I've studied gnostic and new age teachings for years before Jesus took over my life. The ideas and concepts in The Shack are not new. Using the 'Holy Spirit' to tell lies is like the biggest no-no in the Bible. Please pray for the Holy Spirit to reveal whether the teachings in The Shack are true or not. There is no 'secret knowledge/wisdom' to know God. To know God you must turn your life over to Jesus. Its not WHAT you know, its WHO you know. That's Christianity. Gospel not in The Shack once.
Nice job..Where can I find the real movie though?..I read the book and to my surprise it brought tears to my eyes..Sad and joyous..Thank you and God Bless:)
Good idea. I was hoping to see the full version of "The Shack", the entire book/movie. Some day, after all the controversy, maybe it WILL become a beautiful movie.... Until then, home made versions is all we can expect.... You guys, did a great job.....Hope for more. Thank you !!!
Kristenyemma this was a very good class project to do. Advertise what you intend for people to respond to. I would LOVE to see Carrie Under wood do the music for the movie if they do make one! I loved the book, so I of course notice the flaws in attitudes as well as cast, but you worked with what you had. Congrats, and I hope you got a good grade for your efforts. Be careful how you respond to people. Rise above name calling. Thanks for reminding us of the book.
As a Christian, I loved the book. I do not believe the author intended for readers to take what is in the book as scriptural. What I received from this book was a deeper understanding of the incredible love the Father has for me. I also realize that some people might have problems with the images that God is portrayed as. Why couldn't he reveal Himself to us as a woman, as a different race other than what people are taught to believe He looks like? If the man in that story needed the comfort of
@ItsJustMandi In my opinion God wouldn't place himself in the cross nor deny the hierarchy of him nor place metaphysical astrals all over the place portrayed as a fairy ! Theres more than what meets the eye on this one. The Bible says how much the father loves you and that should be enough as believers to believe. We dont need more junk trying to entangle us into the metaphysical world of the devil by trying to zoom how big the name of the Lord and his love is for us. Amen!
I pray that this book is never made into a movie. The book has done enough damage!! Anyone who reads this book and thinks that it is a book about "God" needs to get out their Bible and read it. This man is a tool of Satan and they have twisted the word of God. It is disgusting the heresies that are in this book. I pray against the influence of this book and that Yahweh will open the eyes of people to see this book for what it is.
its had 9338 views because there are people out here who are waiting and hoping that the REAL movie will be made...this was misleading.......and fyi...I am not an idiot
all you commenters are idiots. this was a high school english project not an actual movie trailer so sorry we didnt happen to have a black woman, fully grown man, or asian in our assigned group. instead of commenting on a childrens english projects on youtube you should try to have a life. btdubs its had 9338 views. beat that.
@kristenyemma Actually you should be proud of the editing, cinematography, and creative set and location work. What I don't understand is why on earth you chose such a mindless piece of drivel as "The Shack" for your project. Surely even high school students can see what a piece of trash that book is. I am not trying to be a troll and it isn't the subject matter I object to. The book has a ridiculous plot, atrocious dialog and the most horrible prose style I have ever encountered.
@kristenyemma I also noticed that you don't have Bog, Jeebus, or the Holy Goat. Guess they weren't among your talent pool either. Know why? Because they DON'T exist! Go put an ad on Craigslist for a casting call. You will get plenty of "grown" men who are more than willing to enact any role you like. Ever seen "To Catch a Predator?" There will be several dozen at your door before the day is over. Just be careful because Bog won't help you. You'd be better off praying to Chris Hanson
That book made me cry, laugh, and have more faith in things. Im on the part where Makenzie see's Missy under the water fall but Missy cant see him but she can feel him i guess missy is in heavin. Its so sad i was like crying all day. They really should make that a movie. Heyy i would love to watch it.
@john146only Biblical world view??? Can you describe God phiscially? This book shakes those that limit God down to a little box because of their own definitions. Yes, it changes views away from the modern western world attitude that believes God only lived in the civilization that we know. This book is NOT scriptural, i however it shows another image that we are not used to seeing using the same biblical definations. For example, should not Christ look like a regular Jewish carpenter?
