She sounds very nervous. This is understandable. At her first performance, she had nothing to lose. Here, the world is expecting greatness and she feels her whole future is on the line, which, of course,it is. I'm pretty good under pressure, but I'm certain that my voice would shake a whole lot more than hers.
well, this may not have been her best, but it was a great attempt for someone like her, and I like her to, but i dont think this song fits her style really, I mean, if it was a different beautiful meaning song, she probably would've done better, I think personally she had stage fright at the beginning which wore off nearing the end, and she made a beautiful ending
The people who put the thumb down is either don't speak English or they are so idiots ! I don't use bad words at all , but I'm so sorry to say FUCK YOU !
@99IraqBaghdad99 I'm not doing a THUMBS DOWN, all in all she sang beautifully, yet didn't you notice the first few notes wewre sour. They sounded sour to me, anyway. Otherwise, she caught herself, got back on track and did a beautiful job. Maybe that's why people didn't like this video. Facts are facts. The first few notes were sour. That's no reason to use the F word. And I don't thinkl you were sorry at all in using the F word. If you were, you'd delete the message.
@ArabellaTV I noticed her first few words were sour, or sounded sour to me. I am not an expert, though. I liked her singing Wild Horses better than this song. Yet, after the first few notes, she improved and I thought she sounded good. Again, WIild Horses, to me , anyway, was a better song for her.
@twiwonder I just got done listening to Elaine Page singing the same song, and I could tell the words. I couldn'y exactly make out the words when Susan sang it.o, yes, she could improve her diction. But, I felt for the most part she sanf beautifully.
i like have no clue who she is but i just saw this video and clicked it so im not trying to be rude but i dont really like the tone and sound of her voice. it sounds like the songs out of her rage also. sorry fans of her but its just my opinion.
@AbbeyJoLarry ....listen to her sing i dreamed a dream....and you will hear what everyone else does...a beautiful voice coming from a beautiful soul. And considering that all 3 judges gave her a standing O, I say she sang it pretty well.
@Moony479 Well, someone's got to lose. But, in my mind she didn't lose. She went on recording songs, made a career of it. That's not losing. In this song, Memory from Cats, I noticed that the first few notes were sour, or seemed sour to me. She lost out to Diversity. Maybe they made no mistakes, she made a few. Yet, again, she didn't exactly lose. Coming out second---that's a great thing.
Boyle is interesting phennomenon but... did you see the lady who won "Ukraine's Got Talent" in 2009. She drew with sand. You can find on YouTybe, her name is Kseniya Simonova. That was smth EXTREMELY BREETHTAKING!!! A sand story about war, about a tragedy. And the girl herself was like a hero from "Matrix" - so charismatic and young! And by the way - beautiful. Then I said;"Well. Boyle is not that unbelieveble!" II think you all should see that Ukrainian winner, just to see beauty and talent..
@topsyluv I don't know if it's out of beat, but I did notice that the first few notews were sour, or seemed that way to me. Then she got back on track, and I thought she sang well.
I don't know what you are putting Susan down like you are? But she does know something about music cause if she didn't she would have not sold more then some other sings out there that have been sing all their lives!! All I can say is Susan never stop doing what you are doing!!
She has no dynamics! Singing is acting and feeling as much as it is technical. She doesn't understand music and as someone who has studied music from the time I was 10, I feel offended that she gets such an opportunity and I'm about to launch myself into the world after 12 years of training and having real moments in my performances.
@ohsinnaman I think your comments are unfair and arrogant. Susan is untrained; of course, she wouldn't know how to give a dynamic performance. She has a beautiful voice and although she didn't know what she was doing, she was willing to put herself out there and take a chance. That's why she got such an opportunity. You shouldn't envy her for having guts. Also, how do you know what she understands? Twelve years of training doesn't make you an authority on music or Susan.
@ohsinnaman i pretty much guarantee you suck balls compared to susan. 12 years of training won't do shit if you don't have the stage presence that susan does. who didn't get chills after the music interlude when she came back in.
Totally she should have won, she was nervous at the start of the song, but she more than made up for it as the song progressed, basically as soon as the crowd went crazy she recovered her confidence
@Charlieandmilly Really? cool. And, you are...? Its not ok to say mean things about the singing if you dont like it, but you look like an asshole if you say mean things about how she looks, no offense .
@linhpiano I disagree. She does have a great voice. but she didn't show the world talent is the most important thing, not the look. If she was an average looking woman, she wouldn't be as famous as she is because the world wouldn't see anything special about an average looking woman having a great voice...but an ugly woman singing like that?! someone get her a record contract! she's famous because she's ugly and because she's a novelty.
