@carvehamwhole2 Did I offend you in some way? If I did i'm sorry and did not intend to :-) I don't know how I was being an ass in the video. This song blows in my opinion, I was just being silly for Kina. I met her at a concert and she remembered me so it was not in vein lol. I can't wait til my EP is released though. Waaaay better production and time spent into the actual writing.
dude your in mpls too?? NICE i like you even more better. maybe thats why you look familiar. mpls/st.paul is the place to be. actually im looking to get outta here, but its still a good home. and i dont know if my other comment went through but very nice, you pick well and your voice is surprisingly good.
@calebtrimbach What'd the comment say lol.. I think the video's pretty cool,and your sense of humors great too.. you score points from me already lol :D hehe keep singing and playings its,cool,you'd never guess it was a crappy guitar :) not that it is..
Nice voice, man! And the playing was no where near crap like you said it would be. Don't even worry about it. And with her spring tour coming, she may even come to you. Just don't drop a knee when you see her...you might not want to walk the walk just yet. Just a heads up.
and i'm ok with "musicstar247", Kina you should be grateful. I want a man who sing me this sort of song ! =) (scuse me for my english, so sorry !! :) )
it's crazy to make song for kina. I love her, yes but have you meet her ? Sorry for my english, I'm french and I don't speak englich very well. But I wana say that if I have understand, you sing for kina grannis because you love her and what she does, what she is and what she sings, no ? hmm... It's so surprising, and crazy (it's not negative when I say "crazy" !!). And your son is very beautiful, I like it ! Keep on it !
No i have not met Kina, I did the song more of just a joke. I do love her music though. I don't really love her like I would marry her because the truth is I don't know her haha
it was all a joke man, I'm not really in love with her. I shouldn't have been so serious as I was making this... but she is amazing. her voice and lyrics are pretty brillient
AHHH!! That chord progression and picking pattern was like dynamite!! And your voice matched it perfectly... too often I see musicians with talen that favors one or the other. This, however, is not the case. Your voice and guitar skills complement each other beautifully!!!
Oh, and this is a sweet gesture. :) I think you just set the standard for every guy in the room!! haha
Man, you're awesome! Like Panic! At The Disco crashed into Matt Nathanson and then they morphed together, kicked Chuck Norris' ass and then flew into space! Maybe not the last two bits but you do have a lot of talent and you should keep it up! Try busking, save up for a mic, do an Original and then take over the world... Again... Maybe not that last bit...
god...how many hearts have you melted!? You are the standard us men should attempt to attain! LEGENDARY you wouldnt mind sending me the tabs to this would you? =P i mean i can see your fingers and stuff...but it would be alot easier if i knew what the tuning was...and what capo =P...would really appreaciate it =D
it's in standard tuning in the key of E. although it's a shitty guitar so the tuning was off i don't really know what key i was in, but really I just did a walk down from E. so it's like E, Eb/E, C#m, C/E, A, B, C#m, Eb/E then it just repeats. then the chorus is just A, E, B, C#m, A, E, B ...... A, E, B, C#m, A, E, B
Have you ever considered doing recordings? Seriously like I said: I like your voice and your style A LOT.... you have a sort of Ben Folds/ Sufjan Stevens thing going on... I love it.... I do enough of this sort of thing (composing/messing around on the piano) to appreciate how hard it can be.... great job
Okay honey, ignoring the VERY SLIGHT stalker thing going on here, you are talented too and adorable... that beginning guitar thing took my breath away.... I love your voice and I would buy your music if you wrote it sweetie... don't underestimate yourselft... you're good...
Yes -- we do love Kina and her gifts! But I grin as I picture you only driving as far as Utah (*1000 miles*) stopping and saying, " ehh, that's it...far enough..."
Don't listen to the haters! This is amazing.... haha I'm sure you'll have no trouble finding a girl to fall in love with you, even if it's not Kina :oP
Your guitar playing and singing are... wow....! As Kina said in her comment, get more of your music out into the world!
