I urge fellow tubers to watch the movie "Ivansxtc", directed by Bernard Rose, a modern take on the Leo Tolstoy novel "The death of Ivan Ilyich". Which uses the prelude and finale to devastating effect. As for the racial politics awash with Wagnerian music, I feel that ultimately the music itself takes precedence, and that it is no longer fashionable to squeak "Racist" at anyone who happens to find the music moving. A sentiment shared by many musical professionals Jewish or otherwise.
this seems to be a brought me here theme.... well i heard this in a cold basement apartment the whole time and sometimes i thought its was cold like the place i was in and then it all started to expand .... i like how it expands.... like a huge ocean. so i figured out was it was called and typed in tristan and isolde and only the prelude appears ... that's waht i heard in the basement it is actually three days long
I, AM here because of Melancholia and am glad to have arrived. The movie, like Wagner's music & many great works of art can leads us to the most profound emotions & thoughts, even inspiring some to go beyond what we thought were their normal limits. Whether the viewer sees the film as a study of clinical depression, Sci-Fi catastrophe, or both, it is rare to find a film such an inspiration for exploring the boundaries of the human experience, but you gotta have an open mind to make the trip.
@hollowcaustic Actually the disgrace is that someone as ignorant as you likes Wagners piece. GTFO, you probably haven't even seen the movie, and even if you did you didn't understand it one bit.
Fullmetal Alchemist is generic Shonen Jump fodder and Samurai Champloo is just daft with it's insipid characters and dialogue, which is only exacerbated by bad hip hop music.
@figocooldude Nietzsche had a love-hate relationship with Wagner (I'm not sure Wagner actually cared too much one way or the other) but Nietzsche eventually turned against Wagner and declared that Carmen by Bizet was superior to any Wagnerian opera. None of the Wagnerian heroes actually ever killed a female heroine, but heroines routinely gave their lives to save the males. I'm not sure what it says about Nietzsche that he was more enthralled with Don Jose & Carmen...
@kalelsjorelson He is talking about the fact that Nietzsche praised this piece even after their break. This piece was very much enjoyed by N. And N didn't like that Wagner's work was becoming more religious and anti semitic, whatever that means. He even mocked Wagner that his father was jewish. Wagner wrote in the letter to doctor that N. nervous problem was excessive masturbating, not that he was homosexual.Letters of his wife show that Wagner felt remorse about break with N.
I'm not here because of Melancholia, that is, by the way, such a huge film that is very difficult to understand. I'm here because Wagner is one of the most greatest composers in History , and particularly this prelude makes my head explodes with, clearly, the most expresive manifestation of culture -Spirit, would say Hegel- of the human kind.
It is well-known that Hitler felt an affection for great artists. Some resisted, others couldn't because they were dead already. The problem is, Hitler did not just hate Jews, he was in many other aspects a very, very sick man. Just because 2 have something in common, they don't have to be particularly fond of eachother. Antisemitism was very common when Wagner lived. Not just in Germany, but in the UK and US too. Hopefully we've come a long way from back then, and are smarter now.
I've never really listened to Wagner before. Seeing "Melancholia" shattered my lens. This piece haunts me, as does the film. I've decided to really listen to as much Wagner as I can find now. I always loved Schubert and Liszt, and now I'm hooked on Wagner even more. Incredible music.
This piece left me paralysed, in addition to the beautiful images by Lars von Triers... really i've reached the peak of sensibility in this piece, and believe me i have listened to many, if i dare put this next to Beethoven's 7th ...
Whether it's because of a movie, a TV commercial, your parents, your high school music class, or your friends, what's important is that you found this great music. Music appreciation doesn't have to start at an early age for it to be genuine.
It's as though Wagner saw way off into the future with music like this. It's simply unfortunate that his views of so many of his contemporaries were so hateful. Definitely a musical genius.
Don't use language in order to abuse it: When making up the word "transcendental" Immanuel Kant was saying that we are able to reflect our ability to think abstractedly. By no means he meant to suggest that we can define a deadline, cross over it and watch the world from the side we have no access to. It was only Hegel, our German idiot, to create such nonsense, followed by the commuists who killed 150 mrd to achieve the job. (You are, however, doing better than expressing your idea by wow, wow.
@MrUmgajo Well, as much as I agree with your last few sentences, it is not sad people had come here because of a movie Melancholia for many reasons, mostly because many people now hear and love this music as much as you and also because it is properly used in a movie that revolves well..around desperation and solitude. So it is an excellent choice for a well made and interesting movie.