@john146 The book asks. Was Christ a Christian? Obviously he was not as Christ himself did not require salvation. The Muppets weren't christian iether but that didnt make it a sin nor make it unappropriate. If that were the case God wouldnt have created a sense of humor. If you think we are in the Laodicea era you are behind the times. Christ's Church is more alive than ever before and Christ is with them today. If you can't see that you are looking in the wrong places; still, be not afraid.
Firstly to those who speak of the heresy in the Shack, get over your religious self.
It’s a story! A novel and speaks to many people about the love and purpose of a relational God. I bet you’ve never even read the book, but heard from your preacher that it’s bad because the concept challenges religious Hierarchy.
It’s a great story with a great and is NOT a substitute for the Bible and in no way does it contradict the Bible. God is LOVE and that is the premise of this book.
@xtatik74 You are from New Zealand right? What if I wrote a fictional book about an American fellow who met a New Zealander. And he discovered everything about New Zealand he thought he knew was false. There were no mountains there, and it was not an island, it was a peninsula of Alaska. And all the people there were black slaves from Africa. This is what the Shack does about the God of scripture. It re-writes what the Bible says is true and confuses the reader as to what is fiction.
@xtatik74 I'm not sure what happened but I will respond to your comments. If you write a fictional novel you can write whatever you want? Okay, how about I write a story about how Doc Brown and Marty McFly go back in time and discover the holocaust never happened. Or discover that Abraham Lincoln invented communism and secretly hated America, and this is why he was shot. Furthermore, the Bible says only the Son was crucified, unlike the Shack. And I could go on and on.
So you dont believe that Jesus is the personification of God? that they are 3 but one? That if one part of the trinity went through the crucifiction then all suffered?
Jesus said I and the father are one.
Keep it coming.
Spiritual truths can come thru fiction, and they have in an amazing way in the Shack.
Its ok if you dont like it, but I know so many who have been plessed by it. And some have come to know Him. How can that be bad?
@xtatik74 I would recommend searching for a video that talks about the Shack in detail point by point and why it is bad. And no, the Father was not crucified, regardless of whether an argument that the Father was in the Son is made. If the Father was crucified, then the wrath of the Father was not atoned for by the Son. The centrality of the cup of wrath the Father made the Son drink is gone. This is how heresy starts....do you believe in heresy?
@fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp YOU are making a judgment that does not exist, you are writing your own Gospel. It is OUR sins atoned, not Gods wrath. Our penalty is eternal death because of lack of salvation NOT because God is angry nor does his anger need atonement. An immortal (God),cannot be killed hence so God manifested himself as Christ ( mortal) to sacrifice to atone OUR sins, then paid the death penalty for OUR benefit, not his own. Without Christ we were forever dead. DEFINITION OF TRUE LOVE!
Wow! Are we talking about the same book? Or are we reading the same bible?
If you were writing a fictional book then you would be entitled to write what ever you wanted
Secondly my bible speaks of a loving relational God who desires relationship with His childeren. This book does an excellent job of painting a picture of this through a fictional story. If you bible says anything different, you should hit the auther up about that.
@xtatik74 the author of the book claims that the events in the book actually happened to him but was told to say that the book was fictional as not to offend anyone
there is nothing holy nor trinity about this book - Christians, read your bibles! This is some of the heresy that the bible warns us of :( sad to see the spiritual chronic fatigue among so called Christians....
@fntp23 really, thats weird because ive read the bible and am halfway through the book and its matching up perfectly with the word, have you read the bible? because i could give you several things on how its matched up with the bible with scripture to back it up
@joecarter2727 You have to understand that there are people who were taught that a SPECIFIC interpretation of scripture is the TRUTH no matter what else comes in the way. In fact, they might even consider us evil for even allowing ourselves to be open minded about it. Diligence is a two-way street, and each of us believes that the other isn't using it enough. lol quite funny, actually. just gotta keep praying that the truth will show itself. and that people calm down.
@fntp23 No one states it is holy nor trinity. Its only an interpretation of direct definition of scripture which shakes people's religious comfort zone. The literal definition of scripture without the western style hang-ups. For example: in our lifestyle we would never consider God kissing Christ on the lips, but it is only by modern western views that sees this wrong. Also, can't God be shown as a black woman, man was created in Gods image, MALE & FEMALE! Can God not choose how he is seen?
