Added: 5 years ago
From: videosnyc
Views: 214,113
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (208)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • suena pesimo !!!! .. sin SLASH , DUFF , IZZY Y STEVEN no es ni parecido U.U .... ahora axl es el único que vale en la banda ..... axl es lo mejor pero puede ser mejor con los integrantes antiguos ... GUNS N ROSES lo mejor siempre !!!

  • @matyjeffhardy Steven Adler has never played November Rain...

  • @AbsoluteRPadmin bueuno se me vienen ellos a la mente al hablar de la formacion mas historica pork ni la original es ... bueno matt sorum pero aun asi , PESIMO SONIDO ! .... NO MAMEN , SLASH ES IRREMPLASABLE !

  • @matyjeffhardy yep, GNR needs 3 guitarrists to replace Slash and Izzy.

  • aHHH were is the full version??????????

  • godsmack is a complete moron..........Axl is GnR the new band is great.....get over it punk

  • i would like to see the complete performance of this song!!!

    love it!!!

    i enjoy bumblefoot's part!

    I love u Axl!!!!

  • Who let Finck to play second solo?

    Better give it to Fortus

  • haha axl got slapped that night by tommy wats his name

  • haha. NO he didn't. Tommy ended up getting escorted out of the building. haha. LAME.

  • youre so stupid, axl kick that gay ass

  • you fucking retard tommy grabed axl and pushed his drink and axl stood up and had to be held back from kicking the shit out of him while tommy who removed from the building ya fucking fag

  • even those critics who have not given the album positive reviews have acknowledged that Axl's voice sounds excellent on it. you may be locked up in some adolescent "beat your woman/ do drugs" phase but Axl happens to be 46 now and is a lot more mature. the music reflects that.

    if you think his voice is gone because you saw a poorly record 1 minute clip, then thats your problem. watch the KROQ inland invasion show here on youtube and you'll see how good he sounds.

  • he's not more mature. He sounds bitter as fuck when you read his recent interview with Del James, who himself is just a hanger on.

  • maturity is not some either/or issue. reviewers have noted the maturity of musicianship in the album. a simple comparison between Sorry and Get in the Ring would suffice to help make this point. axl has a right to state his perspective and thats what he did.

  • as far as bitterness is concerned, slash admits to his own bitterness in his book and steven adler is still sitting around blaming axl for the sad decline in his life even though it was his own choice to fall under the sway of drugs. perhaps you prefer their brand of maturity. :)

  • you can laugh but this guy is a great song writer, without him and izzy stradlin writing the hits gnr would be crap...look at velvet revolver lol, slash and duff are good guys and slash is a great guitarist but they cant write songs for shit...their solo stuff is awful and in my opinion axl and izzy were by far the most important members of the band. they wrote all the hits...november rain,patience,you could be mine,dont cry,sweet child of mine, estranged and co wrote paradise city and w.t.t.j

  • wow are you so so so wrong i wont even go off on how incredible wrong you are but as for Izzy and his creativity what has he done in the past decade? nothing what has Slash and Duff and Matt done? Put out successful albums such as the two realized from Slash's snake pit, Contraband. The solo stuff from Duff. Izzy has done like absolutely nothing

  • PS. Slash was nothing before GNR. The other members were already established musicians in the hollywood club scene while slash played his BS in matt's garage.

    As for Velvet revolver's shitty albums.... they sold ok, but Chinese Democracy already outsold them in it's first few months.

  • hhahaha wow you really know nothing about GNR you are talking to the biggest gnr fan. CD has only sold so much because it's under the Guns N' Roses title everyone knows that album is absolute shit. So terrible that the radio stations wont even play those garbage NIN wanna be songs. Go suck your dads dick some more and maybe his cum will supply you with real music knowledge FUCKING COCK MOUTH

  • Chinese Democracy and Better get more airtime than Velvet Revolver does, and although not as much as old GNR songs do, they are still getting airtime. See you just proved how stupid you are, can't even hold your own argument without pullin shit out of your ass. Get your facts straight before you reply, INBREED xD

  • jessdaman08, love your comments to that asshole. I'll help too.

