Idina is one of the great vocalists of our time. She is so underused on Glee. If i had an actress/singer like her i would be getting her to sing at least two songs a show. LOVE HER.
@CrepesSuzetteGirl I know right? It baffles me. She is the exact OPPOSITE of those things. I saw her live in Wicked and everyone came away from the theatre saying she had the best voice they had ever heard. Literally.
I love Idina but wtf. Her voice is all over the place,and she adds these strange embelishments in places that don't need it. It's so overdone ithat it sounds like a bad pop song, not pretty.
Julia Murney sings this so much better.... Idina has HORRIBLE diction through this entire video. She can never seem to complete a word, with ending consonants completely ommited or mumbled. Julia also acts this WAY better and with so much intensity. Idina doesn't seem to have a clue what she is singing about...
@doriangraylabel ............ completely agree - I saw her live in this concert and she was terrible.......she sang Heaven Help my Heart like she was singing a nursery rhyme......Elaine Paige will always be my favourite, but Julia Murney sings and acts this about 1000 times better. I do think that Idina is terribly overrated.
I like to listen to this and Julia Murney's version either before or after. Their performances are just so different and I can't tell which one I like more. Julia hits that high note at the end and has her signature vibrato, and Idina holds solid strong notes and sings them with a lot of power. Both amazing
I adore Idina Menzel, but this was not the best song for her or her best performance. She is holding back. She isn't as harsh or as intense as Florence calls for. It feels very casual and relaxed.
i can't stop listening to 3:08 over and over and over again. idina is seriously my inspiration. i don't get the hate. i think she's absolutely wonderful as florence.
I prefer Judy Kuhn or Julia Murney's version of this, but there is something about this that is very easy to listen to, at least in my opinion. Not my favorite thing of Idina's, but then, this is also such a wonderful song that it would be hard to ruin it completely for me.
"will go wrong" OMFG i get chills everytime XD
CrankDatJonasBoi 14 hours ago
I know this musical was expensive to produce in its day but what is it going to take for somebody to bring it back?
inspiredandroid 4 days ago
my favorite song in chess :)
softballer911 2 weeks ago
i feel so proud to say this woman is my idol :')
mconstanta 2 weeks ago 4
She's very nasal in this performance. And her diction is just terrible.
shmoogle14 3 weeks ago
Wow! She is unreal
idinafanboi 3 weeks ago
3 people are on Freddie's side
epacmo1807 3 weeks ago
its wonderful to see this beautiful woman sing the exact way from my cd!
AngeLexa11 4 weeks ago
Idina is one of the great vocalists of our time. She is so underused on Glee. If i had an actress/singer like her i would be getting her to sing at least two songs a show. LOVE HER.
babsbestinhistory 1 month ago 2
Her voice is breath taking!!!! She feels each note and each word she is singing.
Loopylaurz87 1 month ago
Guys, how is Idina "horrible", "terrible", "the worst singer ever", and "awful"? Is there something up with your ears?
CrepesSuzetteGirl 1 month ago 6
@CrepesSuzetteGirl I know right? It baffles me. She is the exact OPPOSITE of those things. I saw her live in Wicked and everyone came away from the theatre saying she had the best voice they had ever heard. Literally.
idinafanboi 3 weeks ago
@idinafanboi Exactly. Yeah guys, she sucks. That's why she won a Tony...that makes SO much sense.
CrepesSuzetteGirl 1 week ago
Is this all vowels? Where is her diction? Urrghh. Horrible.
laureneeni 1 month ago
@laureneeni :/
idinafanboi 3 weeks ago
I'm sorry, but I prefer the original broadway cast
princepeterwolf 1 month ago
Yes of course Idina sings terribly, that's why she has a Tony for Best Lead performance in a musical, because she's such a bad artist!
ddc163264 1 month ago 8
Sent shivers down my spine , she made it her own . Beautiful !!!!
jquiogue 1 month ago 2
i dont like that she doesnt finish her words..
jonasbroluver1996 1 month ago
@jonasbroluver1996 only for this...look at wicked or rent!
ZZZ99913 1 month ago
@ZZZ99913 oh i know that she is absolutely amazing normally. she just needs more diction in this particular performance
jonasbroluver1996 3 weeks ago
One Of The Best Performances Iv Seen Her Do! A World Wide Treasure!
rory89 1 month ago
I love Idina but wtf. Her voice is all over the place,and she adds these strange embelishments in places that don't need it. It's so overdone ithat it sounds like a bad pop song, not pretty.
searchingstarlight 2 months ago
@searchingstarlight only for this...look at wicked or rent!