This has been flagged as spam show
I've studied gnostic and new age teachings for years before Jesus took over my life. The ideas and concepts in The Shack are not new. Using the 'Holy Spirit' to tell lies is like the biggest no-no in the Bible. Please pray for the Holy Spirit to reveal whether the teachings in The Shack are true or not. There is no 'secret knowledge/wisdom' to know God. To know God you must turn your life over to Jesus. Its not WHAT you know, its WHO you know. That's Christianity. Gospel not in The Shack once.
djquiz6425 3 days ago
VERY WONDERFUL JOB!! So sorry for all the ugliness in people who feel they must try to hurt others..BEAUTIFULLY DONE!!!
GwenT42 2 weeks ago
are you sick taking the mick out of this?
MorgandHenry139 1 month ago
Nice job..Where can I find the real movie though?..I read the book and to my surprise it brought tears to my eyes..Sad and joyous..Thank you and God Bless:)
Thednatto 2 months ago
this book has a lot of theological CRAP in it!
Norseman870 2 months ago
People say read the bible ! Who's to say the bible isn't fiction !? Half of the stuff in the bible are probably mistaken alien encounters !!!!
millburyman1020 4 months ago
Great job guys, it doesnt need to be perfect you know, what did the teacher say about the project?
bgdomisals 5 months ago
Good idea. I was hoping to see the full version of "The Shack", the entire book/movie. Some day, after all the controversy, maybe it WILL become a beautiful movie.... Until then, home made versions is all we can expect.... You guys, did a great job.....Hope for more. Thank you !!!
tennesseecraig 5 months ago
Kristenyemma this was a very good class project to do. Advertise what you intend for people to respond to. I would LOVE to see Carrie Under wood do the music for the movie if they do make one! I loved the book, so I of course notice the flaws in attitudes as well as cast, but you worked with what you had. Congrats, and I hope you got a good grade for your efforts. Be careful how you respond to people. Rise above name calling. Thanks for reminding us of the book.
hawfitch 5 months ago
Wow this is so far from book. i think you should re read the book and then try another one.
shorey1990 5 months ago
I am sad that the greatest book someone reads is a book of fiction. The greatest book I ever read is the WORD of GOD the bible...
Chey60 6 months ago
Greatest book I ever read in my life....
Greenhornet270 7 months ago
Speak to them first. There. That is my piece!
ItsJustMandi 7 months ago
As a Christian, I loved the book. I do not believe the author intended for readers to take what is in the book as scriptural. What I received from this book was a deeper understanding of the incredible love the Father has for me. I also realize that some people might have problems with the images that God is portrayed as. Why couldn't he reveal Himself to us as a woman, as a different race other than what people are taught to believe He looks like? If the man in that story needed the comfort of
ItsJustMandi 7 months ago
@ItsJustMandi In my opinion God wouldn't place himself in the cross nor deny the hierarchy of him nor place metaphysical astrals all over the place portrayed as a fairy ! Theres more than what meets the eye on this one. The Bible says how much the father loves you and that should be enough as believers to believe. We dont need more junk trying to entangle us into the metaphysical world of the devil by trying to zoom how big the name of the Lord and his love is for us. Amen!
sgttorre 7 months ago
I pray that this book is never made into a movie. The book has done enough damage!! Anyone who reads this book and thinks that it is a book about "God" needs to get out their Bible and read it. This man is a tool of Satan and they have twisted the word of God. It is disgusting the heresies that are in this book. I pray against the influence of this book and that Yahweh will open the eyes of people to see this book for what it is.
MomMessianic 7 months ago
This book is full of false doctrine. Don't read it!! Read the Bible, get your view on God from the Bible!!!
ez33watchman 8 months ago
I appreciate seeing this effort. The book was superb and I really enjoyed this short film. Thanks for your efforts and look forward to seeing more.
himself13 9 months ago
its had 9338 views because there are people out here who are waiting and hoping that the REAL movie will be made...this was misleading.......and fyi...I am not an idiot
taichishe58 9 months ago
Good job!
TechGrl101 10 months ago
Watch these will be the kids who graduate and actually make this a movie like we've all so longing been waiting for!
Good job guys!
DOSmassyMas 10 months ago
Nice job! I hope somebody does make a movie of this excellent book some day.
Munchabunch56 1 year ago
no it's a class project
kristenyemma 1 year ago
@kristenyemma THAT WAS AWESOME!!! THANK YOU!!!! GOD BLESS!!
