Nightwish - Bye Bye Beautiful

[morpius13]

let's see tarja try to sing this.....

[Becks790]

very good job, anette

[YumesDream]

I like Anette singing her own songs because I really can't understand what died in their minds as they decided Anette singing TARJAS Songs... I am quiet a Tarja Fan, she's the goddess of the singing, but I really like Anette more performing her own songs. Because they are the songs she at least don't destroy.. And by the way she really had a nice voice singing her own songs..

[PsyloOfficial]

Im gonna go with..Empuu is the best. Just because...listen to that guitar. He dont miss ANYTHING! ...ROck on Empuu... /\m/\



[Wampa842]

Tarja or Anette. Anette or Tarja. SHUT THE FUCK UP, MARCO IS THE BEST!

[hortonfuturecentre]

She looks like Janine from Eastenders lol

[armes30]

Tarja is Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

[YelwSow]

shes soooo cute *_*

[loser2theMAX]

best moment: 1:17

[FireLysm]

Pop bjach! Nightwish change that lame pop princes please !!

[nestor8629]

Tarja!!Tarja!!Tarja!!!!, fuck anette!!!



[DDKPDK]

I can barely hear Marco`s voice

[LTCannibal68]

wtf marco?

[TheRamsteinWarrior]

@MrMylifeboy And i totally agree with you

[nikininja3]

no passion, no power, no Nightwish

[kinkylien]

omg tuomas has a other puppet on his keyboard :o

[SMBGamer]

Anette is amazing live. She has talent.

[angelsdoweep]

@SMBGamer talent for other band or genre. not for nightwish

[jhjkhkjkjhjkhkjk]

I wanna see Anette sings Stargazers or Siren :DD It will be so funny :D

[Sitexful]

@jhjkhkjkjhjkhkjk Maybe, but may you want see Eminem sings Ave Marja? Why comparing Anette to Tarja? They are the two other singers... Anette CAN sing, look at this one watch?v=kJzA43L3M3I&feature=re­lated ;P

[jhjkhkjkjhjkhkjk]

Anette can sing, but her own songs, not Tarja's, its too hard for her...

Not bad song from her own :))

[darkgothic8]

i need to die to feel alive? huu?

[darkgothic8]

(b)lowlands =D

[mjroris]

pienso q ella canta bien pero que ya no cante en vivo la musica de tarja la mata!!!

[tamagochi48]

pues yo veo a los fans cantar muy felices como lo ahria yo pq esta gente en concierto debe ser impresionante.yo los conoci hace poco y me parece q anette tiene una voz muy bonita y buena para este grupo..tarja era buena, pero ya se fue, asi que...a seguir disfrutando!

[RobinGothic16]

Tarja couldn't have done this song any better :)

[katalinaheathcliff]

pinche cancion tan mas ardida, que ridiculo tuomas, yo ke anette no me prestaba a berrear eso..

[rauloliveiraful]

Anette é uma otima cantora e tem uma otima performance de palco...

[AcePilotAldan]

Good god look at all of the twits here. Anette != Tarja. If you want Tarja, go somewhere else you pining fools.

Anette sings very beautifully, and IN A DISTINCTLY DIFFERENT STYLE. When you compare her to Tarja, it's like comparing apples to oranges, to use a terribly old (but true) cliche.

I know you want the past to come back, but you need to stop weeping and move on. Tarja has two decent albums so go listen to those (and old Nightwish). Please stop posting such hateful comments.

[Sharkis12]

She is ugly, she cannot sing, she is hopelesss....bye

[HawleyChanna]

@Sharkis12 I dare you to post up something of yourself singing her stuff, its hard. and she isnt ugly; thats just mean. and kind of immature.

I like the era with Tarja better too, but I like this Nightwish and Anette plays her part well, Tarja wouldent fit into this song at all. ever. They are both good in thier own ways to Nightwish, its about preference

niether sings better than the other, its about style. if they sang in the same style then you could judge.

[Sharkis12]

@HawleyChanna

1) Im not singer, Im guitarist.

