Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,793)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Beats the original in each and every aspect.

  • This song it's really cool

    obviously you can't make a bad cover of such a good song (:

  • i'm a huge zeppelin fan, and this still turns me on, it's good, different, but possibly just as good

  • More of a techno-esque vibe?

    Whatever the goal is, I like the end result.

  • Comment removed

  • Love it

  • This one is going for a totally different vibe. It's not fair to compare the two.

  • Oh, I'm sorry if I like this one better than the original. Its something called opinion, or taste, if you will. Both versions are great, I just like this one more.

  • I like it and, given that the movie's lead character is a woman, I think it had to be sung by a woman. Wouldn't have made since otherwise and Karen O did it justice.

  • Like!

  • I love this track.

    

  • Don't compare. That's not the point of covers.

    The point of covers is for the covering artist to present his or her own interpretation of the original and make it their own, which is exactly what is done in this version. Both versions sound incredible, in two totally different ways. Beautiful song.

  • led zeppelin all the way

  • I Love Karen O!

  • Not bad, I have to admit... but something is missing.

    Ah, I know: Add some Plant, Page, Jones and Bonham, remove some other things and we have a perfect song! ;)

  • Don't even compare!

  • In my personal opinion, this is better.

    But i love both (:

  • I love both versions.

  • This is that one cover that has balls to go real unorhtodox, but manages to capture the greatness of the zep. One has to realise this was made more than 40 years after the original and both songs are contrasts of both times

  • I like this version......but better the original, HELL NO! some covers are better( I feel that John Grant's cover of the beatles "two of us" was fantastic and better than the original and I LOVE THE ORIGINAL!) it does give the song a new edge to it. please understand people we are all entitled to our opinions but to insult the classics shows how narrow minded you are. also in return, can we progress in music if we don't try something new also?

  • someone gave me the link and when i saw it was a cover i was like "dear god please...why this song?!!?! they could have ruined any other song!!!" but...this is actually good! agree it is hard to work with classic material without making a mess...but i am impressed

  • I have never seen this movie nor the swedish version but I have read the series and they were good. My favorite was the second one cuz of all of the tension that it brought.

  • amaziing!

  • I actually love this version more. It's darker and more badass. Very hard to modernize a classic. Daring and ACCOMPLISHED!!!

  • Sick fucking epic winning song.

  • I adore the original but I like this one better beacause its darker and the rawness of karens voice is just amazing I love her

  • For fuck sake people! It's all personal preference! I personally don't like the original, but I adore this cover. We all have different taste! If we didn't it would be boring. Just listen and shut up, thank you :)

  • i just finished my pilates ab workout to this song, i feel amaaaazing & ready to kick martin vanger's ass.

  • @softcorenightsxox spoilers

  • @EderRedfield the movie itself is a spoiler, they made it so painfully obvious! ):

  • I like them both. The cover and the original. :)

  • Holy Shit @SeraphimZ3r0 You definitely need a major mood modifier like ummm Thorazine or ummm say LSD maybe even Arsenic. Do the world a favor don't breed. I Like the Original but I also Like this as well they each have there own merits. OUTIE

  • aaaaa aaaaaaa aa aaa vuuuuuu vuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuu haaa huh

  • wow led zeppelin elitist's and haters can go away, this is a great cover for a great film so enjoy the music and stfu

  • @Sheepeyy it is a great cover, but not as good as the original, that is all i am saying.

  • HPacheco2009 s pussy hurts.

  • I listen to both this one is better. Just an opinion people dont cry bout it.

  • yeah fuck the USA, but dont say "Americans" i am Argentinian, and i am part of america too ^

  • And the american version of that movie is discussing never but never ever this girl can take the original spot of Lisbeth Salander is just about soul not manipulating media. Tell the girl to go prostitute herself somewhere instead get easy life trying to still others people role.

  • @HPacheco2009 i agree that the original actress is far more better than the usa version

  • Fuck you Americans using pure european souls and gave strong sounds in something already created. This is not creativity and Atticus Ross and Trent you guys fuck you drug pricks manipulating media tools and pretend you are musicians sorry you need much more the volume sounds to impressive someone. And How to destroy angels is a name from Coil's band nothing new unless for the stupid crowd you guys have in US.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 mediocre? overrated? MY ASSS! Led Zeppelin: stairway to heaven 1973, trent reznor or anybody can make such a great live performance as that 1. if u dont like led zeppelin, u dont like music. go listen justin bieber cunt.

