Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (330)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • personally as a brit i'm glad shes gone to america because the british media were wankers with her, the british media are the worst in the world

  • In my opinion, better than her final performance. She looked somewhat like she had given in at the final and just came out as a courtesy.

  • Your my number one and i will buybyour crisrmass your cd lots of love fromme Holland Sylvia Bos

  • Awsome

  • fantastic! everyone knows she had a shakey 5 second intro but who can blame her....the pressure she was under! Go susan...bring on the final, im sure she'll learn from her mistake and be perfect!

  • crazy people love crazy people!!

  • WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • We listen to Susan's videos all the time and always feel inspired. . I will be glad when all the pressure is off her and she starts making CDs. She has an amazing talent that touches the heart. An artist needs to perform and should not have to compete! She IS an artist!!

  • I think the biggest winner could be Simon :-)

  • nihaltm thank for your comment it's better for you to go back your own shell... i think it needs you t0 go back there bye bye

  • nervous start but she got it back this woman deserves every bit of fame and money..anyone here disagrees you are on the wrong site folks

  • I'm in the USA and yes, I agree with Simon Cowell when he said "The whole world is watching Susan Boyle tonight. I wouldn't want to be standing where she is right now." A ton of pressure. I could tell she was nervous when she started even though she denied it. I still say that to me SUSAN BOYLE REPRESENTS THE SPIRIT OF GREAT BRITAIN. She's fab. I'll buy here CD!

  • She strained a few notes, messed up on the first, but it's understandable. When you've gotten the kind of press she has, it's hard not to be nervous.

  • I also think she a bit over rated but thats not a reason to call her ugly

  • Her voice cracks on the opening note...............and shes off key for the first couple of lines - shes allright but is overrated.

  • i think she's over rated , the only reason why she got so famous was because she is ugly and can sing OK that's it and on this clip i think she screwed it up

  • That is such an unkind thing to say. Who are you to call her ugly?

  • dick head, who are you to call her ugly she's an amazing singer and nobody thought she would be and she is u have no right to call her ugly for all we know u could be a fat ugly heffa with a bunoin

  • anyway im not fat and u kno im rite ye she might be ok but i am rirte

  • the surprise has now gone, and now its jst a fat ugly woman who can sing half good.,,, who the fuck wants to see that?

  • nihaltm the surprise has now gone, and now its jst a fat ugly woman who can sing half good.,,, who the fuck wants to see that?

    Ok your words..I am puzzled why you are on here then?you are like the hitlers of this world..and we all know what happens to those dictators..ie saddam hitler stalin..they die .Susan Boyle may not be picture book but she will always be more beautiful than you sick bastards. Your day will come.

  • typical american talking absolute shit

  • Americans... The only country where the people go out of their way for foreigners, adapt to their customers when visiting, shows empathy for for everyone else while putting themselves last, almost religiously, yet they are the only country ridiculed for making everyone else comfortable.

    ON TOP OF THAT...

    people from all over the world come to the United States for whatever reason and "COMPLAIN" about how it is so much better in THEIR country, but when to asked why do you stay, they go SILENT!?

  • what country are you talking about because it isnt america

  • americans copied the brits with all u mentioned and we do a better job, our problem is we dont ask if foriners want to stay they just let them selves in legaly or not, we too damb polite to turn them your way!!!!

  • get lost mf, i live in texas and i think she wonderful, you must be a male without a heart, god help you.

  • we do support every country, people come here to become somebody, like yourself, you just proved how stupid you are, rhonda, beaumont, texas. and the grand usa. get a life who ever you are, and i love susan boyle, she is great

  • Ok,

    STupid bitch doesnt BEGIN to vover it Mr. Spud.

    HOW ABOUT you learn to read and then RE-READ what I typed. I pretty much said the exact same thing YOU DID.

    JFHC!

  • Nihaltm, I DO!

    And so do millions of people around the world.

    How many people want anything to do with you?

    I'd say no one. You're a pitiful, lonely person with nothing better to do then insult.

  • I don't think she should really win it, neither the young boy.. not because i have anything against them but mainly because it's for a 'Variety' show. how much true variety is there if there's like 10 singing acts and 4 different acts. People like this should enter Xfactor instead. I would much rather see flawless win this year.

    (P.S. Please don't flame this as its only my opinion as i'm sure you have yours)

  • everyone acts like she has already won, there is still more semi finals let alone the final, with some other very talented acts. susan isnt the only one to beat and the judges should stop saying "you could give susan boyle a run for her money" have they already decieded who will win?!