I strongly believe everyone should hear and be familiar with the piece. It's massively important to western music, and I'm glad that von Trier's movie brings people to it. My issue is that von Trier uses the piece (or about the first page of the thing) so excessively and so obviously that it becomes parody. It becomes self-referential, reminding us of the prologue to the movie that we're still watching. For me, this dulls the piece's impact and makes it into a self-indulgent tool
Love, longing, orgasms, whatever, yes, but no "desparation" - there are plenty of other works for that kind of stuff.
No "rage", either.
"Tristan and isolda"
No - this music was written with these characters in mind, but as a standalone composition, it only conveys abstract emotions and assocations not specific to even the "star-crossed lovers" archetype.
Oh gee... a pretentious, wide-eyed pseudo snob? Not a good combination :D
This is the most erotic piece of music ever written. A hymn to love and death. Proper for the rituals of Lars Von Trier and in my view, grotesque complement to a movie where no hope arises but the power of universe itself contrasted to the punity and lonliness of Man. A film that will be a landmark to the history of cinema and mostly as the quite opposite of Tarkovsky's "Sacrifice". Satanic, Ironic and deeply Erotic.
@mattcooper07 I'm Jewish. I listen to this over and over. Politics/religion shouldn't factor into the equation when we're talking about a masterpiece like this. Period.
@chamuda610 yeah and dont forget that Wagner was born wayyy before Hitler was conceived so as far as i am concerned just because some a**hole used music for political agenda doesnt make the artist guilty
@del4m3u then why the fuck you commenting. Shut the fuck up and mind your own damn business... it's easy to ignore a few comments out of thousands on a goddamn youtube video.
@altertheskyy1 i agree no one cares i look down in the comments and see 2 of yours and i have to say stop crying on youtube and get a life...no one cares what religion you are or what ou like/dislike...
@chamuda610 Hmm, have you read any of his essays? Do you fully understand the man?
He was a repulsive man, with many flaws, but his music was amazing. If I were Jewish, I'm not sure I could enjoy his music as much as you seem to. While much of his music can be separated from his political views, anti-antisemitism is clearly present in his operas.
Poor example maybe, but I wont watch any Mel Gibson movies, past or present, solely based on his bigotry.
Well, you know, I'm not sure if I could enjoy music by a murderer (such as Gesualdo) without feeling uneasy - but even in that case, I'd recognize it as personal bias of mine.
There is no logical argument supporting the rejection of art based on the artist's biography.
Otherwise, feel free to study every performer's and composer's biography and interview their friends and family before daring to listen to a CD. Consistency is where it's at ;)
@twooffour "no logical argument supporting the rejection of art based on the artist's biography"
- I don't think there are logical arguments for taste, appreciation and artistic ability or factoring in an artist's negative past vs they positive abilities.
I actually think artist details/history can dramatically enhance appreciation of an artist, as well as diminish appreciation. Each to his own.
@costcordero2 Yep! It takes my breath away every time. Maybe a lot of my Jewish friends/family won't listen to Wagner, but I don't care. This is too beautiful.
This music is just one magnificent way of pulling on my heartstrings, intent on warming it, and opening my eyes to the sheer beauty and prowess that the piece exudes infinitely.
for anyone who is interested, this prelude by wagner is used repeatetely throughout the new film Melancholia directed by Lars Von Trier. It is the only major piece of music used repeatetely in the film. I'd consider it the theme music for the film.
Why do people feel the need to argue, here and now, in front of a beautiful piece of music giving itself fully to us all? Sit back and enjoy the show--it will bring you peace. Be humble, that we don't have to go further than a few clicks to see a magical show.
@bayreuth79 hah hah i agree this is SUBLIME... still Wagner, as great as he is , cannot be compared to BEETHOVEN my friend...nobody, no Schumann,Brahms, Wagner, Berlioz or Scriabin or Anybody, can EVER be compared to Beethoven . have a nice day friend...
@maiseyferret It's funny that you say it's cinematic, since they didn't even know what "cinematic" was at this time. This music is just plain amazing. :D
I fully intend to listen to Tristan and Isolde and other works of Wagner in its entirety, which I would not have not done so if I had not heard 'Prelude' in the film. I listen to classical music but knew very little about Wagner. Get my drift?
I echo the last two comments. I saw the film Melancholia today and was introduced to this music for the first time. If people are introduced to beautiful music through popular culture, all the better. This music is not for the elitist few.
