@figbat1 obviously Paul McCartney doesn't feel the same considering Grohl has let's see... PERFORMED THIS SONG WITH PAUL MCCARTNEY!!! Hmmm who's musical opinion should I trust: some random ass youtube user or the writer of the song and a former Beatle... Hmmm
@lastpman .....get ready to hear the foo fighters version of "red telephone" by love in the near future......it is psychological......they think if they keep on doing covers of classic songs that their own s h i t is 5 stars.....but sadly only reaches 3 and 4 stars. some bands just dont have the chemistry to record 5 star albums.......sorry dave.
Both the original and this cover are phenomenal! The nice thing is they put their own twist on it. A cover is to honour a beautiful piece of music, and that is what the Foo Fighters did. Adding their own twist made it their own, and I 100% respect both Paul and the Foos. They both played a wonderful song, and we should respect the Foo Fighters' taste in music, not beak them on how it doesn't sound the same. IT SHOULDN'T. NO COVER SHOULD
they are surely doing nothing more than muddling through a song they have zero chance on improving on...This isn't a "take" on a classic....It's an under talented rock group destroying a classic, carefully crafted arrangement...this is a cheesy bar band effort.
and I like some foo fighters too...just honest assessment.
@k2ombs This is just pure bullshit. Foo Fighters are really talented band and this is their cover of the song, like it or not. Music isn't a fucking competition.
In Thank god that fooeys did this cover not guns n roses (though they were the best cover band). I would still rather go to local bar and listen to a band who does covers than paying for guns n roses. SLASH is cool. Axl Rose or Oral sex sucks. Sorry to say, but Paul Mcartney should of sued him for making LIVING LET DIE sound like shit. Foo Fighters rocks. They are my Beatles IN my generation.
@jb29783 Dude are you kidding me? GNR's version of Live and Let Die was one of the best covers they ever did. Not trying to start anything but Foo Fighters and GNR are both really great bands and both have unique ways of covering songs.
@BurritoBryan actually guns and sucks ABSOLUTELY SUXX and Sir Paul McCartney should have sued their asses for totally fucking up his music. axl rose SUXX slash SUXX and guns and sucks SUXXXXXXX!!!!!!!
@jb29783 Your an idiot when a band remakes a song and does a cover its usually to make the song better or to add there own twist that makes it sound better
LOVE THIS SONG!!! ITTOTALLY BEATS THE OTHER ONE!!! but. if they never made the origional then there would have never been this one :O its kinda cool if you think about it. ANY WAY ITS AWESOME!!!!!!
It sad that some people can't understand the love in McCartney's music. He is arguably the greatest singer / songwriter ever along with Dylan and Lennon. If you don't like the man don't waste our time putting him down just so you can feel better about you crappy taste in ehem, music. I hope that you find your way to Pepperland someday brother, it's Paradise. Love is waiting.....................................
This is a good rendition by a newer band that obviously has some talent. It's a lot harder sounding, but it works - good job Foo Fighters.
I like how they respectfully included footage as dedication to the music of the past.
This song and video show some taste - not like other remakes which deystroy the feeling, such as Limp Biskit's shitty version of The Who's Bihind Blue Eyes.
I still like The Wings original version better, but I applaud The Foo Fighters for their version also.
I don't get this hate. Wings are phenomenal, Paul McCartney is phenomenal, David Grohl is phenomenal, Foo Fighters are phenomenal, and music is music. It's as if the music doesn't even matter, only a competition of who is better than who. Does this sound like the wings? No way. Does it suck? No way. Is it a great feeling to know that good music is perpetuated by modern bands? you're god damn right it is.
It's all subjective really (like you pointed out - just your opinion). It doesn't matter if you feel Mcartney sucked or was the second coming yet I'm interested to learn more. Do you feel his "talent" sucked - that he had no ability to create or compose music and should have been cleaning up after livestock instead? That kind of sucked? Or, do you just not care for his style of music? I tend to like more heavy music myself but it seems obvious that his talent and musical ability is incredible.
@ploopterfarm When he was tempered by others in the Beatles he was as good as they come. When left to his own devices he sold out for the allmighty British pound sterling. Like yourself I like lean to harder, more mature stuff, ie. Allman Bros, Bob Dylan, LZ, Moody Blues, ZZ Top, Black Sabbath, etc. but I do have a soft spot for gentler music, James Taylor, Don McClean (sp), Elton John and the likes. To answer your question...No I do not like his post Beatle music. It sucks very badly.
