@yubtub89 That happens A LOT with many, many bands. If the vocalist is having an off night, chances are high that he/she will feel much more pumped up and into it after a crazy guitar solo, lol. I'm not even kidding, just listen to any metal band play live.
@yubtub89 His throat and mouth were probably dry, it tends to happen, but if you notice as the solo started, he runs up the stand that Jason's on and grabs water, so yeah, could be why..
@JordanM56 I think he's a badass frontman. He gets (or well, in this case, TRIED to) get the crowd pumped up and into the song, he's got a lot of good movement and great energy. I'll give you the fact that his clean vocals aren't all that much to brag about, but he makes up for it with pure energy and his screams. The song rocks, the band rocks, and the crowd just didn't want to be there.
If you dumb fucks would know about atr he was sick the whole week before performing this I've seen them 3 times this year the he is not a horrible singer so chill the fuck out.
Oh my god... I have never seen a singer so catastrophic.. It's pathetic.. Go to look Lamb Of God, Carcass, Tool or what you want, but a real band. This shit should not exist..
Thank you for posting this video. If you like All that Remains, I shot them live in concert in Little Rock. You can check it out on episode 5 of Metal Fallout. The Video link should be posted.
i hate faggots that search songs just to say its bad. if you really hate it, what is the point in looking it up? search your little pussy ass bieber and fuck off
@mr0scary the singer is a guy....,.. the bassist is my friends sister, well not really a friend. just a kid that i talk to on my bus. do you mean your sister's friend?
@TheKylesauce The one and only Jason Costa..good friend of mine..was Diecasts original drummer..been playing that way for over 25 years.. one of the most talented and skilled drummers you will ever come across and most humble and nicest too..and we got stupid fucks with no talent getting more exposure ..shit annoys me man!
The crowd sucks ATR sucks live, Oli can't perform his solos, the lead guy can't sing and the rhythm guy is just embarrassing, only talent in the band is the drummer
Wow, that crowd is so fucking pathetic. There is no reason that people in the front, or anywhere in the crowd for that matter, should be standing still and looking at ATR like a bunch of retards.
that's the problem with playing in LA. almost all big bands come from that area so the crouds are almays gonna be pretty shitty. they feel like they've seen it all before. "All That Remains is playing..... and?"
@CadaverKevin There are loads of bands that aren't brutal and their fans still go crazy. What does musical brutality have to do with it? I've seen fans go crazy for Trivium, fans have gone crazy for Smashing Pumpkins - someone died in the pits at one of their gigs. Is that not a crowd going crazy? But you wouldn't call the Smashing Pumpkins brutal, would you?
@j0gan673 The Smashing Pumpkins had some pretty brutal songs in their day. The Mosh pits and fans where much more crazy back then. But I still stick to my words and say this song isn't brutal at all to todays standards. But they do have some pretty brutal songs before they became mainstream.
@CadaverKevin I do agree that this isn't brutal, but I don't think brutality really comes into how much a crowd moves. But fuck it, this is meaningless, we'll argue whatever the other says :P
lol he's saying to the crowd "don't please give up on me!"... bc he "swears I never gave up on you". The man lived the lyrics in his song... irrrooooooonnyyy
@win3andsniperbullets they WERE good live, i saw them back the fall of ideals came out, and they were amazing, phil just never took care of his voice...drinking jim bean show after show like he did can't be good for your voice, oh well he was an amazing singer back then and now his voice is raspy and out of tune
And as for people saying they suck live. They don't This was back in '09. Just saw them 3 weeks ago, and they are on of the best bands I've ever seen live.
@OMFGMew sorry buddy but it's true, the phil labonte of today does not even compare to anything the phil labonte could do back in the fall of ideals days.
@Ricsic6 ha, your funny. seriously if you don't like a band, don't look them up. it's that easy. the people that do, including you, really need to get a life. i only get on youtube once every few days, and i look up what i want to, i don't go trolling on every video i don't like.
@nothin2 I like his voice an he is way better than most live don't expect anyone to be good live the only band I've heard that was good live was avenged sevenfold and they were extremely good. Most people use special mics to make them sound good if you want people that use those mics listen to hip hop.
