Jennifer Hudson Vs Carrie Underwood Vs Jordin Sparks Vs Kelly Clarkson: A Star Spangled Vocal Battle

[Hugopeacelove]

Jeniffer is the best

[carolinagirl009]

Kelly is easily the best at the anthem hands down

[musiclover19ism]

I love them all , I'm all there fans but I must say Carrie was defintely the first, then Kelly, and Jordin

[FaEMelLLaflare]

Carrie underwood....Flawless

[msUniverse4lyf]

CARRIE is simply the BEST!!!

[TheNeffy]

I dnt give a fuck what noooo body says jennifer blew tht bitxh no if and or buts about it

[taraujo398]

i think carrie is first kelly is second jordin is third and jennifer is fourth

[KnowYourEnemys]

So many idiots.. jennifer can hit any note okay... but there's a thing as too powerful.. carrie vs clarkson for first and id say carrie but I'm a diehard carrie fan so it might be a lil rigged.. I have to admit I never realized clarkson was THAT good

[KnowYourEnemys]

Carrie came out on top as alway.. hudson just blew it and sparks just sucks

[salwa9895]

kelly the best

[matt1991000]

Hudson sucks

[kellox8888]

JORDIN!!!!!!!!!!!



[21ctm21]

1.Kelly

2.everybody else

[Lostie424]

Kelly

[bowlosoup]

carrie is america's sweet heart, and deservedly so. Her voice is so pure and amazing, that every song she sings is just pure heart felt. Country fried goodness.

[msUniverse4lyf]

i have watch all of their performances and versions of NA,

1.CARRIE-in whatever version,such a powerful, clean and natural voice!!

2.kelly-she is supposed to be my 3rd but her new version push her to 2nd..

3.jordin-nice dynamics

4.jennifer-high vocals!but they kill the true meaning of the song!!

[mrsbradpaisley2412]

carrie of course :)

[gokuspr345]

jennifer hudson and carrie and jordin annnnnd kelly. okay fine.....I pick carrie

[TheFear1611]

Umnn Kelly ofc?o-O

[herabay]

Kelly. 

[Wendolyn79]

CARRIE ! <3

[carolinagirl009]

There needs to be one from Kelly's performance of the NA last month at the World Series. It's way better than all four of these performances (including Kelly herself). :)

[carolinagirl009]

1. Kelly

2. Jennifer (in a close 2nd)

3. Carrie

4. Jordin (in a close 4th)

*All four ladies did a great job though :)

[DUDA1101]

My opinion

1-KELLY

2-KELLY

3-KELLY

4-KELLY

[gigigirrl]

In this grouping, I would say Carrie. Pure clean notes. Kelly was a little breathy- but in the video from October 2010 World Series - Kelly knocks it clean out of the park. If you used that video as Kelly's, then she would win hands down. BTW I am a huge fan of both Kelly and Carrie's.

[chantoya17]

ok people just state who's version do you prefer. mkay?

[chantoya17]

stan wars.... sheesh! -_-

[rebarules13]

1 kelly

2 jordan

3 Carrie

4 jeninifer

[annehartje]

1-kelly clarkson

2- jennifer hudson

3- carrie underwood

4- jordin sparks.

well, i think they're all amazing singers.

but kelly is the best, always.. and jordin isn't nice here, but normally she is...

[kellyshairman2010]

@olafsen23 Ok so i definatley think you are tone deaf sweatheart. Kelly has proven herself time and time again as well as carrie. They are both amazing and just get used to it. Its no use putting kelly sucks on anything dear there's just to many die hard kelly fans that are gonna respond back. Like moms say if you dont have anything nice to say... keep your damn mouth shut.

[carshe209]

@olafsen23 haha, bitch.. we all know that carrie is talented... but kelly has way more to offer she's more versatile and can belt 5 notes higher than carrie with more resonance power and fluidity.. and kelly sing an octave higher than carrie.. so how come carrie is better? pls explain..

[welshjoe21]

Clarkson's version in 2009 at Yankee Stadium is a lot better than the one she did on this video and a whole lot better than the other three ladies.

[pritykazy]

@olafsen23 lol, you can say carrie as number 1, very normal.. but kelly sucked? haha.. thats abnormal... remember.. kelly clarkson named as the best contestant on AMERICAN IDOL EVER.. better than thse 2.. plus combined jordin,carrie,jennifer album sales would not even matched kelly.. so fuck you bitch!

[BringMehSomeWater]

1. Kelly all the way! The soul, technique is incomparable.

2. Jen: Raw Power

3. Carrie

4. Jordin

[clpnyc]

1. Carrie

2. Jennifer

3. Kelly-Jordin

[albrtkc]

1. kelly

2. jennifer hudson

3. carrie

4.jordin

[BigDawg1990]

1. Carrie!! = amazing!!

2. Jennifer & Kelly

3. Jordin

[sharapova4eva]

1. CARRIE

2. Kelly

3. Jordin

4. Jennifer

[JavaCHpFrap]

1. Carrie

2. Jordin

3. Kelly

4. Jennifer

[1geoallee]

1. jordin

2. kelly

3. jennifer

4. carrie

[americanidolfan55]

although i do prefer kelly's anthem at the 2009 yankees stadium opening

[americanidolfan55]

1. kelly

2. carrie

3. jordin

4. jennifer

sorry but as great of a singer as jennifer is, her anthem was WAY too much. it took out the meaning of the song.

[Myra1991JR]

1. Carrie

2. Kelly

3. Jennifer

4. Jordin

[sly4u06]

1. jennifer

2. jordin

3. kelly

4. carrie