Added: 4 years ago
From: thekato
Views: 103,130
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (119)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Just because it's a cover of the original song doesn't mean you have to automatically resent it. If you could just put aside the fact that it's a cover of a famous song by the beatles and listen to how beautiful she sounds and remember being in high school having these feelings... it's just so amazing.

  • the dude in the bottom of me, has no taste in music, like come on. It awesome... but hey, it that person opinion, u like it or u don't, but this is a good movie!

  • this movie ruined the beatles songs

  • the song is by the beatles and they dident want to alter the song to make it fit

  • I really whant 2 cry...

  • those are my school colors.

  • mine too!!!

  • your school's a booger

  • shes not a les.

  • yes she is.

  • i meant not in real life... i meant to say what

    burning1rain1nk said

  • she is but just for the movie.

  • she is...she was singing to a girl

  • I admit the references are a bit vague at first glance, but I believe that is purposefully so. In my day (the 60's), it was absolutely scandelous to be other than totally heterosexual. As the movie is set in that period, it makes sense that references to Prudence's persuation would be left questionable.

  • Yes, she is Lesbian. Prudence is singing longing to her cheerleader teammate, the blonde one. Also, the musical call of the New York flat renters to their love-struck roomate Prudence, weeping in the CLOSET, is "COME OUT to play"; humorously poignant as well as deliciously tongue-in-cheek. Add to this, when they all meet up again at the Circus, Prudence happily remarks that her new ladyfriend is a Contortionist.

  • i think she's bi bcuz at 1 point she mentions that she sleeps w/max so...

  • yes u guys she is a lesbian in this scene she is talking 2 the blonde cheerleader and in that one "i want u" scene she is talking 2 sadie

  • that was for kismit1...;D

  • lol.. i thought that too but if you hear whatthey say when their talking about prudence while she is sitting outside looking at sadie they say something like i think she loves her... im pretty sure shes a lezbian but i could be wrong ;P

  • exelent movie

  • EVERY SONG iS BY THE BEATLES ON THiS MOViEE

    SHE iS AMAZiNGGGG

    i AM OBSESSED WiTH THE MOViE

  • good job tv..! your such a good singer love your voice.

  • who sang this song? I love it

  • i wanna hold your hand - by the beatles

  • DO NOT READ THIS IF YOU HAVENT SEEN THE MOVIE**

    -------

    ------

    -----

    -----

    her name is Prudence (yes shes a Lez)

    the one she loves turn out o be Sadie (but sadie doesnt love her back sadie loves JoJo)

    in this clip shes singing to one of the cheerleaders (who i guess she fell in love with at the time) and thats why she goes to New York, to get away from all the sadness cause she couldnt stand the pain

    hope this clears a few thing up

  • shes bisexual

  • wait seriously?

  • didnt she like max?

  • yeah she likes sady right?

  • yeah, I thought she liked Lucys brother, like he said she was hung up on him when they were singing "Dear Prudence".......and she was in pain because he was going into the army..

  • she is gay, there is the part where she is singing to the cheerleader and then she like SADIE duh when her and the guiterist are dancing prudence is like singing to her and then the contortionist umm.... DUH

  • her name is T.V?

  • Um she is definitely gay, and theres like three scenes that make it very very obvious.

  • *SPOILER!*

    I think she was gay: that part where she said "she's a contorshionist" near the end...

  • The truth is that everyone tought that... "is that girl gay?" there are a lot of scenes

  • DONT READ THIS IF YOUVE NOT SEEN THE MOVIE YET

    we were watching this and my friends like "isnt she gay?!?!" gah, pissed me off and totally ruined it.

  • who kares if she likes a girl or NOT! it would be the same with a guy....anywayz,,i think this scene is beautiful..i have the DVD and i love listening to this song....SO BEAUTIFUL!

  • This is my fsvorite song by he Beatles but least favorite from the movie. I dont think it was a good version of it.

  • this sucks but the movie is like the BEST movie ever created

  • In my opinion is the most beautiful scene EVER in a movie! T.V. Carpio, is beyond beautifully talented! She is a special creation!

    Rob Byrd/Poulele

  • I agree....I thought this scene was VERY touching. Prudence is my favorite character.... :~}

  • I completely agree....It's SUCH a touching scene. I was so happy for the movie to include this. :~}

  • youll let me be your man?

  • she likes the girl.

  • omg!!! i didnt know that :S

  • Omg!!! really¿?¿?¿ i didnt know that :S:S:S

  • Amazingly well produced film! I love how the director used this song to show the aching heart of a girl who has a crush on another girl in school. very moving. And they couldn't have picked a better voice!

  • yeah. i love her character too! and she's really cute! ^^

  • one of the best voices in the

    movie

    i think she has a bright future and hopefully

    we will see more of her =]

  • bellissimo il film e stupende le canzoni!!!

  • I think she has an amazing voice

  • i support love. Whether its gay, strait, monster, dinosaur. Whatever. If its love its love, and thats all that matters.

  • strait....? like the georgia strait?? never heard of having sexual feelings for geographical locations but whatever floats your boat.