Go away Melancholia people. You wouldn't be here if weren't for that movie. Bit like Black Swan really. Some ignorant people never heard of Tchaikovsky before and suddenly they say 'Actually, that's not bad music.' Funny about that.
@t3331157 it's good that people discover this kind of wonderfull music and if movies like melancholia help then more of that please(btw melancholia is a great movie). people like you should be silent, your opinion is not important
@VaultTex I'm not aiming my comments at people like you, nor am I being elitist. I'm referring to people who usually completely listen to popular music and suddenly realise that classical music ain't so bad after all. Film, let's face it, is now for most people the most viewed and accessible art form at the expense of many others, so that gems like Tristan und Isolde are reduced to the stakes of popular culture. If you want to listen to Wagner, listen to Wagner, not its bastardisation.
Just saw Melancholia last night which this piece of music featured prodominantly.
Very fitting indeed, coupled with the subject matter and some of the scenes was at times, sad, unnerving, forboding and sometimes even a little scary.
I do honestly feel that this piece of music made the film what it was and without it the film would have nowhere near the impact.
I died at 07:28
VictorMLudwig 3 days ago
I urge fellow tubers to watch the movie "Ivansxtc", directed by Bernard Rose, a modern take on the Leo Tolstoy novel "The death of Ivan Ilyich". Which uses the prelude and finale to devastating effect. As for the racial politics awash with Wagnerian music, I feel that ultimately the music itself takes precedence, and that it is no longer fashionable to squeak "Racist" at anyone who happens to find the music moving. A sentiment shared by many musical professionals Jewish or otherwise.
Lordstanleyenglish 3 days ago
Soberbo!
itosanjesusprpriedad 4 days ago
This was used so well in Van Tier's film Meloncholia
hereitgosagain12 1 week ago
@hereitgosagain12 Who the fuck is Van Tier ?????????? :D
buraktsch 3 days ago
this appears in God's iPod
33 australopithecus
IORITZgudari 1 week ago
smoking too much dope brought me here
wistoncap 1 week ago 2
this seems to be a brought me here theme.... well i heard this in a cold basement apartment the whole time and sometimes i thought its was cold like the place i was in and then it all started to expand .... i like how it expands.... like a huge ocean. so i figured out was it was called and typed in tristan and isolde and only the prelude appears ... that's waht i heard in the basement it is actually three days long
goupi 1 week ago
Sir Alec Guiness, George Lucas and JRR Tolkien brought me here.
AngeloNiklis 1 week ago
Tirem urgente essa propagandinha idiota do "my fun card" que fica apitando e atraplhando. Não dêem um tiro no próprio pé. Se liga !!!!!!!
roryalmeida 2 weeks ago
Your mum made me come. Now get on with it.
balonglongllama 2 weeks ago
a dream brought me here
SeRe290392 2 weeks ago
nothing brought me here. i just tiped Wagner: Tristan und Isolde - Prelude and than clicked play. hello from Bulgaria :)
erres1981 2 weeks ago
"Love in the Afternoon" more comical than "melancholia"
lynn10flash 2 weeks ago
My personal taste in music brought me here.
Ostrakov 2 weeks ago 6
clicking on about 10 related links brought me here
devilxhlywood 2 weeks ago 3
I was reading nietzsche
ticosexy22 2 weeks ago 2
Thumbs up if Proust brought you here...
vulvakillfire 2 weeks ago in playlist For Work N stuff
seminar presentation deadline looming brought me here ....
hol08048275 2 weeks ago
Isolde brought me here .....
panosfrantzis 2 weeks ago
Melancholia brought me here
angelsalad 2 weeks ago 2
my music teacher made me come here.
cutetip3 3 weeks ago 3
wikipedia brought me here.
mellonxcollie 3 weeks ago
I, AM here because of Melancholia and am glad to have arrived. The movie, like Wagner's music & many great works of art can leads us to the most profound emotions & thoughts, even inspiring some to go beyond what we thought were their normal limits. Whether the viewer sees the film as a study of clinical depression, Sci-Fi catastrophe, or both, it is rare to find a film such an inspiration for exploring the boundaries of the human experience, but you gotta have an open mind to make the trip.
abernardcorpus 3 weeks ago
Fuck Melancholia (Oh what's that in the sky? A rogue planet twice the size of Jupiter heading towards us? Who knew.)
