I always preferred Sir William Walton's score to Ron Goodwin's score for "The Battle Of Britain", and the sound of the celli simulating the sound of the propellers has got to be the best case of film music imitating the sound of aircraft since Hugo Friedhofer's use of brass imitating the sound of the B17s in "The Best Years Of Our Lives" where Fred Derry sits in the cockpit in one of the abandoned planes.
This is an absolutely seminal piece of film music - it turns quite some not great film making in this scene into jaw-dropping action. The German theme is great too - all the more so for it being composed by an English composer.
@peteste1 how right you are my friend, the music took the film to a whole new level, this is an astonishing sequence, just watching the movie on my 32 inch screen as I write and all I can say is: WOW, WOW, WOW!
Battle in the air - the incredible urgency of this music really communicates the terror of what those young men experienced. But no one will ever know of course except them.
I think I've heard almost all versions, including ... orig. 1969 M. Arnold-conducted score (2nd best, but see comments below); Chandos (Neville Marriner, AoSMitF, 1990; So-so perf.); EMI (Carl Davis, 1987. AWFUL perf.!). But this one from BBC Proms 2007 blew me away: Very tight, dynamic, and CONTROLLED performance. It's fast-paced but never rushed.
@h0ll0wm9n ... (cont) "Rushed" with what I might call "asymmetric tempo/meter" is how I'd describe Arnold's orig. 1969 performance (but he may have HAD to do this -- i.e., sacrifice pace and flow performance, by compressing or stretching tempo/meter -- to fit film edits/cues).
The YouTube version's sound quality is decent (and hints at what full-rez may be capable of!!), but, alas, not in stereo and image is cropped from 16x9 to 4:3.
@h0ll0wm9n ... (cont. 2) Can't find the 2007 Proms on DVD or CD (source, anyone?). I would LOVE to have a higher-quality version -- video, audio-only, whatever. Please reply in-thread or we can communicate off-list. Thx!
Sad by the way if James Bernard wasn't part of this. He was in many ways the most popular of British film music composers, with his brilliant Hammer Films scores.
This is a magnificent piece, the rendition by the orchestra here lacks the energy and accuracy of the original soundtrack of course, and the conducting is sluggish, but it's fantastic to see this fabulous music played live. And yes, this is as good, or better, than anything John Williams ever wrote.
I dont´t get it... i look for William Wallton... and what is, what i get??? John Williams... Harry Potter... Well nice Music... in Fact the only Place where you can hear it on YOUTUBE... but...
The musis would have gone very well with the attack on the Death Star sequence from Star Wars. I may edit it on to see what it looks like. By the way have you noticeed how the opening fanfare sounds like part of the Superman theme by John Williams? (although predating it by 10 years)
Indeed! A great show that BBC Proms! The audience enjoyed very m,uch, as we can see. And Sir Richard Attenborough´s words about Bafta were very interesting. As we may be tired of Hollywood aesthetics, it´s great to watch those British productions.
ASTONISHING PIECE OF MUSIC, wish to God I was there in the Albert Hall that night!
corcaighrebel 1 month ago
Red 2 much closer that i can hardy see you!, Now stick to me like glue!
benylemoni 1 month ago
'Its like shooting rats in a barrel!'
'You'll be in a barrel if you dont watch out for the fighters'
pazuma 4 months ago
I always preferred Sir William Walton's score to Ron Goodwin's score for "The Battle Of Britain", and the sound of the celli simulating the sound of the propellers has got to be the best case of film music imitating the sound of aircraft since Hugo Friedhofer's use of brass imitating the sound of the B17s in "The Best Years Of Our Lives" where Fred Derry sits in the cockpit in one of the abandoned planes.
vividwatch47 8 months ago
This is an absolutely seminal piece of film music - it turns quite some not great film making in this scene into jaw-dropping action. The German theme is great too - all the more so for it being composed by an English composer.
peteste1 8 months ago
@peteste1 how right you are my friend, the music took the film to a whole new level, this is an astonishing sequence, just watching the movie on my 32 inch screen as I write and all I can say is: WOW, WOW, WOW!
corcaighrebel 1 month ago
I absolutely *adore* the french horn solo in the 'Siegfried Music' section of this :]
elh666 8 months ago
@elh666 Oh wait, they're not doing the whole suite. Ignore me! xD (but look it up)
elh666 8 months ago
Boy, you can really hear how John Williams was influenced by this great composer.
peppersax 10 months ago
Wonderful stuff, the contrast between this and the muck they produce with X-factor hold no bounds.
johno1066 10 months ago
Battle in the air - the incredible urgency of this music really communicates the terror of what those young men experienced. But no one will ever know of course except them.
