Added: 4 years ago
From: SilenceLive
Views: 109,584
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (217)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the best cover is from Novembre

    

  • 1:27 - Why is her voice the same volume away from the mic as it was during the rest of the song?

  • "depeche mode rulesss!!"lmfao

  • Hm. i love oyu Shiny toy guns but rammstein  does it better :p

  • Hey can you, the audience, give us permission to play a song that is much better and far more legendary than anything we will ever write? Yes? Ok, cool.

  • Whoever thought rammstein wrote this song originally is a complete moron.

    Like S.T.G, They Covered it.

    Hell, even before they played it they annouced that they were covering Depeche

    Mode.

  • @Cinedhiothu ya and plus Rammstein is german

  • Damn this song is good, gives my the chills. Wish the sound was better.

  • Carah commands so much stage presence. Love this cover. Love her and her tattoos, too (especially the 'walk together/rock together' 7 Seconds ink).

  • actually is a cover of a Depeche Mode´s song....wtf Ramstein?...jajaja

  • Carah's great in the albums but awful live, and Treasure (or whatever the f*** she's called is just awful...

    IMO

  • @unknown3333333333333

    "Carah's great in the albums but awful live, and Treasure (or whatever the f*** she's called is just awful..."

    You're right, it is just your opinion, A pretty poor opinion.

    You do realize that the sound quality live and in person is totally different then a live video uploaded to sites like youtube, right?

  • @Cinedhiothu This is when they were first starting out carah and chad had gotten A LOT better since then.

  • @FrozenGenesis Wait what am I saying they sing good back then too.

  • 0:10 "depeche mode rules"

  • This is WRONG!!!!!!!

  • yeah depeche Mode Wrote that shit long before they were born

  • lmao you're an idiot of you think rammstein wrote that song :D

  • i love carah SO MUCH and without her shiny toy guns is crap. end of story

  • that was great when she looked right in the camera singing w/o the mic.

  • I think Rammstein does a better job of covering this IMO

  • @IrWinRawr1 Rammstein's vocalist sounds like he tries too hard. Plus, it pretty much depends on your genre preference. There really isn't much comparing the 2.

  • @a7xfreIk Yes, you are right. I'm not going to be ignorant and argue with you like most youtubers ^^

  • @IrWinRawr1 WHAT!? Why not! Damn it, I need your arguements to feed me! Your face smells! *waits for reply*

  • @a7xfreIk Umm. Your umm... feet are.. badly shaped? xD

  • @IrWinRawr1 You win this round >,>

  • @IrWinRawr1 I love Rammstein to death, but nope. Can't compare.

    Till's voice isn't ment for Depeche Mode.

  • one of my favorite songs avd carah looks hot

  • who the hell cares, Carah is fuckin' hot

  • Good song!! However there will never be a band that will do it as good as Depeche Mode!! Nobody can't ever duplicate Dave and Martins singing, especially Dave's tone. Its so deep, mysteriou, spiritual and sensual.

  • I would just stop singing if i were her and walk off the stage cuz he is a fuckin hog!

  • I want her in my bed mhmmm.

  • the guy has such a good voice man :]

  • dude! it TOTALLY sounds like her mic is turned wayy down, CARAH WAS SO MUCH BETTER THAN SISLY!!!!

  • Her tattoos make her arm look shiny. :D

  • @EricaLuvsParamore prob got sun block on them and stuff u put over them to keep them from fading and getting all nasty when ur out in the sun all day

  • i love it at 1:27

  • wished we could hear her voice more , but i love this version

  • Her arm is shiny.

  • @BlockisticStudios lol... fresh tattoos.

  • Good remake in studio version, but her voice is too weak in live performance:( Im a bit dissapointed

  • Looks almost like she has realization that his microphone is louder than hers...

    I don't think it's because of weak voice. He's just a greedy spotlight whore.

  • @MajkenEva hillarious he is a greedy spotlight whore!lol!

  • this is an awesome cover to a band i have seen live and love till this day,,,,,L L D M

  • her voice is sexy....

  • And that comment was directed at Tim733733.

  • Comment removed

  • I LOOOOOOOOVE HER SOOOO MUCH <3

  • depeche mode is the writer of this song and I love Dm! Dm is much better and this group

  • sorry dude, but im pretty sure Depeche Mode wrote that song, and not rammstein

  • Yep, this is a song written by British band Depeche Mode, NOT those German groaners Rammstien. This SNG version is probably the only really good cover.

  • Actually, Depeche Mode said their personal favorite cover anyone has done was Rammstein's. They're a lot more than "groaners", they're the most successful German language band of all time, and their lead singer is not a "groaner", he tends to be a touch operatic at times and his spoken word lyrics are spine tingling. As well as that, Gore is an acquaintance of the band.

    You can have your opinion, but don't go around calling R+ groaners when you've never heard songs like Nebel, Sonne, etc.