A disgrace to Wagner's masterpiece
hollowcaustic 3 weeks ago
@hollowcaustic Actually the disgrace is that someone as ignorant as you likes Wagners piece. GTFO, you probably haven't even seen the movie, and even if you did you didn't understand it one bit.
fullmetalchamploo 3 weeks ago
@fullmetalchamploo
Your taste in anime sucks as well :)
hollowcaustic 2 weeks ago
@hollowcaustic Please do elaborate on how Fullmetal Alchemist and Samurai Champloo are considered anime that "suck" in your dumbass opinion.
fullmetalchamploo 2 weeks ago
@fullmetalchamploo
Fullmetal Alchemist is generic Shonen Jump fodder and Samurai Champloo is just daft with it's insipid characters and dialogue, which is only exacerbated by bad hip hop music.
So there you have queef jerky
hollowcaustic 20 hours ago
@hollowcaustic Fuck off, troll..
swa5297 2 weeks ago
Does somebody know when this was recorded?
FallenTaru 3 weeks ago
Nietzsche brought me here.
figocooldude 4 weeks ago 67
@figocooldude Nietzsche had a love-hate relationship with Wagner (I'm not sure Wagner actually cared too much one way or the other) but Nietzsche eventually turned against Wagner and declared that Carmen by Bizet was superior to any Wagnerian opera. None of the Wagnerian heroes actually ever killed a female heroine, but heroines routinely gave their lives to save the males. I'm not sure what it says about Nietzsche that he was more enthralled with Don Jose & Carmen...
kalelsjorelson 1 week ago
@kalelsjorelson He is talking about the fact that Nietzsche praised this piece even after their break. This piece was very much enjoyed by N. And N didn't like that Wagner's work was becoming more religious and anti semitic, whatever that means. He even mocked Wagner that his father was jewish. Wagner wrote in the letter to doctor that N. nervous problem was excessive masturbating, not that he was homosexual.Letters of his wife show that Wagner felt remorse about break with N.
miledestroyer1 1 week ago
@miledestroyer1 Exactly.
figocooldude 1 week ago
@figocooldude Ecce Homo?
lpfreak007 1 week ago
@figocooldude me too
derfyxxx1 1 week ago
@figocooldude Me too buddy!
LazyGun625 2 days ago
I'm not here because of Melancholia, that is, by the way, such a huge film that is very difficult to understand. I'm here because Wagner is one of the most greatest composers in History , and particularly this prelude makes my head explodes with, clearly, the most expresive manifestation of culture -Spirit, would say Hegel- of the human kind.
javiermonoartico 1 month ago
Comment removed
clementleung17 1 month ago
Muchas gracias por compartirlo.
sirjuandabicho 1 month ago
It is well-known that Hitler felt an affection for great artists. Some resisted, others couldn't because they were dead already. The problem is, Hitler did not just hate Jews, he was in many other aspects a very, very sick man. Just because 2 have something in common, they don't have to be particularly fond of eachother. Antisemitism was very common when Wagner lived. Not just in Germany, but in the UK and US too. Hopefully we've come a long way from back then, and are smarter now.
nomajeen 1 month ago
music that frees up the soul...
datojana 1 month ago
I am a martian cheesemonger and I like this music.
hellraidzor 1 month ago
This was the only thing that hitler was actually right : this is good music
juanaraci 1 month ago 3
Thumbs up if Melancholia brought you here.
Lildrummerboy50 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Lildrummerboy50 stop asking for thumbs up you beggar
johnmuie 1 month ago in playlist class2
@Hamgammy most of these old composers were pretty eccentric. Seriously they were all nuts in their own ways.
clyve1227 1 month ago
Wagner reportedly had dreams where the ghost of Beethoven visited him and told him he was a better composer. Wagner was a bit eccentric.
Hamgammy 1 month ago 2
na ich bin eine gummi puppe
FranLidiaix377 1 month ago
Can we stop the bullshit and pettiness and focus on the music?
classicallady 1 month ago 25
omg this music
pbpeex 1 month ago 5
Oh, the tension... oh lack of true release. What a great metaphor for the whole of Tristan und Isolde.
RayeChalar 1 month ago 3
What a performance!
DimitrijFedorovic 1 month ago 2
Best performance ever!
CrudeleFan 1 month ago 3
I've never really listened to Wagner before. Seeing "Melancholia" shattered my lens. This piece haunts me, as does the film. I've decided to really listen to as much Wagner as I can find now. I always loved Schubert and Liszt, and now I'm hooked on Wagner even more. Incredible music.