How come no one else thinks this is a little creepy.... You must all be girls. This guy doesn't even know who she is, just from watching her videos and maybe going to a concert or two he says he loves her. He doesn't know what love is. By the way you do have a great voice and it is a good song, but use it on someone you know and actually have a chance with. Good luck man.
dude... for you to think i was serious about this clearly shows that you consecutively smoke marijuana. it was a joke, and yeah i think a lot of these girls are a bit weird to find this sweet. i honestly think it's frickin odd that kina said she liked it.
so i thank you for being the first person to see this as weird, cause i was trying to make a joke
You have just become my motivation! that is exactly what I'm after, being able to express myself through music..I do have a guitar but I left it back at home to get fixed while I'm away at College so I haven't played for a while...I promise to pick it up soon and as soon as I learn to play something decent I'll send it to you!!!
yeah soz 4 correcting u ( i live in Australia but i think the miles were correct ) well u should feel goood about urself ur so great i wish i could play or sing like that xoxo Claire
Oh... also your voice is awesome.. and your guitar skills are sick. Did you study music is college?
videogamejo 5 months ago
You got cojones man. I respect that. Btw I'm kind of in love with Kina too lol
videogamejo 5 months ago
Comment removed
carvehamwhole2 11 months ago
@carvehamwhole2 Did I offend you in some way? If I did i'm sorry and did not intend to :-) I don't know how I was being an ass in the video. This song blows in my opinion, I was just being silly for Kina. I met her at a concert and she remembered me so it was not in vein lol. I can't wait til my EP is released though. Waaaay better production and time spent into the actual writing.
calebtrimbach 11 months ago
this is soo cute! Kina should subscribe! seriously SO cute!!
jettoy1 1 year ago
wow.. i thought u where one of those losers who cant sing.. but ur actually great..
dramaprincess77 1 year ago
@dramaprincess77 Well thank you Darlin :-) I can't believe this was shot over two years ago lol
calebtrimbach 1 year ago
@dramaprincess77 lol well then ... Hahha but true !
courtneyheaton10 8 months ago
Q linda declaracao!!!!
kelly060489 1 year ago
wow...the guitar in the beginning..so stunningly beautiful
then you started singing- my goodness, your voice is enchanting, this vid is brilliant! keep it up
sanchovoe 1 year ago
dude your in mpls too?? NICE i like you even more better. maybe thats why you look familiar. mpls/st.paul is the place to be. actually im looking to get outta here, but its still a good home. and i dont know if my other comment went through but very nice, you pick well and your voice is surprisingly good.
rinajoyification 1 year ago
nice picking i was not expected you to be so good. your voice is velvety too. nice!
rinajoyification 1 year ago
did kina ever reply to this?
booksluggg 2 years ago
yeah, in one of the way earlier comments
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
@calebtrimbach What'd the comment say lol.. I think the video's pretty cool,and your sense of humors great too.. you score points from me already lol :D hehe keep singing and playings its,cool,you'd never guess it was a crappy guitar :) not that it is..
TheSheridanOfAnewAge 1 year ago
Nice voice, man! And the playing was no where near crap like you said it would be. Don't even worry about it. And with her spring tour coming, she may even come to you. Just don't drop a knee when you see her...you might not want to walk the walk just yet. Just a heads up.
quickattack 2 years ago
Forgot to add a smile to that. haha. So...=).
quickattack 2 years ago
this is beautiful :)
buhbuhburt 2 years ago
I LOVE YOU MY LITTLE MONSTURDS
<3 Lady GG
iamgonnafuckyourmom 2 years ago
Good job Caleb. She is one attractive gal!
Reizermo 2 years ago
hey buddy, get in line!
Sokur22 2 years ago
aw.. cutie pie
freddyfuegoNYC 2 years ago
hmmmm...we got a STALKER~!!!!!!!