  • @beach1chic I don't think you should mess with monsters or dinosaurs. They never call you back.

  • @beach1chic This would be more appropriate under the comments for "All You Need Is Love".

  • Prudence is beautiful.

    Alot of people wonder what he sexuality was. But the thing is, we can't really know.

    She definitely into girls, and possibly into guys as well.

    I'm so happy that Julie Taymor chose to represent orientations other than heterosexual in this movie.

  • In the movie she is lesbian.

  • i don't know.. oh well.

  • yeah i kinda don't think she is les.

    because in the REAL song by the beatles

    they said that.

  • Did you watch the rest of the movie?

    She's pining after Sadie in one scene (Hence the "Does Sadie know?" question), and then later in the circus, introduces a girl to everyone in a loving way. Saying that she's a contortionist, even. xD

    She's either bi or a lesbian - either way, she definitely likes girls to some degree. xP

  • then you think she is looking at the cheerleader out of intense friendlike but in no way sexual feelings and wants to hold her hand and tell her she loves her because she thinks she is a super person??? you are stupid..

  • its weird when she says let me be your man?But other than that i love this movie!

  • ya cuz she's in love with the cheerleader ( shes Bi)

  • i kinda sure that prudence is lesbian..

    but shes cute :)

  • Actually, she's bisexual

  • only in the movie and she is BI.

  • ofcorse shes bi on only on the movie , its acting , not real life ^o)

  • one of the BEST parts of the movie. i loved this scene. LOVED it. we all went crazy for it! no one rolled their eyes... ????

  • I disagree. I thought T.V. did a great job with this scene. She sounds perfect, and it establishes a lot about her character.

  • I really liked Prudence's character.

  • Me too. I don't see why everyone is making such a big deal about her sexuality. Yes, she's a lesbian, but homosexuality has been in movies before.

  • I agree. she is my fav character weather shes a lesbian or not.

  • It really doesn't matter, it'd be the same if she was in love with a boy.

  • I had a feeling she was gay but I too am slow I became aware of the possibility when she was singing "I want you (She's so heavy)". I had a feeling she was really singing to sadie I guess my hunch was right. Awesome movie by the way. Definitely in my top ten. After watching this my heart really felt heavy for America, the troops and the Middle East

    The only song that I felt they really should have had in their was "Imagine" Lennon.

    Peace be with us...

  • yeah, but this movie is made with the songs from when the beatles were together, Imagine, is by John Lennon, from his solo career

  • I know but it still would have been extremely appropriate no?

  • Yeah. It was by Lennone alone but I LOVE IT! It would've fit the movie. You know how they sang, "Because" they should've have done something similar but with "Imagine". That's why I like APC's version as much as Lennon's Becuase of he harmonizing.

  • yes, she was with the girl from the circus thing. she introduced her in a loving way.

  • lol yes, as a contortionist.. haha

  • I thought she was bisexual?

  • I already knew that she was a lesbian, but it didn't stop me from giggling with my friend when she started singing to the cheerleader. I love the fact that her name is TV. xD

  • her name isnt tv...its prudence.

  • oh wait. haha just kidding, i thought you meant in the movie.

  • in the movie her name is Prudence (beatles song Dear Prudence) and in real life her name is T.V. Carpio

  • TV Carpio is her real name dumbass

  • ... Her name is Prudence.

  • Oh god, me either lmao

  • I didn't even realize that she was a lesbian until like halfway through the movie my boyfriend pointed it out. I'm a little slow I guess. Amazing movie and amazing song nonetheless.

  • i love this version! it's slower and it's sweeter. <3

  • I thought this was one of the best scenes...sooo heartbreaking, and the way she sings it is amazing. Nice to see a clip from the film.

  • Her singing was okay, but I thought prudence's character was ultra creepy, not because she was gay, but because she was all stalky and...creepy about it...and then she joined the circus, i was like...WTF?!

  • rofl

    I kinda did too

  • who is she supposedly in love with in the movie?

  • at first, it was Lucy, but then it was Sadie, and then she runs off to the deserted circus tent and has fun with the contortionist.

  • Lmao...the circus part scared the crap out of me.

  • The cheerleader she loves isn't Lucy... it looks like her though!

  • it was not lucy retardo

  • is prudence gay or straight

  • she's gay, from wat the moviie indacates, though it is never litterly mentioned...

  • i loved loved loved this song!

  • ok...so why does this movie TOTALLY KICK ASS?!? I've seen in twice in the last 24 hours

  • it is a work of art.

  • i ment i love her voice tehehe 8)

  • I LOVE PRUDENCE!!!!!!!!!! this song is the BEST i and i love this song lol 8)

  • Aw Prudence is so pretty

  • What the hell?

  • she was a lesbian in the movie ... U didn<t realize???? must be blind!!

  • I realized that, but it sounded like you were called her, the person who said she was pretty, a lesbian. She was pretty. You don't have to be attracted to her to see that she's pretty.

  • Homophobe.

  • this is my favorite scene in the moviee!!

  • omg I love it?!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more