreaker62 1 year ago
This looks like the Las Vegas USA version. Doug Storm playing Quasimodo
Gringoire2001 1 year ago
Actually Ian Pirie is Qusimodo in the first part, then it changes to the superior Garou!
Gringoire2001 1 year ago
These lyrics kill the beauty of the French ones... -_-
MiSsClOnKy 1 year ago
God, the voices are of Garou, Daniel, Steve, but who're singing????????
MrCucdanho 1 year ago
Great song. I liked every version that I've seen.
AS566 1 year ago
Wait!, the men who are singing, are not matching with the man you see.
You hear, Garou, Daniel and Steve, And you see others...
Charlottjuhhh 1 year ago 57
You're right that's just Lipsing ! They don't sing. That's the voice Of Garou,Daniel and Steve
johnathan1990 1 year ago
@Charlottjuhhh the video is from another language version. (not french :P)
BlackRainMoon 1 year ago
@Charlottjuhhh can it be ???? Really??? What a shame!!!!
nalbant99 11 months ago
@Charlottjuhhh well if u look very very closely, u can see the mouthing, it english but a delay.
SakuraBloome 4 months ago
wow , it rythmes!
minato6115 1 year ago
@minato6115
yeah!!!!!and more so in french!!!
Rosamorrable 1 year ago
I like the French version better...
Charlottjuhhh 1 year ago 129
@Charlottjuhhh me too, prefer French verson
noumercy 1 year ago 2
@Charlottjuhhh I think italian version is better!
ZiaTobia 5 months ago
love it x)
x3Heroiinex3 1 year ago
Everyone lusts after her, it must be witchcraft..jk!
This is such a powerful song! Thank you for posting it!!!
:)
LolitaLexi 1 year ago