Absolutely fantastic scene and film- leave it to the Marx Bros. to convince someone not to kill themselves! Love it and it is so true that it really is the little things in life that make meaningful and it us worth it just to be a part if the experience
woody is crazy and hilarious as all out... the neighbors ringing the bell and knocking on the friggin' door is what makes me laugh the most. only woody can deliver like that while speaking to a much larger audience about belief and faith ;o) love him ;o)
As hard to believe even the most small and trivial thing like a funny movie can erase all the pain, depression and doubt. All of it gone in an instant.
I know a lot of people love “Hannah and Her Sisters” and Woody Allen in general, but this resolution is completely flawed because it’s so Hollywood. There’s no way a hypochondriac with deep-seeded issues can resolve their problems by simply watching happy people in a movie. Life isn’t that simply. It’s okay to like this movie, but I don’t see how anyone can defend this ending.
@Beale64 Thank you! I love Woody Allen, but this ending always felt like it was influenced by the movie studio. Those deep-seeded issues are explored wonderfully in the film up until that point, and fortunately in his other movies as well (at times with much better, though not as optimistic, conclusions).
When I first saw this scene I was fourteen and just starting to come out of a long depression. I seriously believe this helped. I've loved it ever since. <3
As absolute as this scene is. You will probably never see this type of thing In cinema again. There will never be another. Enjoy while you can. Wonderful scene. Wonderful film, wonderful writer and director.
i've felt this fear at times, and woody allen helps put the world back into rational perspective, his insights on life and the fear that comes with it are wonderful and helpful.
the best part is Max von Sydow's monologue as Frederick. He and Barbara Hershey give one of the greatest acting scenes I've ever seen since "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf."
I love this scene so much, it means so much to me, to givi it a houmorus sense to something I'd been so depressed about, and that after all it is such a "who caaaaaaaares" kind of thing.
And I love this cut, when he says , "...and put the world back into rational perspecitve..." and next you see a brilliant but totally absurd scene from Graucho Marx ... and that shows you, how absurd life is. The most rational way to handle it, is just to laugh about it. Brilliant WOody
The philosophy of existentialism really. You cannot prove the supernatural because it's very nature is inexplicably by rule of nature, which is all that we can test. So for the duration of your life you must define who you are by your own standards.
"Well, last month you thought you had a Malignant Melanoma" - .... Woody: "Well, with a sudden dark spot appearing on my back".... Woman: "It was on your shirt......"
Woody: "Well, how was i to know, everyone was pointing to my back"
HANNAH ET HER SISTERS! GREAT, SILLY, FILM, WOODY'S BEST AND MY FAVORITE!
Once again Allen's trying to answer the question: what's the meaning of life? And, in this case, the answer is- try to enjoy your life. I like that and it's fine with me.
Woody's character in this movie is exactly how I feel about dying. It scares the beejesus out of me, and I feel the same sense of bewilderment that he does when he looks around and sees people calmly accepting the concept.
p.s. Astrosecret, you're a very sad individual. It only took eight actual words of yours to work that out.
p.p.s. Manhattan and Annie Hall, and this, are hard to beat as his best movies, but his funniest would have to be Love and Death.
I second that sentiment about Allen's attitude towards death. Most of the people I know are all complacent about it, mostly b/c of some religious belief or another, and I'm terrified. I love Woody Allen <3.
It's a good lesson to clear your head with a good walk, there are no drawbacks to it. Maybe getting hit by a car, caught in the rain, stepping in dogshit, and bumping into someone you don't want to see. That's all I can come up with. My favourite line in this movie is Woody narrating about Nietzsche's philosophy of eternal reccurence and saying "Great, I'd have to see the Ice Capades again, it's not worth it."
I agree, this is my favorite Woody Allen film. Manhattan, Annie Hall, Stardust Memories, Match Point and Interiors are other masterpieces that are nearly on the same level but my personal favorite next to Hannah and Her Sisters is Play It Again Sam and maybe Bananas next.
This is one of Woody's best films. As a student of philosophy, I can honestly say that Woody Allen is the most interesting existential philosopher out there. His humor brings to light deep insights about the human condition. What a terrific film.