  • Dude you proved my point again why would Velvet Revolver get as many plays as Guns N' Roses it's GNR fool they used to be the biggest band in the world know it's full of wanna bee slash idols. VR has had to work to get their shit on the Radio and even Contraband had 3 or 4 songs on the Radio. GNR's CD didn't have to. IT was the most anticipated album for more than a decade and it blew they supporters of that album are NIN nails fans and people who would listen and like anything that GNR put out

  • I'm a fan of whatever Axl puts out, and the band are far from slash wannabes, they're more skilled and probably wish they don't have to lower their playing skill while covering slash's solos.

    I have nothing against slash, he did great in GNR, but these new guitarists are much more technically skilled, and he's admitted it.

    I may be a person who would listen and like anything GNR put out, but only because Axl's still in the band. You're just a slash fan biased like the rest.

  • dude not at all i bought CD hoping it would rock knowing slash and the rest of the original members were gone i prayed that i would be good but it sucked GNR just got sued for using a part of someone else's song in theirs. They don't even have the balls to come play in the US they have to go to Asia and Canada

  • Saying it sucks is only your opinion, and they're being sued by a band barely known by anyone, they'll lose badly, Geffen's lawyers will make sure of it.

    But siously though, it's all opinion, and there's millions of people that disagree with you, and millins that disagree with me. There's no real winning in this sort of argument, seeing as people's taste in music varies.

  • I do take back any insults I may have said to anyone on here... I just don't see the point in searching a band you dont like

  • It's about the passion not skill! ;)

  • if thats the case i should be a guitar god :P I looooove guitarin more than anything, but i couldnt touch slash, buckethead or bumblefoot in terms of skill. lol Musical quality, to a high extent, is to do with skill, and then passion etc

  • And everyone knows it's shit? The new GNR songs on youtube have hundreds of supporters commenting, and then ever now n then ya get one or two pricks like you sharing bullshit with people who'd rather just listen to the music

  • Are you sure you don't mean that you are the biggest jelly sucking mental midget? Because from here it looks like your IQ would double when you swallow a fly. You obviously know nothing about either the old or new GNR. Good luck with those tiny nuts sinkin' in!

  • I meant steven's garage lol. Got confused between the drummers.

  • Don't spread lies, Slash was in Black Sheep whom was in the process of getting a record deal at the time, BEFORE he joined GNR. Just because your semi well known in the club scene back in the day didn't mean shit. Unless you had a record deal you were nothing, and GNR didn't get that until all 5 members put their heads together. GNR would have never gotten anywhere without Slash. Chinese Democracy got 90000 times more publicity then VR because Axl was making the fucking record for 15 years.

  • Wait wait hold on.... lol

    Black sheep went nowhere, their frontman couldnt hold a note to save his life, and the only reason slash was really even considered for his place in GNr was because Black sheep had the same agent as hollywood rose. Without this agent, Axl n Slash would have never bn introduced, GNR has had success without slash, more than Velvet revolver even. I'm not spreading lies, lol just stating fact, thanks for the reply

  • Slash was in Black Sheep and they were getting a record deal, whether you liked the singer or not means nothing. GNR has NOT had success without Slash. Chinese Democracy was a considered a failure because it's sales were MUCH lower then what they figured it would sell. Not to mention VR had 6 months of publicity VS CD 15 years in the making but ok.

  • It sad to see people thinking that certain members not being there is resulting in Gn'R not being good anymore. Never mind the fact that this was a live recording on a shitty digital camera.

  • it's sad to see the affects of those members not being in the band resulting in such a shitty new metal album being put out

  • who says that the new album was ever meant to be a "metal" album anyway? GNR werent "metal" even on AFD.

    Chi Dem is excellent. if you want metal, listen to Sabbath or something. Chi Dem is a layered, complex album of varying styles. its an ambitous and deep record. just give it a chance.