Wow! Just stumbled across this whilst getting my fix of Rope to keep me going until the new album is released.
Like many have said, you'll never beat the original Wings version of this, it's a classic, but Foo Fighters have sure as hell give it their best shot. It's hard to respect the original yet still give it the flavour of the covering band but I think FF have struck a beautiful balance and I've got to respect them for that. Big thumbs up from me :o)
I think that's Dave at 2:11 ;)
tinman24601 2 weeks ago
is there any classic song that the foo fighters dont feel the need to butcher?
figbat1 2 months ago
@figbat1 obviously Paul McCartney doesn't feel the same considering Grohl has let's see... PERFORMED THIS SONG WITH PAUL MCCARTNEY!!! Hmmm who's musical opinion should I trust: some random ass youtube user or the writer of the song and a former Beatle... Hmmm
lastpman 2 months ago
@lastpman .....get ready to hear the foo fighters version of "red telephone" by love in the near future......it is psychological......they think if they keep on doing covers of classic songs that their own s h i t is 5 stars.....but sadly only reaches 3 and 4 stars. some bands just dont have the chemistry to record 5 star albums.......sorry dave.
figbat1 2 months ago
@figbat1 your foovaratie song is waiting
dkitty8124 1 month ago
@figbat1 wow, I think they did a great job
hansmon4 3 weeks ago
@hansmon4 ...for a bunch of gay pretenders!
figbat1 3 weeks ago
This is the music video to Free as a Bird off the Beatles Anthology
RichLikesDucks 2 months ago
great musician performing a great song written by another great musician...did i say it was a great song??? it is.....
cowboyschamp22 2 months ago
i always listen to this
but i never really watched the video
the vid is just as good as the song!!
rfghy100 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love this band! Check out this band from Norway, inspired by Foo Fighters: watch?v=w5kmafJnxQM&feature=channel_video_title
CaveOfficial 2 months ago
Foo fighters rock the shit outta this song, both are great obviously, I like the Foo Fighters style much more alternative and excelent <3
DigitalNinjaz 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No cover of "Band On The Run" can get any better than this! The song seems like it's meant to be covered by the Foos! =)))
jan279 3 months ago
Comment removed
jan279 3 months ago
love it 1st time 've heard it
mandstngt 3 months ago
@mandstngt go listen to the original then :D
ShadowNick3 3 months ago
Amazing.
RandomHero5677 4 months ago
Gr8 version
Thechristiancullen 4 months ago
Wow, love it. The original is fantastic, and so is this.
Sheratain 4 months ago
1:18 to 2:12 Epic-ness
ACZxGalm2 4 months ago
@ACZxGalm2 no... 0:00-5:08 is epic ness
holyshitaflyingbanna 3 months ago
sooooo much better than GnR's cover of live and let die....
belvaar 4 months ago
DUUUUDE THIS COVER IS FUCKIN AWESOME :D GOOD JOB FOOS <3
mrsalezaelovely 5 months ago 4
=) excelente!
MsterAntho 5 months ago
Great video! The music is so good as the original!
aninhastarkey 5 months ago
Better than the original
buster6866 5 months ago
Both the original and this cover are phenomenal! The nice thing is they put their own twist on it. A cover is to honour a beautiful piece of music, and that is what the Foo Fighters did. Adding their own twist made it their own, and I 100% respect both Paul and the Foos. They both played a wonderful song, and we should respect the Foo Fighters' taste in music, not beak them on how it doesn't sound the same. IT SHOULDN'T. NO COVER SHOULD
ROCK ON PAUL! ROCK ON FOOS!
FUCK YOU HATERS!
Igglybuff222 5 months ago 2
Is this video like a scene from a Beatles movie, because I just saw Ringo Paul and George in there and John.
sinksinmud123 5 months ago
@sinksinmud123 It's the "Free as a Bird" music video.