MartianStories 1 month ago
this cannot be compared with the beethoven's 7th because this is a OPERA :p
pbpeex 1 month ago
MELANCHOLIA!!!! I loved the movie!
Ghostshepard 1 month ago 3
This piece left me paralysed, in addition to the beautiful images by Lars von Triers... really i've reached the peak of sensibility in this piece, and believe me i have listened to many, if i dare put this next to Beethoven's 7th ...
sometimesilovelife 1 month ago
astonishing overture
kobyisraelite 1 month ago
@chamuda610 It is worth to read the comments on YouTube just to read enlighten comments like yours.
Mazunteful 1 month ago
Thumbs up if Nietzsche brought you here.
JonathanArsenault12 2 months ago 4
The best music ever composed. Nothing compares to Tristan and Isolde
Veigueta 2 months ago
@Veigueta if you look at german music in general it is very different you can tell it has that German sharpness.
LazyBoy9476 1 month ago
One of the deepest pieces of music ever written brilliantly chosen to become a part of one of the depeest movies ever made.
Lars Von Trier, you are a genious.
sweaq123 2 months ago 3
don't see melancholia, it sucks, even Wagner couldn't save it
fluffyman64 2 months ago
@fluffyman64 "Sucks". What a great critical opinion of a film.
Distortion0 2 months ago
This is an amazing piece! You can hear the solitude and desperation just screaming out! So hauntingly romantic!
Hamgammy 2 months ago
Comment removed
MrUmgajo 2 months ago
mahler mahler
bbawful 2 months ago 2
mahler
bbawful 2 months ago
Whether it's because of a movie, a TV commercial, your parents, your high school music class, or your friends, what's important is that you found this great music. Music appreciation doesn't have to start at an early age for it to be genuine.
WBOwensV 2 months ago 3
It's as though Wagner saw way off into the future with music like this. It's simply unfortunate that his views of so many of his contemporaries were so hateful. Definitely a musical genius.
edhastie 2 months ago
And this is what I think about that.
BenderThaMagnificent 2 months ago
it was the fav music by luis bunuel he had used it, in andlusian dog, the golden age, el, viridiana and that obscure object of desire
MrBandera1968 2 months ago
Don't use language in order to abuse it: When making up the word "transcendental" Immanuel Kant was saying that we are able to reflect our ability to think abstractedly. By no means he meant to suggest that we can define a deadline, cross over it and watch the world from the side we have no access to. It was only Hegel, our German idiot, to create such nonsense, followed by the commuists who killed 150 mrd to achieve the job. (You are, however, doing better than expressing your idea by wow, wow.
MK40213 2 months ago in playlist wagner
bellisimo!!!
pianomirtha 2 months ago
Comment removed
MrUmgajo 2 months ago
@MrUmgajo Well, as much as I agree with your last few sentences, it is not sad people had come here because of a movie Melancholia for many reasons, mostly because many people now hear and love this music as much as you and also because it is properly used in a movie that revolves well..around desperation and solitude. So it is an excellent choice for a well made and interesting movie.
santiagoh92 2 months ago 40
@santiagoh92 well said :)
GrupoAP12e 1 month ago
Comment removed
jeremyrandallhirsch1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@santiagoh92
I strongly believe everyone should hear and be familiar with the piece. It's massively important to western music, and I'm glad that von Trier's movie brings people to it. My issue is that von Trier uses the piece (or about the first page of the thing) so excessively and so obviously that it becomes parody. It becomes self-referential, reminding us of the prologue to the movie that we're still watching. For me, this dulls the piece's impact and makes it into a self-indulgent tool
jeremyrandallhirsch1 1 month ago
@MrUmgajo
Love, longing, orgasms, whatever, yes, but no "desparation" - there are plenty of other works for that kind of stuff.
No "rage", either.
"Tristan and isolda"
No - this music was written with these characters in mind, but as a standalone composition, it only conveys abstract emotions and assocations not specific to even the "star-crossed lovers" archetype.
Oh gee... a pretentious, wide-eyed pseudo snob? Not a good combination :D
twooffour 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@twooffour oh I see... this is too funny !! let's all make a party with this song because this is too happy !!! :D
MrUmgajo 2 months ago
Comment removed
MrUmgajo 2 months ago
This is the most erotic piece of music ever written. A hymn to love and death. Proper for the rituals of Lars Von Trier and in my view, grotesque complement to a movie where no hope arises but the power of universe itself contrasted to the punity and lonliness of Man. A film that will be a landmark to the history of cinema and mostly as the quite opposite of Tarkovsky's "Sacrifice". Satanic, Ironic and deeply Erotic.