MrRubnsmoke 4 months ago
@kristenyemma Great choice, well done
roxie64fyi 2 months ago
is this an actaull movie tralier ??
Hero4thelord 1 year ago
Good Job :)
Bettlejack 1 year ago
but thank you to those who supported this video =)
kristenyemma 1 year ago
all you commenters are idiots. this was a high school english project not an actual movie trailer so sorry we didnt happen to have a black woman, fully grown man, or asian in our assigned group. instead of commenting on a childrens english projects on youtube you should try to have a life. btdubs its had 9338 views. beat that.
kristenyemma 1 year ago 6
@kristenyemma Actually you should be proud of the editing, cinematography, and creative set and location work. What I don't understand is why on earth you chose such a mindless piece of drivel as "The Shack" for your project. Surely even high school students can see what a piece of trash that book is. I am not trying to be a troll and it isn't the subject matter I object to. The book has a ridiculous plot, atrocious dialog and the most horrible prose style I have ever encountered.
smegmasaurus 11 months ago
@kristenyemma But being so hateful to others please.
Newtonnewschannel 3 months ago
@kristenyemma I also noticed that you don't have Bog, Jeebus, or the Holy Goat. Guess they weren't among your talent pool either. Know why? Because they DON'T exist! Go put an ad on Craigslist for a casting call. You will get plenty of "grown" men who are more than willing to enact any role you like. Ever seen "To Catch a Predator?" There will be several dozen at your door before the day is over. Just be careful because Bog won't help you. You'd be better off praying to Chris Hanson
smegmasaurus 1 month ago
Woooooow that sucked! Mack is a man not a boy. The acting wasnt even taken serious. No black woman, no asian woman really? This is a joke!
BenLukeMartinez 1 year ago
Comment removed
BenLukeMartinez 1 year ago
Nice song but this looks nothing like the book! Mack should not be a teenager--he has five kids! I'm sadly shocked Mr Young would allow this!
Roni0517r 1 year ago
@Roni0517r it was there refelction of the book, please dont condemn them for there point of view!!!!
saxman9785 1 year ago
this reflects so much of the humour shown in the novel =D (Y) <3
wingszeso 1 year ago
That book made me cry, laugh, and have more faith in things. Im on the part where Makenzie see's Missy under the water fall but Missy cant see him but she can feel him i guess missy is in heavin. Its so sad i was like crying all day. They really should make that a movie. Heyy i would love to watch it.
theMcrWayOfLife 1 year ago 3
@theMcrWayOfLife Who killed the girl?
superCatia 4 months ago
@john146only Biblical world view??? Can you describe God phiscially? This book shakes those that limit God down to a little box because of their own definitions. Yes, it changes views away from the modern western world attitude that believes God only lived in the civilization that we know. This book is NOT scriptural, i however it shows another image that we are not used to seeing using the same biblical definations. For example, should not Christ look like a regular Jewish carpenter?
Crumper00 1 year ago
@john146 The book asks. Was Christ a Christian? Obviously he was not as Christ himself did not require salvation. The Muppets weren't christian iether but that didnt make it a sin nor make it unappropriate. If that were the case God wouldnt have created a sense of humor. If you think we are in the Laodicea era you are behind the times. Christ's Church is more alive than ever before and Christ is with them today. If you can't see that you are looking in the wrong places; still, be not afraid.
Crumper00 1 year ago
Now I am reading the book The Shack. It is great... I´d like to see the film too
Kutnohorak 1 year ago
Firstly to those who speak of the heresy in the Shack, get over your religious self.
It’s a story! A novel and speaks to many people about the love and purpose of a relational God. I bet you’ve never even read the book, but heard from your preacher that it’s bad because the concept challenges religious Hierarchy.
It’s a great story with a great and is NOT a substitute for the Bible and in no way does it contradict the Bible. God is LOVE and that is the premise of this book.
xtatik74 1 year ago
@xtatik74 You are from New Zealand right? What if I wrote a fictional book about an American fellow who met a New Zealander. And he discovered everything about New Zealand he thought he knew was false. There were no mountains there, and it was not an island, it was a peninsula of Alaska. And all the people there were black slaves from Africa. This is what the Shack does about the God of scripture. It re-writes what the Bible says is true and confuses the reader as to what is fiction.
fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp 1 year ago
Comment removed
xtatik74 1 year ago
@xtatik74 I'm not sure what happened but I will respond to your comments. If you write a fictional novel you can write whatever you want? Okay, how about I write a story about how Doc Brown and Marty McFly go back in time and discover the holocaust never happened. Or discover that Abraham Lincoln invented communism and secretly hated America, and this is why he was shot. Furthermore, the Bible says only the Son was crucified, unlike the Shack. And I could go on and on.
fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp 1 year ago
@fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp Please do go on and on, Im enjoying it.
