Miley Cyrus Performing Live American Idol Give Back

[24RoflCopter]

She might be 17 but she has sold over a two million albums,3 hit songs,and over ten million fans,and yet she might be the most famous singers in the 2000's. She is greatly talented.

[liza189710]

she sounds sick..

it might just might be the sound quality..

i love her!!

[dorkimisskaren]

she shouldve chosed another song to sing, im not saying she SUCKS HARD but it just doesnt sound good

[InRealityItsTrue]

she sucks at singing my 7 year old sister sings so much better then her

[ChloesWorld101]

what is this song called

[Miley4eva12345]

This song is called Good and Broken.

[Flitterpaw]

Well, you know there are a LOT of people who can sing much better who worked hard to get where they are. And they still are working hard. And it's really sad when they're nowhere as well known as people like the Disney stars who become the next big thing overnight.

I'm not a fan of Miley, but I'm not a hater. People just say things because they have nothing better to do.

And it's not "jelousy". It's "jealousy"...

[cassidizzlee]

shes so good! =]

[meocon62]

i love it

[lilashioyo]

damn..horrible voice.

what has america come to?

NIN ftw

[whitetigerfanatic]

I for one thinks Miley is amazing. I have always been a fan of her dad and now to find out that she is a singer too. I am proud to be a fan of hers.

For all of you people out there who wants to downsize her and cut her down, all of you are just plain jealous for the simple fact is you probably can't sing at all even though it is your dream to sing... Stop taking out your stress and frustrations on someone like Miley who is really talented and take it out on yourself! Just.. STFU!!!

[slivenne]

u tell them,i agree with u

[AlexisandZahra]

totally agree

[Joanna1095]

me tooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooo

[TifaLockHeartCute]

me third...u go whitetigerfanatic, they are just being jelousy.

[Flitterpaw]

Not all people are jealous wannabe singers you know. Some people just don't like her and have nothing better to do than write hate comments.

So um...you can't exactly say that all of us are "plain jealous for the simple fact that you probably can't sing at all." Because some of us can sing, and not everyone is jealous. Therefore it's not a fact =P

And taking your stress out on YOURSELF would mean cutting yourself and other gross stuff...

Just ignore the haters.

(sorry if I sound rude...)

[CELiiNEKE]

@whitetigerfanatic You go !! (: That are real fans  !

[Joanna1095]

wat song is this

[theCrazySammie]

Its Good and Broken.

[nem1]

if miley was actually on american idol she would lose. i like her music, but she cant really sing

[Joanna1095]

yes she can

[nem1]

look, im not about to get into an argument with a 13 year old miley fan. If you compare her to a real singer then she has no range, no power, and barely even knows how to use her vibrato. She, or whoever produces her, makes pretty good music, and she has a pretty decent sound. But in comparison to Mariah, Christina, Celine, Beyonce, or any american idol winner... there really isnt a contest if you were only measuring vocals..

[Joanna1095]

srry

by the way i am 11

[twilightbookfan1]

she is tight but no one thinks so you rock !!!!!!!!!!!!!˚

[mileygirl619]

good singing bad graphics!!!!!!

U ROCK MILEY

[DAandDAER]

she sucks ROCK ON DEMI!...plz put negative idc if you put negative its just gonna make people wonder why this comment doesnt show

[americangirl1325]

no, no ones gunna wonder why, and ur just jealus of miley, cause if ya hate her, then u wouldnt b friking watching her on here. so just shut ur frikin mouth

[landind]

She sang this song really really good! She moves around the stage, which shows she's a real performer! I LOVE MILEY

[musiclvr4ever8794]

she needs to know how to do breath control, and she needs to stop running around stage everywhere, its not cool, plus it make her sound like a donkey in labour, no offense

[americangirl1325]

dont frikin watch her if u dont like her,stop acting like a frikin no- it- all, so if i were u,i would SHUT UP and dont watch her.

[JBFans7]

i sing this song in my room all the time she sings it better of corse but ya she does good on this song i like when she does the suite it's great.

[Jaidie00]

no its not that bad.. its better than her lyp synching i think.. she's better as miley than as hannah montana

[JBFans7]

me too cause then she can be herself

[americangirl1325]

SHUT UP!! she dont frikin lip sing, r u blind or something(no offense, i usually dont use dat language)

[DAandDAER]

look if you like miley so much why dont you go and fuck her while your at it lmao...what are you 4 years old? ...look noone is jelous of miley ..peole who hate her dont watch her cuz we're jelous we watch her because we enjoy her stupidity and enjoy watchin her embarass herself ..oh plz i should keep my mouth shut?...shes a slut and a skank shes probably gonna end up like lindsey lohan or britney....and the funny thing is everyone is gonna enjoy watching her fall down ....muahahah im so evil...