PreludeSi91 2 years ago
He may be a stalker, but he's a pretty talented stalker.
colvo115 2 years ago 7
na, he's pretty lame
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
Aww its soo cute!! It nearly made me cry..i wish a guy would do that for me :/ Your nice. Well done!! It was awsome
DancerDrum123 2 years ago
thanks :-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
ite...i may have gone slightly over the top with crying...lol sorry. Good video though
DancerDrum123 2 years ago
Comment removed
muZHYkera 2 years ago
you love it
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
aaww.. that was sooo cute!! and the song is realy pretty.. I love you voice..!! please write the rest of the song.. keep it up!! *hugs*
veryconfusing 2 years ago
post a tutorial
youtubing222 2 years ago
please? lol jk
I just might
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
hahahahahhaa WTF SHES MY BABY BITCH HAHAHA
exklimexklim 2 years ago
This is really good, and you can REALLY sing.. Good job! I would love it if a guy did that for me.. :)
Jazmin2914 2 years ago
haha, you're not the first... it totally is creepy lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
damn this guys good
graffruinedmylife 2 years ago
and i'm ok with "musicstar247", Kina you should be grateful. I want a man who sing me this sort of song ! =) (scuse me for my english, so sorry !! :) )
elopelachocolat 2 years ago
it's crazy to make song for kina. I love her, yes but have you meet her ? Sorry for my english, I'm french and I don't speak englich very well. But I wana say that if I have understand, you sing for kina grannis because you love her and what she does, what she is and what she sings, no ? hmm... It's so surprising, and crazy (it's not negative when I say "crazy" !!). And your son is very beautiful, I like it ! Keep on it !
Bye !
Elodie
elopelachocolat 2 years ago
No i have not met Kina, I did the song more of just a joke. I do love her music though. I don't really love her like I would marry her because the truth is I don't know her haha
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
nice voice!!! rly sweet!!! Kina u should be grateful!!!
musicstar247 2 years ago
lol good job dude.
takopachiboy 2 years ago
you love it lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
oh my god. that was the cutest thing i've ever heard.
will you marry me?
monarabba 2 years ago
maybe? do you think we would work well?
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
haha, i think so.
i've already fallen inlove with your voice, and you seem pretty sweet, so i think it would work well. lol.
but when we do, you have to promise you'll write me a song too!
monarabba 2 years ago
well of course... I think i'm going to have to write the song my wifey and i dance to lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
haha slow down sweetheart,
well that a bit sounds kinky, lol
but maybe we should get married before you start dancing for me ;)
LOL
monarabba 2 years ago
ok a hate you cause I never thought of this. shes amazing for sure.. best of luck my friend.
kevinfitz89 2 years ago
it was all a joke man, I'm not really in love with her. I shouldn't have been so serious as I was making this... but she is amazing. her voice and lyrics are pretty brillient
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
I get it was in good fun. I dident think you were really in love with her I was supporting the cause bud
kevinfitz89 2 years ago
dude u are my idol, i wish i was talented enough to pull something like this off. did she ever respond to this video?
liedersk 2 years ago
haha thanks man
yeah she actually responded twice... if you look all the way down she's one of the first ones to comment on it
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
wow man, i was totally expecting this to not be too good (sorry, very judgemental of me i know), however, I'm actually pretty impressed. good job man
phillipmills 2 years ago
haha yeah, i do look pretty little boyish don't I? lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
this is so cute! how sweet are you...
bellesie16 2 years ago
You are like my idol in life for doint this. :D One day im going to write a song for you. Hahahaha.
Tabbitron543 2 years ago
i'm waiting... lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
haha. awh that was so sweet. You are a very skilled musician. Keep it up!
FaithieGirl572 2 years ago
so cute!!!
majshkdt 2 years ago
Wow dude...you got balls..and I can appreciate that...keep tryin man
carhemi72 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
83ajhoover 2 years ago
Comment removed
83ajhoover 2 years ago
Comment removed
83ajhoover 2 years ago
AHHH!! That chord progression and picking pattern was like dynamite!! And your voice matched it perfectly... too often I see musicians with talen that favors one or the other. This, however, is not the case. Your voice and guitar skills complement each other beautifully!!!
