the repeat button is just getting hit again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again. So beautiful
It's not a simple matter of truth and falsehood. Like I said, context. Are you writing an essay? Yes? You'll bomb almightily if you write under the misapprehension that The Waste Land is a novel. But you're not writing an essay. You're talking to people who are listening to music for pleasure, to whom it makes no difference whether it's a 'song' or not, much as it makes no difference to any of us in day to day lfie that what we call our 'weight' is our 'mass'.
As a student currently pursuing a degree in music, I can say with certainty songs have words. I can also say that it's completely irrelevant unless you're writing an essay for college or being an arsewipe with a superiority complex.
You shouldn't take the meaning of a song only from one hand. There are many, many piano pieces named "A Song Without Words"(eg. Tchaikovsky's). Whatever it is, it is an marvelous piece.
@CalumMcNamaraHimself It's true that pieces are to be played and songs are to be sung, but you don't have to be so high and mighty about it. You should keep in mind that not everybody has studied music and cut them a little slack. You're like that kid that went to college and became an elitist, and nobody likes that kid. Anyway, it is an amazing piece.
I'm playing this piece in the Pierneef competition. It's incredibly beautfiul and I don't get why you people are so concerned about the technacalities of the piece, rather than the music itself.
Unless you have the "Lieder ohne Worte" from Mendelssohn and others that followed him in that! In on thing GirlinaDoll is right though; the piece needs a beautiful singing tone!
beautiful
ecoylly1 2 weeks ago
the repeat button is just getting hit again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again. So beautiful
Jessicariscless 1 month ago
Absolutely beautiful, my favourite piece to play(:
crUUw 3 months ago
Parts of the melody remind me of Tchaikovsky's "Autumn Song", with a touch of Debussy.
TheWanderingNight 4 months ago
@CalumMcNamaraHimself
It's not a simple matter of truth and falsehood. Like I said, context. Are you writing an essay? Yes? You'll bomb almightily if you write under the misapprehension that The Waste Land is a novel. But you're not writing an essay. You're talking to people who are listening to music for pleasure, to whom it makes no difference whether it's a 'song' or not, much as it makes no difference to any of us in day to day lfie that what we call our 'weight' is our 'mass'.
DylanCsharpminorG 5 months ago
@CalumMcNamaraHimself
As a student currently pursuing a degree in music, I can say with certainty songs have words. I can also say that it's completely irrelevant unless you're writing an essay for college or being an arsewipe with a superiority complex.
DylanCsharpminorG 5 months ago
If a tree falls in the forest with no one to hear it, does go shoo-doo-shoo-bee-ooo-bee?
junkmarmot 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@CalumMcNamaraHimself This then, by _your definition_, is not a song.
musiclover1485 1 year ago
Wow! I never knew for this composer but I have to choose a modern piece for my ARCT and this sounds great!
ragtimest 1 year ago
@ragtimest same dealio piano playing buddeh
BeeferPig 1 year ago
Why is there a picture of danny devito for the second half of this video srsly guys
forscyvus 1 year ago 2
@forscyvus LOL it's ginastera...not danny devito
cutieluck15 11 months ago
@CalumMcNamaraHimself
You shouldn't take the meaning of a song only from one hand. There are many, many piano pieces named "A Song Without Words"(eg. Tchaikovsky's). Whatever it is, it is an marvelous piece.
ArnoGHumal 1 year ago
Comment removed
celticbp 1 year ago
@CalumMcNamaraHimself It's true that pieces are to be played and songs are to be sung, but you don't have to be so high and mighty about it. You should keep in mind that not everybody has studied music and cut them a little slack. You're like that kid that went to college and became an elitist, and nobody likes that kid. Anyway, it is an amazing piece.
celticbp 1 year ago 15
I'm playing this piece in the Pierneef competition. It's incredibly beautfiul and I don't get why you people are so concerned about the technacalities of the piece, rather than the music itself.
hangtenjo 1 year ago
Where is this song thing coming from? The first word is DANCE (of the meuse of donosa)
dmwilk99 1 year ago
Unless you have the "Lieder ohne Worte" from Mendelssohn and others that followed him in that! In on thing GirlinaDoll is right though; the piece needs a beautiful singing tone!
Starwalker6978 1 year ago
a song doesn't have to have words. it can be a musical composition. but i digress, appreciate the music, don't criticize it.
itswillo 1 year ago 6
Currently working on this song...so mesmorizing
GirlinaDoll 2 years ago
so beautiful!!!!
blueyoyi 2 years ago
Fantastic!
alexilmagnifico 2 years ago
Bizarre and gorgeous.
FranzofL 2 years ago
Very very beautiful melody thanks!! I will post too this pieces played by Panizza!
MagicDonDino 2 years ago