Streetlight just sounds more professional while Catch feels like a garage band performance. Both have their own sound despite being so similar.
In Catch, you can here the little hickups and provides a "care free" swooning attitude towards their music. Kind of like, let loose and go nuts.
In Streetlight, we have strong musical talent combined with perfection, sort of how Catch was suppose to sound. The quality is clear and the music flows better providing the intention given.
here we go ..some poser band destroying the legacy of real Ska and punk music..stop this nonsense..this is not real Ska or punk...People expand your mind...LISTEN TO THE REAL THING....
Besides, Tom himself avoids referring to Streetlight as Ska, punk, skapunk, or even putting a genre of it. And I agree. Streetlight is so awesome that it transcends genre. So go be a hipster somewhere else; we'll stay here enjoying some kickass music.
@vnvnation06 Oh I'm sorry. I like music because it sounds good not just because it happens to fit in a specific genre. I'm sorry if I'm just another supporter of a band that's destroying legacies. Perhaps they are making their own with music that is different from any genre. As long as it's a basic similarity then that's all that matters because Genres are designed to let people know what they like and what other bands play somewhat the same type. Not to stifle creativity.
@vnvnation06 From what I've come to conclude, any band claiming to be 'punk' ever in the history of the entire musical world is a poser band. Even the ones that weren't posers because they eventually sold out and became posers because of it.
P.S. Streetlight is a conglomeration of several musical genres and as such are no single genre themselves. I find it hard to understand by what "expand your mind" means when it comes to such a musically diverse group.
@vnvnation06 Bro, this is the second streetlight vid i've seen you on... if you hate them so much then stop searching their songs. see what i did there youtube?
I love both versions I mean really there both amazing albums and versions Best bands ever really almost same band different lead singer slighty different sound. But Can't go wrong with either album there both equal as in best albums to me ..
@riseagainst112994 I respectfully disagree. I wouldn't even mind so much if they occasionally did it the right way. But they never do. Then again, I've always despised acoustic versions of anything.
Streetlight Manifesto covered an entire Catch album because the genius behind Streetlight was in Catch when they recorded the album and wanted to "take his songs back"/make them better.
okk let me explain tom formed a band called gimp then from that formed catch 22, he went to colledge and when he got done catch22 was over already so i got some old members and started up streetlight, he then re recorded the keasby knights album thats why there songs are all the same, i like catch 22 better though because it was when they where younger and its got more life and energy itll never be the same again.
LOL dude if anything the SLM ver of the album is better, and if anything Catch 22's best CD is keasby where as SLM has 2 albums that are equivalent or better then keasby. How can you like catch22 better, they're better now as SLM then catch22 ever was or will be. SLM still doesn't have a single bad cd where as catch 22 has many.
Actually, Catch 22 was still a band at that time, and has continued producing records to this day.
Streetlight formed from some members of Catch 22, but also from members of another New Jersey-based Ska band called One Cool Guy.
He re-recorded the album because Catch 22 was going to re-release the album, and Tomas wanted to at least re-record it to make it sound better, as explained in the outro of "1234-1234".
All that being said, Catch 22 and Streetlight are both awesome as hell...
DrVonSka, you have won the award of "most polite explanation on Youtube". Congratulations. Also, that's the first time I've seen the correct explanation.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
first off who the fuck r u? you just talk shit to random people online u fuck. secondly i meant new as in not a classic rock band. i consider ne band from mid 90's 00's to be new. and streetlight is new generation/wave ska newayz..retard
Anyone that isnt tone-deaf or has the slightest bit of musical knowledge would tell you that the C22 version is MUCH worse due to the horrible hornline.
In the Streetlight version, the hornline doesnt sound like a bag of shit, the tempo of the song doesnt change every 5 seconds, and the guitar parts are cleaned up significantly.
@KymeraGR7 yeah you misunderstood haha i know this is the streetlight version. i said "it is the original" cause catch's version was the last one i had referred to in my comment
YES SEEING THEM TOMORROW!!!! So fucking pumped to see 'em at toads!!!! Second time since NYC!!!! WITH REEL BIG FISH HOW THE FUCK COULD IT GET BETTER THAN THIS!?!?! I LOVE FUCKING LIFE RIGHT NOW!!!!!!