2) Nightwish with Tarja ---> Masterpiece, Nightwish now ---> Usual band with frontgirl

3) Well Anette tried to sing Sleeping sun and a lot of the other Tarja stuff and she failed hard... so why cant I compare??

[gentletuesday]

@HawleyChanna Tarja wouldn't fit to this song? LOL...no, she would just put that song much more epic than this. In this song Anette is not out of tune, but it is more a mainstream song, with a common voice.

And you are not right. Tarja knows how to sing. Not because of opera education, just because she CAN sing.

A good singer don't get out of tune like Anette. It's not a question of prefenrece, it's a question of opening your hears :D

[96luddelus]

I love nightwish! I cant stop listening to this song, it´s so good =)

[mathouneify]

please Annette stop singing àr learn how to sing because my ears are hurt!!!!!!!

[seven7du5t]

wow she has a sexy body!!!!

[kaify12]

2:20 to 2:40

Anette did a great job

I really like this part

[ambmartins]

primeira banda que vejo querer mudar pra pior... voz muito fina, pra esse estilo de música fica horrível.

[Anettelover10]

ahhhhhhhhh, the voice of an angel....

[skumpik666]

Her moves are not natural, she's fake.

[kim0mandelli]

@skumpik666 Tarja's moves, like a Brazilian funk dancer, were SO natural, huh?

[96luddelus]

@skumpik666 HA HA " her moves are not natural" well tell me then what natural moves are?  And whats fake about Anette? She rocks!!!

[gentletuesday]

@96luddelus She moves well, but the more important thing - to sing - is not so good... Most of the times she gets out of tune. She is a common singer, who gives a 'pop' sound to Nightwish...

[NightwishFanGreece]

Awesome crowd! They are in Netherlands I think..

They must love NW very much there! :D

[ricsim78]

Tarja: More dramatic, fitting for older songs of Nightwish. Arrogant, no band member should ever feel they do not "need" their band. No one needs to be in a band, they should want to be in the band. Seemed to let everything get to her head, she felt too good for Nightwish. Negative.

Anette: Great voice, fits in better with the band's new music than Tarja would. Seems like a sweet person, the band seems a lot happier and she is very talented. Positive.

Nightwish: Amazing either way!

[SilverNirvash]

-sigh-...i love anettes voice just because its so beautiful...but....if it was tarja it woulda come out much more dramatic...thats the one thing anette can't compare to tarja in....she had the ability to make even the softest song seem completely deep and dramatic. just look at the crowd....they arent pumped up as much as tarja got them going....its just not the same anymore. it sounds nice but not AS good if you ask me.

[BlackMoses009]

You all can keep whining and crying 'bout how Nightwish became Pop or whatever, but one thing is undeniable: Now that Tarja and her "Look at me, I'm the best" attitude are GONE, and Anette and her charisma (not just physical appearance here, but behavior) are in the band, you can actually see the guys enjoying the whole thing. Some fans aren't happy, but the rest of Nightwish is happy, so fuck you all, Anette haters, she excels at the essential point where Tarja failed.

[Juliamk9]

Since Anette is in nightwish, this turned into a pop band. God damn .l. fuck ya anette :c i want tarja back!

[sokete3000]

i would so fuck the shit out of anette

[JacobGrimmFollower]

burk

[maddostar]

nightwish is pop now ¬¬

[EdwardAlchemist343]

@maddostar

You really dont know anything about music

If you think this is pop, then you dont know the styles of music, maybe Nightwish changed, but they're still awesome

[maddostar]

@EdwardAlchemist343

ok they're awesome and everything only if you say so..

but I have to say annette's voice is bad ¬¬ you've got to recognize and don't be one more blind fan.....thank u .

[EdwardAlchemist343]

@maddostar

Anette voice is not bad, and im not a blind fan, im a fan of NIGHTWISH, not a Tarja Fan or an Anette Fan, i love the band, no matter whos the singer

Anette is one of the best singers i've ever seen, one of my inspiration, maybe you think is bad, but i think is awesome

[Laxkiithaaax]

Vale mierda wm .. kiero a liv kristine de buelta

[reveprofond]

@Laxkiithaaax

Por qué Liv Kristine? Nada que ver... cuec xD

[anaglyfos]

I still can't understand why they don't have the bassist do the lead vocals.