  • @SBlachere Stairway was *the* most overrated song. I'm convinced that nostalgic hippies and ironic hipsters are the only reason it's still such a big deal. It isn't all that good.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 what music do YOU hear? i dont want to know, i know it is crap. Led Zeppelin created this song, THIS cover is overrated, not Led Zeppelin. Stariway to Heaven is A BIT overrated ( i think it is the greates song ever, but i have my reasons) But that doesnt mean it is "mediocre" like u say, hippies and hipsters? what!? i am not either of those. U sir Are a complete asshole, u need to learn what is and what is not music. Led Zeppelin is one of the greatet gifts music gave us.

  • @SBlachere Calm down guy

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • rooney mara was AWESOME in this movie !!! hope she wins the oscar...unfortunately the people's choice does not win :(

  • enough with the shit of "this version is better", two different takes on the song and two completely different genres of music, anyone who say one is better is a douche, it's your personal preference. This is Led Zeppelin's song and this it trent reznor's take on it. I'm a huge Zeppelin fan my whole life, they took blues songs and made them into hard rock songs, so what?

    Zeppelin fans shouldn't care so much, and reznor fans shouldn't say which is better, just shut the fuck up and listen

  • @LpZil91 i am also a led zepplin fan. i think you are right it is his take on the song. does not mean the remake is better or worse. i do like the original better this is my personal taste. unless the remake is extremely bad then i will trash it.

  • You are correct, Led Zeppelin IS a band. 

  • Pretty freaking amazing cover! Led Zeppelin are way over rated. And the movie was awesome. And she's really hot...should I add anything??

  • @Rimherk they are not over rated -.- overated is the modern music, people call justin bieber "music", Led Zeppelin were the gods of rock...they still are. each of they songs was worth listening to, they didnt have a crapy album with 2 good songs and the rest shit.

  • @SBlachere I personally have listened to A LOT of rock music. And Led Zeppelin have some really good songs; they simply are not "gods" of anything. I think that Them Crooked Vultures are way better than Zeppelin, and Jimmy Page did much better when he played with the Yardbirds back in the days.

  • @Rimherk well, Them Crooked Vultures are really good ^ i didnt know them, but it is a "super group" formed by already famous artists. One of them: The bassist formed part Led Zeppelin. Led Zeppelin was formed by unknow musicians (not jimmy page) Jhon Bonham was kicked from a bar for his way of playing and still is consider one of the best drummers of all history. Page was way better in Zeppelin than in the yardbirds. I have also listened a lot of rock music, nothing like Zeppelin.:)

  • @SBlachere I know that JPJ was a member of the Zeppelin, that's why I quoted them as being better than the Zeppelin. Bonham was a kick-ass drummer, there's no doubt about that. But the mingling of Bonham, Page & Plant just didn't work for very great music. There are a bunch of catchy tunes, and some really good songs. But overall they're not that great.

    Zeppelin's version of this song is not as good as Trent Reznor's...imho!

  • @Rimherk wow, One of the best Led Zeppelin atributes was their connection, page & plant specially, overall? not that great? D: good guitar (the best in my opinion) great vocals incredible drums and really good bass. Every Zeppelin song has a catchy tune, and every song is a really good song. Trent Reznor version is a different genre, The original song genre is Hard Rock, reznor song doesnt feel like hard rock.

  • Anyone who likes covers of songs that don't include real instruments, like this crap, is a fag. Dislike.

  • I love this cover, no matter what anyone says.

  • This cover and Lisbeth Salander are both dazzlingly appealing

  • orgasmic voice. fuckkkkk

  • Full body eargasm.

  • Volim Zeppeline ali ovo je 100 puta jače! Ovako ja zamišljam R'n'R za 21. vek!

  • This should have been used in the movie Thor.

  • @pyrogyra72 This should have been used in every movie. Even the kiddy ones. Even the OLD ones.