Dimitrios Koukoulakis, Greece
jamkouk 2 months ago 4
interlace is killing the video.
zeroinfinit 2 months ago
whoever could possibly dislike a thing as this...
i honestly cannot comprehend.
such sounds are ecstasy for the ears.
i can't even be distracted listening to this.. i have to stop whatever i am doing and just listen in dumbfounded amazement.
LuckyB107 2 months ago
My introduction to this piece of music was Excalibur, 1980 or sometime in the early eighties. That flick should have been called Wagner's Excalibur!
jonbap426 2 months ago in playlist Sith Soundtrack
this at the beginning of the movie brought tears to my eyes
krystalericalewis 2 months ago 3
Wagner achieves structural unity in his gargantuan productions via the
usage of leitmotif, sequences, and periods.
Periods are structural divisions of acts often with AAB (bar form) or
ABA (arch form – or bogen). However, these forms are not aurally obvious
and are camouflaged by transitions, codas, introductions, etc.
Francesko263 2 months ago 2
@Francesko263 Awesome! Thanks for telling me that.
I herd this in Von Trier's Melancholia. Fucking excellent movie and piece of music!
MsBickle76 2 months ago 2
Sequences or semi-sequences abound in Wagner’s operas, whereby
motives recur (possibly with slight alterations), transposed to other degrees.
Schoenberg called this formal approach “developing variation” and it assists
the listener in making the themes memorable.
Francesko263 2 months ago 2
Chromaticism in the music of our time tends to fall into three categories:
1) Momentary chromaticism.
A chromatic note is considered a “non harmonic” tension and is quickly
resolved (usually by step) to a consonance (usually a note in the chord).
2) Delayed resolution.
A chromatic note is “elongated” or prolonged in time before eventual
resolution. This increases the importance of the “wrong” note.
Francesko263 2 months ago 3
3) Pan-tonal chromaticism.
A chromatic note may not resolve at all. Tonal ambiguities in the harmony
are manifested by complex polyphony. Tension is a relative term and
notes tend to speak with almost equal importance. Tone colour, rhythm
and orchestration come to the fore as important elements of “hamony” and organization of musical space.
Francesko263 2 months ago
Comment removed
Francesko263 2 months ago
Comment removed
Francesko263 2 months ago
Comment removed
Francesko263 2 months ago
People who dislike this piece just don't like Romantic music. ;)
existentialistcat 2 months ago
einfach nur wunderschön bin gerade in einer andren welt
doifal 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
29 people don't have a soul.
or they could be jewish...
mattcooper07 2 months ago
@mattcooper07 fairly certain the conductor is jewish
devilxhlywood 2 months ago
@devilxhlywood Actually Indian, but he's conducted in Israel.
chamuda610 2 months ago
@mattcooper07 I'm Jewish. I listen to this over and over. Politics/religion shouldn't factor into the equation when we're talking about a masterpiece like this. Period.
chamuda610 2 months ago 64
@chamuda610 yeah and dont forget that Wagner was born wayyy before Hitler was conceived so as far as i am concerned just because some a**hole used music for political agenda doesnt make the artist guilty
LazyBoy9476 2 months ago 2
@LazyBoy9476 Agreed.
chamuda610 2 months ago
@LazyBoy9476 Thank you! =) ( I totally agree.)
MusicBeautyLove 2 months ago
@MusicBeautyLove he was openly anti-semite, you cant take that away from him.
LazyBoy9476 1 month ago
@chamuda610 you are still a jew
johnmuie 1 month ago in playlist wagner
@johnmuie Your comment says a lot more about you than it does about me. Shabbat shalom.
chamuda610 1 month ago 3
@chamuda610 Jew ...
You, you can not appreciate this delightful music.
markitosbdn 1 month ago 7
@markitosbdn shut the fuck up dumb ass. unless you're kidding.
altertheskyy1 1 month ago
@altertheskyy1 This demonstrated that the Jews did not aprencian art.
The only art they have is if anthropological system of "copy".
Never create only copied.
They can not appreciate art.
markitosbdn 1 month ago
@markitosbdn My father's jewish you fucking retard. stop generalizing. stupid fucking anti-semite.
altertheskyy1 6 days ago
@altertheskyy1 Sorry, if your father is Jewish, you are racially Jewish.