  • thank you for the support everyone!

  • i think you are doing so well especialy now with all the presure you must be under.good luck + i wish you all the best xx.

  • America loves ya Susan---we are pulling for you

  • is it only me that thinks shes not that great a singer? This country has far better singers than this...

  • This is good but not as good as her first/audition in my view

  • The nerves are pretty hearable. I agree with the critics, this wasn't a great performance. But I'm quite sure she can actually, because she has the voice and the control necessary to pop it. Just let her get used to such a public, and you'll see.

    Go Susan!

  • i love susan ,she has a sweet voice, lovely tone to it.she may have waverd a wee bit but it was nerves.i hope she wins the show. go 4 it susey girl.good luck. i will b voting 4 u.xx

  • This was rubbish! way overhyped!

  • She was ok, but there are a lot of other acts better than her. I just hope that all the media attention surrounded around her doesn't affect the other acts.

  • She is competant but nowhere near as good as the hype plays her up to be, she would for example get nowhere near singing a lead role in a West End production which i guess is how you would measure someones abilitiy overall...i full expect to get flamed for this but hey, its my opinion and i have seen plenty of fantastic singers in the West End to be able to make a reasoned comparison.

  • Nowhere near in West End? ;\

    think you've been a bit harsh there.

  • Quite some false notes in there. I do like the woman's singing.

  • but if you can't do it yourself, then you don't and shouldn't have a snipe at someone who does.

  • By shit theres some negative sods on here!!!

    Look, she had a go, she did an AMAZING job the first one...and because she's had all the feedback, she got nervous...like Simon said, the whole world was watching her , so of course she was nervous, and started off slowly. It looked to me like she relaxed as she went through, and realised the audience was all pulling for her...

    For my money, I reckon if you want to make negative comments then thats up to you...

  • I got no talent..I dunno how to judge Susan..

    btw, she is going tobe famous or by luck!

  • 2:57

    O_O

  • Susan your great and looks are not everything when you have a voice all yours.

  • she's not terrible. either this song just wasn't for her or she was really nervous.

  • why i dont want susan boyle to win,dont get me wrong shes good but First of all i believe shes not as amazing as people are making out she is and i believe the only reason she is so popular/famous is because it was so unexpected of her. Secondly she doesnt need to win, her life is gonna change for the better from now on and shes gonna be famous anyways even if she doesnt win. Thirdly to be honest i dont think she wants to win as much as other contestants cos her dream has already come true.

  • well said!!!!! Exactly what i was thinking also.

  • I hope she wins shes amazing

  • she's amazing she's got a future for movie voice as well as her own hits I bet her future is looking pretty bright .

  • i love her

  • Watch full episodes of britains got talent + britains got more talent on my channel ,semi-finals will be posted every night except wennesday ,please subscribe :)

  • º¤ø„...ø¤º° ¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨

    ¨°º¤ø„¸ GO SUSAN !! ¸„ø¤º° copy and paste

    ¸„ø¤º°"" BOYLE!!! °°º¤ø„¸.. if you think

    ¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º¤ø„¸¨°º¤ Susan is the best

  • yeah and you're so unoriginal and boring

  • good one!

  • Magnifique !

    J'aime elle me fait penser à ma mamie !

    I hope she gona win !

  • superbe, quelle voix ! j'adore la regarder et l'écouter changer

  • she really makes ye cringe for her sometimes...i've felt awful for AGES for laughin @her orginally (yep i am a bad person)...still want diversity to win tho...

  • Way too much expectations from everyone. Susan is overhyped and cannot live up to such enormous expectations

    This performance was mediocre and not a patch on her first performance

    She fluffed the beginning

  • weak beginning,but marvellous late...

  • I supported her at the onset - but this overated performance has made me lose my 'vote.' She did NOT nail this performance and Amanda's comments were completely off track on this one. A disappointment for me here (and I am entitled to my personal opinion and view). This performance is not a 'winning' one in my books and one must be fair to all the other performers. She may get a career but I would not run to see her after this until she improved by leaps and bounds - sorry folks.

  • I couldn't agree more :)

    I feel Susan Boyle is very overrated and I think this performance proved it.