  • cool cover

  • This is the best version of any Zeppelin song I have ever heard. That includes Zeppelin themselves.

  • Comment removed

  • the modern version of Immigrant Song. ^

  • This is so cool.This is so sexy

  • Sexy

  • If ya like this one, than check the ''DEMONS AND WIZARDS'' version of the ''IMMIGRANT SONG'': it ROCKS!!

  • better than original tbh

  • @WhiteWoodGaming Your comment 4 sure will turn everybody crazy around here son

  • My neighbor listens to this song everyday. Whether he likes it or not!

  • @portuguesechicken Whoa u r really a badass don´t you?

  • @portuguesechicken HAHAHAHAHAHA

  • @portuguesechicken

    I like loud music too, but I"m not an inconsiderate asshole with no manners, I use my headphones.

  • can;t get enough of this song! trent reznor is the man!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Coooooooool!!!!

  • KAREN O IS MY IDOL!!! SHE IS BEAUTIFUL AND AMAZING (:

  • Better than the original. Then again, I'm nor overly fond of zeppelin.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 Wait, wait...

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 Have you actually listened to Zeppelin? Have a night alone with them. Just sit back and let that band seep into your soul. It doesnt take long. If you can watch their live dvd (this song particularly) and still not be infatuated you are from another planet.

  • @arobinson807 Yes, I have listened to zeppelin. A million times. I've listened on my own. I've had other people try to make me listen. I've had advice just like yours, in which people treat zeppelin's music as though it's a spiritual experience. In every instance, I've found them to be completely mediocre and could not get into it at all. Perhaps I *am* from another planet. If so, I hope it has decent music.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 no its not. One thing is remaking the song with computer sounds and other thing is making a cover. Also, NEVER, NEVER a cover or a remake will be better than the original, it is easier to cover than to create ;)

  • @SBlachere That doesn't make any sense. Of course a cover can be better than the original. The original was abrasive to my ears, and I like this one. Therefore, to me, this is better than the original, since I didn't like the song at all when it was done the first time. As I previously said, I've never cared for zeppelin. I think they're one of the most overrated bands in history.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 I actually think Nirvana holds that title... imo anyway

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 "Better than the original" ??? !!!

    How dare you

  • @Veronikaynadamas Yes, how dare he have one of those opinion thingies.

  • @Veronikaynadamas But it is better than the original....

  • @Veronikaynadamas Its better than the original

  • @AbsolutVeidt You suck

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 I understand you not being a fan of Led Zeppelin but please do not say that this is better than the original. It is nowhere near better.

  • @stickmaster546 It's better to me. I can only state my opinion haha. As far as I'm concerned, zeppelin isn't all that good, and this is the only version of this song I've ever found palatable.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 At least respect the band. They created Immigrant Song so give them props for that. Zeppelin is still way better than this crap..

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 BITCH DON'T EVER DISS LED ZEPPELIN. I will hunt you down and rip your ears off.

  • @SeraphimZ3r0 ok because i dont know you, im going to pretend i didnt hear that

  • @theygunaHATEME Haha don't pretend on my behalf. I stand by it. The nostalgia factor is the only thing keeping them relevant.

  • This song, this movie and this girl makes me feel immediately in a maze, matted by this masterpieces...

  • Personally, I'm sick of this reputation that Led Zeppelin fans have built for that fucking band. They're a band. A really good band, but at the end of the day, they're human beings. Why the fuck can't they be covered just like every other god damn band out there? This cover is fucking amazing.

  • @ProWrestlingAttack mostly because karen o is an annoying hipster cunt

  • @ProWrestlingAttack : I agree. Though, this is one of the Few times it goes right. lol. !

  • @ProWrestlingAttack Agreed. I mean, there's been covers of Beatles songs and Elvis songs, so why are Zeppelin immune to it? And I'm a LedZep fan.

  • @Eurashal :P Led Zeppelin doesnt want his music to be used for commercial shit. Elvis is death, the Beatles doesnt exist anymore.

  • @ProWrestlingAttack too many hours spent in cess pools have given you shite between your ears.....now get a job and leave your mom's basement.

  • @ProWrestlingAttack

    WHO THE FUCK IS LED ZEPPELIN????