[americangirl1325]

no, im not 4, im 11. And no, your not really evil, you think that your all that and your jusy a fuckin bitch, so your the one that needs to fuck off,And ya, you should really keep your mouth shut, and maby shoove somethin up ur ass while your at it. You can be any age and like miley.Cause my dad is 62 and is a fan of miley. So shut your fuckin mouth ya asshole

[Flitterpaw]

Pretty dirty mouth for an 11 year old...better learn to control your tongue before you get out in the real world. People get hurt when they talk like that.

So the other person was rude, and you were offended. What you could have said instead of what you did say was "No, I'm 11 not 4. And what you said offended me. You can be any age and like Miley 'cause my dad is 62 and a fan. Please, if you're going to reply, reply politely." Nicer, no?

Think before you type ;)

[americangirl1325]

than dont reply to me thinking your all that. im gunna be 12 in 20 days and im not offended, if u were offended than ur a big baby!

[Flitterpaw]

So what if you're going to be 12 in 20 days? It doesn't matter how old you are. Everyone needs to learn to control what they say. And it's a lesson that needs to be learned as soon as possible in EVERYONE'S life. Again: People get hurt when they use language like that so freely.

No, I'm not offended. And if you weren't offended by what that person said then WHY did you you need to respond in a rude, foul mouthed, inconsiderate way?

[americangirl1325]

because people need to stop watching her videos than calling her on it. if u dont like her than dont watch her damnit

[Joanna1095]

she really did sing

cause her voice is different

[americangirl1325]

no duh

[SkittleBunny13]

C'mon people.

I mean, I don't really like Miley either, but she didn't do that bad.

I mean, it's sounds pretty good for a live performance.

[mapjap001]

She is really pretty, although, I don't like how she dances. She looks like she is having a spaz attack...I think she should tone it down a notch. But she is pretty talented....just hopes she keeps her head on straight.

[mofobio]

shee actually did a good job

[schminaschmindell]

you people with the mean comments need to just shut up you obviously cant hear corcectly because she is amazingggg!!! you are just jealous or you just belive what you hear well maybe you should start seeing her for how she really iss she is an amazing person and everybody makes mistakes have you ever heard the song nobodys perfect? welll get that song through your thick head i love you miley!!!

[disneyeasy2sing]

AHAHAHA

simon would ruin her she sucks

i mean thats embarrising considering its american idol and the contestants deserve her fame soooo much more

[sailormewpinkmermaid]

stick to lip synching still a fan tho

[teattrey]

I Know What you mean but i think she's great in other places but not on idol gives back.I'm still her fan.

[SexyBelle2000]

She can't sing. Sorry but she can't. This is terrible. She sounds horrible. How can anyone say this is good. She shouldn't be famous for singing cuase it's not what she's good at. She just wants to be a bigshtot and wants all the attention.

[lilknipeyxxo]

i wonder wat simon would say...

[StarrMusic108]

lol probably "terrible, just terrible"

And she's flat too... I like the outfit though...

[ihtzjessica]

hahaha how old is she? 15? an AA?

my friend is like 14 and has a way bigger chest than her and she's like a D

[commonNcrime]

1. this is really badd

2. what does this song have to do with giving back?

[angelordeath12]

this was a bad song for her to sing and why does she always have to dance and shake her head near the band for

wow she a lozer

and she can sing but she shouldn't be in the spotlight because someone out there is way better then her and deseveres a chance to shine.........because miley is in the sunshine a little too much and if she stays in longer she will get burned

[angelordeath12]

this was a bad song for her to sing and why does she always have to dance and shake her head near the band for

wow she a lozer

and she can sing but she shouldn't be in the spotlight because someone out there is way better then her and deseveres a chance to shine.........because miley is in the sunshine a little too much and if she stays in longer she will get burned

[Audiomuse]

It was obviously live trust me and it was amazing!

her perfomance was great.

there was one tiny part that was a little pitchy that's why I know it was live but the rest of the song SHE WAS AMAZING!

[Audiomuse]

It was live!!

it was amazing!!!

[GossipGirlAddict]

You rock Miley ! I don't understand people who say she can't sings live... Just open u your eyes, she's amazin' !

[WileyCoyote69]

No breath sounds.

She was lipsyncing.

[itbritneyspearsbitch]

it was too bad for lip synching