    She's been so hyped up and this was such a big let down. Other acts deserve to win so much more :)

  • haha are you trying 2 sound smart or something :L lemmie tell u, itz not working :D and yes we all no ur entitled 2 ur own opinion, and dont take this the wrong way but who says "This performance is not a 'winning' one in my books and one must be fair to all the other performers" LOL but yeah i get where ur coming from nw :D

  • Well your twopenny opinion is swamped by the deluge of opinions that rejoice in her singing-seems you're out of step with the millions who have fallen for her singing. By the way it's not all about technical perfection-otherwise everyone would listen to Sarah Brightman all day long-it's the timbre of her voice that draws the millions of fans in.

  • What does Susan say between 0:19 and 0:23?

  • youtube was knew to me the only tube i knew about was a tube of smarties

  • I'm from scotland and even I found it difficult to understand what she was saying.

  • something about eating a tube of smarties i think

  • i didnt like this audition she was a bit rubbish i think and idont want her to win.

  • Susan was really nervous, and for good reason with all the global attention this humble woman from Scotland has been getting for the last month. As Simon said, none of us would want to be in her shoes at that moment and under that kind of pressure!! She has a beautiful voice and way of presenting herself and is always an inspiration. Always makes me feel uplifted to see and hear her.

  • SHE IS A DOLL ! lol has she got a boyle on her arse ?

  • im not into this music...but i saw audition and it was really nice..very good....but this i though was weak and poor (still better than i could dream of doin but its not about me) this really didnt live up to the hype everybody trying to throw around :/

    but good on her for havin fun she seems nice lady i hope next one will be good :)

  • why doesn't she show a unique talent by fucking dropping dead. now.

  • Ok well that is a little bit harsh! Show respect for human life!

  • Ok...I was a fan of the first one...but this is CRAP! The first one was based on shock factor...this is just all sorts of messed up! People who like this have obviously NEVER attended DECENT theatre in their lives. Watch Elaine Paige sing this in the DVD of 'Cats' and you learn what goosebumps are! Sorry Susan Boyle...Big strike...however you did deserve to win the semi final cause everyone else was even worse than you...and that's saying something.

  • butr she is rubish her talent

    Whats the fuss

    Just sayin My Opinion

  • I love this voice-emotional when I saw your video and could not contain the lagrimas.Espero love coming to portugal, we have that here.

    Susan Boyle forever

    bjs de portugal

  • i hope she wins!! either her or darth jackson - just so simon will quit!!!

  • darth jackson is out

  • If the public like Susan,then she will win !

    All other acts will be seen by ...scouts...and agents, and they will still get the chance of fame if they are good enough !.We will see what happens.

    Silly and nasty comments are so sad,and generaly posted by Pond Life.

  • SHE IS SHIT...

    Why dod people like her...just coz she is ugly!

    Shes sooo overrated.

    DIVERSITY TO WIN

  • It doesn't matter how she looks like...At the first place counts her talent...Your opinion is very upset...Sorry school boy!

  • 2:09 mins gawd shes trying so hard to cry FAKE BITCH p.s am talking about amanda lolz

  • She had a few bum notes at the start but other than that I thought her performance was realy good, the show's not fixed don't be daft.

  • Paying for votes. Shame.

  • god i hope she does not win!!!

  • absolutely beutiful - i got even goosebumps :D i love her!!!

  • All very average compared to her first performance

  • Susan you have a beautiful voice. Ignore the ignorant they don't have a life and resent you trying to change yours. Whatever happens your life has now changed for ever. Good Luck

  • quote

    Kesa 1968

    ''I live next door to Susan, I can say without a doubt she has made all of us realise she is a rare talent, she is so humble and kind in real life and I think that is why all of us nice people of the world love her so much. I can only say to the people who like to post bad comments, if u ever reach heaven prepare to be judged, she is awsome ty Susan for lighting the light the whole world needed at this hard time. god bless u Susan. love Paul and Teresa ur neighbours :) ''

  • I agree with Watofan. They keep talking about her inspiration not singing because then they would have to admit that it was a mediocre performance with missed notes.

  • This is obviously FIXED. This act wasnt as impressive as the first, and she was still given a pass through to the finals when there are better acts. Shameful.

  • She's an amateur singer but I think if Barbra listen she 's stand up cheering her. Not so easy for her because almost all the world know her and want to see her next performances.

    Susan sings so nice, superior than some stars of Broadway.

  • What a wonderful voice. I hope she does really well. Thank you Kathleen for sending it to me.

    Joanie

  • I want to eat this ladies asshole

  • What a lovely voice, shame and hard to believe she wasn't discovered earlier.

    Thankyou Kathleen for sending to me.