  • i have there are only a few songs on it even in the new style that are worth hearing, out of all the old bands that put out new albums ( ACDC, METALLICA and GNR) GNR had the worst album it's just not good and i hate sabbath ozzy is a shitty front man. Axl's voice isn't even his voice anymore in my opinion he needs to go back to drinking and doing drugs because that's when he sounded the best

  • Your mom needs to go back to doing drugs and drinking so that she'll end up accidently gettin pregnant and perhaps having another child who may have good taste in music.

    Don't say "Axl sounded better when he was doped out" etc, he's dropped the reckless attitude, which is what most of you bitches whined about.

    Axl rocks, fuk off.

  • you're a fucking idiot everyone knows axl was better when he was coked out and he is still a reckless ass hole. I know far more about Guns N' Roses than you ever will you fucking faggot. He still walks of stage like the same ass hole he used to be his voice and his writing was far better drugged out with the original members. YOu should have been Aborted

  • Fuckin LOL. I bet your mom wishes the same. Wonders why she had such a dipshit of a child. Someone who'd selfishly wish a drug addiction on someone they've never met. You're a fuckin loser, the scum of the earth.

    Fuck off.

  • Came make me you fucking cunt

  • HA! i went out and bought CD right on the realease date. Axl is washed up he's crap he doesn't even have a voice anymore have you HEARD better he sounds like he had his nuts cut off he doesn't even scream anymore because he can't he needs to go back to drugs and alcohol and beating up his girls that's when he sounded good

  • technically then, screaming makes a front man? not his ability to write, reflect and alter the lives of those around him?

    And to you sully erna is that man? *scoffs* " .. I'm doing the best I ever did ." its not good enough " .. now go away .." better.

  • It is sad to see that guns n roses without slah duff and izzy turned out this bad

  • NOvember rain is here(L)

  • Do u have the full version? would love to see it

  • i'd hate to think that this is what gnr turned into...

  • You are so fuckin right and it is without slash and duff they fuckin suck major balls. they can't even book a good place to play

  • That is just a scum-bag solo. But it is actually a decent one if you compare it to his other bullshit-solos.

    Keep your hands off November Rain... Clown.

  • That Solo was created from just one man!..SLASH! PERIOD!!Finck could be the mpst technique Guitar Player of the World but doesnt have the Bluesy Feeling of SLASH! SLASH is a BIG part of GUNS N ROSES HISTORY! thats a FACT!and U cant measure a Guitar Player just only on his technique!Theres also others elements to judge if theres a GREAT GUITAR PLAYER there! U wanna examples; Steve Vai, Eddie Van Halen, Joe Satriani, SRV, Joe Perry, Randy Rhoads, Jimmi Hendrix, Clapton, Page,Hammett and MR SLASH

  • I can play a piece by Mozart but im not Mozart! History will remember people that created not people that played

  • Wukurac you are TOTALLY RIGHT!!

  • That was one of the smartest comment I found on Youtube, a thumbsup is not enough to show my appreciation.

  • @wukurac axl created this song idiot.

  • @FelipeGNFR I know that ,read the comments right you fuckin monkey.

  • i think i like fincks solo better

  • your comment was +2, I marked you down, just sayin

  • Is this the same night that he beat some one up??? lol I can't believe I didn't go that night!

  • who played the first solo?

  • Finck

  • if slash hadnt written the solo every1 elses solo wud sound utterly ridiculous

  • i love this song but this version is too short

  • Yes Finck rules--

  • he plays in his way...different, and I like it

  • i have to say, the start of the solo sounds very good... slash make a excelent solo, but this was a good cover...

    bye

  • The o only think what we get is a retarded comment by gonzo

  • that guitar solo is funny he is trying so hard not to play what slash does but cant help wanting to do it. so u get a retarded version of the slash solo.

  • hahah. That was fucking horrific

  • OMG, my ears

    oh, please please slash come back!!!

  • Rosario Dawson you are a lucky bitch, you got november rain live by axl for your birthday, shit are u sure you deserve it?