ZZZ99913 1 month ago
00:57 "i have still a lot to poo"
burnedginger 2 months ago
Julia Murney sings this so much better.... Idina has HORRIBLE diction through this entire video. She can never seem to complete a word, with ending consonants completely ommited or mumbled. Julia also acts this WAY better and with so much intensity. Idina doesn't seem to have a clue what she is singing about...
doriangraylabel 2 months ago
@doriangraylabel lol when I first watched this all I was thinking was when did they rename the song LOBODEH'S ON LOBODEH'S SIIIIIGH
omglolwhatever 1 month ago
@doriangraylabel ............ completely agree - I saw her live in this concert and she was terrible.......she sang Heaven Help my Heart like she was singing a nursery rhyme......Elaine Paige will always be my favourite, but Julia Murney sings and acts this about 1000 times better. I do think that Idina is terribly overrated.
MTA1966 1 week ago
i adore idina menzel but judy kuhn rocks this song!
lilithmoon1979 2 months ago
I like to listen to this and Julia Murney's version either before or after. Their performances are just so different and I can't tell which one I like more. Julia hits that high note at the end and has her signature vibrato, and Idina holds solid strong notes and sings them with a lot of power. Both amazing
LeBronP 2 months ago
Indina simply rocks this part....no other can compare! Would love to see her include this in her concert series.
jeffreyjbuck1 2 months ago
@jeffreyjbuck1 im sorry, but who is INDINA?
zillious06 1 month ago
if i could only listen to one singer for the rest of my life it would be Idina Menzel - lover her!!!
angel4eyes 2 months ago 3
@2.17 onwards i my fave bit :) but i love her anyway...
hannahgleek89 2 months ago
I adore Idina Menzel, but this was not the best song for her or her best performance. She is holding back. She isn't as harsh or as intense as Florence calls for. It feels very casual and relaxed.
Phoebeshome 3 months ago
Everybody is on Idina Menzel's side. :)
SuperZackMonster 3 months ago 5
i can't stop listening to 3:08 over and over and over again. idina is seriously my inspiration. i don't get the hate. i think she's absolutely wonderful as florence.
Mshottie6 3 months ago 5
more emotional than the original.
Mmyysstteerryy 3 months ago 6
i just love her end of :)
staceyhelmore 3 months ago 4
mmmmm...delicious
bwlove25 3 months ago
I prefer Judy Kuhn or Julia Murney's version of this, but there is something about this that is very easy to listen to, at least in my opinion. Not my favorite thing of Idina's, but then, this is also such a wonderful song that it would be hard to ruin it completely for me.
stradivariuscello7 3 months ago
@phalllacy
And so is everyone else. Not hard to be better than Idina Menzel.
EuphrasieF 3 months ago
I'M ON IDINA'S SIDE <3
MissMonster525600 4 months ago 3
a great song ruined by the over rated idina menzel!!!! i really don;t see what people see in her!!! but thats just me xxx
carwyncymru 4 months ago
@carwyncymru i dont think the song was ruined but her voice is/was stronger then this but during her day in rent her voice became lighter
TheKARMACREW 3 months ago
Great song, oversung by Idina. She can belt but her nasal cadence grates on me.
deriobamba 4 months ago
@deriobamba I love the young, childish sound to her voice. It balances out her huge, powerhouse belt perfectly.
idinafanboi 3 months ago 8
I just saw the touring production of Chess yesterday, and I want to see it again!
oatmealboy6 4 months ago
I find this performance uncomfortable.
Pose83 4 months ago
NO ONE is better than IDINA MENZEL!!!!!!!!!!
ChenzelElph 4 months ago 48
love herr!!!!!! idina!!!!!!!!!!!
AngiePeacee18 5 months ago 5
I LIKE HOW SHE DOES HER LIPS WHEN SHE SAY TO SOON
TheKARMACREW 5 months ago 4
the song of my life, sung by the love of my life....
ernesthroop 5 months ago 31
@ernesthroop I agree on this A THOUSAND PERCENT!!!!!!!!
JamieFrench01 3 months ago
im the only one to comment......i love the rip ive been looking for footage like this thank you
TheKARMACREW 5 months ago 3