I disagree that Woody is a philosopher in any way, shape or form. More like someone who read a Time article about a certain philosophy or an encyclopedia entry and made a joke from it.
Yeah, but now he has 7 years of bad luck to live through.
gardenvarietypenis 4 months ago
I love it!! My favourite Woody Allen film
leeloo1967 4 months ago
Nice scene, Kubrick loved his films too. Woody is great.
saqibk1 4 months ago
Absolutely fantastic scene and film- leave it to the Marx Bros. to convince someone not to kill themselves! Love it and it is so true that it really is the little things in life that make meaningful and it us worth it just to be a part if the experience
moviebuff995 9 months ago
Comment removed
zhunt 11 months ago
woody is crazy and hilarious as all out... the neighbors ringing the bell and knocking on the friggin' door is what makes me laugh the most. only woody can deliver like that while speaking to a much larger audience about belief and faith ;o) love him ;o)
emailkenny 11 months ago
i felt that way many times
Pillarmoon88 1 year ago
I like this.
Glinkaism1 1 year ago
the key to being happy is to stop expecting the world to make you happy. I know, its a paradox. ;-)
TadRapidly 1 year ago
@TadRapidly Well put. and exactly true. This is a great scene from America's pre-eminent moviemaker.
coyotesong 7 months ago
I love you tidesturn
circlegame666 1 year ago
As hard to believe even the most small and trivial thing like a funny movie can erase all the pain, depression and doubt. All of it gone in an instant.
johnyzero2000 1 year ago 2
I know a lot of people love “Hannah and Her Sisters” and Woody Allen in general, but this resolution is completely flawed because it’s so Hollywood. There’s no way a hypochondriac with deep-seeded issues can resolve their problems by simply watching happy people in a movie. Life isn’t that simply. It’s okay to like this movie, but I don’t see how anyone can defend this ending.
Beale64 1 year ago
@Beale64 It's called having an epiphany, and it can easily change a person's life.
germansoccerfn 1 year ago
@Beale64 who knows?!
happiness is in the small things of life...
rafaguimaandrade 1 year ago
@Beale64 Thank you! I love Woody Allen, but this ending always felt like it was influenced by the movie studio. Those deep-seeded issues are explored wonderfully in the film up until that point, and fortunately in his other movies as well (at times with much better, though not as optimistic, conclusions).
anthonyct 1 year ago
"don't you wanna be part of the experience?" such a great question... kudos to woody.
AndresPajaro 1 year ago
Carpe Diem Mr.Allen, Capre Diem.
NuclearPlanet 1 year ago
People who call suicide hotlines should just be sent a copy of DUCK SOUP - they'll never doubt their own being again.
rtmiyake2 1 year ago
@rtmiyake2 I'd sooner send them a copy of Hannah and Her Sisters tbh.
TheAlmightySmurf 1 year ago
It seems I've heard that song before, it's an old familiar tune. I know it well that melody.
yak6ex 1 year ago
nice
Ipoustigi 1 year ago
Amazing, simply amazing.
iliketacos27 1 year ago
great scene great perspective on life
dewbunny110362 1 year ago
Definitely in my Top Ten favorite scenes of all-time.
mf1932 1 year ago
When I first saw this scene I was fourteen and just starting to come out of a long depression. I seriously believe this helped. I've loved it ever since. <3
I4gotmyMANTRA 1 year ago 5
I gotta check this whole movie out again! I just love this scene! Thanks for sharing it. Woody was really saying something here!
903davesharonpoky 1 year ago
My favorite film scene of all-time
AnthonyAmmo 1 year ago
As absolute as this scene is. You will probably never see this type of thing In cinema again. There will never be another. Enjoy while you can. Wonderful scene. Wonderful film, wonderful writer and director.
nasplimp 1 year ago 3
Thank you for putting this up. I've been searching for it for a while now.
Great soliloquy from a classic movie.
gabbimassi 1 year ago
i've felt this fear at times, and woody allen helps put the world back into rational perspective, his insights on life and the fear that comes with it are wonderful and helpful.
2whombrother 2 years ago
the best part is Max von Sydow's monologue as Frederick. He and Barbara Hershey give one of the greatest acting scenes I've ever seen since "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf."