TotzthePlaid 5 months ago
this is nothing without paul. sorry
sansdeity420 5 months ago
they are surely doing nothing more than muddling through a song they have zero chance on improving on...This isn't a "take" on a classic....It's an under talented rock group destroying a classic, carefully crafted arrangement...this is a cheesy bar band effort.
and I like some foo fighters too...just honest assessment.
k2ombs 5 months ago
@k2ombs This is just pure bullshit. Foo Fighters are really talented band and this is their cover of the song, like it or not. Music isn't a fucking competition.
GoodGuitarSolos 5 months ago
really good cover! love the original but this just seems to have more energy
smt2542 6 months ago
the three cuntpickles that disliked this video are the three band members on the run from the Justin Beiber 'tribute' band
CobainGrohlFan 6 months ago
In Thank god that fooeys did this cover not guns n roses (though they were the best cover band). I would still rather go to local bar and listen to a band who does covers than paying for guns n roses. SLASH is cool. Axl Rose or Oral sex sucks. Sorry to say, but Paul Mcartney should of sued him for making LIVING LET DIE sound like shit. Foo Fighters rocks. They are my Beatles IN my generation.
jb29783 6 months ago
@jb29783 Dude are you kidding me? GNR's version of Live and Let Die was one of the best covers they ever did. Not trying to start anything but Foo Fighters and GNR are both really great bands and both have unique ways of covering songs.
BurritoBryan 6 months ago
@BurritoBryan actually guns and sucks ABSOLUTELY SUXX and Sir Paul McCartney should have sued their asses for totally fucking up his music. axl rose SUXX slash SUXX and guns and sucks SUXXXXXXX!!!!!!!
SocratesTheGadfly 6 months ago
@jb29783 Your an idiot when a band remakes a song and does a cover its usually to make the song better or to add there own twist that makes it sound better
smiller517 6 months ago
they need this by itself on itunes..u can only buy it with the rest of the album which is like $6
21chargers17rock56 6 months ago
@21chargers17rock56 Dude, buy it. I bet you won't regret the purchase, for sure.
Jaysun814 6 months ago
@Jaysun814 i just did cuz i finally got itunes money(:
21chargers17rock56 5 months ago
see in the 2:24 is paul mcCartney
elpanecillo 6 months ago
FUCK I have the foo fighters greatest hits but this song didnt come in it, that sucks :'(
pavoman3 6 months ago
I like how differnt it is from the original!!!
addboy720 6 months ago
One of the few times when I prefer the remake to the original.
Aritul 6 months ago
LOVE THIS SONG!!! IT TOTALLY DOES NOT BEATS THE ORIGINAL!! No one can touch Paul's talent. but this is still fucking awesome!
ArizonaKnightWolf 6 months ago 26
@ArizonaKnightWolf
it wouldnae be hard to beat the origional..... its total pish man !
Ultrasonic1979 1 week ago
LOVE THIS SONG!!! ITTOTALLY BEATS THE OTHER ONE!!! but. if they never made the origional then there would have never been this one :O its kinda cool if you think about it. ANY WAY ITS AWESOME!!!!!!
Eeveelutions898 7 months ago
This made my day.
purefault 7 months ago
I like this version and got the album "Radio 1 Established 1967"
Unfortunately this compilation album is lame, the Foo Fighters are the only bright spot.
NaturalThingalong 7 months ago
Foo Fighters are sooo much better then Nirvana. Thank you Mr. Cobain!
bonerock1 7 months ago
The weird little Wowowowowowow noise was keyboard I think in the original, and this sounds like bent guitar strings. Am I right?
HeavyMetalMarauder 7 months ago
@HeavyMetalMarauder You are right.
TimothyQStanton 7 months ago
I didn't want to like this, but I do.
TimothyQStanton 7 months ago
its good but not as good as the original :)
benom888 7 months ago
As long as the Foo is helmed by Grohl, they can do anything.
livetorokk 7 months ago
I don't understand how anybody could not like this
LostintransitionLIT 7 months ago
for anyone wondering, the video is from Free As a Bird off the 95 anthology 1 album ! :D
christianalexlea 8 months ago
gotta admit, i was skeptical listening to this....dave grohl, as usual,. nails it
one of the few celebs i'd actually like to meet
banklikefrankwhite1 8 months ago
ITS ABBEY ROAD OMFG!!!!!