No wonder you can appreciate this music, quiet, do not fret.
markitosbdn 6 days ago
@markitosbdn whatever. I appreciate art. My father does as well.
altertheskyy1 6 days ago
@altertheskyy1 no one cares
del4m3u 6 days ago
@del4m3u then why the fuck you commenting. Shut the fuck up and mind your own damn business... it's easy to ignore a few comments out of thousands on a goddamn youtube video.
altertheskyy1 6 days ago
@altertheskyy1 i agree no one cares i look down in the comments and see 2 of yours and i have to say stop crying on youtube and get a life...no one cares what religion you are or what ou like/dislike...
darrenegan2k9 5 days ago
@chamuda610 Hmm, have you read any of his essays? Do you fully understand the man?
He was a repulsive man, with many flaws, but his music was amazing. If I were Jewish, I'm not sure I could enjoy his music as much as you seem to. While much of his music can be separated from his political views, anti-antisemitism is clearly present in his operas.
Poor example maybe, but I wont watch any Mel Gibson movies, past or present, solely based on his bigotry.
clearlogicify 1 month ago
@clearlogicify
Well, you know, I'm not sure if I could enjoy music by a murderer (such as Gesualdo) without feeling uneasy - but even in that case, I'd recognize it as personal bias of mine.
There is no logical argument supporting the rejection of art based on the artist's biography.
Otherwise, feel free to study every performer's and composer's biography and interview their friends and family before daring to listen to a CD. Consistency is where it's at ;)
twooffour 1 month ago
@twooffour "no logical argument supporting the rejection of art based on the artist's biography"
- I don't think there are logical arguments for taste, appreciation and artistic ability or factoring in an artist's negative past vs they positive abilities.
I actually think artist details/history can dramatically enhance appreciation of an artist, as well as diminish appreciation. Each to his own.
clearlogicify 1 month ago
@chamuda610 how can u be jewish and appericate this? r u a self hating jew?
meiro00102 1 month ago
@meiro00102 I'm jewish and I don't mind. It's really good music.
ApolyonTheSoulRender 1 month ago
@chamuda610 ... couldn't agree with u more, i'm african - american & i know this is an absolute masterpiece ...
costcordero2 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@costcordero2 nigger
johnmuie 1 month ago in playlist class2
@johnmuie You have a problem, man. Peace.
chamuda610 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@costcordero2 wat r u talking about u poor dumb nigger? u like this music? lol
meiro00102 1 month ago
@costcordero2 Yep! It takes my breath away every time. Maybe a lot of my Jewish friends/family won't listen to Wagner, but I don't care. This is too beautiful.
chamuda610 1 month ago
This is stunning.
kittenwit 2 months ago
This music is just one magnificent way of pulling on my heartstrings, intent on warming it, and opening my eyes to the sheer beauty and prowess that the piece exudes infinitely.
mattchoules1 2 months ago
Comment removed
mattchoules1 2 months ago
Oh man. What happened to the pizz at the end??
jhernandez16 2 months ago
this is such an intense piece. it's heartrending and beautiful all at once.
bingin15 2 months ago
Might be hard to follow a baton that changes to pixels when it's diagonal like that
TehKeytar 3 months ago 5
for anyone who is interested, this prelude by wagner is used repeatetely throughout the new film Melancholia directed by Lars Von Trier. It is the only major piece of music used repeatetely in the film. I'd consider it the theme music for the film.
AFcunningham 3 months ago 80
@AFcunningham no shit sherlock, did you figure that out by yourself?
TheBombson 2 months ago
@AFcunningham I read that in EW. They are showing the movie on Demand the same day as the theatrical Can't wait to see the movie!
gypsygirl58 2 months ago
@AFcunningham now I've watch the film, I can't help having the last scene in my mind when the climax comes. just unforgettable...
Yonderin 2 months ago
@AFcunningham Also used at the end of the Russell Crowe film HEAVEN'S BURNING. Unfortunately it's not uploaded here.
1915fas 2 months ago
@AFcunningham thats what brought me here. its a beautiful movie
bullbunnies 2 months ago
@AFcunningham already seen... its marvelous, beautiful, its THE movie.
andyy91 2 months ago
InternalCompass needs to go home to the Kibbutz.
HangAllKoonz 3 months ago
Why do people feel the need to argue, here and now, in front of a beautiful piece of music giving itself fully to us all? Sit back and enjoy the show--it will bring you peace. Be humble, that we don't have to go further than a few clicks to see a magical show.