    Geena

  • Go lakers! lol. :P

  • Such a beautiful voice. Wonderful talent. She's living the dream! :)

    3:00 wow...

  • Susan is a International Class Act I can't wait to buy her Album when it comes out.

  • i love that she is real, and spunky and alive with life! I love to listen to her because of the entire package

  • Oh, I love Susan! So sad she missed the first few notes at the end, but she was understandably nervous, and eventually she hit her stride. You go girl! Much love from the USA!!!

  • I love her, and she has such a fantastic voice! It's sad though that she's nervous in the start, but she quickly turns better in the song :)

  • The only tube she needs is a tube of smarties!

  • Wow, one of the best rendition of Streisand's by an amateur. Streisand recorded hers in a studio but this is live. Bravo!

  • Barbra Streisand sang it in more than one live performance - sorry.

  • Now You Go Darling u rock buh i must say i prefered A dreams a dream but still u made it throo keep going girl!

    Scotland Is Behind You!!!!

  • nobody is perfect, for me, she did very well, i like her talent... gambateh

  • you are Truly an Inspiration...u go gurl..

  • Still love her, still hope she wins, still think she's the best discovery since sliced bread. But I don't think this song was strictly right for her - it's wispy and she's not a wispy character. She WOWS when she can belt it out and show her STRENGTH which is what we all fell in love with - her strength and spirit. Give her a song that is full of spunk, charm, strength, and spirit! She's a magnificent alto, don't give her the wishy washy frilly frothy wispy sitting by a window tunes. Love ya!!

  • PS I would love, love, love to see her duet with Paul Potts on "Make Our Garden Grow" from Candide. Wow.

  • Why no mention from the judges about the awful off-key start and all the bum notes? They'd have crucified anyone else for it. Money making scam for Cowell. everyone who voted is a fool.

  • To Watofan. Your comments are Sour Grapes from somone who has no past & no Future. Crawl back under that rock and stay there.

  • Yeah. :(

  • Ahi ahi guys, envy can really make you go to hell. She is gifted, no discussion about it. Maybe she is not the prettiest girl on this planet, but the way she sings is just awesome. She can really make my cry. Thank you Susan.

  • god damn you! you just dont have talent. your attitude is much ugly than her!

  • a bit envy? ahahah relax man, and enjoy her magnificent voice!!

  • fhatfarm your just envious! because your not famous like susan. maybe your a good looking person but are fucking idiot! your more than a bitch!

  • she really took off from 1.18, fantastic!

  • Awesome from that point on. Hated seeing her stumble at the start. I LOVE Susan, a beautiful woman from the inside out.

  • 'Memories' is not an easy song to sing. As I remember it has at least 2 key changes in it. She was a bit off at the start but pulled it back. If you think a rottweiler is good looking you seriously need to see an optician.

  • A little shakey start but wow the rest of the performance, world class!!

    Excellent Susan, all the way to win.

    Don't take any notice of the people who are quick to shoot you down, they would not have half the courage you do to stand in front of the world!

  • susan boyle storms on stage last night like a snorting charging rhino ...and leaves it a winded hippo... the worst performance ever on bgt ... surely the hype is over . not only is she unattractive but she realy cannot sing either . so many gullible imbiciles on you tube that are now hiding and i bet they all feel complete fools ...as they should .. let this be a lesson never judge a book til you get to the last page .

  • LOL! Sounds like you have a Susan Boyle up your ass.

  • i've just been susan boyled what a great feeling

  • aaaugh there's pebbles her little kitty cat. i can die in peace now

  • A nervy start, only to be expected. She picked it up then and like a real pro she hit you with it. Well done Susan. Keep at it, you really could win this.

  • i think she is overrated. Iffshe was half good looking, she wouldn't have got all this publicity which means she is front runner already. People will bvote even if she sings average which she did tonight. PPotts as far better. And what is with the over dramatics at the end.,.., embarassing.

  • Comedian Phua Chu Kang of Singapore

    looks like a brother of Susan Boyle.

  • Oh yeah, she doesn't disappoint. She doesn't pick easy songs either.

  • I just reviewd some famous singers for this song. S.B has done a wonderful job...even better than Celine Dion.

    Before you are going to make a inconstructive comment, please go to research first. I am happy to have her CDs in my bookshelf with Babara S, Elain P,etc...such a beautiful voice

  • she must be the winner. She has something very special, her voice sound like angel's singing.