[catstrings]

if Marco would be lead vocals, nightwish sound's like his other band Tarot

[LizPer49]

Me neather.. <<

[freakinthefoghell]

she sees a little fat

[freakinthefoghell]

I don´t hate her..

but her hair it´s horrible!!!

[LizPer49]

Agree =D

[nightwalkerca]

she sings better with the new song cause the song is just made for her. if she tries old songs which Tarja used to sing. she probably found out it might be tough.

[azurebel87]

She sings better new songs (:

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

The first think i must say is:

I want Tuomas' Edward Scissorhands o.o!!!

The second think is that i do like the song and I feel kinda fun when i remember nw's show at my country, particularly in this song some guys where singing -''singing''- 'Bye bye Tarjaful'' ...i am not saying is 'correct' i think of Tarja in a respectful way, but honestly, it was funny ._. -and in my particular point of view, we can say the same of Anette with some songs, like Slaying the dream which she sings terrible.

[bloodybuterfly]

they`re boring now...Tarja...8-|

I agree "vertigo21aa"

[elpeppo75]

lol ,at 0,28sec

[vertigo21aa]

i fall in love with this band first time i heard it, great guitar sounds, drums and bass, and the singer put the last garin to make a perfect, awesome band......

now i'm disapoiment, and i fell the band boring and weak..... no offense

[milaina22]

I like the friendliness of it, the smile, charisma, humility overflowing, it is very cute.

I'm Anettete ♥

(my english is poor)²

[danielbox66]

wow, the first song where anette not clash!

lol anette sucks.

[r0k94]

omg tarja cant come back-she on her own now! but if u wish her back soo much try to imagine her sing this song... O_O

[zelkim]

I think that Anette sings well, is beautiful, and deserves to be in Nightish ... Tarja sang well, but is no longer part of nightwish ... In my opinion, the new music of Nightwish, Tarja would sing like hell, so for now I prefer Anette in Nighwish ... (sorry, my english is poor).

[salizar125]

A: your english is fine and B: I couldnt agree more

[360Darkaro]

@zelkim

oooh how stupid!!!!!!!! you think Tarja would sing like hell one fucking album!!! I think Anette sings like hell all the albums before her!!!!!! who would be so stupid to compare one damn album with ten years of Nightwish with Tarja!!!

[bleed767]

@zelkim ell yeah!!they both rock!!if you pick one nobody else is good!both is bad as hell!!!!!

[FireLysm]

@zelkim Holy shit man, you're such an ignorant. Don't you see? OK she's trying, she would do fine in rock band with lower expectations... songs have been wrote for professional singer with higher voice tone, which she doesn't have. She's humming half of the songs, and trying to sync. notes that she can't really sing. Zelkim, 3:20 what is this man ? Can you explain?? Not even humming dude.. she's choking. Whole NW team is just sorry that they kicked Tarja, they just don't have balls to say it!!

[himelodykek]

@FireLysm fucking rtarded she does that on purpose you stupid moron -.- lol no way how stupid can u be ;) ? /pat

[zelkim]

Acho que a Anette canta bem, é bonita, e merece estar no Nightish... Tarja cantava bem, mas não faz mais parte do nightwish... Na minha opinião, nas músicas novas do Nightwish, a Tarja iria cantar super mal, por isso no momento prefiro a Anette no Nighwish...

[Tarjista1]

oooo esto es nightwish ,,,,,

jaja parece cuento de horror

nightwish o lo k keda con chuki....

[AnYyYsEk400]

Anette is horrible__Tarja pleas<3

[SeriouslyLooL]

Haha AnYyYsEk400, Anette is way better for the band than Tarja, Tarja is Great i agree but, Anette is still better, her style is totally new for the band, and that makes them better, you can't keep everything in the way it just to be.

your opinion is okay, but write it in one of the old videos instead of flaming Anette on her videos :)

btw you are Horrible ..!..