  • @tonycorleon123

    1001% right ;-)

  • omfg they are just so different, even.

    It's pretty obvious it was Depeche Mode xD

  • @tonycorleon123 yeah, Depeche wrote it, but I personally like Rammstein's Live version from Volkerball alot better. more aggressive, I guess that fits a kid raised on the Ramones and Nine Inch Nails.

  • they are such a gooood

  • Rammstein did a cover of this song by Depeche Mode from their album that was from '86

  • This cover is amazing,woah im impressed <3 it !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Agreed its not often i prefer a cover to the mighty Depeche Mode original

  • It almost seems as if purposely her mic was turned down, and HIS was turned up. Doesn't it? They sabotaged Carah in this! =(

  • @joshnshan7744 i highly doubt that is the case... if you look from where the person is filming the vid from, they're more stage left, meaning that w/e speaker is on that side would sound louder. so if his speaker was on that side, he's gonna seem to be louder. which im assuming is the case bc there's a bit of delay in her vocals, meaning w/e sound it's picking up on camera had to travel farther. same thing happend @ a show i was at last year, dep. on where you stood. 1 vocalist sounded louder

  • @joshnshan7744 eh, chads a better singer anyways

  • @joshnshan7744 i was there it seemed well eq'd the video just does weird comparison shit

  • @joshnshan7744

    did you notice there was no change in volume of her voice between when was singing with and without the mic?

  • @joshnshan7744 They were assholes to her. I hope she's doing well with her new endeavors.

  • @PompousFlea You know Carah's back in STG, right?

  • @Zeronautic NO WAY! Seriously?! 

  • @PompousFlea Yeah, seriously! Check out their website, and their new song "The Sun."

  • @joshnshan7744 The irony/falsehood in your statement is A. The performers don't have control of the levels of volume, the sound guys do. B. Carah was dating their sound guy at the time, and is now married to him.

  • @joshnshan7744 I just think, generally, he was quite dickish in regards to Carah.

  • i never say "oh that singers hot" blah blah cus that's just stupid..... but, carahs fuckin hot dude lol shitttt

  • her mic needed to be turned up a little bit more. other than that, it was great

  • If Missing Persons gave birth you have Shiny Toy Guns. I think theyre great...!

  • Love Shiny Toy Guns.. anyone else noticed how Chad lost a bit of zeal in live shows after Carah left? He had much better chemistry live with Carah. Love this song

  • Shes wonderful & georgous

  • I love Depeche Mode and this is an amazing cover. Love that girls voice.

    bren

  • I think the guitarist was trying to cover a note he missed in the begininning. I wish I could hear the girl better.

  • I fucking hate the guitar player because he always want to sing, I think that was the reason why Carah was kicked out form the band, because that ball-less stupid! attention whore

  • hey. I love Carah and am furious they kicked her out although I love Versant now (her new band) way more than new shiny. But Chad is still a good singer so don't be bashing on him

  • I am seriously in love with Carah Faye right now

  • you can barely here her voice over the music

  • OMG! I LOVE YOU, CARAH!!!

  • Depeche Mode Rulez!!!

  • depeche mode!! i guess they did it better, but martin still wrote it

  • she looks like my step mom with all her tattoos and hair. this is a great song btw

  • dude you should bone your step mom

  • im a girl!

  • Thats even better.

  • Your sick!

  • Haha yeah. Most probably.

  • I'm a girl too and still do it!

  • Lmfao

  • She's so pretyy and I love her tattoos

  • atta be. me to bro

  • i love her broad shoulders :)

  • 1:29 was great :D

  • & i meant "process". lol. just thought i'd throw that out there. :)

  • She left? :(

  • They kicked her out so that Sisely could join.

  • unfortunately. she DID start a new band, though! :D it's called Versant. they're in the progress of making a new album. you should be able to listen to them on MySpace. they have two demos up right now... PLUS a "Versant Valentine" video on YouTube that has a bit more of their new music. really good. :)

    (sorry if it seems like i'm advertising, everyone! but yeah. for those of you who like Carah... she's not gone! check Versant out. they're really good. :D)

  • they kicked her out

  • carah is so much better!

  • Love this song.

  • god chad is so cute!

  • Comment removed

  • why did she leave the group?

  • carah rules she left because the band was going ina direction she didnt wanna go in

  • you can say bitch you know

  • Carah come back!!!!!!!

    we miss you :'(

  • yeah you do know they might not ever play their old songs live anymore cause they had carah in them and i don't think sisley can top the voice!

  • Just saw them live with sisley. She did alright in general but couldn't top carah in 'le disko'. she doesn't have that badass screaming voice lol

  • I could stare at Carah all day...

  • love this song :D

  • fucking!!!!Shiny Toy Guns

  • rammstein=D nice

  • Sounded so much better than the album version. Way more intense.

  • Was this on an album of theirs? Its only an EP as far as i know on vinyl and iTunes.