We literally owe everything to them.
tuftybox1821 10 months ago
I think I've heard almost all versions, including ... orig. 1969 M. Arnold-conducted score (2nd best, but see comments below); Chandos (Neville Marriner, AoSMitF, 1990; So-so perf.); EMI (Carl Davis, 1987. AWFUL perf.!). But this one from BBC Proms 2007 blew me away: Very tight, dynamic, and CONTROLLED performance. It's fast-paced but never rushed.
h0ll0wm9n 1 year ago
@h0ll0wm9n ... (cont) "Rushed" with what I might call "asymmetric tempo/meter" is how I'd describe Arnold's orig. 1969 performance (but he may have HAD to do this -- i.e., sacrifice pace and flow performance, by compressing or stretching tempo/meter -- to fit film edits/cues).
The YouTube version's sound quality is decent (and hints at what full-rez may be capable of!!), but, alas, not in stereo and image is cropped from 16x9 to 4:3.
h0ll0wm9n 1 year ago
@h0ll0wm9n ... (cont. 2) Can't find the 2007 Proms on DVD or CD (source, anyone?). I would LOVE to have a higher-quality version -- video, audio-only, whatever. Please reply in-thread or we can communicate off-list. Thx!
h0ll0wm9n 1 year ago
Walton piece -- possibly best ever performance. Hats off to John Wilson / BBC Orch.
marcosnardon ... thx for uploading. Too bad image sides are cropped (modern broadcasts are captured in 16x9 'widescreen' HD). Also, no stereo :(
Was this released on DVD or CD? (recall years ago Walton Sym 1 was on BBC Music magazine CD)
h0ll0wm9n 1 year ago
The men...the machines....the battle and the bravery in the air....all summed up in the most wonderful and inspiring piece of music. Sheer genius.
Azena63 1 year ago
Sad by the way if James Bernard wasn't part of this. He was in many ways the most popular of British film music composers, with his brilliant Hammer Films scores.
tklogan11809 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
20 minutes ago
This is a magnificent piece, the rendition by the orchestra here lacks the energy and accuracy of the original soundtrack of course, and the conducting is sluggish, but it's fantastic to see this fabulous music played live. And yes, this is as good, or better, than anything John Williams ever wrote.
tklogan11809 1 year ago
Comment removed
tklogan11809 1 year ago
I dont´t get it... i look for William Wallton... and what is, what i get??? John Williams... Harry Potter... Well nice Music... in Fact the only Place where you can hear it on YOUTUBE... but...
MoBinger 1 year ago
The musis would have gone very well with the attack on the Death Star sequence from Star Wars. I may edit it on to see what it looks like. By the way have you noticeed how the opening fanfare sounds like part of the Superman theme by John Williams? (although predating it by 10 years)
ewaf88 1 year ago
Comment removed
ewaf88 1 year ago
"Is there everything up? No Reserve? THat's what I told to prime minister..."
tomenicus 1 year ago
@tomenicus
'Is everything up?'
'The lot, sir.'
'Reserves?'
'None.'
'That's what I've just told the Prime Minister.'
Elitist20 1 year ago 6
@Elitist20 Come in Blue 2...
LockAndLoadp 2 weeks ago in playlist British film music
Fabulous music from Walton.
This and the sight of Susannah York in a man's shirt are the absolute highlights!
NonInflatable 2 years ago
Wow, fantastic, thanks for posting.
I've always enjoyed Walton's contribution to 'The Battle of Britain', and seeing it played live by an orchestra is terrific.
Thanks again!
TheMightyHartley 2 years ago 2
Indeed! A great show that BBC Proms! The audience enjoyed very m,uch, as we can see. And Sir Richard Attenborough´s words about Bafta were very interesting. As we may be tired of Hollywood aesthetics, it´s great to watch those British productions.
marcosnardon 2 years ago
Excellent film - most excellent piece - thanks for sharing marcosnardon - thanks for composing Mr Walton.
yabunchacunts 2 years ago 4
I enjoyed very much this BBC Proms! I wish BBC could produce a similar show but just with theater music. Wouldn´t be nice?
marcosnardon 2 years ago