Oh, and this is a sweet gesture. :) I think you just set the standard for every guy in the room!! haha
FieryDeb 2 years ago 3
i think she has a bf and what effects are using to get that delay or reverb?
btruboff 2 years ago
...wow. you are extremely talented, not to mention cute for confessing your love like that:)
marisanicole4 2 years ago 3
Hello:)
This is so beautiful! If my BF did something like that, I would cry from happiness !
Keep your music!
(sorry for my english)
TheArtSoul 2 years ago
this was so good and so cute! I I didn't realize I was smiling so big until the song was over. You're awesome!
Bella11489 2 years ago
you're awesome!
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
by his description of it i thought this was gonna suck so bad....i so wrong
KingMooseSLSK 2 years ago
Man, you're awesome! Like Panic! At The Disco crashed into Matt Nathanson and then they morphed together, kicked Chuck Norris' ass and then flew into space! Maybe not the last two bits but you do have a lot of talent and you should keep it up! Try busking, save up for a mic, do an Original and then take over the world... Again... Maybe not that last bit...
Really cool man! You should be proud!
Slàn! ;)
writesingplay 2 years ago 3
hahaha thanks broseph
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
man...you are adorable! and you're great!
analtube89 2 years ago
uhh-mazinggg! (: ha, it totally does NOT sound bad!!!
toribabe034 2 years ago
haha well thanks
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
yeah i totally look like a pussy don't i lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
haha i was suprised by the first line..
but wow you have some serious talent dude.. KEEP IT UP!!
colinweeksmusic 2 years ago
shmanks :-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
lol.dude,you're good!
secretamelody 2 years ago
dude i love her so much too. grrrr. lol. hey did she ever message you or comment you?
fabian1king 2 years ago
yeah... she's one of the first people that commented on this video
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
That was a fun song. BTW, Google says that Minneapolis -> Mission Viejo is 1,928 miles...
martalli 2 years ago
Damn lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
I love Kina too! I like your voice. Very nice! Too bad the audio and video were off. Do you have other vids? I enjoyed it!
adrienne5145 2 years ago
cheaa i have other vids
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
you are good....raw talent folks
ising2love 2 years ago
ha ha i agree with the rest... BALLS!
Pretty good though man! and way to represent minneapolis!!!! we're the most underrated city in america!
andyboy713 2 years ago
hahahahaha! BALLS! you got a pair for sure!
kkimiwimi 2 years ago
haha. one brave guy. its cool how you still reply to comments about 8 months on. do you email/twitter kina?
yougivemesomethinggg 2 years ago
na... im just kind of waiting for her studio album to come out
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
I like it for reall!! :) Your Great!
MTLShawtay 2 years ago
that was so beautiful!
RiteSyte 2 years ago
your voice sounds nice but did she accept your proposal????
dynamitee8 2 years ago
haha, it was more of a joke. besides... im pretty sure her and David Choi are a thing
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
god...how many hearts have you melted!? You are the standard us men should attempt to attain! LEGENDARY you wouldnt mind sending me the tabs to this would you? =P i mean i can see your fingers and stuff...but it would be alot easier if i knew what the tuning was...and what capo =P...would really appreaciate it =D
chrislaurocksyoursox 2 years ago
it's in standard tuning in the key of E. although it's a shitty guitar so the tuning was off i don't really know what key i was in, but really I just did a walk down from E. so it's like E, Eb/E, C#m, C/E, A, B, C#m, Eb/E then it just repeats. then the chorus is just A, E, B, C#m, A, E, B ...... A, E, B, C#m, A, E, B
:-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
hahaha man u are awesome thanks a million =D
chrislaurocksyoursox 2 years ago
anytime breh! :-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
Whaaaaaaaaaaaat!?!?! Another Caleb playing guitar who likes Kina? Impossible... I challenge you to Mortal Kombat! There can only be one -_-
But seriously man, it sounds good, I can dig it. When I get a camera again you'll have to check out some of my stuff
RapidNameChange 2 years ago
haha, alright man
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
wereee yall actually dating?