  • It's on We Are Pilots v2.

  • OMG i fell in love with this song the first time i heard it years ago and i still love it !!!!!!!

  • she needs to speak up. cant hear her at all.

  • daym, dat gurls hott... i love this song even more now that i saw who was singin it ;)

  • chad looks so much better with short hair, dont you think?

    ohhh god, so fucking great!! love these guys

  • CooL!

  • Not bad, not bad, I liked it! And yeah dude, Depeche Mode rules!!!

  • Im so glad i didnt see them live when they came here cuz i think they were with the new singer =(

  • i love them...first time i see them 'live'

  • Carah!! ^^, friggin love her !

  • The sound guy screwed up. What a crying shame!

  • I like the part where Carah looks to the camera!

  • I TETRACT FULLY THE COMMENT I JUST LEFT. HAVING HEARD THESE GUYS DO A STUDIO VERSION OF STRIPPED I AM A NEW FAN SO BIG SORRY FOR SLAGGING YOU OFF.Obviously the sound guy on the day this was done was banging up.

  • what the fudge is this FILTH! Doesnt anyone do any sound checks anymore. Poor old DMode must be laughing their arses off.These guys are surely not serious. Please tell me this video is from a comedy scetch PLEASE...!!!

  • DUDE DEPECHE MODE.....gahh Love them so much you guys rock to ...good cover!

  • lol its funny cause your probably just some little kid, cause no mature adult would talk that way XD

  • troll.

  • uh oh looks like we got some 4channers up in here

  • im pretty sure carah quit...not positive but pretty sure...

  • carah did quit, she wanted to start her own band.

  • this isong is from Depeche Mode. thought id share :^p

  • this is one of their best of this song ive seen. i love how carah looks directly into your camera on that one part. shes amazing

  • i haven't heard seasons of poison, and probably won't since carah's gone. not just cuz she was spectacular, but cuz the way they kicked her out was especially dickish.

    no more respect for STG.

  • This kids sucks!!!!!(my balls!!!)

  • with or without cyrah... shiny toy guns will always be shiny toy guns!!! thier music is just superb,,,,, but cyrah will be missed....

  • d00d hmkay, so i saw them last year when carah was still in the band and they were ahh mazingg and then i went to see them last week and i had NO IDEA that she wasn't in it and i didn't find out until that part between when the opening bands and the main bands play and i was SO EFFING PISSED i wanted to LEAVE.

  • well if you didnt notice y were u so pissed? u obviously couldnt tell the difference

  • Carah is awesome but Sisely can sing too! They will still be awesome. Carah didn't write much as far as I know, I think it's mostly Jeremy and Chad.

  • Agreed.

  • all of you that are going to stop listening to them or not listen to them as much because carah isnt in the band anymore are idiots

  • wow, they still sound amazing live.

    <3 carah

  • STG isn't the same without Carah

    TT ^ TT

  • Shiny Toy Guns isn't the same band without Carah. I fell in love with STG because of Carah, that should tell something already. Carah<3

  • ninaj1 all that tells us is that you don't like the band for their music, you like them because of one person, not the whole

  • What the hell?! I do like Shiny Toy Guns for their music! I don't listen bands who's music I don't like. All I was saying was that I think the band won't be itself without Carah. Don't put words to my mouth.

  • Actually "one person" can make the difference. Especially if that person is a vocal performer. I like STG with Carah. Without that one person their sound suffers greatly. Since this vid is a cover of a Depeche Mode song, I'll use them as an example. DM has had a few members leave in the past but have been able to keep their sound in tact. If, however, Dave Gahan left the band (or was fired), it wouldn't be worth it for them to make another album. Their sound would be gone.

  • I was there!!! I love this band and I'm so pissed that Carah isn't there anymore!!!!!!!!!!

  • AMAZING!

    <3

  • i probably would have went crazy if she would have looked right in the camera like that. they're amazing.

  • amo a la vocalista de este grupo , es una diosa , canta como un angel . es un angel

  • jajaj si es demasiado hermosa. como para soñar con ella todos los dias.

  • cant realy hear her sing

  • Dude She Sang At Your Camera!

    WOOHOOO

    Lucky Bugger!!

    I LOVE This Sover..I LOVE STG

    :D

  • Oh my gosh! That ruled right?! lol Caught me offguard. :)

  • FINALLY!

    A band that did a good Depeche Mode cover.

    Shiny Toy Guns are awesome, and them singing a song from the greatest band of all time, makes them even better in my book.

  • great live performance but i couldn't hear carah at all.

  • the carah part was awsome

  • i luv that song but i could hardly hear carah's voice T_T but they still did an awesome job

  • that part at 1:27 when carah yells into the camera is wonderful!

  • Thats awesome!!! Yeah!! Depeche mode!!!!!!!!

  • i think the person who recorded this has an un healthy obsesion with carah. (but she is hot)