Holy craaaaaaaaaaap this is awsome! :D
Cactusman96 5 months ago
any suggestions for a first time listener of ska?
Alejandro4891 6 months ago
@Alejandro4891 you're listening to it.
TSDAudioDeck 5 months ago in playlist Streetlight Manifesto
@Alejandro4891 The Toasters.
SMfan199 5 months ago
@Alejandro4891 Streetlight Manifesto, Big D, Mustard Plug, the Toasters.
maciasterence 5 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Streetlight Manifesto
@shnee12- you do realize they are nearly the same band right?
sk8eerbooy44 6 months ago in playlist Streetlight Manifesto
@sk8eerbooy44 waddafug??
TSDAudioDeck 5 months ago in playlist Streetlight Manifesto
Streetlight just sounds more professional while Catch feels like a garage band performance. Both have their own sound despite being so similar.
In Catch, you can here the little hickups and provides a "care free" swooning attitude towards their music. Kind of like, let loose and go nuts.
In Streetlight, we have strong musical talent combined with perfection, sort of how Catch was suppose to sound. The quality is clear and the music flows better providing the intention given.
I love'em both.
supercoolninjayo 7 months ago
Experts call the genre streetlight belongs too FUCKING AWESOME.
TalkingTadPol 9 months ago
the difference between catch 22 and SM to me is that C22 is raw as balls and SM SOUNDS like they did it in a recording studio
C22 versions are imperfect, hell yea, which makes it more exciting to me
if i want to listen to something clean id listen to radiohead or something not ska lol
my 2c
schemes16 10 months ago
@schemes16 See, now that's a position I can understand. It's not my philosophy, but at least you make sense. Kudos for that, man -- to each his own.
trdl23 9 months ago
here we go ..some poser band destroying the legacy of real Ska and punk music..stop this nonsense..this is not real Ska or punk...People expand your mind...LISTEN TO THE REAL THING....
vnvnation06 10 months ago
@vnvnation06 lol wut?
khack45456 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@vnvnation06 lol wut?
khack45456 10 months ago
@vnvnation06 Art thou roused, sire?
Besides, Tom himself avoids referring to Streetlight as Ska, punk, skapunk, or even putting a genre of it. And I agree. Streetlight is so awesome that it transcends genre. So go be a hipster somewhere else; we'll stay here enjoying some kickass music.
trdl23 10 months ago 4
@vnvnation06 Oh I'm sorry. I like music because it sounds good not just because it happens to fit in a specific genre. I'm sorry if I'm just another supporter of a band that's destroying legacies. Perhaps they are making their own with music that is different from any genre. As long as it's a basic similarity then that's all that matters because Genres are designed to let people know what they like and what other bands play somewhat the same type. Not to stifle creativity.
Conchobear 8 months ago
@vnvnation06 From what I've come to conclude, any band claiming to be 'punk' ever in the history of the entire musical world is a poser band. Even the ones that weren't posers because they eventually sold out and became posers because of it.
P.S. Streetlight is a conglomeration of several musical genres and as such are no single genre themselves. I find it hard to understand by what "expand your mind" means when it comes to such a musically diverse group.
JenkinzFilmz 7 months ago
@vnvnation06 Bro, this is the second streetlight vid i've seen you on... if you hate them so much then stop searching their songs. see what i did there youtube?
VraiDave 6 months ago 3
Listen closely at 1:22 someone's sing WAY FAST lyrics in the background. What are they lol?
MrNickeh 11 months ago
@MrNickeh It's that part from Keasbey Nights "I can fade away to anywhere don't stop, Because you might get stopped."
itskragus 10 months ago
Well fuck me I was slightly wrong same lead singer sue me ..
sickboy5284 11 months ago
I love both versions I mean really there both amazing albums and versions Best bands ever really almost same band different lead singer slighty different sound. But Can't go wrong with either album there both equal as in best albums to me ..
sickboy5284 11 months ago
@sickboy5284 same lead singer different band
DanielJacksonSg1civ 11 months ago
if anything this song dosent make me feel sick or sad
8ninjaguy8 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song is great !!!