casue you asked her to marry you haha
magsss7 2 years ago
lol no... it was really just a joke
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
umm not to be rude but it looks like you are lip singing! but oh well... : ]
foxprincess787 2 years ago
that's because the audio track was off the video track. i'm sorry i'm still an amateur at video editing
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
omfg you are so amazinggg <3 <3
balbulmaya 2 years ago
Amazing! love that song + your voice :)
2lovin 2 years ago
The guitar playing in this video is incredible... wow. Really good stuff; & You have an amazing voice. Great vid =)
xoRaqstar 2 years ago
thank you
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
love it.. so much.. your just too sweet.. <3
kina grannis 4evah!! xx
tangirlz 2 years ago
That'd be awesome! I unfortunately don't have garage band myself but if you want to read my lyrics you're welcome to
theCsherm 2 years ago
Have you ever considered doing recordings? Seriously like I said: I like your voice and your style A LOT.... you have a sort of Ben Folds/ Sufjan Stevens thing going on... I love it.... I do enough of this sort of thing (composing/messing around on the piano) to appreciate how hard it can be.... great job
theCsherm 2 years ago
haha, yeah i do record a lot on garage band... i could send you some shit if you'd like
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
Okay honey, ignoring the VERY SLIGHT stalker thing going on here, you are talented too and adorable... that beginning guitar thing took my breath away.... I love your voice and I would buy your music if you wrote it sweetie... don't underestimate yourselft... you're good...
theCsherm 2 years ago
haha well thank you. i hope one day i can just make a living by making others happy with my music
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
RED ALERT! RED ALERT! STALKER! LOL.
cuteguyfromcanada 2 years ago
SHIT! lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
this is just to cute! did u really just make that up? it sounded like some planning went into it..either way its great!
AmberNicoleOHW 2 years ago
na i just made it up. it's pretty crappy though lol
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
amazing.
simply put
xoxochanelxoxo 2 years ago
wow dude this is awesome and question who is kina?? does she have youtube? if she does can i get a link for her stuff?
iloveemomusic1234 2 years ago
yeah man, she's awesome... there's a link to one of her videos right under this one... the one that says this is a video response to...
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
YOU ARE SO ADORABLE THIS IS CUTE!
Rubyellen7 2 years ago
that was GOOD.
thespartanchannel 2 years ago 2
well thank you :-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
Yes -- we do love Kina and her gifts! But I grin as I picture you only driving as far as Utah (*1000 miles*) stopping and saying, " ehh, that's it...far enough..."
great song -
sgnormut 2 years ago
hahaha... i've been to Utah, good times
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
aaaaah your so adorable!
Feebslovesyou 2 years ago 2
finish the song! It is good!
jarrodabanks 2 years ago
cute in an odd way... lol very nice voice and guitar playing.
kandis912 2 years ago
actually no it's not haha it's not cute at all... but thank you :-)
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
That was so cute. I look forward to hearing more of you when you become famous!
Tricksypotater 2 years ago
Don't listen to the haters! This is amazing.... haha I'm sure you'll have no trouble finding a girl to fall in love with you, even if it's not Kina :oP
Your guitar playing and singing are... wow....! As Kina said in her comment, get more of your music out into the world!
joyzaphinemusic 2 years ago
I'm trying lol, im working on an EP
calebtrimbach 2 years ago
Well i like it even if he didnt mean it lol. the melody is reallly good and i wish i could play like that lol :L x well done i liked it ^^ x
x1xBlackx2xRainx3x 3 years ago
lol thanks... i like you too
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
Lol
Thankyou
<3
x1xBlackx2xRainx3x 2 years ago
How come no one else thinks this is a little creepy.... You must all be girls. This guy doesn't even know who she is, just from watching her videos and maybe going to a concert or two he says he loves her. He doesn't know what love is. By the way you do have a great voice and it is a good song, but use it on someone you know and actually have a chance with. Good luck man.
joshlake08 3 years ago
dude... for you to think i was serious about this clearly shows that you consecutively smoke marijuana. it was a joke, and yeah i think a lot of these girls are a bit weird to find this sweet. i honestly think it's frickin odd that kina said she liked it.
so i thank you for being the first person to see this as weird, cause i was trying to make a joke
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
"clearly shows that you consecutively smoke marijuana"
ignorant statement.