I would say she just sings average like a normal person and was really wobbly and bad at the start if you listened carefully. I like the orginial song 99% better than this one and honestly don't think shes that good. Everyone thinks different though, so you can't say that I am talking utter rubbish.
WOW!, i mean u can see she was kinda struggling at the very start, see da hand trying to catch da melody? but as she keep singing from "touch me" wow that part its to forget all those first little mistakes :D
poor susan...she was so off her game that night...all the pressure. she was flat here, pitchy there..rushing in some spots...she has a beautiful voice but i guess nerves got her. understandable....she needs more practice in front of large crowds i guess to build confidence.
Les premières mesures ne sont pas terribles du tout (elle chante même faux les deux premières notes !), c'est décevant. Dommage. mais, cela semble s'arranger par la suite...
HaveSwagCom. I wonder what your comment says about you? No class, no compassion, low self-esteem? If one feels good about him/herself, they don't feel the need to belittle another person. Susan is a real, honest-to-God person. Strange, isn't it, that we seem to overlook the physical appearance of male singers, but not women.
she is amazing!!!!
mariaartfactory 1 day ago
She sounds very nervous. This is understandable. At her first performance, she had nothing to lose. Here, the world is expecting greatness and she feels her whole future is on the line, which, of course,it is. I'm pretty good under pressure, but I'm certain that my voice would shake a whole lot more than hers.
MaiHarinder 1 week ago
Standing Ovation
DominiqueToretto70 4 months ago
well, this may not have been her best, but it was a great attempt for someone like her, and I like her to, but i dont think this song fits her style really, I mean, if it was a different beautiful meaning song, she probably would've done better, I think personally she had stage fright at the beginning which wore off nearing the end, and she made a beautiful ending
MusicCuresTheLiving 4 months ago
that was beautiful :')
vampirelova0406 4 months ago 2
The people who put the thumb down is either don't speak English or they are so idiots ! I don't use bad words at all , but I'm so sorry to say FUCK YOU !
99IraqBaghdad99 6 months ago 2
@99IraqBaghdad99 I'm not doing a THUMBS DOWN, all in all she sang beautifully, yet didn't you notice the first few notes wewre sour. They sounded sour to me, anyway. Otherwise, she caught herself, got back on track and did a beautiful job. Maybe that's why people didn't like this video. Facts are facts. The first few notes were sour. That's no reason to use the F word. And I don't thinkl you were sorry at all in using the F word. If you were, you'd delete the message.
Peggycass 5 months ago
einfach nur super gut
minniii7 6 months ago
I think she was just nervous at first. She definitely aced "Touch me, etcetc."
crayonsinorange 7 months ago 2
She was sharp in the beginning, and her diction could use some work, but she had beautiful tone.
Glitter742 7 months ago
Ahhh she rushed it /:
amixdeuxkpthluvr92 7 months ago
She is a great singer but she sang this too fast at at a lot of parts.
EraMinkie101 8 months ago
She's good but i don't like her singing this song. she doesn;'t sound good singing it.
ArabellaTV 8 months ago 2
@ArabellaTV agreed
tingirlful 8 months ago
@ArabellaTV I noticed her first few words were sour, or sounded sour to me. I am not an expert, though. I liked her singing Wild Horses better than this song. Yet, after the first few notes, she improved and I thought she sounded good. Again, WIild Horses, to me , anyway, was a better song for her.
Peggycass 5 months ago
she didnt win? well hey, i live in the U.S. so i dont watch this show!!!!! but she didnt win????? that is ridiculus!
enkoorsss 9 months ago 4
Brilliant job, Susan. You are a sweetie. Your words are far too constrained though-- you need more diction. it sounded all slurred
twiwonder 9 months ago
@twiwonder I just got done listening to Elaine Page singing the same song, and I could tell the words. I couldn'y exactly make out the words when Susan sang it.o, yes, she could improve her diction. But, I felt for the most part she sanf beautifully.
Peggycass 5 months ago
2:23 OHMAHGAWD She is the Second Coming.
OblivionRangerofDOOM 10 months ago
like this is susan boyle is awesome.... sorta! :)
heyyouthere5656 11 months ago 2
she looked happy walking on to the stage
MsMonopod 11 months ago 2
oh look grizzaballa lol
ticketsarenowdiamond 11 months ago
i like have no clue who she is but i just saw this video and clicked it so im not trying to be rude but i dont really like the tone and sound of her voice. it sounds like the songs out of her rage also. sorry fans of her but its just my opinion.