0:58... cmon... I hate it when bands don't stick to their album frets. I mean, I love ATR, and their performances are epic and all, but c'mon... If you can't do what the album plays, fuck up your producer until he/she gets it right.
@antdawg420 Hell yeah! you got that right wtf, why even go to a concert when you obviusly dont feel the music i would be jumping and climbing and headbaanging the hell out of that performance.
Yeah, it's not just you. Sometimes the sound doesn't come through in that awesome "live" way. Not sure why. I imagine it has to do with how the sound was set up or something.
ever notice at events like this, where its all about rock/metal music, that the crowds ALWAYS FUCKING SUCK?! come on! if ur going to an all-out event like this, at least come back with a broken nose!
wow worst crowd, they dont even know what they are listening to
TheJuxtaposedKing 1 week ago
wow this crowd fucking blows
whiteynator 1 week ago
0:26 Buzz kill
NarKill44 2 weeks ago
crowd sucks. i would be going ape shit on this song..
exra23 3 weeks ago
singer entertains like m shadows from a7x
ryangr7gisback 3 weeks ago
@ryangr7gisback Fuck yeah man, Philip and Matt are crazy
leftyguitarist13 1 day ago
that was an excessively loud bleep :(
acltear89 3 weeks ago 3
i think its cool that a rock drummer holds his sticks like that
886spencer 1 month ago
wow. i was just about to punch my computer and headbang but as soon as i heard PUT UR *BEEEEEEEEEEP* IN THE AIR. i lost that mood.
USsniperElite 1 month ago
He was definitely sick
He's one of the best rock singers out there
And btw
The crowd sucked asshole
RevivedBlade 1 month ago
Once again u can never hear Jeannes bass </3
ShutUpAndHeadbangg 1 month ago
mtv equalization you can suck my balls
Caayaaa 1 month ago
watch?v=oPT0O0tJNkI this is metal
nocturnalcaos 1 month ago
weak crowd!!!
bagelisdelish 1 month ago
@bagelisdelish That's California for you.
KHfan4ever23 1 month ago
Next time don't cuss during the solo!!
69stratmaster 2 months ago
Phil can do so much better than this..
midgetmike10001 2 months ago
Retarded drummer....
Ricsic6 2 months ago
@Ricsic6 agree
Cray0on 1 month ago
@Ricsic6 what's wrong with him?
MudlinFounded 1 month ago
the crowd sucks D:
SustainableChaosDrum 2 months ago
Shit crowd.
sovereignsjust 2 months ago
fuck that crowd
15wabostank 2 months ago
Yeah these vocals are HORRIBLE... he was either high, sick, or he sucks in general :P
Hrtsniper159 2 months ago
Is it just me or did the vocals sound way better after the guitar solo?
yubtub89 2 months ago 19
@yubtub89 i noticed around 2:20 he went to have a drink of water so it prob cleared his throat some i heard it too
marcelb666 1 month ago
@yubtub89 That happens A LOT with many, many bands. If the vocalist is having an off night, chances are high that he/she will feel much more pumped up and into it after a crazy guitar solo, lol. I'm not even kidding, just listen to any metal band play live.
Bludhoundz8 1 month ago
@yubtub89 His throat and mouth were probably dry, it tends to happen, but if you notice as the solo started, he runs up the stand that Jason's on and grabs water, so yeah, could be why..
leftyguitarist13 1 day ago
Phil was definitely sick at this time. I've seen them 3 times, he always sounds exactly like he does on the albums.
MetalFreak2000 2 months ago
good song, shit singer, shit crowd
JordanM56 2 months ago
@JordanM56 I think he's a badass frontman. He gets (or well, in this case, TRIED to) get the crowd pumped up and into the song, he's got a lot of good movement and great energy. I'll give you the fact that his clean vocals aren't all that much to brag about, but he makes up for it with pure energy and his screams. The song rocks, the band rocks, and the crowd just didn't want to be there.