NICE ONE BRA
p.s. kina smokes
cooltobehip 3 years ago
I love you man... that's all there is to it
you can take it or leave it
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
You have just become my motivation! that is exactly what I'm after, being able to express myself through music..I do have a guitar but I left it back at home to get fixed while I'm away at College so I haven't played for a while...I promise to pick it up soon and as soon as I learn to play something decent I'll send it to you!!!
thank you, you're amazing, love your voice!
xx
tcholana 3 years ago 2
I am honored to be your motivation... please do send something when it happens
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
AWW! did she comment back? i bet she liked it.
pantherNJOH 3 years ago
haha yeah she did... twice!!! lol
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
holy crap! i love how you sing!
artista67 3 years ago
well shank you :-)
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
Hey Caleb, beautiful beautiful video, really!:)
Maybe she' ll understand. I don' t know, anyway that' s a sweet thinking.:)
Bye Man.:)
JuLeSpIrAtE 3 years ago
OMG when u gave ur rant at the start, i was expecting something average... but bloody hell man that was simply AMAZING!!!
pendleaussie 3 years ago
hahaha, thanks breh.... you rock
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
dude great voice you remind me of the same voice of uhhhhhhhhh fuck let me find out the band ill get back to you.
dudekevlar 3 years ago
Great job dude.
CreateCreateYours 3 years ago
Not going to lie, that was the cutest thing I've ever heard :)
mileycyrushater45 3 years ago
you must have not seen too many cute things in your life then, haha. jk thanks miley cyrus hater ;-)
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
Haha, aw. So modest. Speaking of cute things, you are one of those :O
mileycyrushater45 3 years ago
fight back atcha miley
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
Aww!
Your so sweet.
I love your voice,
and your guitar-playing is awesome :D
miniFriis 3 years ago
Aww :D
Your voice is very soothing! Cute song ^^
Mobomu 3 years ago
this is the sweetest thing i've ever seen
eerrahh 3 years ago
aw that was so cute!
pinkelephantz017 3 years ago
and my heart melted lol
RicoLovesMAC 3 years ago
CaleblovesRico&MAC
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
i really like this, and same as you i love KG!
on3p1g 3 years ago
beautiful guitar playing :)
rox1612 3 years ago
aww this is extremely cute :).
and i think that you're very good.
shelby62191 3 years ago
i think you're extremely nice :-) thanks
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
oh my goodness(: this is one of the sweetest videos i've ever seen. (:
punkurstyle 3 years ago
OMGosh you are one of the sweetest persons to ever be on youtube!
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
aw :D
punkurstyle 3 years ago
you're really good
brightlywound001 3 years ago
thanks :-)
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
hey that was really good :)
im a new fan :)
MsDaiSyXO 3 years ago
Hey your really good
Gizelle101Graceful 3 years ago
hey you're really nice :)
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
np mate good luck with the singing
icepick40 3 years ago
thanks man
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
im from englang so i ddont know how much things are over there so yeah i though i judt tell u just incase u didnt know
icepick40 3 years ago
it's cool broseph... i gotts say, i appreciate your concern
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
the mic is called a condensor mic buy them for like $140
icepick40 3 years ago
i actually just bought a three hundred dollar one... i know what a condenser mic is, it just slipped my mind.
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
i think its 1700 miles from Minnneapolis to california but still it was a funny joke i loved the melody and ur awsome picking skills
CleaChVon91 3 years ago
i love your ability to make me feel good about myself :-)
calebtrimbach 3 years ago
yeah soz 4 correcting u ( i live in Australia but i think the miles were correct ) well u should feel goood about urself ur so great i wish i could play or sing like that xoxo Claire
CleaChVon91 3 years ago
well thank you claire... it's greatly appreciated
calebtrimbach 3 years ago