    (just kidding ^_^)

  • @ProWrestlingAttack I cannot agree with you more. This is an unbelievably good cover of a song from a great, but not divine band. Unfortunately, those of us who do not act as if the members of Led Zeppelin are deities are often silenced.

  • mükemmel bir filme harika bir soundtrack.

  • This song makes me want to come out of the rock I live under and explore the world more maybe then it wouldn't have taken me so long to find this... I adore the mighty Zep and Karen O and this is almost better then sex...

  • I agree, BEST movie intro ever !!!!

  • this cover rocks! set the tone for an amazing film

  • I have a question for English-speaking people. Do you really understand every word Karen sings without reading lyrics first ????

  • @aga1789 not always....but it's like that with most artists, not just karen.

  • @aga1789 I actually do, more than the original version by Led Zepplin.

  • Lol at the long line of spammers a few pages back.

  • Jack Black! School of rock!

  • I like it when she says "AHHHH, AH, AHHHH, AH!"

  • I prefer this version to Zeppelin's. Im not bothered what other's say.

  • Fuck Yea =D

  • Absolutely in love with Lisbeth. This song fits perfectly, 'nuff said.

  • Comment removed

  • So hot.

  • Bloody brilliant. The edge and venom in this piece is pure Reznor, and the vocals bring the angst that fits the movie perfectly. A note-worthy cover of a classic.

  • @nerosevengen The opening of the movie with this song is pretty darn slick too

  • That movie was the best movie i have ever seen, fucking brilliant.

  • @JKryanX Why would you say that here? lol GTFO

  • just came back from the pictures and saw this film, pretty fuckkin' awesome to!!

  • one of the best remakes i have come across....sets the tone of the movie!!!!!!!!!!!

  • best part of the movie IMO

  • Imagine if "The Dark Knight Rises" intro started like this. O_______O I fucking love this movie btw.

  • @HurleenV It's getting there...

  • The vocalist sounds just like Taylor Momsen from The Pretty Reckless

  • Led Zeppelin version is obviously awesome, but this version gets you super pumped to watch the movie (which is awesome too) XD!!!

  • OMG!! the rape scene both in the english and swedish version made me want puke, i seriously panic every fucking time

  • If Batman Beyond ever gets made into a movie, get Trent to do the music score. No exceptions. :-)

  • Trent reznor and david fincher combined= orgasm

  • orgasm!!!

  • KAREN O!!! only she would sing such a badass song

  • Great intro as good as in Se7en or Fight CLub. David Fincher is amazing!

  • If a wrestler had this as his entrance theme he would instantly be the most awesome wrestler ever.

  • @RySenkari WOMAN wrestler! YEAH!

    

  • @RySenkari AS long as as he was Scandinavian.

  • good but no coconut.Led Rules...dred zeppelin a close second

  • I know everyone thinks of 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo' whenever they hear this, but I always think of Shrek lmao

  • @KangarooBird121 my best friend said the same thing... hahaha

  • @KangarooBird121 IKR? And Snow white! But that was "Barracuda"

  • @KangarooBird121 OMFG SAME!!! I love how i'm not the only one

  • @KangarooBird121 Same here. xD

  • @KangarooBird121 lmfao. Shrek is pretty bad-ass too!

  • @KangarooBird121 I think of School of Rock

  • @GoughyBCFC Your comment makes me think of tenacious D when I think of this song lol fuckin jack black

  • @GoughyBCFC call me strange, but i think of Led Zeppelin when i hear "Immigrant Song."

  • @KangarooBird121 lolwut?

  • @KangarooBird121 ........I think of School of Rock when I hear this song. The original is better...

  • @KangarooBird121 This song was in Shrek the third, very briefly though.

  • @KangarooBird121 I think of Led Zeppelin who made the original

  • @KangarooBird121 LOL!!!

  • I LOVE THE DRUMS ON THIS <3 <3

  • Best movie intro ever

  • @PatrycjaPolechonska Actually, the best intro to a movie is probably Lord of War, if you haven't seen that check that out. Not only a great song, but amazingly filmed. The movie was excellent too.

  • @coryboy345 I haven't seen it yet but I will definitely check it out!