AbbeyJoLarry 1 year ago
@AbbeyJoLarry ....listen to her sing i dreamed a dream....and you will hear what everyone else does...a beautiful voice coming from a beautiful soul.
dlmtns101m 11 months ago
@AbbeyJoLarry ....listen to her sing i dreamed a dream....and you will hear what everyone else does...a beautiful voice coming from a beautiful soul. And considering that all 3 judges gave her a standing O, I say she sang it pretty well.
dlmtns101m 11 months ago
I love this! And I love Susan Boyle's singing! She should of one! I started punching the wall when she didn't win!!
Moony479 1 year ago
@Moony479 Well, someone's got to lose. But, in my mind she didn't lose. She went on recording songs, made a career of it. That's not losing. In this song, Memory from Cats, I noticed that the first few notes were sour, or seemed sour to me. She lost out to Diversity. Maybe they made no mistakes, she made a few. Yet, again, she didn't exactly lose. Coming out second---that's a great thing.
Peggycass 5 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Boyle is interesting phennomenon but... did you see the lady who won "Ukraine's Got Talent" in 2009. She drew with sand. You can find on YouTybe, her name is Kseniya Simonova. That was smth EXTREMELY BREETHTAKING!!! A sand story about war, about a tragedy. And the girl herself was like a hero from "Matrix" - so charismatic and young! And by the way - beautiful. Then I said;"Well. Boyle is not that unbelieveble!" II think you all should see that Ukrainian winner, just to see beauty and talent..
BigShowMr 1 year ago
in the begining i was like meh what ever then she got my atenchen
Gaarafreak911 1 year ago
it seems a little out of beat? who agree's?
topsyluv 1 year ago
@topsyluv I don't know if it's out of beat, but I did notice that the first few notews were sour, or seemed that way to me. Then she got back on track, and I thought she sang well.
Peggycass 5 months ago 2
not her best performance, I think they should have slowed the tempo for this song for her. Her voice is still amazing though!
XDreamingX 1 year ago
Outstanding ~
raffjj36 1 year ago
I don't know what you are putting Susan down like you are? But she does know something about music cause if she didn't she would have not sold more then some other sings out there that have been sing all their lives!! All I can say is Susan never stop doing what you are doing!!
stevensbabygirl4ever 1 year ago
Comment removed
stevensbabygirl4ever 1 year ago
esto me gusta!!!!
sabricu 1 year ago
She has no dynamics! Singing is acting and feeling as much as it is technical. She doesn't understand music and as someone who has studied music from the time I was 10, I feel offended that she gets such an opportunity and I'm about to launch myself into the world after 12 years of training and having real moments in my performances.
ohsinnaman 1 year ago
@ohsinnaman I think your comments are unfair and arrogant. Susan is untrained; of course, she wouldn't know how to give a dynamic performance. She has a beautiful voice and although she didn't know what she was doing, she was willing to put herself out there and take a chance. That's why she got such an opportunity. You shouldn't envy her for having guts. Also, how do you know what she understands? Twelve years of training doesn't make you an authority on music or Susan.
ashleymarisa 1 year ago 12
@ashleymarisa She's not exactly untrained. She had a private voice instructor, had singing lessons. That's not untrained.
Peggycass 5 months ago
@ohsinnaman i pretty much guarantee you suck balls compared to susan. 12 years of training won't do shit if you don't have the stage presence that susan does. who didn't get chills after the music interlude when she came back in.
JEDean89 1 year ago
@ohsinnaman so can we see your performances?
lwh6 1 year ago
@ohsinnaman oh ya? how about those who claim to be sooo good but is born without any talents? what a waste of training.
winteryeve 1 year ago
Poor thing. She looks terrified :/
countrypanda94 1 year ago
She had voice fatigue at this point. Her studio recordings are where she's able to shine at 100%.
LoreleiMission 1 year ago
She did ok, but this song just doesn't work for her.
foreverdawn6 1 year ago
A bit of a rough start, ey?
screamolives 1 year ago
Very pretty, but this song is not for her.
twiwonder 1 year ago 4
Totally she should have won, she was nervous at the start of the song, but she more than made up for it as the song progressed, basically as soon as the crowd went crazy she recovered her confidence
maranghellito 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
EWWWW THIS IS HORRIBLE!! SHES UGLY AND WEIRD!