TheKylesauce 2 months ago
Phillip is awesome live!
xXMusicxMadnessXx 2 months ago
Is that a Ibanez Xiphos? The same guitar used by Muhammed Suiçmez from Necrophagiast?
TheLondonGuy123 2 months ago
@TheLondonGuy123 Yeah I believe so
MikeyJTheGreat 2 months ago
two weeks you........................
bagelisdelish 2 months ago
3:09 Watch Phil closely. He waves his hand like, "Whatever..." Were all those shitty people forced to be there?
fastfiddler1625 2 months ago
3:48 i thought they were gonna turn to stone!
ibanezrockerdude 3 months ago
censoring, really? this isn't primary school
MRA7XMAD 3 months ago
2 days before I em with ffdp and hatebreed!!!!!!!
Livingformusic666 3 months ago
Sick band, Shitty audience.
quentrypop123 3 months ago
Comment removed
ryanstitch21 3 months ago
If you dumb fucks would know about atr he was sick the whole week before performing this I've seen them 3 times this year the he is not a horrible singer so chill the fuck out.
iTz2Lethal 3 months ago
The singing wasn't even that bad , really? Pricks ...
sasukeholly77 3 months ago
at least his singing got better :)
goreobsessed1221 3 months ago
<3 all that remains <3 Two weeks, but he cant sing for shit:/
deathmetal1700 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh my god... I have never seen a singer so catastrophic.. It's pathetic.. Go to look Lamb Of God, Carcass, Tool or what you want, but a real band. This shit should not exist..
LoicKD57 3 months ago
Comment removed
LoicKD57 3 months ago
There should be a tv channel for strictly metal.. no censored shit! Hoo RAH!
kirkwells101 3 months ago
Thank you for posting this video. If you like All that Remains, I shot them live in concert in Little Rock. You can check it out on episode 5 of Metal Fallout. The Video link should be posted.
MetalFalloutTV 3 months ago
MTV playing music?
AngryFacing 3 months ago
i hate faggots that search songs just to say its bad. if you really hate it, what is the point in looking it up? search your little pussy ass bieber and fuck off
roflmfao15 3 months ago
metal should'nt have censorship -.-
Carnifex11100 3 months ago
the bassist is my friends aunt
jager11599 3 months ago
@jager11599 The singer is my friends sister............
mr0scary 3 months ago
@mr0scary the singer is a guy....,.. the bassist is my friends sister, well not really a friend. just a kid that i talk to on my bus. do you mean your sister's friend?
jager11599 3 months ago
That xiphos! So sexy!!
danpluso 3 months ago
worst crowd ever
Sdvbr 3 months ago
Comment removed
MetalTillIDie461 3 months ago
OMG! Metal drummer with traditional grip?! who is that?!
TheKylesauce 3 months ago
@TheKylesauce
Shannon Lucas? It was anyway.
NRGMetal 3 months ago
@NRGMetal Ah. Well he's awesome.
TheKylesauce 3 months ago
@TheKylesauce The one and only Jason Costa..good friend of mine..was Diecasts original drummer..been playing that way for over 25 years.. one of the most talented and skilled drummers you will ever come across and most humble and nicest too..and we got stupid fucks with no talent getting more exposure ..shit annoys me man!
KeMiSTv1 3 months ago
@KeMiSTv1 No doubt. I'm definitely going to check into some more of his videos.
TheKylesauce 3 months ago
3:48 fail
Commenter176 3 months ago 18
@Commenter176 Wasn't a band fail. More like a crowd fail. That crowd sucked.
MrNinjakiller31 1 month ago
@Commenter176 no, it's the 2nd guitar who slide ;) hear it ! it's the rythm guitar who slide not the lead ;)
oversamp 1 month ago
@oversamp im talking about how the audience wasn't singing.....
Commenter176 4 weeks ago
@Commenter176 lol...........
