I have no idea why this is disliked so much. This is a cover, not a copy. Personally, I'm tired of uninspired „cover“ songs that just imitate the original song. I'm glad to see that Frank Turner made something different in his own style...
I disagree, not that I don't like the original, but, I think the power in this one comes from Frank's singing. The very stark, bleak sound, and his pain and desperation, which is very clear in his voice.
Having just gone and watched the Shellac version, and having seen the abuse Frank's getting, i really can't understand why you lot are moaning. Shellac just seem to be another wrist-slitting i'm-so-fucking-miserable band. Frank's got a fantastic education, a good sense of humour and understands irony and satire. Frank's version is better if i might offer my opinion.
Actually, Steve Albini is a fantastic songwriter. (His songs consist of repeating and amplifying a single conceit beyond the point of hyperbole--if I might offer my opinion.) His songs are about obsession and the uglier parts of life, but none of it has ever struck me as anything close to suicidal., or miserable. Try again.
Oh, well there we are then. Sorry Frank, don't even think about playing this again. Ever. Sorry. Can't have the youtube dwellers getting upset, can we?
frank turner is a fuckin ace guy and musician!! he has more spare talent coming out of his fucking arse hole than anyone who has given him abuse here!!!!!!! when a song is put out it is open to interpritation by anyone!!!!! all of your favourite bands will have covered songs by someone at some point. is it just too weird that somone else has heard a song you like and can relate to?????????
omgz frank what were u thinkin coverin a song u lyke m8?! get a fucking grip people covers aren't about playing lets copy the artist we're covering. Maybe Steve Albini would want to punch Frank in the face, but I'd take a shit on his....cool.
don't get me wrong, I'm no fan of this guy and its not amazing but all these comments are surprising. its not that bad. is it the english accent that's ruining it? I don't really get it. for a guy that used to be in million dead who's trying to cover a great song, he did as good a job as anyone could
Sounds like he's crying like a woman....
DirdeeD 1 week ago
I have no idea why this is disliked so much. This is a cover, not a copy. Personally, I'm tired of uninspired „cover“ songs that just imitate the original song. I'm glad to see that Frank Turner made something different in his own style...
Dezibelchen 5 months ago
awkward.
lollercoaster2010 10 months ago
I have that shirt.
xrockthe40ozx 11 months ago
I liked it..
Taranis2734 2 years ago
Oh dear...
asparagushunter 2 years ago
wow, that's actually awful. if steve albini was dead, he's be turning in his grave.
peeveee 2 years ago
@peeveee Dont speak of such things lol!
grandmasterdeafchild 11 months ago
total shit.
wwxoxww 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Playing this acoustically is a disgrace to the original. Without the energy and crunch of the drums and bass the song is nothing.
kja30 3 years ago
I disagree, not that I don't like the original, but, I think the power in this one comes from Frank's singing. The very stark, bleak sound, and his pain and desperation, which is very clear in his voice.
ExUSSailor 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This version made me vomit.
no offence to the frank turner appreciation society.
I love you all.
but seriously...
it sounds like eagle eye cherry.
mrbarkmarket 3 years ago
this is epic.
xkbix 3 years ago
Three years ago today. How times change.
bluesgunner 3 years ago
"Shellac just seem to be another wrist-slitting i'm-so-fucking-miserable band"
dont make a comment about a band you dont know.
jamjargod 3 years ago
who said that??? what an idiot, he/she couldn't be anymore wrong!
thepriceofreality 3 years ago
Having just gone and watched the Shellac version, and having seen the abuse Frank's getting, i really can't understand why you lot are moaning. Shellac just seem to be another wrist-slitting i'm-so-fucking-miserable band. Frank's got a fantastic education, a good sense of humour and understands irony and satire. Frank's version is better if i might offer my opinion.