Charlieandmilly 1 year ago
@Charlieandmilly Really? cool. And, you are...? Its not ok to say mean things about the singing if you dont like it, but you look like an asshole if you say mean things about how she looks, no offense .
dynoh 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No No and No. Sorry
karlos274 1 year ago
Did she did an amazing job for not being a person who sings everyday, or is a "professional." She's just a lady that could live next to you!
KitKat9109 1 year ago
she make me cry.................................
bob840620 1 year ago
she makes me cry!!!
DakodandLina 1 year ago
very rough start but shes gotten so amazing!!!!
RACHELSARAHFLYNN 1 year ago
Fuck Yea
ThePSP1290 1 year ago
it wasnt that good
gustavo2009133 1 year ago
it's such an angel voice.She showed the world that talent is the most important thing,not the look.She is my favorite artist
linhpiano 1 year ago
@linhpiano I disagree. She does have a great voice. but she didn't show the world talent is the most important thing, not the look. If she was an average looking woman, she wouldn't be as famous as she is because the world wouldn't see anything special about an average looking woman having a great voice...but an ugly woman singing like that?! someone get her a record contract! she's famous because she's ugly and because she's a novelty.
TopdollarStudio 1 year ago
She should play the role of Crizabella! :-)
Seastorm13 1 year ago
why didn't she win??? she's amazing!!!
w1o2n3n4y 1 year ago
I would say she just sings average like a normal person and was really wobbly and bad at the start if you listened carefully. I like the orginial song 99% better than this one and honestly don't think shes that good. Everyone thinks different though, so you can't say that I am talking utter rubbish.
lulujv 1 year ago 10
@lulujv I agree!!
ll0uu 1 year ago
@lulujv I don't think she's average... It's not jaw-droppingly amazing but it's not average at all.
junenostalgia 1 year ago
she sounds terrible at the start if you really listen btw cats is my all time favorite musical
jumpandgym63 1 year ago
Its Fuc*in Amazing !!!! :O GREAT
eldamsel 1 year ago
Tears started streaming down my face when she sang the last chorus. That was incredible. <3
FMAfanFMA 1 year ago
Omg you are soo good :D i really really love your voice :D
Imasinger97 1 year ago
Power Lady ! Stunning Voice ! Great !
TomsKingdom 2 years ago
AMAZING!
daddysbrat09 2 years ago
very good but at the start she sort ov messed it up ,but wen sh say i dremt a dream from les miserables it brout tears to my eyes
Noodlecraft101 2 years ago 2
this woman is stunning!
vale641 2 years ago
Marvelous! I could listen to her voice all day long, its so beautiful.
countrybugbug 2 years ago
BRAVO!! =) she is realy talented
CandyGirl4evaa 2 years ago
wow britanian's they really have talents!
WolfyLuka 2 years ago
EXCELLENT SINGING
VERY GOOD SUSAN.
ferrarriaantje 2 years ago
this is awful...
FrancesSD 2 years ago
I think she did ok,she got a wee bit off in the begining but she did fine with the rest of it. and her Cd is really good.
OLAYXX 2 years ago 3
Elaine Paige... does it so much better.
Boonedaba 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
ciaoooooo...
sapevii che sono aperte le iscrizioni per la nuova scuola di cinema e recitazione
a Cinecittà: EUTHECA !?!?!??!
L'unica scuola GRATIS, con recitazione bilingue,
alto livello degli insegnanti e interscambio culturale.
cerca EUTHECA o contattami...è bellissima la scuolaaaa....non vedo l'ora di cominciare!
ti aspettoooooooooo
bacini bacini bacini
MaryKicko87 2 years ago
... she did okay in "I dreamed a dream" but this is... sorry but this is bad.
Flickarounie 2 years ago
yeah I
WHORUTOQUESTIONME 2 years ago
yeah I think this song was a bit out of her range but if you listen to her album that just came out she is incredibly stunning
WHORUTOQUESTIONME 2 years ago
i dont understand why everyone thinks shes godly! i mean shes ok but shes not "OMG THE BEST TING EVARRRRR" you know?
knoxvillechick4life 2 years ago
WOW!, i mean u can see she was kinda struggling at the very start, see da hand trying to catch da melody? but as she keep singing from "touch me" wow that part its to forget all those first little mistakes :D
seaglec 2 years ago
wow I am crying...Susan Boyle...
Really an Angel!!!!!!!
Ethereobscur 2 years ago
this is aweful
Barenzial 2 years ago
ładna dupcia
zukos190 2 years ago
she went offtune in some notes but i think even if she went offtune she still sounds like an angel and it adds value to the song!
xdarkCRIES 2 years ago 2
oh my gooood,great.
karinayleo 2 years ago 4
Beautiful!
vickietravis 2 years ago 4
epic(:
goinghero 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
she suxxxxx
dachshundluver12 2 years ago
Hang in there Susan, stardom can be brutal.