Wrathofkala 2 weeks ago
@Commenter176 mdr
jordymoi 1 week ago
ahahahaahahahhahahaha that first bleep made me LOL
theRDRman 3 months ago
Lol the bass is bigger than the bassist the one and only girl in the band
TheLegacy1395 4 months ago
Good Song, boring people...
manuelanorga 4 months ago
The crowd sucks ATR sucks live, Oli can't perform his solos, the lead guy can't sing and the rhythm guy is just embarrassing, only talent in the band is the drummer
musicaws2 4 months ago
Wow, that crowd is so fucking pathetic. There is no reason that people in the front, or anywhere in the crowd for that matter, should be standing still and looking at ATR like a bunch of retards.
MrBrink10 4 months ago
that's the problem with playing in LA. almost all big bands come from that area so the crouds are almays gonna be pretty shitty. they feel like they've seen it all before. "All That Remains is playing..... and?"
grifballa 4 months ago
wtf? why he can´t say fuck?
larussural 4 months ago
the singer is a fake M.Shadows xD
nikyhammett 4 months ago
Not a shitty crowd. It's just All That Remains, arn't that brutal.... So they feel no need to go crazy. It's like going crazy for trivium.
CadaverKevin 4 months ago
@CadaverKevin There are loads of bands that aren't brutal and their fans still go crazy. What does musical brutality have to do with it? I've seen fans go crazy for Trivium, fans have gone crazy for Smashing Pumpkins - someone died in the pits at one of their gigs. Is that not a crowd going crazy? But you wouldn't call the Smashing Pumpkins brutal, would you?
j0gan673 4 months ago
@j0gan673 The Smashing Pumpkins had some pretty brutal songs in their day. The Mosh pits and fans where much more crazy back then. But I still stick to my words and say this song isn't brutal at all to todays standards. But they do have some pretty brutal songs before they became mainstream.
CadaverKevin 4 months ago
@CadaverKevin I do agree that this isn't brutal, but I don't think brutality really comes into how much a crowd moves. But fuck it, this is meaningless, we'll argue whatever the other says :P
j0gan673 4 months ago
i hate these fu*beep* beeps......
GreenJokerXI 4 months ago
lol...censored metal show....worthless.
Madderhatter85 4 months ago
they play better live then what most bands can! ima see them next month hopefully! and 5FDP!!!!
maggot6639 4 months ago
lol he's saying to the crowd "don't please give up on me!"... bc he "swears I never gave up on you". The man lived the lyrics in his song... irrrooooooonnyyy
bullseyearrow 4 months ago
damn...They really suck live...true bands can perform live
win3andsniperbullets 4 months ago
@win3andsniperbullets they WERE good live, i saw them back the fall of ideals came out, and they were amazing, phil just never took care of his voice...drinking jim bean show after show like he did can't be good for your voice, oh well he was an amazing singer back then and now his voice is raspy and out of tune
Alfonso732 4 months ago
BEEEP xDDD
supergoku2000 4 months ago
Shitty crowd, the beeps fuck it all up.
And as for people saying they suck live. They don't This was back in '09. Just saw them 3 weeks ago, and they are on of the best bands I've ever seen live.
OMFGMew 4 months ago
@OMFGMew sorry buddy but it's true, the phil labonte of today does not even compare to anything the phil labonte could do back in the fall of ideals days.
Alfonso732 4 months ago
i luv the guitarists hair
hello1235678910 5 months ago
The singer is so full of energy
Melermometal 5 months ago
crowd - shit
DronGuitarFun 5 months ago
Man ceases to be dumb.
And take the BIP.
Son of a bitch
celiogdcc 5 months ago
drummer plays like a pussy...
xXMatthewCoreXx 5 months ago
Bunch of pussies too scared to mosh.
XC2long4u 5 months ago
seco canta muy bien
sebscratch 5 months ago
there are better crowds at punk concerts
exitoftheend 5 months ago
great, they censored a little bit of the solo -.-''
94RicardoC 5 months ago
shitty crowd
1pullthetriggerbitch 5 months ago 37
@1pullthetriggerbitch Think you mean shitty band.....
Ricsic6 3 months ago
@Ricsic6 ha, your funny. seriously if you don't like a band, don't look them up. it's that easy. the people that do, including you, really need to get a life. i only get on youtube once every few days, and i look up what i want to, i don't go trolling on every video i don't like.