  • Further to my previous post - unlike some people I don't think she is a "bad" singer because she goes "off" a bit - very few people can sing like she can. What I mean is that her voice is approaching its "sell by" date. I hope, with the help of a few "studio tricks", her album sells in the tens of millions. I just wish she'd been discovered ten years or more ago.

  • Susan Boyle - "Youtube is fairly new to me, the only tube I knew was a tube of Smarties" how funny you go susan!

  • There's something very special that happens when Susan Boyle sings.

  • and futhuremore her manerisms in front of the panel were absolutely cringeworthy

  • your spelling is cringe-worthy

  • theres nothing worse than hearing someone sing out of tune. they took her to london and gave her voice coaching they should have left her alone. whilst parts were ok most of it wasnt. if she sings as badly as this in the final it would be a travestey if she won

  • She hasn't got the voice control she once had. Few women of her age can maintain their vocal abilities without sophisticated training and constant rehearsal. I hear an "aging" voice. She needs to get into the studio as soon as possible, get out her album, make a few million ... and live happily ever after. I think maybe she should have her own TV show ... promoting talented amateur singers. Presenting her as an "amazing singer" is confusing her ... she knows she's not THAT good!

  • Susan appeared visibly nervous at first and could sense her own difficult start. But as she is, when it became most difficult, that is when she delivered. I think she will be fine and will be able to relax before the finals. She may need to calm the physical antics down a bit though. They could steal from her performance.

  • I had goosebumps through the whole song!Her voice is magical...

  • A little disaster @ the begining of the song but later everything was OK. What they do with her eyebrows? I think that Simon replays the same tricks like in Paul's case to attract TV audience concern with an odd lookimg singer. People start to laughing @ the begining of an audition and then they are ashamed with their own rudeness. Go Susan, go!

  • that wasn't too good

  • Bravo from Terezina, Brazil!!!!

    Susan, Brazil loves you!

  • Bravo Susan Boyle. We got your back!!!!

  • The whole world is watching.

    Simon said correctly - I would not be happy to be instead of her. There is so much pressure on her. At beginning she was nervous, though at chours she was just perfect!

    Greetings from Latvia

  • Is soo much pressure on her!!.. The whole world is looking at her is true!!.. regardless she is a inspirational sample of never giving up on your dreams!! Good Luck Susan!! from SFL,US.

  • Even Simon said that he would not want to be standing where she is tonight. Yes, I prefered the other song perhaps, but even this one has some words to match her life story and personality. Go Susan - I hope you win

  • 311 views.

  • Very well done!!.. To me she is a winner...

  • not my choice of song for Susan but at the end I think she nailed it. I would prefer Susan singing songs like she sang previously. However, well done. I think she will be one of the finalists, possibly even the winner.

  • I love it whens she gives her small smile and nods to the audience.

  • To see this sung as it should be find Elaine Paige on you tube at the Lloyd-Webber BD at the Royal Albert Hall in 1998. Yes EP is a professional, but this is truly singing from the heart and soul, feeling it and making the audience really feel it too. ABSOLUTELY NO COMPARISON. Meomory is and always will be Elaine Paige's song. Period.

  • Todos con SUSAN!!! sera la vencedora les guste o no!!! ella es unica su voz la pide el planeta, necesitamos la vos de Susan para reconfortar nuestros oidos ante tanta maldad en la tierra, y tanto desastre en el planeta, escuchemos la voz de este angel y disfrutemos!!

  • fucking fantasitc i think she is the winner already fantastic singer

  • Early nerves were to be expected, but she still managed to raise the roof. I thought, considering that it was only her second performance, that it was incredible. I really hope she wins. She's a bit nuts, in an endearing way of course, and I'm definitely voting for her next Saturday.

  • She was shaky at the start and a bit off key near the end - that's true! But she must have been bricking it, knowing that millions would be watching her. Anyway, I've heard plenty of professional singers going off key from time to time. Even Pavarotti did it. I think she did well and there were large parts of the song where she sang brilliantly.

  • Susan is absolutely beautiful and she seemed nervous at first but got it under control and pulled off a stunning performance.

  • i think people were expecting so much from her, and 4 her 2 be even better than the audition, but i dont think she was really that great tonight,,& she messed up in the begining.

    and she is still gonna win it,,she defo gets the sympathy vote,,george sampson got the symapthy vote (he WAS my favee tho)

    & 2 be honest, Greg Pritchard is better than her and he didnt get a quarter of the coverage shes getting !!