LiaxJersey12 3 months ago 3
Comment removed
InternalCompass 3 months ago
@LiaxJersey12 It's a Wagner video; we must argue.
OldSchopenhauer 3 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@OldSchopenhauer Heil Hitler!
domdeone 2 months ago
This is music at its most sublime- no composer before or since has reached so deeply into the human spirit than Wagner.
bayreuth79 3 months ago 3
@bayreuth79 hah hah i agree this is SUBLIME... still Wagner, as great as he is , cannot be compared to BEETHOVEN my friend...nobody, no Schumann,Brahms, Wagner, Berlioz or Scriabin or Anybody, can EVER be compared to Beethoven . have a nice day friend...
sessionmessiah 1 month ago
So good!!
EsmeraldaIris36 3 months ago
Like is not enough. I am completely in love with this overture
MrLeonardomalaguti 3 months ago 2
Seriously, moments like that at 7:30 are why I love music. Such emotion and beauty, this music is so cinematic...
maiseyferret 3 months ago
@maiseyferret It's funny that you say it's cinematic, since they didn't even know what "cinematic" was at this time. This music is just plain amazing. :D
aahwUNL11 2 months ago
enchanting!
rhiannonbjones 3 months ago
For goodness sake shut the fuck up!
Mike5626 3 months ago
Also found this after watching Melancholia- this composition also inspired Vertigo's composition
PtAltmVansanTarr 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
9 times out of 10, the person criticizing Wagner's music is a Jew, Half-Jew or Jew-lover. Fuck them.
HangAllKoonz 3 months ago
Comment removed
InternalCompass 3 months ago
Comment removed
InternalCompass 3 months ago
I cant even stand when i listen to this, its just to amazing, I find his use of key as a system of emotion the best part
Contrabassology 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wagner sucks
Jaujaujau01 3 months ago
This brought tears to my eyes.
randomUnhold 3 months ago 19
I fell in love with this piece of music from 1983's Excalibur.
jonbap426 3 months ago
I fully intend to listen to Tristan and Isolde and other works of Wagner in its entirety, which I would not have not done so if I had not heard 'Prelude' in the film. I listen to classical music but knew very little about Wagner. Get my drift?
mspeaceist 3 months ago
i only see the blue planet melancholia when I hear this
isistylelab 3 months ago in playlist isistylelab's favorites
Comment removed
isistylelab 3 months ago in playlist isistylelab's favorites
VOYAGE DANS LES HAUTES SPHÈRES DE L HUMAIN.
revelatorization 3 months ago
I echo the last two comments. I saw the film Melancholia today and was introduced to this music for the first time. If people are introduced to beautiful music through popular culture, all the better. This music is not for the elitist few.
mspeaceist 3 months ago
Go away Melancholia people. You wouldn't be here if weren't for that movie. Bit like Black Swan really. Some ignorant people never heard of Tchaikovsky before and suddenly they say 'Actually, that's not bad music.' Funny about that.
t3331157 3 months ago
@t3331157 it's good that people discover this kind of wonderfull music and if movies like melancholia help then more of that please(btw melancholia is a great movie). people like you should be silent, your opinion is not important
johnmuie 3 months ago in playlist wagner 2
@t3331157 I know a lots of classic music, I play in an orchestra. And I first heard it in the movie Melancholia.
So what the fuck?
VaultTex 3 months ago 3
@VaultTex I'm not aiming my comments at people like you, nor am I being elitist. I'm referring to people who usually completely listen to popular music and suddenly realise that classical music ain't so bad after all. Film, let's face it, is now for most people the most viewed and accessible art form at the expense of many others, so that gems like Tristan und Isolde are reduced to the stakes of popular culture. If you want to listen to Wagner, listen to Wagner, not its bastardisation.
t3331157 3 months ago
this has me feeling "Melancholia" and the like.
osbely 3 months ago 3
Life is only on earth
and not for long.
VaultTex 3 months ago 5
Just saw Melancholia last night which this piece of music featured prodominantly.
Very fitting indeed, coupled with the subject matter and some of the scenes was at times, sad, unnerving, forboding and sometimes even a little scary.
I do honestly feel that this piece of music made the film what it was and without it the film would have nowhere near the impact.
Sensational
LivinJoke84 3 months ago
OBRA MONUMENTAL, MARAVILLOSO , COMO UN PAJARO COLOR ORO EN UN CIELO AZUL
Gmpim121 3 months ago
Thumbs up if you're here because of Friedrich Nietzsche.