KDR466 3 months ago
@nothin2 I like his voice an he is way better than most live don't expect anyone to be good live the only band I've heard that was good live was avenged sevenfold and they were extremely good. Most people use special mics to make them sound good if you want people that use those mics listen to hip hop.
ErrectifiedPeePee 6 months ago 2
Hi anyone knows the following: this song reminds me to Disturbed. same catchy thytm and smiliar lyrics. which song of disiturbed sounsd like it?
IAmMyOwnSavior 6 months ago
@IAmMyOwnSavior sure, i'll look em up. i dont remember all of em
SetsunaInoue 5 months ago in playlist All That Remains
@SetsunaInoue thnx i will look into it as well. must know it
IAmMyOwnSavior 5 months ago
I think the singer should have more reverb on his mic
djjazzek 6 months ago
Im pretty sure the guitar, is the only reason people listin... if he could sing, oh sweet baby jesus
nuthin2 6 months ago
THis is terrible, Atleast the vocals....I just saw them a week ago and they did way better lol
deadnightwarrior44 6 months ago
Phil's starting to develop Corey Taylor's thick ass neck haha.
bloodhound22297 6 months ago
i have respect for this band, but the vocal sucks tbh..
shurnleet 6 months ago
crap crowd ever!
MjNois 6 months ago 2
shittiest crowd ever. If it was anywhere else, the crowd already started 2 moshpits
Rambot12 6 months ago
Goooooooooooooood
holydiver654 6 months ago
I feel a little anger against that shitty crowd.
PineappleJaguar 6 months ago
The beginning where they bleeped it startled me XD
deathmancerp 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i'd fuck her
DESTROYER68483 6 months ago
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!! MerWevo! XD .... lml
ejrplml 6 months ago
this band is pure fuyk talent all the way around from bass to drums
slipknotftw1000 6 months ago
this band fuk slays the best !!
slipknotftw1000 6 months ago
drummer is a fucking gorilla mr acosta rules!
slipknotftw1000 6 months ago
my favorite band if u sit down when they play u shud be shot! phil is epic singer man he has fucking skillz
slipknotftw1000 6 months ago
my favorite band if u sit down when they play u shud be shot!
slipknotftw1000 6 months ago
0:58... cmon... I hate it when bands don't stick to their album frets. I mean, I love ATR, and their performances are epic and all, but c'mon... If you can't do what the album plays, fuck up your producer until he/she gets it right.
PatricHerrera 6 months ago
At 03:08 the hand sign, he is sick and tired of that crowd
TheDomi06 7 months ago 37
@TheDomi06 yeah... fuck that crowd dude
MikeyJTheGreat 7 months ago
@TheDomi06 If I was there that crowd would look 10x better than that! this crowd is fuckin lame.
MikeyJTheGreat 5 months ago
@TheDomi06
Gotta be the poorest excuse of a crowd ever...
dpatt21 3 months ago
ATR IS BEAST WTF wrong wit the crowd they should be ina mosh pit or at least moving
AvengedSevenfold9000 7 months ago
this fuckin crowd SUCKS what a bunch of pussies you can tell its LA fuckin stiffs!!!!!!!!!!!!
antdawg420 7 months ago
@antdawg420 Hell yeah! you got that right wtf, why even go to a concert when you obviusly dont feel the music i would be jumping and climbing and headbaanging the hell out of that performance.
ghost500e 6 months ago
man if i was there i start the biggest mosh pit ever to this song... the crowd just sits there! they suck
1xMANxMOSHxPIT 7 months ago
Yeah ATR is awesome, but the singers strength is screaming vocals, definitely not so much for singing clean.
Nragemachine 7 months ago
I love atr, but Phils voice is Kinda bad :/
AMEVAFAN0 7 months ago
live sucks xD, but studio is awesome
anguspetrucci 7 months ago
theyre really good live
MrRight533 7 months ago
phils voice aint bad some people are just haters like to see u get up there on the stage and do what he does
zombiemovierater3 7 months ago
i like how that second beep was right through the beginning of the solo. that was just fantastic...
tobiasdick09 7 months ago
i saw them live and they were much better. somethin's wrong here..