  • mandou bem alana

  • yah it's gnr..looks like a fake but it isnt ;)

  • The solo sucks!!! Slash come back!

  • slash slash regresa

  • ummm yes it is sir....

  • no its fuckin fake guns. these guys suck. theres no such thing as guns without slash, izzy, duff and matt or steven.

  • this is not guns...

  • axl has lost his classic quality!! i saw a video of gnr performin patience(axl begins wid how many of u thought v wouldnt be here today?) it was not at all like da classic ... the original gnr band was the best!!!

  • Slash, pleas come back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • slash has said the original GNR would never ever get back. He's moved on....

    and well axl being the main reason guns broke up it would be in axls hands to even begin to try to restore the original guns.. and i dont thinkg THAT will happen either

  • hes tried...there are movin towards it however slash said that he will never step on stage with him again

  • As long as they release the illusion tour footage. Aparently they had two cameras follow them for that whole tour!

    so the tapes are sitting in some vault somewhere until they can iron out thier legal issues

  • was slash fired , no he left guns n roses AND the guns n roses fans , thats one thing cleared up

    2ndly on brazilian MTV slash said it would be cool do to a few shows with the origanal GNR asnd the origanal stone tempell gay piolets together so slash has said in a way he would do it so dont post shit some children will read your words and think your correct when infact your not , good day

  • slash never abandoned the fans. He hung in for as long as possible until it was not worth it anymore. And He Made two amazing albums with the snakepit and is still doing what he loves and is playing. Whether people like it or not is another issue.

    If anything axl's ego and management is what took guns away from the fans.

  • the riff of the guitar player sound so bad, never like a Slash, never.

  • yes i agree

    NO ONE can replace slash

  • Axl is the best! I don't know some idiots can say that he's not good anymore. Come on, he sings it perfectly! The other guys from the new band are not that good but, we have the redhair Axl to make the things work! I just don't know who is Rosario Dawson...

  • AC/DC or GunsNRoses? please reply its a survey

    untill now gns wins by 48 to 39

  • GUNS

  • Excellent! Another Live One from the Axl!

  • is not noob,,, he can make the solo in the same way that the originañ,, but he has his own style

  • axl sings this song very good compared to the other november rains from 2002-2006/07

  • you try to find a live november rain when slash played it EXACTLY as it should THEN complain that Robin Fink aint doing it right.

    TITS

  • that gorilla who is playing guitar sounds like me playing guitar 6 years ago :d

  • wukurac AXl made this song

  • slash can't be replaced, too bad for axl who still can't make fans scream exept by old guns n roses stuff, pathetic.

  • you are pathetic. I was there. and this was by far the coolest acoustic show I've ever seen. they played new stuff at this show, and the crowd went mad during those songs too. so stop being a hater and return to YOUR pathetic life.

  • ....if you were there (or if you had even watched the video, for that matter) you'd have noticed that this definitely wasn't an acoustic show

  • just understand the guy. in reality it is easy to compose a solo but the memorization is hard. it is also hard to try to play the solo if the composer did it well. what the heck... that guy sucks axl's balls! even a kid goofing around with an electric guitar jacked up, can do what he did in this shit.

  • that guitarist sux balls,noob fuck

  • The November rain solo writen by Slash is a masterpiece so get this guitarist to learn it..

  • replacing slash by this stupid amateur is like replacing axl by avril lavigne

  • or scot weiland

  • fuck you

  • wow that guitarest sux balls and no one will ever be as good as slash

  • the best song the worst by new guns n roses they suck epsecially that stupid cave man called buket head.

  • buckethead is not there! hello?!

  • yes he is derrr at the start 8 seconds...

  • that's not buckethead. i think it's robin finck.

  • it's so great

  • To: BeatrizRose - GET A FUCKING LIFE HOLY CRAP!