MyHeart48 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
evilhamsterz 2 years ago
she gives me chills!(:
broadwaygal34 2 years ago 29
i love u susan
Comenter0555 2 years ago 7
ELAINE PAGE DOES IT BETTER. sorry, but i am a huge fan of cats, so....
mistomungomeow2 2 years ago
susan isnt that bad singing this song but this is definetly Elaine's song! for sure.
krystalloveselvis 2 years ago 8
Susan looked and sounded beautiful, had a cold accounting for the few "croakey notes" at the beginning of this song.
aldenbuzz 2 years ago 2
poor susan...she was so off her game that night...all the pressure. she was flat here, pitchy there..rushing in some spots...she has a beautiful voice but i guess nerves got her. understandable....she needs more practice in front of large crowds i guess to build confidence.
sarabaack 2 years ago
you're right ..
newberry58 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Elaine Page is far superior!
i think its ok, incredible is a big overstatement.
HollyMushh 2 years ago
Elaine Page has been singing professionally for a long time. You can't compare the two.
jeanjov9502 2 years ago 6
Nah I can compare the two - Susan Boyle's voice OWNS Elaine Page's voice!
baz3006 2 years ago
she should have won
lyriclex 2 years ago 41
@lyriclex who won
dumasrulez1423 1 year ago
@dumasrulez1423 Diversity, that dance troup. they were quite good
lyriclex 1 year ago
i love this song so much! and susan sang it so well!!
Its a pity she couldn't win the compeition that means she won't be able to perform in front of the queen:(
Cloud10v35Aerith 2 years ago 4
She is incredible !
manny32616 2 years ago 9
she's wonderful
twocentsin 2 years ago 6
the thing in the begining is in chris angle
microwavablebolony 2 years ago 3
So unfair she only got 2nd place!
What an angelical voice!
I have cancer and listening to her soft beautiful voice gives me peace. I wish this woman a beautiful life.
She is beautiful!
jibaradepr 2 years ago 9
i wish U a beautiful life too!
Redtracks 2 years ago 6
And you seem beautiful too. Peace be with you.
jeanjov9502 2 years ago
i think she is o.k but flawless will win lol
susanwilson13 2 years ago
it went from decent to brilliant with the scale change...
neel261087 2 years ago 4
so true. i cant stop replaying right when they change.
Mehecanogeesir 2 years ago 2
she wont win cause she doesnt need to win diversity will win
alexnzx 2 years ago
Susan remember these exact words:
Daylight
I must wait for the sunrise
I must think of a new life
And I musn't give in
When the dawn comes
Tonight will be a memory too
And a new day will begin
sassyruta 2 years ago
she is so picthy ugh that sucked
Moonligth123 2 years ago
sensational voice
viosteaua 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
a m a z i n g
gnral81 2 years ago
The way she sings the song is so moving
It made me cry
I wish her all the best in the final
iloveupeterpan 2 years ago 4
i think she's lovely (:
LiLsArCaStIcGaL 2 years ago 3
She will win BGT!!
awesome!
...she will!!!!! :)
TheSimpsonsWorld 2 years ago 4
i cant belive how amazing she is and she makes me cry WELDONE!
scholsey09 2 years ago 4
go get 'em susan!
BoxedPaperTv 2 years ago 3
Quite agree with Blondie65355
Capsicum1336 2 years ago
wow!!! susan to win!!!!
1209purple 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!
aamo215 2 years ago
Susan that was awesome!!
RunescapeFlashFlood 2 years ago 2
Les premières mesures ne sont pas terribles du tout (elle chante même faux les deux premières notes !), c'est décevant. Dommage. mais, cela semble s'arranger par la suite...
labcdaire 2 years ago
Lol, yeah she did. She's soo freaky goofy but can sing her butt off
HaveSwagCom 2 years ago
HaveSwagCom. I wonder what your comment says about you? No class, no compassion, low self-esteem? If one feels good about him/herself, they don't feel the need to belittle another person. Susan is a real, honest-to-God person. Strange, isn't it, that we seem to overlook the physical appearance of male singers, but not women.
blondie65355 2 years ago 4
She messes up at first, but that's okay!! You did wonderful!
SusanBoyleTalented 2 years ago
She was nervous. Just like you would have been!
Bernievill 2 years ago