UK Indendent Review of HTC Magic (Vodaphone) vs HTC G1 (T-Mobile) Form/Factor

[Thekingof21]

t mobile g1 kills my touch 3G yeh.

[TheJacksp4]

jacky knows wat he's gonna get!

=)

[mrkhan]

no lie. That was the best review/comparison I've seen so far!

Very well done

[iSwaggrite]

g1=528MHz

Magic (G2)=also 528MHz

magic prob faster beckuz its newer and less apps

[AK963]

There are two different versions of the magic, one with 192MB of ram and one with 288mb, so the magic has the potential to be a lot faster.

[AltDimension]

The UK Vodafone branded Magic only has 192mb RAM

[AK963]

Yup, Rogers Magic has 288

[brianv3ntura]

its faster because the magic has more ram. and its not called g2. the only android phone that is call g2 is the g2 touch from tmobile uk which is the htc hero

[bero008]

u forgot about the battery n the OS ver.

[bero008]

u forgot about ram and OS

[adammorris321]

Due to get this phone tomorrow, with any luck.

I've seen a lot of reviews of this phone, and you seriously did a good job here. Most of the others state the obvious, and take a long time doing it too.

You gave your honest opinion, and that's a lot more useful that just giving out the stats that everyone else does.

nice one.

[sophabgurl]

this is a reali good review, alot better than those ones with experience in reviews

[zlada]

nice review man

[Younggin20]

one question, when is it coming out in america?

[iSwaggrite]

soon...rumored next week to tmobile

[MyTrophySpace]

Great review

[methodandsound]

sweet review man, this may sway me.

[maxclatters]

you should've kept the g1.

[ruiruivo83]

nice review.

[TooSmallToBeTrue]

just to let you know the G1 now has a recorder and the on screen QWERTY keyboard with auto retation. . . tbh i think they are both the same but the magic is smaller, by a diffrent company so if you dont like T-mobiles tarrfs you can go to Vodaphone's Magic which is realy the same phone, its more faster, and the selling point the batt life is somewhat better than the G1. . . but still the G1 is better :L! :p

[dev8D]

As much as I like the look and feel of Magic, I couldn't give up my click keyboard.

[andyhwaiting]

Nice review. My love for Google might be enough to make me switch from a Blackberry to Android. How is typing on the Magic? Though Dream has the physical keyboard, it just ain't sexy.

[sandsea15]

you looked nervous mate :D nice try for the first time! thank you for the sharing.

[ursimon]

got the same tee!

[watchurmouthyoungman]

can i have your g1? :P