Ferrari Virtual Academy vs Gran Turismo 5 - Ferrari F10 at Nurburgring

[acke666234587]

FVA wins hands down because it doesn't force me to spend half my life driving 1HP S*IT BOXES around just to get in a F1 car!!

[sbowesuk]

GT5 wins. The wheels actually turn correctly, the sound is less computerised, the reflections on the pain are far more accurate. Clear winner for realism.

[Driftstarwarrior]

Lol FVA fail XD when the car turns,you can bearly see the wheels moving,as for gt5:EPICNESS.

[42Mooey]

The only thing I see wrong with GT besides the sound is that the drivers hands on the wheel don't cross over

[MrUppmas]

@42Mooey That's because it is the base turn radius of the wheel in GT5.

[MtMarshi]

gt5 clear winner on all fronts in my opinion

[ishamael0]

fva does not show any shifting whereas gt5 does

[MeshUpIt]

Awful shadows at the right side.

[MrUppmas]

@MeshUpIt Blurry numbers on the left side.

[AdamTheMan1993]

@MeshUpIt blame god for creating the sun

[pratikparija]

They both look similar but Ferrari Academy's F10 has a louder but similar sound as that of the F10 in Gran Turismo 5. Nice

[rsplayerbaby]

all GT5 needs is a real wheel like that, and we have us a winner !

[sal2ize]

gt5's steering wheel doesnt turn as much as the steering wheels of f1 cars do in real life

[SAFFY7411]

Ferrari Virtual Academy looks better IMO

[ghalloikbenhet]

sound in FVA is amazing, way better than gt5''s

[ICEMANZIDANE]

FVA looks shit , i think its not right to compaire it with GT 5. GT 5 is a Monster Game ! FVA is a new little Game ...

[from33to77]

@ICEMANZIDANE

for realism Rfactor>FVA>GT5

[jukka0taxi]

I say gta 5 have better shadows

[jefaxdmonster]

@jukka0taxi ja serean pero sombras pixeleadas mire bien



[Silver73Stone]

This gt5 ferrari looks like the codemaster 2010, the sound too... Indeed, the both look so real...

[MangoTangoFOx]

@ThaDRP Once again, go back to first grade. You seriously need to work on your grammar. For your information, I am 18. We are talking about Formula 1 cars here. Since when did F1 switch to a 6 speed stick shift? Sure it may not be as complicated as a standard stick, but who can handle a stick going in excess of 180mph on some of the tightest tracks in the world? Oh and, "Big boys with big boy toys"? We are talking about a video game here. Its a hobby, at most. You are a fucking worthless.

[boomee78]

gt5 is pretty good



[Uff182]

FVA wins hands down in terms of physic and sounds.

[KeenoMc95]

why not just get f1 2011

[VictoReX11]

What happen with the GT 5 sounds? F1 car in gt

[n00bm0de]

GT5 lacks some bass in the engine sound and its open wheel physics needs more understeer.... lol

[tbok75]

Ill say it again... the only reason they post these comparison vids is to get people riled up. And it works!! Listen to y'all! Jittery this, sound that... just go play.

[wolftmfg]

It's sounds like that (again) GT5 is not winning in this matter :)

[undeny]

Why does the GT5 clip look lower-res?

[SApcGUY]

OMG the gt5 ferarri sounds like a microwave having sex with a fridge

[undeny]

@SApcGUY More like a chainsaw that choked on a pine-tree after watching that microwave "defrosting" away on the fridge..

[SApcGUY]

@undeny hahaha LMAO good one

[MangoTangoFOx]

@ThaDRP First of all, go back to first grade. Second of all, what does a jittery camera have to do with game skill? And I use a wheel with paddle shifters, on manual transmission.

I play many racing games, and it is the only one that bounces (unrealistically) that much, even on perfectly flat road. (Only in cockpit view) It is so bouncy that it is disorienting. I CAN play with it, but it forces your eyes to focus much more intently, compared to other camera positions (GT5 only).

[UDDeganidesings]

hand animations on GT5 still sucks alot

[obscuresword]

@UDDeganidesings Actually the hand animations on FVA suck more For instance @ 1:29-1:32 when braking in GT5 you see the drivers hand actually downshift by pressing the paddle shifters, in FVA the driver doesn't even move.

[mailmeonline]

oh my god...those awefull gt5 sounds

[TheAntihero6212]

@mailmeonline Fuck you and fuck off, cunt. ENGINE SOUNDS DO NOT MAKE OR BREAK A RACING GAME, PEOPLE!!!! THIS IS NOT REAL LIFE!!!!!

[mailmeonline]

@TheAntihero6212 at the same time, they call themselves the best racing simulator

[mxartist8]

gt5 looks so much better

[tulloch09]

GT5 has rubbish sound

[obscuresword]

@tulloch09 The sound is the same except GT's is lower.

[ENKElXPRESS]

Both look pretty damn realistic to me..

[MagicalChickenWings]

Lol, mouse cursor. 

[MangoTangoFOx]

I personally just hate the way the camera is so jittery in cockpit view of GT5. The head camera moves 1 to 1 with the car when it hits any sort of bump in the road. While on other games and other cameras in GT5, the car jitters, but the cam stays relatively smooth. That's why I always use the above driver view in GT5 with the F1's.

[whatnow1204]

@MangoTangoFOx Hopefully GT can improve on this issue

[obscuresword]

@MangoTangoFOx ??? in FVA the camera is more jittery. Plus for some reason people complain and how much it isn't XD.

[MangoTangoFOx]

@obscuresword Wrong. If you look at both clips you see that in FVA, the car bounces relative to the camera. In GT5, the car and camera are completely locked. The only camera movement is a slight look down when braking. Because of this, the view of the road jitters, and the view of the car stays perfectly aligned. Since your eyes are ON THE ROAD, that constant jitter makes it hard for the eyes to focus. This occurs ONLY in cockpit view of GT5.

[obscuresword]

@MangoTangoFOx I got yeah. You're talking about how much it vibrates when looking at it in cockpit mode. For instance on Cirthe when going 200mph the car is relatively still but in cockpit mode the camera itself shakes quite a bit. I think that's what you're saying.

[VictoReX11]

@MangoTangoFOx If you got a PS Eye you can do head tracking in GT5.

[Fille3133]

FVA!

[TheAntihero6212]

I can barely read the speedometer on the F10 in FVA. 

[obscuresword]

@TheAntihero6212 lol i notice that too.

[kennmmanproductions]

I like GT5 more :)

[Xzibitfreek]

0:42 GT5, i dont think that would happen in real life too

[TheEryk03]

Ferrari Virtual much better physic.

[TactfulValkyrie]

Just get F1 2011 if you want to do this.

[MechsFan2011]

@TactfulValkyrie Damn man,now just damn straight. +1

[TheEryk03]

@TactfulValkyrie F1 2011 is just fuck,'n arcade... Ferrari academy is rather good sim.

[iAussieGamer]

apart from sound there is not much difference between the two graphically

[halflife103]

both aren't presenting themselves well.