what if all the crappy jobs are automated? then I won't need truckers whose weight in lbs. is at least four times their IQ to live anymore ... this idea of the "public good" is rather flimsy
It's about a lot of things...LIKE why game theory & instances of it like the prisoner's dilemma played in cooperatively, not competitively can have better outcomes
BUT, yes, it's also about something called Eusociality (Greek eu: "good/real" + "social") , a term used for the highest level of social organization in a hierarchical classification. It's NOT advocacy for that system particularly. It's studies its functionality
As for truckers who may be displaced from their jobs...I'm confused. These truckers are , unfortunately, not likely to do extremely well no matter what society they're living in, right? So I don't see the connection between their really bad plight and Martin Nowak's work or his book on evolutionary theory dynamics...
I could use your reasoning to say that printers are bad for society and we should instead hire scribes. The printing press replaced the scribe, and something else can replace the trucker's job. There is no reason why this would be bad for society. In fact, it would be good.
Uprated and favorited! Just today I spoke about groupthink, and yesterday, about altruism. This video will be a good supplement to share if they do well on my groupthink assignment . . .
I had come to the conclusion that morality was transactional but this seems to extend well beyond any thought I'd given it. What a lovely and brilliant young woman.
Thank you very much for bringing up this subject - the various mechanisms for the emerging of morality as we know it. It is not very simple. You can't describe this evolutionary (biological and social) process in one slogan. There are many books about it, and I would encourage a dialogue on this topic here on you tube, which is necessary, if we are to refute the theologians' ridiculous argument of 'objective' moral values, existing independantly from humans!
Yes, I agree...It's too easy to reduce the complexity of evolutionary theory to a meme like "The Selfish Gene" for example. (Something that Dawkins, himself, has objected to in the past) To get a grip on it, we need to spend time exploring the literature on the subject as dispassionately as possible
That includes some exploration of evolutionary game theory, evolutionary mathematics, the ramification of culture on evolution, & likely a number of divergent theories as well.
Thank You
Great info
f417h2GRACE 9 months ago
@f417h2GRACE
:)
I don't believe in coincidence
f417h2GRACE 9 months ago
what if all the crappy jobs are automated? then I won't need truckers whose weight in lbs. is at least four times their IQ to live anymore ... this idea of the "public good" is rather flimsy
odenskrigare 9 months ago
@odenskrigare
Sorry but it's NOT about 'public good' per se...
It's about a lot of things...LIKE why game theory & instances of it like the prisoner's dilemma played in cooperatively, not competitively can have better outcomes
BUT, yes, it's also about something called Eusociality (Greek eu: "good/real" + "social") , a term used for the highest level of social organization in a hierarchical classification. It's NOT advocacy for that system particularly. It's studies its functionality
[Con't]
2bsirius 9 months ago
(2)
As for truckers who may be displaced from their jobs...I'm confused. These truckers are , unfortunately, not likely to do extremely well no matter what society they're living in, right? So I don't see the connection between their really bad plight and Martin Nowak's work or his book on evolutionary theory dynamics...
2bsirius 9 months ago
@odenskrigare
I could use your reasoning to say that printers are bad for society and we should instead hire scribes. The printing press replaced the scribe, and something else can replace the trucker's job. There is no reason why this would be bad for society. In fact, it would be good.
mazuiface 6 months ago
Uprated and favorited! Just today I spoke about groupthink, and yesterday, about altruism. This video will be a good supplement to share if they do well on my groupthink assignment . . .
slobomotion 9 months ago
Thanks very much.
This is looks really extraordinary.
I had come to the conclusion that morality was transactional but this seems to extend well beyond any thought I'd given it. What a lovely and brilliant young woman.
DeathofSpeech 9 months ago
I watched the film. It was good. Thanks for the link.
DanaGarrett 9 months ago
Thank you very much for bringing up this subject - the various mechanisms for the emerging of morality as we know it. It is not very simple. You can't describe this evolutionary (biological and social) process in one slogan. There are many books about it, and I would encourage a dialogue on this topic here on you tube, which is necessary, if we are to refute the theologians' ridiculous argument of 'objective' moral values, existing independantly from humans!
Thanks for mentioning me, too. :)
dewinthemorning 9 months ago
@dewinthemorning
Yes, I agree...It's too easy to reduce the complexity of evolutionary theory to a meme like "The Selfish Gene" for example. (Something that Dawkins, himself, has objected to in the past) To get a grip on it, we need to spend time exploring the literature on the subject as dispassionately as possible
That includes some exploration of evolutionary game theory, evolutionary mathematics, the ramification of culture on evolution, & likely a number of divergent theories as well.
2bsirius 9 months ago
Just beginning to look at game theory. Thank you for the links.
DitM is awesome.
Celephais42 9 months ago
@Celephais42 :-)
I wouldn't go so far as to say you are wrong. :D
dewinthemorning 9 months ago