was there ever a model that did not have a chime? before I moved away from dc I boarded a car that did not have a chime, or a blinky light. if I recall it did not have a grill for a speaker ether. but i am not 100% sure.
@AMD1 Prior to 1996, no WMATA rail cars had door-open chimes. The first "doors opening" message was introduced in 1996 with the Sandy Carroll version of the chimes. Also, the 5000-Series (intro 2001) was the first car class to have flashing lights over the doors. The 1000 through 4000-Series cars as built did not have those lights. Likewise, the 1000 through 4000-Series cars did not originally have external speakers. All but the 4000-Series have since been retrofitted, however.
@LlanFair22 Actually, this was the first chime, rolled out on a test basis on certain 5000-Series cars. However, when the final, less-pushy chime was rolled out across the entire fleet, the cars with the original chime were not updated. From what I can tell, the original chimes are on 5080-5081, 5100-5101, and 5178-5179.
I just miss the original chime which sounds similar to the NYC subway system. But then again, I guess tourists in DC need it fed to them when the doors are actually closing. Its sooooo annoying.
@ineedabuspass Actually, I think that this new door chime was aimed at the regulars, not the tourists. The regulars are the ones who will crowd the doors and treat the chime like a yellow light. I've noticed that tourists generally just try to find a seat and otherwise have room to breathe.
@jammes122 Indeed, I wish more metro systems had forceful announcements like this. In Boston, most trains don't even have automated announcements and the gentle reminders by conductors (when they remember to do so) are barely audible. Often I've found myself stuck at the door, and often I've found myself the asshole yelling at people to move into the car (with plenty of space...).
Very few cars have the specific version of the recording. Only a few 5000's have the version shown here. Most cars were given a toned-down version, which is less forceful than this one.
As for the old Sandy Carroll chimes, I've not heard the Rohr/Breda version since April 2006, but I have heard the CAF/Rehab version here and there, but it's rare. I think that stems from the fact that the Breda rehabs and Alstoms were delivered with the old chime, and were changed to the new one in DC.
Do you (or does anyone) have a recording of the old Sandy Carroll announcements? I'd like to hear what they sounded like, since many people seem to prefer them to the newer ones...
Also the chimes sound professional compared to BART. I mention BART because the cars they use are the same but the WMATA seems so much more sophisticated. People in the Bay Area think everything they do and the land of eternal sunshine everything should be modeled after. WMATA is a good system.
I like the DC metro door chime-- very important to hear this message. The BART system is so amateur that you can hardly hear any message. The train operators are all tense and take out their aggression on the passengers; I would rather hear an automated recording so I don't have to hear BART employees anger.
I was actually on 5101 on Saturday, running as yellow line. Either there was a malfunction, but this car still had the original Randi Miller recording.
My guess is that the CAF cars that have the original version as shown here will keep that version until either (A) Metro decides to change the chimes again, or (B) the CAFs enter rehab around 2021 or so, whichever comes first.
A number of years ago, WMATA changed their terminology on that one, so their riders are now officially "customers" rather than "passengers", and this is consistent with that.
Considering that you're talking to other "customers" with these announcements, saying "customers" is somewhat inappropriate. Perhaps saying "other riders" would have been more appropriate.
I'd say they did a really bad job in the editing, if nothing else. The final version that they ended up deploying to the rest of the cars sounded a lot more natural.
the guy with the phone looks so sketchy
ILLINOISLOYALTY1 1 year ago
was there ever a model that did not have a chime? before I moved away from dc I boarded a car that did not have a chime, or a blinky light. if I recall it did not have a grill for a speaker ether. but i am not 100% sure.
AMD1 1 year ago
@AMD1 Prior to 1996, no WMATA rail cars had door-open chimes. The first "doors opening" message was introduced in 1996 with the Sandy Carroll version of the chimes. Also, the 5000-Series (intro 2001) was the first car class to have flashing lights over the doors. The 1000 through 4000-Series cars as built did not have those lights. Likewise, the 1000 through 4000-Series cars did not originally have external speakers. All but the 4000-Series have since been retrofitted, however.
schuminweb 1 year ago
Is that Washington Subway ?
eaglehockey16 1 year ago
@eaglehockey16 Correct. WMATA = Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority. Thus WMATA = DC Metro.
schuminweb 1 year ago
this is the second version of this chime this is only played during rush hour for pushy commuters
LlanFair22 1 year ago
@LlanFair22 Actually, this was the first chime, rolled out on a test basis on certain 5000-Series cars. However, when the final, less-pushy chime was rolled out across the entire fleet, the cars with the original chime were not updated. From what I can tell, the original chimes are on 5080-5081, 5100-5101, and 5178-5179.
schuminweb 1 year ago
I just miss the original chime which sounds similar to the NYC subway system. But then again, I guess tourists in DC need it fed to them when the doors are actually closing. Its sooooo annoying.
ineedabuspass 1 year ago
@ineedabuspass Actually, I think that this new door chime was aimed at the regulars, not the tourists. The regulars are the ones who will crowd the doors and treat the chime like a yellow light. I've noticed that tourists generally just try to find a seat and otherwise have room to breathe.
schuminweb 1 year ago
That lady means business!!
vwestlife 1 year ago
@vwestlife Apparently the don't care about periods either. Those sentences definitely were back to back. I couldn't even understand the first time.
donsherio 1 year ago
This isn't NYC
ThePhantom2K9 1 year ago
What's up with the red light blinking when she say " Step back , doors closing " ? Is it to tell that the doors are closing ?