  • oh my god William you still are a handsome man and you look so cute playing my song baby I miss you so much and I´m sure that you miss me too!!! honey we can still have a second chance William please come to see me if you read this we both know that´s the reason why you love to sing this song sweetie

  • guns n roses without Slash are crap...

    this guitarist cant replace him

  • he did alright

  • fuck them!!! you cant call them guns n roses!!!! they are just a bunch of assholes!!! I'm sorry axl but you have fucked it up!

  • damme right!

  • How did you get a hold of this video? Is there more? I looooooooooooove it and would give anything to have been there, so close to Axl!

  • he made it himself

  • I wish I could hire GNR for my Birthday :)

  • Holy shittt... AXL just get fucked up with all those shittt . . . . . wtf are they showing the Novrain lyrics for. . .

  • did they not have the video screens SO THE FOREIGNERS COULD SING ALONG? Jesus christ!

  • damaskdit ylis monebo

  • motherfuckers, axl has performed the songs lots of hundredstimes, so how can he forget the fucking lyrics, he doesnt have any fucking problem to forget the fuckin lyrics, buy yourselves a mind and suck my dick

  • you can hire guns n roses for birthdays?

  • wonder if you could sell me this video thankssss

  • Those ppl are so lucky party w Axlman!

  • but he hasn't used it.

  • I am sorry to take you out of your dreams but in the UYI tour Axl used a teleprompter. It can be seen on the many bootlegs around on the Internet.

    A teleprompter is a sort of karaoke machine that displays the lyrics of the text.

  • yes axl in tokyo read the lyrics......

    about this video, i think axl now is a poor looser, he don't have voice now, and really this shit is not gnr...

  • wtf is this???

  • 1st of all, i got those jokes, 2nd i think that 99.9% of gnr was axl and that .1% was the microphone

  • whats a teleprompter

  • I'm sorry, but I was at the taping of the original November Rain video and this was just too painful to watch...! I love Axl, but Axl without Slash and the boys just doesn't have that same magic. :(

  • And some trashed-park-bum can make his motor hum.

    Get the joke? If u do, ur a GnR fan/knower.

  • yeah the lyrics were for kareoke, and Axl never used a teleprompter, eholtz is a dipshit

  • wow ur an idiot have u ever seen gnr in tokoyo? axl has used a teleprompter since the use ur illusions tour

  • original line up is the original, no fighting that... but talent wise the new musicians can tear it up, they are good... and Axl's voice sounds amazing. Axl is 80% of GnR anyway. I was at the unplugged show at the Plumm... incredible!

  • Pretty good. But not like the original. The original lineup was a lot better, and back then Axl didn't need to look at the lyrics to hi own songs.

  • Axl's used a teleprompter since '91

  • missing the point.. the show was set up like Karaoke... so the people at the club could sing along... I think when the event was getting set up something along the lines of "girls sing GnR songs at clubs, but don't know who GnR is" this was just kinda being funny... it was not a show environment, it was for Rosario's B'day. Just people drinking and having fun with a little GnR

  • Well, I guess I never knew that. Oh well.

  • errr the lyrics were there so the audience could sing along

  • axl always had a little screen to view the lyrics: you don't belive me, go see the DVD´s of the use your ilusions I & II live

  • yeah, he did, they had video screens onstage, look at the tokyo dvd

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=K2L7xdZdk8o

    See this clip, it's cool

  • Axl has lost his voice! He can´t sing more than 3 songs

  • Screw Axl Rose!! He thinks he's the sh!t by talking crap about his ex-band members from the original GNR.

  • They also talk crap about him...What´s the difference?

  • axl drinking with a chick

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=xGzmlMG00gI

  • do u think world will end like this?? >_<

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=3DWuGgq3z68

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=_84M6jJGvNQ

    Hey also check this clip

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=ck92BSqmGFM

    Visit that link to see the best vid

  • Its gd but the original line ups alot better.

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=sa2Zec0u2yU

  • cool ...  www.antiplictiseala.com/masini­.htm

  • una mierda!

  • THEY R ALL IN R bAND call VELVET REVOLVER!!