BeatlesMusicRocks 8 months ago
Very beautiful.. it's rare to find a cover so pretty; maybe they could add a bit of originality..
stefansson11 8 months ago 2
@stefansson11 your crazy. they added 100% originality
shaggyrogers1234 7 months ago
great vid match!
jasonb123go 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This video was just added to a music playlist at JustPlay.fm
justplayfm 8 months ago
It sad that some people can't understand the love in McCartney's music. He is arguably the greatest singer / songwriter ever along with Dylan and Lennon. If you don't like the man don't waste our time putting him down just so you can feel better about you crappy taste in ehem, music. I hope that you find your way to Pepperland someday brother, it's Paradise. Love is waiting.....................................
joeblinn1 8 months ago
wow this is rad
b182dood 9 months ago
Great song, but you can tell the band has way less experience in music.
RuberHammer 9 months ago
2:13 should have reverted back to clean tone woulda made the music tell whole new stories
Sk8forfunitsfun 9 months ago
This is a good rendition by a newer band that obviously has some talent. It's a lot harder sounding, but it works - good job Foo Fighters.
I like how they respectfully included footage as dedication to the music of the past.
This song and video show some taste - not like other remakes which deystroy the feeling, such as Limp Biskit's shitty version of The Who's Bihind Blue Eyes.
I still like The Wings original version better, but I applaud The Foo Fighters for their version also.
sumofone1969 9 months ago
classy take
machachos1 10 months ago
Bad ass!!! The Foo Fighters aren't competing against Wings. It's an homage. I think some people miss the point.
mpowell95 10 months ago 2
I don't get this hate. Wings are phenomenal, Paul McCartney is phenomenal, David Grohl is phenomenal, Foo Fighters are phenomenal, and music is music. It's as if the music doesn't even matter, only a competition of who is better than who. Does this sound like the wings? No way. Does it suck? No way. Is it a great feeling to know that good music is perpetuated by modern bands? you're god damn right it is.
invictive 10 months ago 54
@invictive damn it right
ciriloud 10 months ago
@invictive Here's my unsolicited opinion....Wings sucked very badly and Paul McCartney was the head suckee.
bthor76 10 months ago
@bthor76 so why were you here listening?
1vilnius1 9 months ago
@1vilnius1 Well how else would I know if it sucked if I didn't at least hear it once?
bthor76 9 months ago
It's all subjective really (like you pointed out - just your opinion). It doesn't matter if you feel Mcartney sucked or was the second coming yet I'm interested to learn more. Do you feel his "talent" sucked - that he had no ability to create or compose music and should have been cleaning up after livestock instead? That kind of sucked? Or, do you just not care for his style of music? I tend to like more heavy music myself but it seems obvious that his talent and musical ability is incredible.
ploopterfarm 9 months ago
@ploopterfarm When he was tempered by others in the Beatles he was as good as they come. When left to his own devices he sold out for the allmighty British pound sterling. Like yourself I like lean to harder, more mature stuff, ie. Allman Bros, Bob Dylan, LZ, Moody Blues, ZZ Top, Black Sabbath, etc. but I do have a soft spot for gentler music, James Taylor, Don McClean (sp), Elton John and the likes. To answer your question...No I do not like his post Beatle music. It sucks very badly.
bthor76 9 months ago
Love this, Free As A Bird video
MrHacko21 11 months ago
no competition the wing are still graet
denzil1001 11 months ago
no competition
denzil1001 11 months ago
Wow! Just stumbled across this whilst getting my fix of Rope to keep me going until the new album is released.
Like many have said, you'll never beat the original Wings version of this, it's a classic, but Foo Fighters have sure as hell give it their best shot. It's hard to respect the original yet still give it the flavour of the covering band but I think FF have struck a beautiful balance and I've got to respect them for that. Big thumbs up from me :o)
FreakinMerv 11 months ago
Best video I've seen !
cclar051 11 months ago
I fucking love this song and the Foo Fighters the two go together quite well!
BeingRob 11 months ago
This cover is not even in the same ballpark as McCartney's original. Good effort though
RHeckman00 11 months ago
Great cover!!!
PChemato 11 months ago
great unique take on the song - really good vid too
societiescrazybreed 11 months ago
epic cover
McFro95 11 months ago 2
Along with Nirvana covering Man who sold the world this is one cover that is better than the original.
kriskaos1981 11 months ago
This is a great cover! I love the guitar part from 1:32.
annamila1 11 months ago
classssss!!!!!!
seamy88ify 1 year ago
Love love looooooove it :D
T4STYCOCOMAN 1 year ago
Amazing tune ...Covered brilliantly by them !!!!
buckfastbam 1 year ago
great cover!
