シューマン トロイメライ Schumann Traumerei 牧瀬由紀子

[cityhunter04]

すごい

[johnnyzing]

The recording is a bit live so it's hard to enjoy the soft nature of this song. Eventually she may play it less Pianistically and more legato. Just let the notes flow....yet keep the tempo even as zabki22 mentioned. Yet even doesn't mean metronomic even it means tone, texture and touch even. John-Hans Melcher

[pbryld]

Too slow, too loud.

[merry1002]

緊張しててテンポが速くなってしまったのかもしれませんが、もう­少しゆっくりと気持ちを込めて弾いてみたらどうですか？？

[zabki22]

@merry1002

Schumann's tempo instruction is 1/4 = 100. This means, that he didn't want a "slow" Träumerei, but a tempo like "allegretto". I repeat what i said before, other pianists play it slower, i mentioned the tempo, for an other commentary said it would be too fast. I think, Yukiko Makise's main mistake is the uneaqual tempo.

[reonald911]

@zabki22

＞I think, Yukiko Makise's main mistake is the uneaqual tempo.

There is sense of incongruity in an irregular tempo indeed. I understood it well. Her　Träumerei becomes early suddenly and becomes late, but I think that this is a mistake.

[masumarko]

いいテンポだと思う。やや淡々としたリズムのうえに乗る和音のバ­ランスが整っていて、すごく聞きやすい。

[zabki22]

@masumarko

i know, it is very hard to follow Schumann's instructions, for Träumerei becomes a complete other piece then we are familiar with. Sorry, but Yukiko Makise plays, what Schumann calls "der Gang eines Betrunkenen", the walk of a drunk - long notes very slow, eigth much quicker. That makes the accord seems to be "free". "Spiele im Takte! Das Spiel mancher Virtuosen ist wie der Gang eines Betrunkenen. Solche nimm dir nicht zum Muster."

[nimesse]

@zabki22 du sagst es muss wie eine Betrunken sein, aber, wenn ich betrunken bin, ich gehe langsamm, LANGSAMM! ich glaube es ist zu schnell.

[zabki22]

@nimesse

nein nein, es soll _nicht_ wie der Gang eines Betrunkenen sein, ist es aber leider.

[nimesse]

@zabki22 ahhhhhhhhhhhhh

idiotisch bin ich, entschuldigung...........

[EdleJulve]

too fast, but beautiful

[zabki22]

@EdleJulve

... not too fast, but much too slow. Schumann says 1/4=100, she plays 1/4=63-72 ca. - ok, others play it slower ...

[bunhiroharu]

はやいよ。情景がうかばない

[reonald911]

@bunhiroharu

同感、ちょっとテンポが早すぎて「夢想」のイメージに合わないの­では！

[zabki22]

@reonald911

Why a dream always should be "slow"? - there are dreams or reveries more fluent or even quick ones! Have a look to Schumanns "Traum eines Kindes" = "Dream of a child" in his sonata op. 118c, there he says "Sehr lebhaft" = Very lively.

[Blacklorigine]

Really good played :p

[zeromecinzia]

Bellissimo *.*

Ma il vestito... Io sarei belle e soffocata.

Non e' possibile suonare con un vestito del genere

[chikyunodonfather]

Uuuf!

it came, wonderful!

[spewgilist]

great interpretation

[sameermahoolkar]

.

excellent !

.

[RobertoFasciano]

Good expressive touch, perfect performance. Congratulations!

[joosangbai]

near perfect!

[whizkid7562]

Love listening to you play. That was lovely

and thanks for sharing your musical artestry.

R.

[vultur4]

Beautifull... I am just lerning this piece... you have helped me alot with this, Thank's

[lara9114]

gorgeous.

sentimental, sad, wonderful.