So you dont believe that Jesus is the personification of God? that they are 3 but one? That if one part of the trinity went through the crucifiction then all suffered?
Jesus said I and the father are one.
Keep it coming.
Spiritual truths can come thru fiction, and they have in an amazing way in the Shack.
Its ok if you dont like it, but I know so many who have been plessed by it. And some have come to know Him. How can that be bad?
xtatik74 1 year ago
@xtatik74 I would recommend searching for a video that talks about the Shack in detail point by point and why it is bad. And no, the Father was not crucified, regardless of whether an argument that the Father was in the Son is made. If the Father was crucified, then the wrath of the Father was not atoned for by the Son. The centrality of the cup of wrath the Father made the Son drink is gone. This is how heresy starts....do you believe in heresy?
fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp 1 year ago
@fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp YOU are making a judgment that does not exist, you are writing your own Gospel. It is OUR sins atoned, not Gods wrath. Our penalty is eternal death because of lack of salvation NOT because God is angry nor does his anger need atonement. An immortal (God),cannot be killed hence so God manifested himself as Christ ( mortal) to sacrifice to atone OUR sins, then paid the death penalty for OUR benefit, not his own. Without Christ we were forever dead. DEFINITION OF TRUE LOVE!
Crumper00 1 year ago
@Crumper00 9Since we have now been justified by his blood, how much more shall we be saved from God's wrath through him! (Romans 5:9). God bless.
fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@fgsltwhghobstwbihsnp
Wow! Are we talking about the same book? Or are we reading the same bible?
If you were writing a fictional book then you would be entitled to write what ever you wanted
Secondly my bible speaks of a loving relational God who desires relationship with His childeren. This book does an excellent job of painting a picture of this through a fictional story. If you bible says anything different, you should hit the auther up about that.
How exactly does the shack confuse people?
xtatik74 1 year ago
@xtatik74 the author of the book claims that the events in the book actually happened to him but was told to say that the book was fictional as not to offend anyone
beano1 8 months ago
LOL!
999Brazninja 1 year ago
Better than the Matrix
Crumper00 1 year ago
Ummmm? No!
abbyguy 1 year ago
there is nothing holy nor trinity about this book - Christians, read your bibles! This is some of the heresy that the bible warns us of :( sad to see the spiritual chronic fatigue among so called Christians....
fntp23 1 year ago
@fntp23 really, thats weird because ive read the bible and am halfway through the book and its matching up perfectly with the word, have you read the bible? because i could give you several things on how its matched up with the bible with scripture to back it up
joecarter2727 1 year ago
@joecarter2727 You have to understand that there are people who were taught that a SPECIFIC interpretation of scripture is the TRUTH no matter what else comes in the way. In fact, they might even consider us evil for even allowing ourselves to be open minded about it. Diligence is a two-way street, and each of us believes that the other isn't using it enough. lol quite funny, actually. just gotta keep praying that the truth will show itself. and that people calm down.
watchthefaithrain 1 year ago
@fntp23 No one states it is holy nor trinity. Its only an interpretation of direct definition of scripture which shakes people's religious comfort zone. The literal definition of scripture without the western style hang-ups. For example: in our lifestyle we would never consider God kissing Christ on the lips, but it is only by modern western views that sees this wrong. Also, can't God be shown as a black woman, man was created in Gods image, MALE & FEMALE! Can God not choose how he is seen?
Crumper00 1 year ago
I think its going to be a great movie.
ccorley78 1 year ago
Cut it out, it's a nice try, I at least appreciate your effort, I've just read the book three days ago, it's amazing.
Nerevar93 1 year ago
what a waste!
riodejaneir10 1 year ago
I think I'm going to throw up.
booksandvideos 1 year ago
awsome
aya434 1 year ago
soooo good!!! nice job guys!
kristenyemma 1 year ago