For Good - Doctor/Donna

[magichacker]

I don't post normally, but have to add this was amazing. I just finished season 4 and can't stop feeling bad for Donna. I think I would have rather her been killed, but to never have the memory of all she did and became is just tragic.

[ithinkyourewonderful]

The intersecting of two of my nerdiest loves: Showtunes + Doctor Who! Such a brilliant song choice for the two of them! :D

[thedemonhedgehog]

So sad! But beautiful.

[Amazon25]

No words.crying.

[SecretTimeLady]

This song is just... It's bringing tears to my eyes. It's SO perfect. This is one which to ONE HUNDRED % suits their relationship!!

[candymandy224]

that's so sad! because donna won't remember any of the wonderful times she had with her best friend. maybe she was changed a little bit though, even if she doesn't know it.

[fantasylover42]

i was crying 1 minute in :( i loved it!!

It's so true. I love this song, and it fits Donna and the Doctor so well :)

beautiful job.

[queenoftheoutlands]

*cries eyes out*

My goodness thats beautiful

[fate5demand]

Awesome video and this song is perfect. I really do regret how they ended that 4th series. It made me cry. All the good things come to an end I suppose. Well done. Makes it a little less sad really.

[LilyCat03]

Thi is so utterly gorgeous and such a perfect song for The Doctor and Donna. Great job!

[TheAngelofCaffeine]

This is so heartbreaking. Perfect choice of song and clips. I think this is how the Doctor will always remember Donna.

[kaye50000]

I absolutely love this video, and knowing the ending of Journey's End just makes both video and show more tragic, stirring, and all around better. I have trouble not crying while watching this video, because it does fit their friendship so perfectly.

[seb389]

donna was an amazing companion in the sense that she was so human. Catherine tate performance really put the bar of the show very high.

[kissmrule]

i so lvo e this video itos cute and sweet. i so love this song and this show

[Rachelly93]

I remember watching this video like a year ago and i kept replaying it, because i thought it was that good. Love the video and the clips go really well with it. Great video!

[gertymac]

I constantly rewatch this video. It's one of my all time favs.

[helena012]

Hi I Commemted Ages ago. Just Wanted to add That the clips go so well with the lyrics. and ill say it again. The BEST!!!!

x

[piratewench92]

Aw thanks for taking the time to recomment! I'm glad you liked it

[helena012]

I Think This Would Win An Award. Out Of Every Singe Doctor/Donna Tribute There Is On The Net This Has Got To Be By Far The Best. Even Though You Didnt Have Journeys End I think You Told Thier Story Brilliantly Well Done **********

[piratewench92]

Aw thank you so much that makes me feel wonderful =D

[jessicacute321]

i think he loved donna more than rose because he wouldn't say to rose he loved her

[ImADrWhoAddict]

No way. Donna was like his best friend and the same with her. Rose was something special he could say he loved her but the crack closed and he couldn't so he just got on wiht his life. By teh way very good vid. Really fits their relationship well

[jessicacute321]

@ImADrWhoAddict i no but then at journeys end he had the chance to say to rose i loved you yet he didint but his half self did leaving me thinking if you loved her you should express you feelings to her thats all! :D

[ImADrWhoAddict]

@jessicacute321 I guess but the first one knew that if he said it Rose wouldn't let him go, becasue he couldn't stay, whereas the 2nd one, who was still exactly him just half human could grow old with her. Though it still made the first one sad because he loves her too. But if she's happy he's happy.....

[GirlAuthor]

...wow...!

That was so amazing! I really, really enjoyed it. It's in my faves folder now! Fantastic work!

[vickysg1]

My favourite song from Wicked, combined with these two, is perfect! And they did change each other for good. And she did came into his life for a reason.

[datajoe22]

Whell, this should win an award....

Perfect.....

Thanks

JG

[emmabee93]

Its from the musical Wicked and the name of the song is "For Good" Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth sing it.

[ladylake2004]

oh my that was so good what is the name of the song where can i get it

[curlywavy18]

very good. the doctor and donna i don't think were meant to be together but their relationship was a very very very very special one.