KeinBierVorVierAlter 7 months ago
@KeinBierVorVierAlter
Yeah, it's not just you. Sometimes the sound doesn't come through in that awesome "live" way. Not sure why. I imagine it has to do with how the sound was set up or something.
Schatje79 7 months ago
Philip sounds like Dave Draiman live... Weird o_o
leftyguitarist13 7 months ago
You guys play way to fast live, play the songs a lil bit slower and you will sound alot better.
Fableknightube 7 months ago
@Fableknightube
Play metal slower? How dare you! lol
Schatje79 7 months ago
fuck this crowd and its in LA. Dont mean to diss but fuck come to the bay area or san fran i will deff go see this band and go crazy
speedygonzoles 7 months ago
well done talking during the solo, and the bassist has a nice ass
ZeroCool2211 8 months ago
The fact that that MTV even played this does MTV more credit than they really deserve.
XxXHunteRXxX316 8 months ago
All those people who didnt go nuts liked the movie made in manhattan.. they gay if ther are girls they lesbians
Dgrayman2 8 months ago
ever notice at events like this, where its all about rock/metal music, that the crowds ALWAYS FUCKING SUCK?! come on! if ur going to an all-out event like this, at least come back with a broken nose!
ThePistonJack 8 months ago
they r fucking awesome but someone at mtv needs a lesson in acoustics
supersamschwartz 8 months ago
Bad preformance. I blame MTV...
husky940 8 months ago
Jeanne Is like really awkward on stage...
billydumptruck 8 months ago
@billydumptruck But we still love her
TheGrindcore1 8 months ago
@TheGrindcore1 without a doubt
billydumptruck 8 months ago
Wasnt their best live. But their stage presence is amazing, make it good to watch and beastly to listen to.
4lifeKidrock 8 months ago
I love ATR live, but this wasnt a very good live performance. Not the right song choice.
4lifeKidrock 8 months ago
He sounds like a beast life
jonboyxl 8 months ago
@jonboyxl He sounds like shit, I saw them a few days ago and he sounded like shit then too. This band is shit.
Terminxman 8 months ago
@Terminxman And so are you.
MikeyJTheGreat 8 months ago
This isnt perfect song for live singing..thats why it is how it is...
Kacicka999 8 months ago
love their songs on cd, but this live performace sounded terrible. and you cant even hear the bad ass solo. :/
wutever00 8 months ago
@wutever00 Yes, I agree. The audio is terrible, sounds like they went to damn crazy on reverb.
MikeyJTheGreat 8 months ago
LOL do they cencure every dirty word?
Dont want to bring this man out in this video but if eminem was here it was BIP BIP BIP BIIIIIIIIIIP BIIIIIP BIP BIP BIP.
ATR ROCKS
Mshadow250 8 months ago 41
@Mshadow250 what's funny is they failed to censor suicide silence saying "where is your fucking god" that same night, cost mtv a ton of money
DarthFlaw 7 months ago
If it was a shitty band like A7x, they would be going crazy. Morons
desertdemon1993 8 months ago
@desertdemon1993 FUCK OFF DONT LIKE A7X DONT LISTEN TO IT. GET A LIFE
Mshadow250 8 months ago
@Mshadow250 I don't listen to it. And I got a life. Why are you here bitch ?
desertdemon1993 8 months ago
@desertdemon1993 shitty? you sir, are a fucking retard. that is all
jubakabla2 8 months ago
where is the mosh pit, it was crazy in baltimore
stevie123b 8 months ago
ATR motherfuckers!!! -=D
doomdood183 8 months ago
he got fuckin power in his voice!!!
dezad187 8 months ago
They're really awesome live!! I saw them this Tuesday :D
2181337 8 months ago
@2181337 du warst auch in stuttgart?
Bubu2807 8 months ago
Fuck this sucks bad
nooshkababooshka 9 months ago
no shit this isnt his best performance but his voice is just trained from all the singing retards how about you try being on tour. dumbasses
C123Me 9 months ago
he sing sooo shit
kaka66147 9 months ago