WalterSobchak1998 2 years ago
um, guns don't go off when you toss them on the couch
stalepieforever 2 years ago
@stalepieforever
Wow you is smart! You won the internets!
thebutschwacker 2 years ago
Just what I was looking for, thanx for posting that! =-)
anabel7xtina7 2 years ago
who plays that song???
ferferofer 2 years ago
You mean the song at the beginning? It's by Harry James I think.
levanyzzuf 2 years ago
Woody is right. This is what LIFE is all about.
Kodachrome40 2 years ago 5
Woody is right. This is what LIFE is all about.
Kodachrome40 2 years ago
I've never seen this one before...so glad you put it up!
shadowontheway 2 years ago 3
my favorite scene in the movie. if i'm ever suicidal i'll just watch this scene.
or duck soup.
squidlyj 2 years ago 5
that medley is stuck in my head!
name please!
flyj2659 2 years ago
I just love everything about this movie: great story, great cast, great soundtrack. Thank you for uploading!
ayecandy 2 years ago
I love this scene so much, it means so much to me, to givi it a houmorus sense to something I'd been so depressed about, and that after all it is such a "who caaaaaaaares" kind of thing.
janotosinnumeros 2 years ago
i never expected to get such an awesome existential insight from woody allen, of all people...but WOW, that was amazing. <3
khencke 2 years ago 4
I dont understand, there is nothing insightful about it.
smokinbill 2 years ago
I live right next to that theater (it's on 99th St and Broadway). Unfortunately, it's closed down now.
Badgerthegreat 2 years ago 3
GENIUS!
katladevote 2 years ago 5
GENIUS!
katladevote 2 years ago 3
I just watched this film again today for the first time since it first came out. It's brilliant.
My favorite bit is when his father tells him what he thinks about death, "who thinks of such nonsense, now I'm alive, when I'm dead I'll be dead!"
sunnyallthetime 2 years ago 5
what was the song playing in the "Lucky I ran into you" scene
godfatherofwiseguys 2 years ago
If you're talking about the song at the beginning of the scene it's "You Made Me Love You".
Jbellaire 2 years ago
So amazing
LiveAtLeeds2 2 years ago
The Marx Bros. = Something to live for.
RubyTuesday717 2 years ago 3
Woody is a master, and like every real master, hi is not afraid of putting his own personal dilemas in film...awesome
bernardop 2 years ago 4
thanks for the cut.
floridatodaychuck 3 years ago 2
And I love this cut, when he says , "...and put the world back into rational perspecitve..." and next you see a brilliant but totally absurd scene from Graucho Marx ... and that shows you, how absurd life is. The most rational way to handle it, is just to laugh about it. Brilliant WOody
rufus10000 3 years ago 49
@rufus10000 just saw this movie last night. nice insight rufus
buffilms 1 year ago
My favourite scene too. No doubt! When Woody talk about God it doesn't matter if He exists or he doesn't. It's just the sentence.
sombreve 3 years ago
A wondeful movie, one of his masterpieces.
janejones11 3 years ago 5
one of the most brilliant scenes ever made
TokenTim101 3 years ago
The philosophy of existentialism really. You cannot prove the supernatural because it's very nature is inexplicably by rule of nature, which is all that we can test. So for the duration of your life you must define who you are by your own standards.
Humanzy 3 years ago 4
And after death, we get new standards? There is no supernatural to "define", prove or test.
dyinglikeflies 2 years ago
i love movie
iscerlata 3 years ago 2
Thanks for posting!!! My favorite scene, too!
DanNolan22 3 years ago 4
"Well, last month you thought you had a Malignant Melanoma" - .... Woody: "Well, with a sudden dark spot appearing on my back".... Woman: "It was on your shirt......"
Woody: "Well, how was i to know, everyone was pointing to my back"
HANNAH ET HER SISTERS! GREAT, SILLY, FILM, WOODY'S BEST AND MY FAVORITE!
italioguy 3 years ago
Once again Allen's trying to answer the question: what's the meaning of life? And, in this case, the answer is- try to enjoy your life. I like that and it's fine with me.