Pumarastafari 1 year ago
I really wish Streetlight would play this song the right way live. It sounds so bad acoustic.
stanthehamman 1 year ago
@stanthehamman not at all it sounds amazing acoustic, not as good as this version but its still pretty good
riseagainst112994 11 months ago
@riseagainst112994 I respectfully disagree. I wouldn't even mind so much if they occasionally did it the right way. But they never do. Then again, I've always despised acoustic versions of anything.
stanthehamman 11 months ago
enfermo y triste¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
SuperAlejoman 1 year ago 3
I'm turning this into a band arrangement.
sharki766 1 year ago
@aHaikuDaily
Ah so THAT'S what the first line of that bit is.
I could only ever make out the "Don't stop 'cause you might get dropped". Thanks for that!
TheSidewalkCipher 1 year ago
Comment removed
shaneshaneshane94 1 year ago
@shaneshaneshane94 no, just no.
umjim 1 year ago
this versionof sick and sad has not the melodic screams of the second singer, i like it a lot in the catch 22 version
ignaciokehr 1 year ago
I like Catch 22 better but they're both good.
AmandaBanshee 1 year ago
i cant wait im seeing them April 23rd<33333 its gonna be sick
STREETLIGHT<3
Piggy2bacon 1 year ago
sick and sad again (do doo doo doo do doo do doo)
the horns in this rule
rocketgem79 1 year ago
hey does anyone know what the backup lyrics at 1:20 says?
popeOpanda 2 years ago
oh dud you can barely hear it, i thought you were talking about the" And I!" part but theres def somestuff after 1:20
i think its just repeating the words though like
i win against them (agaisnt them)
i dont care (dont care)
i'll follow her (follow her)
to anywhere (anywhere
wtmyageagain 2 years ago
oh i found out, its a part from kesby nights
popeOpanda 2 years ago
"Well I don't care, I can fade away to anywhere, don't stop cause you might get dropped"
Klonny 2 years ago 2
im so confused, i thought this was a catch 22 song??
xxVERYxMUCHxALIVExx 2 years ago
Streetlight Manifesto covered an entire Catch album because the genius behind Streetlight was in Catch when they recorded the album and wanted to "take his songs back"/make them better.
EternalChaotix 2 years ago 3
i am confused too
Demophobie 2 years ago
Comment removed
gamer4life444 2 years ago
Streetlight redid this album when Kalnoky left and formed Streetlight.
lokrat2 2 years ago
i like how every one is finding out about gimp just now
wateregg004 2 years ago
okk let me explain tom formed a band called gimp then from that formed catch 22, he went to colledge and when he got done catch22 was over already so i got some old members and started up streetlight, he then re recorded the keasby knights album thats why there songs are all the same, i like catch 22 better though because it was when they where younger and its got more life and energy itll never be the same again.
revenge507 2 years ago
LOL dude if anything the SLM ver of the album is better, and if anything Catch 22's best CD is keasby where as SLM has 2 albums that are equivalent or better then keasby. How can you like catch22 better, they're better now as SLM then catch22 ever was or will be. SLM still doesn't have a single bad cd where as catch 22 has many.
crystalreports 2 years ago
Actually, Catch 22 was still a band at that time, and has continued producing records to this day.
Streetlight formed from some members of Catch 22, but also from members of another New Jersey-based Ska band called One Cool Guy.
He re-recorded the album because Catch 22 was going to re-release the album, and Tomas wanted to at least re-record it to make it sound better, as explained in the outro of "1234-1234".
All that being said, Catch 22 and Streetlight are both awesome as hell...
DrVonSka 2 years ago 10
DrVonSka, you have won the award of "most polite explanation on Youtube". Congratulations. Also, that's the first time I've seen the correct explanation.
SkankingDonkey 2 years ago
why are there songs by catch 22 and streetlight manifesto that are exactly the same....
