Added: 3 years ago
From: loveablehottie
Views: 31,677
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (77)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • To bad this isn't on iTunes. Amazon song!

  • What release is this from? :)

  • omg i hate this version. original all the way.

  • We were always the greatest, too bad the great will always seperate... Me and Kennedy's song. I haven't talked to her in 5 months...

  • Josiah Leming is amazing

  • such a gorgeous song.

  • been folllowing this kid since American Idol!!!

  • so deeep.

  • I bought his album because I wanted to promote him. Never listen to it. Only listen to the powerful raw videos that make Josiah a true musician unlike all the other american idol computer enhanced singers.

  • @Lukesaunders17 good comment :D

  • Doesn't sound the same without the old, raw piano.

  • Where can i download this?!? its amazing

  • @SmileYourAnIdiot Just go on vidtomp3.com and convert it to mp3 format,so you can download it :) I do that with all the songs I can find only on Youtube,it's the easiest way :)

  • American Idol failed. But thank god you still are pursuing music.

  • I dont get it...it sounds exactly the same as the live version. Why are people hating?

  • it doesnt sound like it's Josiah playing the piano.

  • dude when he was on american idol i was like OH MY GOD. WOW. and when they kicked him off i cried. i was sooo pissed off they let him go ..

  • This sounds awful. The live one he did was brilliant.

  • It's not as good as the original he did. ;o!

  • i really like this song!

  • i know him hes been to my house in MORRISTWON TENNESSEE!!!! hes one of my bros BFF's!!!

  • I wish he'd go back to his original style like the webcam version. He got attention and now they try to turn him into a disney kid. I would totally do the same, seeing that its makin him money. But still, the studio recording of this song is such shit compared to the original. No flavor. He doesn't do his Paul McCartney scream at the end or anything and they added Celine Dion reverb to his voice. This kid is definitely the shit though.

  • i didnt know that he was still here

  • No no no no. : < This isn't anything like the original version. No feelings in this at all. :/ Too bad Josiah let they do this.

  • they totally changed the intense piano from the original!! that makes me so mad! this is not nearly as good as it is live.

  • actually.....this is from josiah's ep. the one he self released. this was his decision.

  • I feel a whole lot more soul in the original video.

  • Thank God his raw talent and passion wasn't "Polished" away by the A.I. Stylists. It would have ruined him.

  • incredible song!!!!! what video are you guys refering to?

  • this song is better live.

    i really love the lyrics.

  • I dont guys i have listened to him for soooo long now like for real and to me all songs that josiah has wrote seem to be all from the heart regardless of how he records it weather it be in the studio or on his camera in his basement... beautiful songs, lyrics. Real shit i promise the world, i will make a song with josiah leming.

    Glad to see he went from living in his car to making music for a living!!!

  • I deffenetly like the original better, it comes more from the heart, and it leaves speechless. But this version still dosen't wrong the song. I'd like the hear the finger snaping part come back though : D

  • I agree with you so much on that - he doesn't sing out from the heart the same way in this version, and I hear that in alot of his recorded songs, which is a shame. Maybe it's a sort of "live" thing though.

    Still love this song.

  • Awesome song..

    Great lyrics..

  • amazing lyrics And i can't open

    The ears for which i sing

    So i'll just pass along

    And maybe you'll start to hear me

  • he recorded this before the video Im pretty sure. Isn't this the one he did on his own computer before he got signed? (might be wrong) Anyway, the video version is perfect and its impossible to capture that emotion when recording, I know from experience.

  • ililke this a lot =D verrrynice.

  • i agree with everyone who says original is better!

  • but, this one is good.

  • lets face it, music whats raw with emotion and still good like his original will always be better.. but it wont sell to the fans that love mediocrity :P

  • I'm quite the Josiah Leming fan, and I don't agree that the original is better. I guess I've analyzed it all a bit too much. Lol.

  • any second im expecting him to explode with vocals emotion and piano skills...but its too perfected and polished like the person below said. the original absolutely blew me away, never seen anything like it.

  • Agreed.

  • it doesn't even sound like him. i like the original version way better. it sounds less like every other band i've heard.

  • hmmmm..... dunno. His story is sad but in fairness, I think dis is what got him as far as it has.....

  • Where can i download his music? there is only 5 songs on itunes and i NEED more than just 5! lol

    so anyone wanna help?

  • torrent it, limewire, anything thats not itunes probably has it.. i think it costs money to put music on itunes.. he might not have that much money.

  • thank youu

  • its " and maybe youll start to hear me." not "baby"

    =]

  • He has such a good story of how far he has come. I really respect this guy.

  • This kid really is gunna go far, i mean he is already on his way.

    they might have made a little bit of a mistake lettin him go,[americanIdol]

    but at least he is doing what he loves.

  • omg, Josiah Leming has come so far, he is friggin amazing!!!

  • i love this song. the music and lyrics are simply heartbreaking

  • his voice sounds so different

    but im still in love with him

    it's ok

  • I agree with the below comments that said his original was better. It was much more raw and passionate.

  • yeah his original was definitely better. I dont like what hollywood did with him. His original stuff was much more raw and actually really really good. They recorded him like celine dion...the diva reverb on his vocals and make him out to be too pretty boyish. He doesn't even scream at the end of this like he does in the original.

  • I most humbly agree. 'Her' was the song that lured me to this artist. The original version was so raw, so pure and filled with emotion. In the original version, he spilled his emotions through his fingers and onto the piano keys. It was amazing! But this version killed the charm in 'Her'. It's been perfected and polished. Just like another typical sad song...

  • Hollywood didnt do anything..well..I remember hearing I think on Ellen that he records his own stuff with his computer and keyboard and stuff..no recording studio or anything..then he puts it on himself..[=

  • ooo the 1 is much better -__________- why did he change it? his voice is much to clean

  • i still luv this song but i loved how raw the other 1 was, it seemed like theres was more emotion more pain and the piano seemed more intense. perhaps thats just because u could see him play?

  • This version isn't even close to being as good as the original. Why did he change it?

  • ever since i saw him on american idol i fell totally and completely in love with him

  • yes plz

  • thank u so much 4 puttn this up....its so deep.i cryed the 1st time i heard it...hes amazing!!

  • great song

  • wow.

    i reallyy dont like how they took out all the emotionn tht her showed when he sang it before..

    it soundss to professionall..

    :D

    butt i still love itt..

  • @stuffandtay they didn't take the emotion out, just cause it sounds professional. if he wrote the music, and he's singing the song, he's got that passion, that fire, and that emotion. nobody can take it away. i don't know, maybe it's cause i'm a musician that i can hear the emotion and verve in his voice, maybe it's just me, but just because they leveled his voice with the piano, it didn't take out the passion, just cleaned the sound up ^_^

  • If you send her those could you maybe send me them also? I can't pay for them right now so im stucj youtubing them 24/7

  • great song

  • no i mean like send me the mp3 to my email...

  • do you think you could send them to me??? i would appreciate it so much :D

  • I love josiah

    thanks so much for putting this up

    i cant wait for his CD

    5 out of 5

    your awesome

  • Where did you get this song? I tried downloading it but I couldn't find it!

  • Honestly I ma tell you....this guy might be liked mostly by girls but he's got catchy voice and piano skills. He is gonna be renowned singer one day.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more