Greenleafff 4 years ago 29
Woody Allen's films are the only films that tug my heart, tickle my funny bone, AND think at the same time.
lucasbig 4 years ago 9
Woody's character in this movie is exactly how I feel about dying. It scares the beejesus out of me, and I feel the same sense of bewilderment that he does when he looks around and sees people calmly accepting the concept.
p.s. Astrosecret, you're a very sad individual. It only took eight actual words of yours to work that out.
p.p.s. Manhattan and Annie Hall, and this, are hard to beat as his best movies, but his funniest would have to be Love and Death.
canichoosethisname 4 years ago 7
I second that sentiment about Allen's attitude towards death. Most of the people I know are all complacent about it, mostly b/c of some religious belief or another, and I'm terrified. I love Woody Allen <3.
Weirfan69 3 years ago
my fav. WOODY ALLEN---yes, ANNIE HALL is great too, so is MANHATTAN, but I can cozy up to HANNAH any time.
moveefrk 4 years ago 3
i love this
klwurste 4 years ago 3
Comment removed
astrosecret 4 years ago
You were dumb to watch it and stick money in the Yid's pocket.Its okay, we give 20% to charity as Commanded.How's your thithe?
MosheNL 3 years ago
hehe nice
falzaabi 4 years ago 2
It's a good lesson to clear your head with a good walk, there are no drawbacks to it. Maybe getting hit by a car, caught in the rain, stepping in dogshit, and bumping into someone you don't want to see. That's all I can come up with. My favourite line in this movie is Woody narrating about Nietzsche's philosophy of eternal reccurence and saying "Great, I'd have to see the Ice Capades again, it's not worth it."
wayne763 4 years ago 2
Allen: the best american director.
eppursimuove64 4 years ago 3
Wow, Woody's dialogue in this scene is so life-affirming. I need to rent this film again. Thank you for posting this.
perspicaciouscritic 4 years ago 2
He's such a brain!!!
solidsn2004 4 years ago
Thanks for this. This scene means a lot...
cbus03 4 years ago 4
I love this scene so much. Thank you thank you thank you.
cbus03 4 years ago
Best Woody Allen film along with "Manhattan", in my opinion. And one of the best films of the 1980s.
zim83 4 years ago 2
I agree, this is my favorite Woody Allen film. Manhattan, Annie Hall, Stardust Memories, Match Point and Interiors are other masterpieces that are nearly on the same level but my personal favorite next to Hannah and Her Sisters is Play It Again Sam and maybe Bananas next.
iloveram 4 years ago 2
This is one of Woody's best films. As a student of philosophy, I can honestly say that Woody Allen is the most interesting existential philosopher out there. His humor brings to light deep insights about the human condition. What a terrific film.
tlinsk 4 years ago 5
I disagree that Woody is a philosopher in any way, shape or form. More like someone who read a Time article about a certain philosophy or an encyclopedia entry and made a joke from it.
wayne763 4 years ago
Thanks so much, just watched this scene on TV and looked on youtube and HERE IT IS! :-) FANTASTIC!!!
shastasladybear 4 years ago
All the movie is completely amazing!!
chorizofrito 4 years ago
I always think about this scene when I'm feeling kind of crappy about everything.
vintajo 4 years ago 8
Me too.
weikko79 4 years ago 2
same
ziegfeldgrl 2 years ago
it's Duck Soup
maharajohn 4 years ago 2
Andr4s
Duck Soup (Freedonia's going to war)
AttheCircus 4 years ago
this is my favorite part of the movie as well - i'm so glad someone had the foresight to upload this! thank you!!
ahahahayeahright 4 years ago
Thank you for posting this - a wonderful clip. Do you have any more clips from this film?
D9l3tt 4 years ago
Which Marx brothers movies is that?
Andr4s 4 years ago
Duck Soup.
brighteyes097 4 years ago
Hey thanks for this!
echosmyron 5 years ago 2
This is my favorite scene too it is just so powerful, I love Groucho Marx and I love Woody Allen, is great.
Andr4s 5 years ago
A great scene, though what precedes it is even better.
weikko79 5 years ago 2
I have seen this movie just now....
It is amazing
karoro1128 5 years ago 2