[daSemPre9Ro4]

TARJA TURN BACK! <3

[EddyDeepSilentNight]

anette go to home,tarja please return,,

[lunasyk]

yo siendo fan de tarja me desespera tanta idiotez, osea superenlo, denle la oportunidad a Anette, imaginense si todos pensaramos igual pues no que caos, todos nos merecemos una oportunidad, yo se que no canta igual de hecho pues ni al caso pero bueno, las rolas de ella son buenas

[nsimcic]

Why do u insult Tarjas fans and call them idiots ....it's not nice....do u think it will bi nice to u if someone calls u an idiot because u're fan of Anette?...bdw i like them both...They are both special on their own way

[starfirew2]

esta cancion es un insulto a Tarja. odio esta cancion.

[Aislinnn87]

lol tarja is not even a third as good as anette...

[hissingatrocity]

HAHAHAHAAAAAA!!!! oooh gawd, you made my day!

[zombinagirl]

this is sad, she really sux man :S

whatever but please don't try to sing tarja's songs, cause u sound stupid.

[SoundCherryGarden]

Could you fool please stop mocking Anette? Just imagine her situation... Becoming Nightwish's new vocalist and being mocked by so many fans, although she does a great job. You should support her if you like Nightwish...

[zombinagirl]

Why i have to support her if i don't like her? xD

whats wrong with u people, xD

i like nightwish but i think we are free to think and tell whatever we want.

so don't spam me, just for think diferent is stupid

[MrMarti666]

hay si sta fea verdad, pero bueno nightwish no sea lo mismo esta como que mas fresa, pero igual esta bien,

[bryturunen]

Me da asco esa tipa

[Nin95]

Pisząc ten list Nightwish na pewno zastanowił się kilka razy.

nie wiemy co zaszło między nimi a tarją w zespole.

kariera Pani turunen toczy się świetnie!

Anette nie jest najgorsza,przeciwnie!Ilu z nas zaśpiewałoby tak jak ona?

Nikt.

Dziewczyna się stara!!!

ma energię,Nightwish ją przyjąl,a my musimy zaakceptować!!!!!

[marianitafanvane100p]

por fa ya dejen de apretarle la nariz a la pobre

[UrbanSpower]

new singer is actually good :)

didn't expect that.

[mattiaguada]

@UrbanSpower it's not good--- she sucks...

[slidonz]

1:52 so nice girl wow :)

[mutantonA]

Kiedy widzę tych ludzi tak radośnie śpiewających ten płytki i jednoznaczny tekst (głównie jeśli chodzi o refren) to robi się przykro. Wielcy fani Nightwish'a, oczywiście patrząc na karierę Tarji a Anette w zespole. Pani już dziękujemy, może pani spierdalać, mówiąc dosłownie.

[Fallen4eva]

One thing I don't get; why doesn't Marco sing the whole part that he's supposed to? He always 'cuts' some of the lyrics with the 'ho.' I don't like it. It irritates me. I want him to sing the entire part AS IT IS!

[dawookiee43]

I feel ya...it was a bit annoying, especially when I Was singing along and like, "What the hell?"

[bukojuko]

studio recording is different than live, i dont think he could do it, hes a great singer but he cant sing that loud for that long. the dude has to breath and he needs to save it for the BYE BYE BEAUTIFUL PART that needs to be loud and strong

Not saying he cant do it but alot of songs are different live.

[ellabiank]

god...what a differenc btween anette and tarja

[DeviMuse]

woow

that's cool

hah

[31uisybz]

Very professional clip.

Very nice girls, Anette too ;)

[xdeviltrunksx]

**I'm not trying to start a Youtube comment fight with the following comment, and I will not respond to any comments about my post.**

The newer singer is cool, but I still prefer Tarja.

PS: So that's what Edward Scissorhands has been up to all these years. lol

[nzutv4x4]

That made me feel young again. Bloody good combo with both male & female lead singers. When are you coming to NZ?

[markushorus]

všichni ruce nahoru!!!

[GhostRiderintheNight]

loooooool now I understand why to me this song is unsingable! marco leave some words of the original text!!! ahahahah old fox!

A.

[CRPBU]

The boy at 2:14 looks more funny. lol

[alexyeung9]

1:51 looks so funny hahaha