Stoli712 4 years ago
you are a fucking twat
jamjargod 4 years ago
why is he?
keppel7822 3 years ago
Actually, Steve Albini is a fantastic songwriter. (His songs consist of repeating and amplifying a single conceit beyond the point of hyperbole--if I might offer my opinion.) His songs are about obsession and the uglier parts of life, but none of it has ever struck me as anything close to suicidal., or miserable. Try again.
mynameistrue 3 years ago
Is that a Black Flag t-shirt?
funkOphile 4 years ago
i belive it is
jamjargod 4 years ago
im a huge Albini fan
And this is good people
if it was his own song you'd all be like "wow wel done frank" but just because it doesnt sound like shellac its all "crap"
jamjargod 4 years ago
don't play that song again!
steplo01 4 years ago
Really humorous video.
mradamcooley 4 years ago
Well done, what kind of douche wants to hear an exact copy?
megnzoe 4 years ago
a hairy douche
thepriceofreality 4 years ago
Just can't do it acoustic.
Nice spin on it though.
Not enough angry behind it really.
dgal2010 4 years ago
god, you can't cover shellac if you are a pussy!
meyouhesheit 4 years ago
Oh, well there we are then. Sorry Frank, don't even think about playing this again. Ever. Sorry. Can't have the youtube dwellers getting upset, can we?
utensilattack 4 years ago 2
it just needs drums+bass.
SonicCommieBlock 4 years ago
frank turner is a fuckin ace guy and musician!! he has more spare talent coming out of his fucking arse hole than anyone who has given him abuse here!!!!!!! when a song is put out it is open to interpritation by anyone!!!!! all of your favourite bands will have covered songs by someone at some point. is it just too weird that somone else has heard a song you like and can relate to?????????
smellmacheese 4 years ago
i only listened to the first three chords... and hung my head in shame for him...
hesamouthbreather 4 years ago
he takes all the irony out of the song, all thats left his self obsession. he just misses the point, its an uncoverable song.
seniorclapshishands 4 years ago
This is truly terrible. Way to drain this song of all emphasis and expression with your shit RAWWK intonation. This guy has no talent at all.
timhulio 4 years ago
omg frank is god u r ummm wankers and million dead r amzing well were no acherly there music is still amzing
vwmacgyiver 5 years ago
i think he covered it well
not the kinda guy you expect to cover shellac
jamjargod 5 years ago
diediediediediediediediediediedie!!!
RandyMahnke 5 years ago
omgz frank what were u thinkin coverin a song u lyke m8?! get a fucking grip people covers aren't about playing lets copy the artist we're covering. Maybe Steve Albini would want to punch Frank in the face, but I'd take a shit on his....cool.
roflharris1 5 years ago
Fuck Million Dead and fuck this guy for covering Shellac. Idiot.
edpanda 5 years ago
don't get me wrong, I'm no fan of this guy and its not amazing but all these comments are surprising. its not that bad. is it the english accent that's ruining it? I don't really get it. for a guy that used to be in million dead who's trying to cover a great song, he did as good a job as anyone could
thischarmingman84 5 years ago
I'm sure Steve Albini wants to punch this guy in the face.
itzSommyJr 5 years ago
hahaha oh my god this sucks
gayassghost 5 years ago
well i fuking love it so fuk off u bunch of pikys
vwmacgyiver 5 years ago
fucking CUNT
z00yorker 5 years ago
verybadstopthisnow!
cymatic 5 years ago
dear oh dear,
do not cover shellac songs, got it!
anystandards1888 5 years ago
yikes
dudeliketotally 5 years ago
horrid, truly horrid.
sjkdhfkjfshdgkhdg 5 years ago
What a fucking idiot.
dirtyzine 5 years ago
It's much creepier like this, that's for sure.
fukembucky 5 years ago
this guy gets on my tits.
sprattsbonio 5 years ago
That's a bit off. Off like cheese. Mind you, he did used to be in Million Deadzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz........
lickmydecalsoff 5 years ago
Nice take on the song.
Love it.
Fatshit6 5 years ago