TheVeggietalesfan1 2 years ago
Correct. That's a warning light for the hearing impaired.
schuminweb 2 years ago
I think I like the current announcement better. This one sounds very pushy, as if the woman really wishes she could say "Move, NOW!", but she can't.
But I like the old, higher pitched door chimes better than the current ones.
jammes122 2 years ago
@jammes122 Indeed, I wish more metro systems had forceful announcements like this. In Boston, most trains don't even have automated announcements and the gentle reminders by conductors (when they remember to do so) are barely audible. Often I've found myself stuck at the door, and often I've found myself the asshole yelling at people to move into the car (with plenty of space...).
Roboboy 1 year ago
the montreal metro lady sound way better and atlest she doest talk too much like when the doors open and close just a simple prochain station
MrZackattack2010 2 years ago
Comment removed
MrZackattack2010 2 years ago
I never understood why they picked her anyway, .......I have heard better versions than that.
BurgerChefGuy 2 years ago
Well, of the field of finalists, she seemed to be the best. The other women's voices started to grate, and one of the men sounded WAY too fatherly.
schuminweb 2 years ago
5101 still has these chimes, they havent been changed
sme19 2 years ago
that guy leaning against the cutting disk is such a hottie!
gaaantz 2 years ago
Comment removed
Thoughtfulguy68 2 years ago
In my city our LRT/subway makes a sound too. it goes "Ding-Dong Ding-Dong" Next stop _____ Station" with a males voice.
SPS148669 2 years ago
Where are you from?
BlGGlE 2 years ago
Edmonton Canada We have just a small 1 line system but under contruction to serve more of the city.
SPS148669 2 years ago
Oh cool.
punjabikillahz 2 years ago
Ben, Does every car in metrorail have this recording now, or do some still have the sandy caroll recordings?
TDFG4602 3 years ago
Very few cars have the specific version of the recording. Only a few 5000's have the version shown here. Most cars were given a toned-down version, which is less forceful than this one.
As for the old Sandy Carroll chimes, I've not heard the Rohr/Breda version since April 2006, but I have heard the CAF/Rehab version here and there, but it's rare. I think that stems from the fact that the Breda rehabs and Alstoms were delivered with the old chime, and were changed to the new one in DC.
schuminweb 3 years ago
Do you (or does anyone) have a recording of the old Sandy Carroll announcements? I'd like to hear what they sounded like, since many people seem to prefer them to the newer ones...
nightferret 2 years ago
I do! I'll have to search around for them, though.
schuminweb 2 years ago
That would be awesome. Thanks!
nightferret 2 years ago
Comment removed
nightferret 2 years ago
Any luck finding the old Sandy Carroll chimes?
nightferret 2 years ago
That voice is annoying.
Step back DOORSSSSSS CLOSSSSING!
RedShadow1917 3 years ago
Also the chimes sound professional compared to BART. I mention BART because the cars they use are the same but the WMATA seems so much more sophisticated. People in the Bay Area think everything they do and the land of eternal sunshine everything should be modeled after. WMATA is a good system.
jaimedemexico 3 years ago
I like the DC metro door chime-- very important to hear this message. The BART system is so amateur that you can hardly hear any message. The train operators are all tense and take out their aggression on the passengers; I would rather hear an automated recording so I don't have to hear BART employees anger.
jaimedemexico 3 years ago
I was actually on 5101 on Saturday, running as yellow line. Either there was a malfunction, but this car still had the original Randi Miller recording.
ma3145tt 3 years ago
My guess is that the CAF cars that have the original version as shown here will keep that version until either (A) Metro decides to change the chimes again, or (B) the CAFs enter rehab around 2021 or so, whichever comes first.
schuminweb 3 years ago
The voice sounds kinda... Bitchy. It sounds like the voice was trying to annoy customers.
"Step back, doors CLOOSSING!"
Kingofdetroit2004 3 years ago
lol the starting should not be customers... it should be passenger
EugeneXL 3 years ago
A number of years ago, WMATA changed their terminology on that one, so their riders are now officially "customers" rather than "passengers", and this is consistent with that.
schuminweb 3 years ago
I have to agree - I find the "customer" label werid too.
I do like the "loud" and "clear" commands though.
NeoFalcon69 3 years ago
Considering that you're talking to other "customers" with these announcements, saying "customers" is somewhat inappropriate. Perhaps saying "other riders" would have been more appropriate.
schuminweb 3 years ago
that guy purposely stood right in front
SchoolBus646 3 years ago
Well, yeah. The windscreens are popular places for people to lean.
schuminweb 3 years ago
sounds like a cell phone ringtone
DrSurprise 3 years ago
That door design was also used on the other D.C. MetroRail cars, the BART cars, the SEPTA ADTranz M-4 cars, and the AmTrak California Bi-Level cars.
Sulaco516 4 years ago
Was Randi drinking before recording these announcements?!
CoastersNSich 4 years ago
I'd say they did a really bad job in the editing, if nothing else. The final version that they ended up deploying to the rest of the cars sounded a lot more natural.
schuminweb 3 years ago
this sounds 2 computerized
sme19 4 years ago
i like version so much more!!!!!!!!!!!!!
brianrgeller 4 years ago