[LisaSimpsonBoobie]

I love Doctor and Donna. It's pretty cool. I think that Donna was very good with the Doctor and I love that. Very good video.

[wanerness]

Amazing the song fits the Doctor/Donna story perfectly and its also one of the best songs from wicked. I hope they find a way 2 bring Donna back like they did with Rose. 5/5 n Faves

[WickedObsesser]

I lovee doctor who and Wicked! (which is the musical the song is from)

the best combination ever =D

thanks so much piratewench92

x

[SciFiGirl1977]

Wow-I wasn't too sure about the song at first,but that was wonderful. The song was so perfect and really touching.

[WickedObsesser]

isn't it just =]

it's my all time favourite song EVER!!

x

[kt27rule]

i love this vidoe it so cute and sweet. i so love t his song

[elfielvr]

OMG - this is WONDERFUL!!! My favorite Doctor/Donna video I've seen thusfar! The song could not have been any more perfect for her, it just about ripped my heart out!! I was crying through the whole thing! WELL DONE.

*sniff* I want Donna back....

[ImADrWhoAddict]

Me too! The show won't be the same without her or DT. Grrr....why do things always have to change!

[Jadera13]

i luv that show!

[gertymac]

Wow. This song choice has even more meaning after seeing Journey's End.

Very well done!

[aflamingmoon]

this is amazing!

[USAFproductions]

wounderful the USAF productions gives you the wounderful memorie award for best doctor who play backs

[clairemmc]

That's beautiful :)

[wycked]

love this

[HeidiGetsCreative]

Lovely video. Really lovely.

Thanks so much for sharing.

[hbpattskyn]

So sad... so wonderful... I miss Donna so much! I loved her from the first moment she appeared in the TARDIS... wonderfully done. Thank you for sharing. What a great song for her.

[LizzyQ16]

BRILLANT!!

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

Beautifully done.

Sobbing, of course, due to the tragic irony in the perfection of this song.

*sigh*

Great job.

[morgeil]

Oh. My. God. I... have no words. Except: Heartfelt, deep and utterly brilliant! XD

[Abbeyb9]

NICE ONE

[jaynem89]

this is such a lovely video, almost had me welling up again.

[draconismoi]

This is great! The song is perfect considering the ending....and since you don't have any clips from the finale in it, this helps me edit those last few minutes of the finale from my personal canon. Bloody writers.

[kt27rule]

i love this video ti so cute

[boobabycluebaby2]

Gorgeous!

[amarvi]

Ohhh, and a Wicked song, as if this couldn't get any better <3

[fredfreddy]

I have been changed for the better...except when my brain gets wiped...I guess that wouldn't make for very good lyrics.

Nice job!

[megaloo]

As basically everyone else has said, this is so much more tragic considering the events of Journey's End. Lovely video, well done.

[gherilain]

*sobbing*

Thank you so much! It is so beautiful!

[thelostgirl101]

Wow! That is such a wonderful video! Made me cry. Poor Donna. I hope Steven Moffat will be kind enough to fix what RTD did.

[moofootiesma]

Oh, lord, this has made me bawl. The song in itself has always made me a little teary, but that with *this* - Donna being changed for good, but *not*. Scarily appropriate song choice, considering this was done before JE, and absolutely, terrifyingly heartbreaking. Excellent job!

[DivasofDestruction4]

this is soo moving great video ,, donna come back:(

[dragon8791]

Fantastic video. It made me cry all over again.

[englishstudent01]

That so beautiful that video I needed to see I miss donna already.

[SleepyKitsune]

actually, considering how Journey's End ended, this is really apt and heartbreaking.

[Niknar89]

such a fitting song for the both of them, then again who could meet the doctor and not be changed?

awesome job!!!!!!!!!!!

[HarryDoesntKnow]

aww! this is sooo sweet! i'm gonna miss donna way 2 much, she was an awesome companion! great vid for them! love the song, perfect clips, just yay! 5 * and faved:)

[piratewench92]

Thanks! I'm gonna miss her so much, she was my favorite next to Rose. Atleast Rose has her memories *glares at writers*