MsSacher78 1 year ago
This is such a great cover, It should have been a single off of E.S.P.G.
curveball135 1 year ago
Comment removed
nikkiR123456 1 year ago
good cover WOW
locurasayj 1 year ago
great cover,video and tribute
phantomhacker90 1 year ago
I normally don't like Foo Fighters but this is a brilliant cover and a great video.
alexandros200 1 year ago
WOW :-))) Wonderful !!!!
pontepolentepontepi 1 year ago
Usually I can't stand covers, but this is awesome! Modern twist to a great song. It doesn't hurt that I like the Foo Fighters, too.
pnut7805 1 year ago
Great!! :D :D
EmGahan 1 year ago
aguante Nirvana!!,,, excellent cover, band on the, run band on the run...........^_^
NeuMond007 1 year ago
fucking brill .
kriss266 1 year ago
This cover is fucking awesome!!!
coocycoo 1 year ago
This just may be the best Beatles/McCartney remake ever!
kliff215 1 year ago
10,000x better than Guns n roses version of LIve & Let Die
kliff215 2 years ago
gnr version is a great tune also
eutortugo08 1 year ago 2
mejor que Wings...
sn277799 2 years ago
1:18
claxnolf 2 years ago
Comment removed
claxnolf 2 years ago
estupenda
christian2007matador 2 years ago
this song is soo kick ass. where can i find a download for it?
ddude7 2 years ago
Uhh... iTunes?
FetaCheese222 2 years ago
Great cover, the footage is cool too, but i think it's a bit sad too.
Love the Beatles and Foo Fighters.
Simto 2 years ago 2
Not sad in a bad way, there's just something bittersweet about the vibe of the song. Great stuff.
Simto 2 years ago
footage is the "Free as a Bird" video from Anthology
NicNac13c 2 years ago
@Simto It's not a beatles song, it's wings.
04scottt 1 year ago
@04scottt Doh, yeah... i just got it mixed up in my head beacause of the video, i even have Wing's band on the run LP in my basement... My bad :)
Simto 1 year ago
Hope they put this on a CD!!!
kentchaisson 2 years ago
Gold.
Evansharma 2 years ago 2
i remember the 1st version-this track is WAY better!!! it freakin' ROCKS!!!!! thanks grohl!!!
circaking90 2 years ago
althought this cover kicks ass
elchucabagra 2 years ago 3
why oh why does nate pick?!
elchucabagra 2 years ago
this sooooo cool love it :)
thewho1219 2 years ago
Comment removed
thewho1219 2 years ago
omg this is the most amazing thing to enter my brain!!!! wow i cant discribe how amazing this is.
haydentube09 2 years ago 3
awesomeness!
myrtia 3 years ago 6
Squeet, (sweet+cool) one of the only bands in the world who could cover a #1 song and give it an enjoyable twist
dernaegle 3 years ago 9
this rocks!
electricdynomite 3 years ago 6
fukn awersome loads better than the orinigal
kruddell 3 years ago 3
Fucking awesome? Yes. Loads better than the original? Hell no.
MadManMason 2 years ago 80
I agree 100%
Spideyfan117 2 years ago
@MadManMason that video is from the first of two beatles songs done after the death of john lennon called free as a bird. It was on anthology 1.
happyface4444 1 year ago
@happyface4444 this is a wings song not the beatles
GearsSG 1 year ago
@MadManMason No better but no worse, in my opinion.
maki0129 8 months ago
@kruddell It's no where near as good as the original!!!
04scottt 1 year ago
@04scottt Dude this is 10 times better then the original, and im a Huge Beatles fan too.
curveball135 1 year ago
@curveball135 1 this this was a wings song 2 hell no
GearsSG 1 year ago
@curveball135 Shows what you know, this is a Wings song...
04scottt 1 year ago
That track works superbly with that video...cool! Grohl = God
simon1000 3 years ago 23
@simon1000 that video is from the first of two beatles songs done after the death of john lennon called free as a bird.
happyface4444 1 year ago