GO CATCH 22
fxhasthemovies 2 years ago 2
cos the first album was written by the lead singer of streetlight manifesto you nit
lsmedal 2 years ago
because the singer from catch 22 letf amd made streetlight
manchillout 2 years ago
fuck my little brother for leaving comments with my youtube account
fxhasthemovies 2 years ago
streetlight is worlds greatest band, that isnt from the classic rock era. jeeze do i have to specify exactly without get flamed
chronz17777 2 years ago
streetlight =worlds greatest new band
chronz17777 2 years ago 5
there not new. retard
plzman1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
first off who the fuck r u? you just talk shit to random people online u fuck. secondly i meant new as in not a classic rock band. i consider ne band from mid 90's 00's to be new. and streetlight is new generation/wave ska newayz..retard
chronz17777 2 years ago
Chill man.
123JoeD456 2 years ago
idiot
leeham987 2 years ago 3
HA some one put a thumbs up HA
plzman1 2 years ago 2
Keasbey Nights album was better as Catch 22
CHRISPWNS1233 2 years ago 4
Anyone that isnt tone-deaf or has the slightest bit of musical knowledge would tell you that the C22 version is MUCH worse due to the horrible hornline.
In the Streetlight version, the hornline doesnt sound like a bag of shit, the tempo of the song doesnt change every 5 seconds, and the guitar parts are cleaned up significantly.
Go listen to the backstreet boys idiot
Patoj007 2 years ago
while i agree that the streetlight version is much more... musical, i don't think you should look down on someone for liking catch's version more.
i mean, it is the original, and does seem to have this energy that streetlight can't quite capture.
but streetlight is way better.
shnee12 2 years ago 45
wow how can u honostly say street is better.. dont get me wrong there both amazing i just liek the original more
plzman1 2 years ago
no i mean all the other stuff is way better.
but i'll listen to catch's version of keasbey if i want to listen to something with some good energy.
shnee12 2 years ago
@shnee12 streetlight=catch22
jello4life73 1 year ago
@jello4life73 not quite, they had the same singer but other than that they are seperate bands
bendl2 1 year ago
@bendl2
i think he meant in quality they are the same
Eggbert1x 1 year ago
@shnee12 true, though i love most of Catch's versions of the Keasbey Nights songs more, some of Streetlight's are better.
jwaey 1 year ago
@shnee12 whatchoo talkin bout willis. this IS NOT catch 22 and the original. LOL or have i misunderstood you?
KymeraGR7 4 months ago
@KymeraGR7 yeah you misunderstood haha i know this is the streetlight version. i said "it is the original" cause catch's version was the last one i had referred to in my comment
shnee12 4 months ago
@shnee12 oooooohhhhhhhhh my bad ;D
KymeraGR7 4 months ago
i TOTALY agree with u dude! all these other guys r fags.
gamer4life444 2 years ago
I LOVE STREET LIGHT MANIFESTO!
CharlieWHU 3 years ago 31
What does the guy in the background say between 1:22 to 1:25? Cuz I can't find out on lyric sites
SvishSvish 3 years ago
Here is the verse:
I try so hard and I never give in,
and I am never satisfied
until the day that I win against them.
But I don't care I'll follow her to anywhere.
your looking for the 2nd two lines
justinlegend8800 3 years ago
"Well I don't care, I can fade away to anywhere, don't stop cause you might get dropped"
it's the prechorus to Keasby nights.
gh2addict 3 years ago 2
YES SEEING THEM TOMORROW!!!! So fucking pumped to see 'em at toads!!!! Second time since NYC!!!! WITH REEL BIG FISH HOW THE FUCK COULD IT GET BETTER THAN THIS!?!?! I LOVE FUCKING LIFE RIGHT NOW!!!!!!
RLhockey203 3 years ago
i love streetlight so much! i cant wait to see them in NYC sooooon
LedHendrix6969 3 years ago
Song quality is subpar.
Richterman1 3 years ago
i love this song. thanks Enfusory!
dion5441 3 years ago
dood u have a lot of streetlight manifesto vidz good job =)
rvpfan 3 years ago
Thank You
bbloto 3 years ago